Missus again. Sigh
Author
Discussion

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
I should take away the keys...

She was hiring a van over the weekend and going down a country lane a car lost its wing mirror as they passed. Van rental man is cool as no chargable damage sustained by the van.

He's telling her she's got to pay and I'm suggesting 50:50.

Neither vehicle came to a halt before the incident so I reckon they were both as dumb as each other. He said he came up the road and she was "all over the road", but when I asked him why he didn't stop he had no answer. I suggested that he thought there was space, she thought there was space and it turned out they were both mistaken...

He's reckoning £100 quid will sort it and because I refused to pay he's off to the rental company to make a claim. I've told them not to pay as we'll deal with it.

So what can I expect?

SM

Muzzer

3,814 posts

252 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
If he wants £100 to sort it, offer him £50.

It's his word against your lady's so split it in half and move on. If he's sensible he'll accept it.

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Muzzer said:
If he wants £100 to sort it, offer him £50.
Hmmm. So if there was £1000 worth of damage to the luton, he'd be happy to pay half that also?

I want to be fair, but in this case really they both damaged their own vehicles, it's just that he unfortunately came off worse.

The rental company man is understandably keen to get this sorted out amicably, and in fairness the other guy seemed fairly amicable on the phone.

So if I stick to my guns, what recourse does he have?

SM


Edited by supermono on Tuesday 8th April 11:50

Mg6b

6,649 posts

294 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
I take it your missus is older than 16 years?

She broke it. Let her sort it out!

They fought years for equality!

My missus is likely to have one through a habit she has when parking. I have already told her about this and when it happens as it surely will, she knows who will be dealing with the claim issue and it won't be me!!!biggrin


SplatSpeed

7,491 posts

282 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Mg6b said:
I take it your missus is older than 16 years?

She broke it. Let her sort it out!

They fought years for equality!

My missus is likely to have one through a habit she has when parking. I have already told her about this and when it happens as it surely will, she knows who will be dealing with the claim issue and it won't be me!!!biggrin
yuo really dont like sex do you

Mactac

645 posts

224 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Angry sex burns more calories I understand

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Mg6b said:
I take it your missus is older than 16 years?

She broke it. Let her sort it out!

They fought years for equality!
Truer words I've not heard. But I've found through experience that these things cost me more money if she deals with them.

SM

SplatSpeed

7,491 posts

282 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
Mg6b said:
I take it your missus is older than 16 years?

She broke it. Let her sort it out!

They fought years for equality!
Truer words I've not heard. But I've found through experience that these things cost me more money if she deals with them.

SM
what he said

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
SplatSpeed said:
supermono said:
Mg6b said:
I take it your missus is older than 16 years?

She broke it. Let her sort it out!

They fought years for equality!
Truer words I've not heard. But I've found through experience that these things cost me more money if she deals with them.

SM
what he said
+1 and would be in the dog house for years to come

+1

Muzzer

3,814 posts

252 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
Muzzer said:
If he wants £100 to sort it, offer him £50.
Hmmm. So if there was £1000 worth of damage to the luton, he'd be happy to pay half that also?

I want to be fair, but in this case really they both damaged their own vehicles, it's just that he unfortunately came off worse.

The rental company man is understandably keen to get this sorted out amicably, and in fairness the other guy seemed fairly amicable on the phone.

So if I stick to my guns, what recourse does he have?

SM
Yeah, but there's not £1000 worth of damage, there's only £100-worth.

If it was a grand then I'd get the insurance involved if he wanted to fight it. But, being as it's only £100 just take a £50 hit and have done with it.

If you want to pursue it further, I'm sure he'll get the insurance involved which could wind up with you in a worse situation of having to pay the excess on your rental policy.

Without seeing the accident, I've obviously got no way of knowing how this will end up but bottom line:

Scenario 1: Give man £50, walk away
Scneario 2: Fight it, insurance involved, lose excess
Scenario 3: Fight it, insurance rule your favour or equal fault, lose nothing.

Your choice - depends on the accident.





supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Muzzer said:
Scenario 1: Give man £50, walk away
Well he's asking for £100 citing her fault. I've not suggested paying half so it might wash or it might not. I get your logic though, just for an easy life. Worth considering.

The thing is if I was him I'd pay for my own mirror and just think the other party was lucky to get away with nothing to pay for making the same mistake. Plus I'd learn to drive/observe better on a country lane to be able to come to a standstill if something coming the other way is too wide to pass -- as I've suggested she does also (not that it'll make any difference).

Often I'll stop in these situations where I can't be sure there's room, that way if the other party barrels on through, they've caused the accident and will be liable.

SM

Eddh

4,656 posts

223 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Mg6b said:
I take it your missus is older than 16 years?
she was driving a van so i would hope so :roll:

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
I though that any colision like that in a country lane is "you pay your own damage". Tell him to sling his hook if I were you.

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
fatboy b said:
I though that any colision like that in a country lane is "you pay your own damage". Tell him to sling his hook if I were you.
Well good sense would suggest that, from the way it was described (I wasn't there and I'm biased of course!)

Is there any case law?

SM

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Why would that be? I live on a country lane, and the worst car I can meet coming from the other side are Ford Fiestas, or Nissan Micras. The drivers often don't know the width of their cars and drive in the middle of the road.

If one of those would hit me, why would I be liable (or even 50%) ?

youngsyr

14,742 posts

223 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
fatboy b said:
I though that any colision like that in a country lane is "you pay your own damage". Tell him to sling his hook if I were you.
I thought that was the unwritten rule on race tracks? confused


winklaugh

supermono

Original Poster:

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
EU_Foreigner said:
If one of those would hit me, why would I be liable (or even 50%) ?
Because you failed to stop before they hit you?

When I've been faced with a nutjob who's on my side of the road I'll stop and hope they miss me. I was driving down the very same stretch once in my 911 when I rounded the corner I was faced with an enormous foreign truck taking up almost all the road. If I'd ploughed on regardless could I have written off my car on his dollar? I stopped and backed up a bit and got into a pull off area and he came through. No harm done.

I wasn't there but he's told me himself he didn't stop, yet now he's claiming her fault. It sounds like they were both going for a gap that wasn't there. Is the stopping requirement key or is it irrelevant?

I want to be fair but I don't want to have the pee taken.

SM

Chrisgr31

14,298 posts

286 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Moral of the story is not to stop after whacking the wing mirror!

Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
I take the view it's knock for knock. You fix your mirror and he fixes his regardless of who has the more expensive mirror. Both drivers are probably equally at fault and it's hard to prove otherwise.

rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Tuesday 8th April 2008
quotequote all
Sounds to me like knock for knock.

Your Mrs hits harder and so wins by default.

If it was more than a 100 i would be looking at this a lot more seriously nut i'd be inclined to A0 find out just how much the mirror would cost to replace (call a stealer?) and take it from there. Again it's only £100 (still plenty of money to look after though i'll grant) so i wouldn't get my karma in a twist over the end result.