Caught on the phone = careless driving for insurance renewal
Caught on the phone = careless driving for insurance renewal
Author
Discussion

streaky

Original Poster:

19,311 posts

280 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
There are reports today that (some) insurers are now treating convictions for using a mobile 'phone whilst driving as equivalent to one of careless driving and increasing premiums.

At the same time, the insurers are not increasing premiums for the first (and sometimes the second) speeding offence.

Applauding the first and declaiming the second will make it the first time that BRAKE have held a balanced view! smile

Streaky

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
Mobile phone use is the latest bogeyman. Like speeding can be done without any appreciable effect on overall danger.

But watch out for insurance companies saying they don't increase premiums for speeding tickets. I am always careful to ask before a quote if they increase, and usually they'll say no just one isn't important. Then I lie and say I have none, get the quote, but then remember that actually I do have one.

Usually the quote goes up...

As a rule of thumb it's well worth not believing a word a theiving insurance company tells you.

SM

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
Mobile phone use is the latest bogeyman. Like speeding can be done without any appreciable effect on overall danger.

But watch out for insurance companies saying they don't increase premiums for speeding tickets. I am always careful to ask before a quote if they increase, and usually they'll say no just one isn't important. Then I lie and say I have none, get the quote, but then remember that actually I do have one.

Usually the quote goes up...

As a rule of thumb it's well worth not believing a word a theiving insurance company tells you.

SM
Mobile phone use is a preventative. In the past you had t deal under 'not in proper control' this required some evidence of bad driving ir, swerving into traffic, hitting a kerb etc. The substantive offence allows action to be taken before the bad driving occurs.

Speeding however is not about preventing a crash its more about reducing the impact of one. In most cases speeding does not increase your chance of crashing but will increase your insurers bill should you crash.

M5Dave

829 posts

240 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
To a certain extent I can see the insurance companies point on this one.

You are probably more likely to have an accident whilst talking on a mobile phone, when your concentration is split between two tasks i.e your telephone call and driving, than when fully concentrating on the single task of driving, albeit a few miles per hour over the speed limit.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
supermono said:
Mobile phone use is the latest bogeyman. Like speeding can be done without any appreciable effect on overall danger.

But watch out for insurance companies saying they don't increase premiums for speeding tickets. I am always careful to ask before a quote if they increase, and usually they'll say no just one isn't important. Then I lie and say I have none, get the quote, but then remember that actually I do have one.

Usually the quote goes up...

As a rule of thumb it's well worth not believing a word a theiving insurance company tells you.

SM
Mobile phone use is a preventative. In the past you had t deal under 'not in proper control' this required some evidence of bad driving ir, swerving into traffic, hitting a kerb etc. The substantive offence allows action to be taken before the bad driving occurs.

Speeding however is not about preventing a crash its more about reducing the impact of one. In most cases speeding does not increase your chance of crashing but will increase your insurers bill should you crash.
Never heard of Crumple zones then?? Sorry complete tosh in most cases the nature of the damage sustained will depend on the age and nature of the incident and how effective their crumple zones are at absorbing impact, even a relatively low speed impact can result in significant panel replacement with modern vehicles if the circumstances are right.



Cheers
So the financial cost of a 90mph crash will be the same as 40mph one then...

Sorry but the faster you travel the greater the cost in financial terms will be. Some speeds will se activation of air bags or other internal devices, the speed will also impact upon how far back the damage in the car goes, the injuries inflicted upon the occupants.

Some low speed impacts can cost a lot of money but in general terms the greater the physical forces involved in a crash the greater the financial and physical cost. Also the more chance of you involving other third parties be it persons, vehicles or street furniture.

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
Abosolutely, if you have a 80mph crash, and there are no injuries you will be setting flags to go have a look. There should be some !

People cost a lot more than cars to fix. Plus solicitors costs.

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
I think people crashing cost insurance companies more money than people who don't crash. I'm not in the industry but it's my understanding that crashing at 65mph costs more than not crashing at 85mph.

I doubt figures show that people who do 85mph crash more often than people who do 65mph.

SM

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
I doubt figures show that people who do 85mph crash more often than people who do 65mph.

SM
They show that people with speeding convictions have higher claims costs. It isn't about crashing, it is about cost per crash.

heebeegeetee

30,264 posts

279 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
Mobile phone use is the latest bogeyman.
Yup. yes

Talking and driving at the same time, the biggest single threat to mankind since the dawn of time.

( scratchchin or is it climate change? Can never keep up with the scaremongering )


Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
Oh Nonsense I have had a number of speeding convictions over 36 years behind the wheel and not one single claim on insurance due to my culpability (I am not unique in this) You can perhaps argue that those with higher claim costs also have speeding convictions but you cannot derive correlation the other way as you would have to have a counter sample to the one you are illustrating. (bit like speed kills really).
Within any group there will be deviations. Some 17 year olds will be perfect drivers. Most won't.

Using a sample of one-or-two isn't really that clever, but for the number of claims insurers see, for a large enough sample those with convictions have higher claim costs.

By "Tango" boxster do you mean Zanzibar Red ? Cool smile

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
Not sure you mean allegorical !

But insurers DO have that data. They have an annual sample rate. Every year they know a) have you been speeding b) what your claims costs are. So they can compare non speeders with speeders in terms of claims costs.

You then need need to compare the claims costs in terms of age etc. So it may be that a speeding conviction has a higher rating factor when compared to younger drivers than it does to older.

It isn't just a case of saying 1 speeding = £20 or whatever. It is a very complicated set of steps and calculations.

BTW Actuaries do have to show their rating is proportionate, they can't just make it up.

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
Interesting though that it varies by country. In NL, it does not matter how many speeding convictions you have as it does not impact your insurance what so ever as they use the normal risk assessment based on the value of the car and the number of claims you have had.

It makes sense though, that as you as an individual have not had a claim in 30 years, why would your risk go up just because you got caught? You are only a bigger risk if you have had a number of accidents, and it will affect your bonus malus for it (i.e. level of insurance discount) if you do, so therefore you pay more then.

Why penalise someone for something that has not happened?

Add to that the fact that I have all toys in my car to prevent me from getting speeding tickets, so my insurance premium is lower then for someone who does not have those toys and does get caught. It should not be an insurance matter.

p1esk

4,914 posts

227 months

Wednesday 9th April 2008
quotequote all
Noger said:
Guam said:
Oh Nonsense I have had a number of speeding convictions over 36 years behind the wheel and not one single claim on insurance due to my culpability (I am not unique in this) You can perhaps argue that those with higher claim costs also have speeding convictions but you cannot derive correlation the other way as you would have to have a counter sample to the one you are illustrating. (bit like speed kills really).
Within any group there will be deviations. Some 17 year olds will be perfect drivers.
Oh I think that's rather unlikely. Perfect drivers are probably aged about 68 or over. rofl

Best wishes all,
Dave.

catso

16,570 posts

298 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Any excuse to raise your premiums, last year my wife had a car accident (non-fault) the car is insured in my name and when I renewed my Motorbike insurance they put it up because of a declared accident on my car policy! now she doesn't ride the bike, hasn't even got a bike licence, so how is this relevant to my bike insurance?

Best of it is she had another crash this year, local superstore delivery van hit her but the driver denies it's his fault (protecting his job I assume), so looking like a 'fault' (50-50) claim, no doubt my bike policy will increase again... furious

Edited by catso on Thursday 10th April 09:54

gemini

11,352 posts

295 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
For £9 or so you can now have a hands free earpiece

So why FFS do so many - knowingthe penalty - still have the phone in their hand pressed up to their ear, whilst driving

For me nick em all!

Two hands free for the wheel must be safer than steering with your knees, changing gear with your left hand and ordering tonights pizza with your right!

davido140

9,617 posts

257 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Guam said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
supermono said:
Mobile phone use is the latest bogeyman. Like speeding can be done without any appreciable effect on overall danger.

But watch out for insurance companies saying they don't increase premiums for speeding tickets. I am always careful to ask before a quote if they increase, and usually they'll say no just one isn't important. Then I lie and say I have none, get the quote, but then remember that actually I do have one.

Usually the quote goes up...

As a rule of thumb it's well worth not believing a word a theiving insurance company tells you.

SM
Mobile phone use is a preventative. In the past you had t deal under 'not in proper control' this required some evidence of bad driving ir, swerving into traffic, hitting a kerb etc. The substantive offence allows action to be taken before the bad driving occurs.

Speeding however is not about preventing a crash its more about reducing the impact of one. In most cases speeding does not increase your chance of crashing but will increase your insurers bill should you crash.
Never heard of Crumple zones then?? Sorry complete tosh in most cases the nature of the damage sustained will depend on the age and nature of the incident and how effective their crumple zones are at absorbing impact, even a relatively low speed impact can result in significant panel replacement with modern vehicles if the circumstances are right.



Cheers
So the financial cost of a 90mph crash will be the same as 40mph one then...

Sorry but the faster you travel the greater the cost in financial terms will be. Some speeds will se activation of air bags or other internal devices, the speed will also impact upon how far back the damage in the car goes, the injuries inflicted upon the occupants.

Some low speed impacts can cost a lot of money but in general terms the greater the physical forces involved in a crash the greater the financial and physical cost. Also the more chance of you involving other third parties be it persons, vehicles or street furniture.
I've written a car off at 30mph (in a 60 limit) before now, was worth about 12k!!

Maybe I'm just special! wink

In all honesty there is a basis of logic and risk assesment behind insurance quote factoring in dozens of different risk calulations. Once this risk assesment is complete, they lick a finger, stick it in the air, see which way the wind is blowing and make a number up.

Thats your renewal remium.

To give you an example, (using the logic that speed causes crashes) is a driver on 9 points a bigger risk or a smaller risk?

Highly likely to be pooting around nowhere near the limit as they risk losing thier license.

But also, just as likely to be a complete tool who doesnt give a toss and will continue driving at speed.

buuuut, we all know that speed doesnt really kill/cause accidents. at least not on its own anyway. (however someone dopey enough to collect 9 points from gatso's clearly isnt looking where they are going!!)

Anyway, this brings me back to my first point, its impossible to really do a "proper" risk assesment for anyone without interviews, driving assesments etc. So essentially you are quoted a made up number! no matter what your convictions/points/etc just keep phoning around all the companies until you get lucky enough to be given a low number!


Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
Yeah right, no they arent supposed to make it up this is true but once again, they do not have the data the way I postulated it, they can do a broad brush total number of speeding convictions against total number of claims this is true, but they CANNOT do what you suggest, as they will not have the names of every speeder to compare against their database of policyholders and claimants, unless the government is in the most massive breach of the data protection act since its inception?


I await your response smile
They don't need the name of every speeder, their sample is just their customers. And of course insurers share data too, via the ABI.

When you buy insurance you tell the insurer what convictions you have had in the last 5 years. OK, so may be some people lie, but most don't. So you look at their claims costs versus their conviction history and compare that across groups. Triangulation, graduated rating curves. It hurts my head.

In practice the "I just ran a speed camera @ 35mph and have never had a crash or conviction in my life" types don't have increased claims. It is the serial offenders that are the ones that the rating algoriths are trying to load up. Which is why the first speeding offence is often ignored.

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
davido140 said:
Anyway, this brings me back to my first point, its impossible to really do a "proper" risk assesment for anyone without interviews, driving assesments etc. So essentially you are quoted a made up number!
But that isn't what insurance is about. It is about pooled risk, not individual risk. You can't do a risk assesment on a every single driver, and even if you did what would you base the answer on, the behviour of one person is not predictable. The behaviour of a large enough number of people IS.

One person with 9 points - who knows when they will have another accident or what the cost will be. 100,000 people with 9 points, that is much easier to predict and price/reserve for.

On average men die before women. But that doesn't mean you WILL die before your missus does it ?

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Look, people caught speeding all eat babies, and have three heads, and emit more UV than Dale Winton's house. And I have the MI to prove it smile

Happy now ?

King of Dings

437 posts

223 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Isn't the point here "is using a mobile while driving dangerous?"

Any sensible person with good judgement and common sense will know the answer to this question.

“Of course it’s not dangerous”.

Otherwise why allow it in most other countries globally, particularly the USA. And why allow it with the use of Bluetooth set and installed car kits.

See it for what it is, another stealth tax on the easiest community to target outside of children and pensioners……car drivers.

The real question here is what the hell are the phone companies and mobile operators doing to lobby the government about this completely pointless law.

There are far more dangerous things to do in a car than use a mobile phone and I’m not talking about the X rated stuff here either….!