How long should/will he get for killing 5?
How long should/will he get for killing 5?
Author
Discussion

matchmaker

Original Poster:

9,091 posts

231 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
What a horrible thing to happen.

Hard to say what is justified without knowing more details. Seeming he's pleaded guilty, we're not going to know all the facts, either.

Five deaths is a lot to have on your conscience, no doubt there's going to be a stiff jail term for him to match.


Mattt

16,664 posts

249 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
65 in a 60? Crazy driving that is, and obviously the cause of the accident.

matchmaker

Original Poster:

9,091 posts

231 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Mattt said:
65 in a 60? Crazy driving that is, and obviously the cause of the accident.
rolleyesrolleyes I know the road quite well - between Perth and Crieff you could do crazy speeds.

Rich-UK

1,431 posts

287 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Overtaking on a blind summit over a solid white line? Execution. (providing the facts are right)

It could have been you, or more importantly me, coming the other way.

matchmaker

Original Poster:

9,091 posts

231 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
The most horrific factor to me was the fate of his passengers. I just hope they died in the collision, and not in the fire.

Battenburg Bob

8,857 posts

223 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Mattt said:
65 in a 60? Crazy driving that is, and obviously the cause of the accident.
No the cause was :-

"He crossed a solid white line into the eastbound lane and continued to drive on the wrong side of the road to the crest of a blind summit in the road."

He deserves everything he gets. Unfortunately the people he killed didn't.

Vipers

33,525 posts

259 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Mattt said:
65 in a 60? Crazy driving that is, and obviously the cause of the accident.
Ho ho ho, funny not. He overtook on a blind bend for christ sake.......crossing double solid lines. give the bugger 10 years, trash his car and more, unfortnately he admitted it, so he will get next to sod all.

frown

P.S. I see Bob beat me to it, but I'll leave my post in anyway.

Edited by Vipers on Thursday 10th April 20:27

matchmaker

Original Poster:

9,091 posts

231 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
I've just asked the Missus and her view is that he should have been done for Culpable Homicide (hey - she knows Scots Law - her husband was a court clerk for 20 years), instead of S1.

I'd tend to agree - maximum sentence for CH is life.

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Battenburg Bob said:
Mattt said:
65 in a 60? Crazy driving that is, and obviously the cause of the accident.
No the cause was :-

"He crossed a solid white line into the eastbound lane and continued to drive on the wrong side of the road to the crest of a blind summit in the road."

He deserves everything he gets. Unfortunately the people he killed didn't.
I'm beginning to think you have a problem spotting sarcasm....smile (At least I hope it was sarcasm from Mattt)

Edited by esselte on Thursday 10th April 21:15

Puddenchucker

6,000 posts

249 months

Thursday 10th April 2008
quotequote all
Previous sentencing example of someone causing the death of five in a crash:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/suffolk...

bi9_jk

883 posts

296 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
Puddenchucker said:
Previous sentencing example of someone causing the death of five in a crash:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/suffolk...
I think what can be distinguished here is that in this case the driver was drunk and therefore the whole journey was dangerous. The case the o/p mentioned does not have this feature therefore the sentence will probably not be as high.

This was not a prolonged bad driving but only one recogniseable error. This was a bad decision he made but this persons character, their driving history and an early guilty plea will find alot of favour. He was not speeding excessivley (perhaps if he was then he would have made the overtake) I reckon this person is at best moderatley culpable and therefore a sentence of about 3 years is appropriate.

What a dummy to plead guilty to causing death by dangerous driving. If he had plead guilty to causing death by careless driving then he would have got at worst a £2500 fine and some points possibly some community sentence. As bad as that would be the outrageously high potential of 14 years is the worst of two evils. Plus the extra insurance costs when he does get a licence back.

Edited by bi9_jk on Friday 11th April 00:31


Edited by bi9_jk on Friday 11th April 00:35

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
Mattt said:
65 in a 60? Crazy driving that is, and obviously the cause of the accident.
A thread to discuss the deaths of five people, what an appropriate place for this kind of "humour" mad

Mattt

16,664 posts

249 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
Mattt said:
65 in a 60? Crazy driving that is, and obviously the cause of the accident.
A thread to discuss the deaths of five people, what an appropriate place for this kind of "humour" mad
It's not an attempt at humour, it's criticising the reporting of the incident.

nats1rt

228 posts

230 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
Mattt said:
thewurzel said:
Mattt said:
65 in a 60? Crazy driving that is, and obviously the cause of the accident.
A thread to discuss the deaths of five people, what an appropriate place for this kind of "humour" mad
It's not an attempt at humour, it's criticising the reporting of the incident.
IMO you were getting at how the press portray speed, "65 in a 60" tells us a) the speed he was traveling at and b) the speed limit, both pieces of information the reader would undoubtedly want to know.

Nothing wrong with the report, very impartial.

heebeegeetee

30,263 posts

279 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
bi9_jk said:
This was not a prolonged bad driving but only one recogniseable error.
>>He crossed a solid white line into the eastbound lane and continued to drive on the wrong side of the road to the crest of a blind summit in the road.<<

Do you reckon a person who drives like that possibly drives perfectly safely, normally?

deviant

4,316 posts

241 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
There was a similar case here in Aus very recently.

A bloke lost control of his car and hit a group of teenager waiting for a bus and killed 6.

He has been sent to prison for 10 years.

crikey

1,705 posts

242 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
He made a conscious decision to drive on the wrong side of the road. Unless he was mentally deficient, or whatever the pc term for it is nowadays, he will have been aware that by doing so on the brow of a hill he was increasing the likelihood of a collision. He will have also been aware that at a speed of 65mph, plus the speed of the oncoming vehicle, there would certainly be serious injuries sustained and very likely death(s) in such a collision.

In short, he made the decision to drive in the manner he did knowing it could lead to someone's death.

Manslaughter at the very least.

JMGS4

8,936 posts

301 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
5x Manslaughter through dangerous driving = 5 x 20 years in my eyes...

Mattt

16,664 posts

249 months

Friday 11th April 2008
quotequote all
nats1rt said:
"65 in a 60"
Notice that the 65mph was witnesses estimates, which are unreliable at the best of times. Now everyone is stating that he was doing 65, he may well have been doing under 60mph.