Points on a Provisional
Author
Discussion

nats1rt

Original Poster:

228 posts

230 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
What is the thinking behind giving points to a driver caught driving illegally with a provisional license? For example driving with no insurance and without someone with a full license in the passenger seat, being caught and receiving 8 points on the license. Surely after taking the test you'd still have 8 points and thus be disqualified?

This brings me onto my second point, extending the period of time a driver is disqualified for. The driver is all ready driving while disqualified, extending the disqualification is unlikely to prevent further unlawful motoring.

Any thoughts?

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
nats1rt said:
What is the thinking behind giving points to a driver caught driving illegally with a provisional license? For example driving with no insurance and without someone with a full license in the passenger seat, being caught and receiving 8 points on the license. Surely after taking the test you'd still have 8 points and thus be disqualified?

This brings me onto my second point, extending the period of time a driver is disqualified for. The driver is all ready driving while disqualified, extending the disqualification is unlikely to prevent further unlawful motoring.

Any thoughts?
1) You don't get disqualified with 8 points on your licence.

2) There is a point to disqualifying someone who drives without a licence.

Firstly if they drive without a licence that is not the same as disqualified driving. You can't go to prison for driving without a licence. If you get disqualified from driving by a court for having driven without a licence, if you then drive again you have committed the offence of disqualified driving & that is imprisonable.

Stu R

21,701 posts

246 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
nats1rt said:
What is the thinking behind giving points to a driver caught driving illegally with a provisional license? For example driving with no insurance and without someone with a full license in the passenger seat, being caught and receiving 8 points on the license. Surely after taking the test you'd still have 8 points and thus be disqualified?

This brings me onto my second point, extending the period of time a driver is disqualified for. The driver is all ready driving while disqualified, extending the disqualification is unlikely to prevent further unlawful motoring.

Any thoughts?
1) You don't get disqualified with 8 points on your licence.

2) There is a point to disqualifying someone who drives without a licence.
But isn't the totting up procedure standard across the board now? so 6 points in your first 2 years and you're banned for 6 months? which surely means as soon as you pass you're banned again.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
Stu R said:
vonhosen said:
nats1rt said:
What is the thinking behind giving points to a driver caught driving illegally with a provisional license? For example driving with no insurance and without someone with a full license in the passenger seat, being caught and receiving 8 points on the license. Surely after taking the test you'd still have 8 points and thus be disqualified?

This brings me onto my second point, extending the period of time a driver is disqualified for. The driver is all ready driving while disqualified, extending the disqualification is unlikely to prevent further unlawful motoring.

Any thoughts?
1) You don't get disqualified with 8 points on your licence.

2) There is a point to disqualifying someone who drives without a licence.
But isn't the totting up procedure standard across the board now? so 6 points in your first 2 years and you're banned for 6 months? which surely means as soon as you pass you're banned again.
Licence revocation for new drivers is not a ban.
Revocation means you lose full licence status, go back to being a provisional & have to sit the tests again. You are not banned from driving.
If a court bans you then you can't drive at all & are forbidden from obtaining a provisional or any other licence until the ban is up.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
how does that actually work in this case then Von? I read it as you get 8 points on your provisional. Pass your test & send it off to the DVLA & they then revoke it so you do the test again a few weeks later & drive off with a clean licence.
seems a bit pointless as it doesnt achive much because as far as I'm aware the second test is on a 'new' licence so you dont need to declare those points for insurance etc?

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
Hooli said:
how does that actually work in this case then Von? I read it as you get 8 points on your provisional. Pass your test & send it off to the DVLA & they then revoke it so you do the test again a few weeks later & drive off with a clean licence.
seems a bit pointless as it doesnt achive much because as far as I'm aware the second test is on a 'new' licence so you dont need to declare those points for insurance etc?
No, the points remain on the revoked licence & must be declared.
If you get 6 points & your licence is revoked your new provisional will still have 6 points on it. It doesn't wipe the slate clean. If you then got a further 6 points on the new provisional you'd be up for a totting ban.

Edited by vonhosen on Saturday 12th April 23:44

Stu R

21,701 posts

246 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Stu R said:
vonhosen said:
nats1rt said:
What is the thinking behind giving points to a driver caught driving illegally with a provisional license? For example driving with no insurance and without someone with a full license in the passenger seat, being caught and receiving 8 points on the license. Surely after taking the test you'd still have 8 points and thus be disqualified?

This brings me onto my second point, extending the period of time a driver is disqualified for. The driver is all ready driving while disqualified, extending the disqualification is unlikely to prevent further unlawful motoring.

Any thoughts?
1) You don't get disqualified with 8 points on your licence.

2) There is a point to disqualifying someone who drives without a licence.
But isn't the totting up procedure standard across the board now? so 6 points in your first 2 years and you're banned for 6 months? which surely means as soon as you pass you're banned again.
Licence revocation for new drivers is not a ban.
Revocation means you lose full licence status, go back to being a provisional & have to sit the tests again. You are not banned from driving.
If a court bans you then you can't drive at all & are forbidden from obtaining a provisional or any other licence until the ban is up.
I got a 6 month ban and retest within my first 2 years when totting up was first introduced (XX99). Was the ban therefore at the magistrate's discretion and something entirely seperate, as I was under the impression that was the standard punishment for getting 6 points within your first two years? As I understand it that's the courts guidelines at least anyway?

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
Stu R said:
vonhosen said:
Stu R said:
vonhosen said:
nats1rt said:
What is the thinking behind giving points to a driver caught driving illegally with a provisional license? For example driving with no insurance and without someone with a full license in the passenger seat, being caught and receiving 8 points on the license. Surely after taking the test you'd still have 8 points and thus be disqualified?

This brings me onto my second point, extending the period of time a driver is disqualified for. The driver is all ready driving while disqualified, extending the disqualification is unlikely to prevent further unlawful motoring.

Any thoughts?
1) You don't get disqualified with 8 points on your licence.

2) There is a point to disqualifying someone who drives without a licence.
But isn't the totting up procedure standard across the board now? so 6 points in your first 2 years and you're banned for 6 months? which surely means as soon as you pass you're banned again.
Licence revocation for new drivers is not a ban.
Revocation means you lose full licence status, go back to being a provisional & have to sit the tests again. You are not banned from driving.
If a court bans you then you can't drive at all & are forbidden from obtaining a provisional or any other licence until the ban is up.
I got a 6 month ban and retest within my first 2 years when totting up was first introduced (XX99). Was the ban therefore at the magistrate's discretion and something entirely seperate, as I was under the impression that was the standard punishment for getting 6 points within your first two years? As I understand it that's the courts guidelines at least anyway?
They can ban you, but that's not revocation because of points.
Courts ban.
DVLA do licence revocation, not the court.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Hooli said:
how does that actually work in this case then Von? I read it as you get 8 points on your provisional. Pass your test & send it off to the DVLA & they then revoke it so you do the test again a few weeks later & drive off with a clean licence.
seems a bit pointless as it doesnt achive much because as far as I'm aware the second test is on a 'new' licence so you dont need to declare those points for insurance etc?
No, the points remain on the revoked licence & must be declared.
If you get 6 points & your licence is revoked your new provisional will still have 6 points on it. It doesn't wipe the slate clean. If you then got a further 6 points on the new provisional you'd be up for a totting ban.

Edited by vonhosen on Saturday 12th April 23:44
ahh it makes sense now, i'd never seen that bit explained on here before. thanks for clearing it up.

Stu R

21,701 posts

246 months

Saturday 12th April 2008
quotequote all
cheers for the clarification, I was under the assumption it was all down to the court smile