Minding my own business, then, BANG!
Minding my own business, then, BANG!
Author
Discussion

MadMacMcMad

Original Poster:

1,267 posts

283 months

Sunday 13th April 2008
quotequote all
Just changed all my water pipes to decent silicon ones, refilled and went out for a drive to makes sure no air trapped.

1st geared and pull away vigorously at a set of lights and BANG. Diff stripped!

No drive in any gear, but you can hear what used to be teeth scrabbling for a bite.

The car is now on top of a flat bed making it's way to plans for I suspect a LSD,Clutch and maybe 6 speed + new crank seal and a big bill.
Lets hope the guys at Plans are not too smashed out and get it all done by LeMans.

Buggerfrown

Jenx

11,579 posts

271 months

Sunday 13th April 2008
quotequote all
Sorry to hear that mate, bummer!

Martin.

mgbond

6,749 posts

261 months

Sunday 13th April 2008
quotequote all
MadMacMcMad said:
Just changed all my water pipes to decent silicon ones, refilled and went out for a drive to makes sure no air trapped.

1st geared and pull away vigorously at a set of lights and BANG. Diff stripped!

No drive in any gear, but you can hear what used to be teeth scrabbling for a bite.

The car is now on top of a flat bed making it's way to plans for I suspect a LSD,Clutch and maybe 6 speed + new crank seal and a big bill.
Lets hope the guys at Plans are not too smashed out and get it all done by LeMans.

Bugger


If for any reason you don't go for the 6spd (and M400 Linkage) then make sure you get the 5spd shot peened (I think). I wish Plans had told me to do this while I had the chance.

Also worth thinking about cutting the bar and re-fixing it like in the USA as this means the engine won't have to come out (saving ££££.

Bondy

MadMacMcMad

Original Poster:

1,267 posts

283 months

Sunday 13th April 2008
quotequote all
Bondy
I was under the impression that for a new Diff the engine had to come out. If not then the removable section is a must do. I will quiz Plans on this tomorrow.

G T 3

2,142 posts

283 months

Sunday 13th April 2008
quotequote all
Alans good with an angle grinder

Jim O.

486 posts

226 months

Sunday 13th April 2008
quotequote all
MadMacMcMad said:
Bondy
I was under the impression that for a new Diff the engine had to come out. If not then the removable section is a must do. I will quiz Plans on this tomorrow.
The diff is installed in the transaxle (transmission). No need to remove the engine to replace the diff, if you remove the transaxle by removing the side bar.

Jim

NobleGuy

7,133 posts

244 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
Yep. That's how they did mine in January.
I found that it saved me about £600-700 (lost a little due to the extra labour to remove and replace the side bar and fashion a fixing point). However, next time round it should save even more as the bar won't need to be worked on - it's now bolt-on.

MadMacMcMad

Original Poster:

1,267 posts

283 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
So, If it is the diff and I don't need to remove the engine, what are the essential mods.
Obviously the LSD upgrade, but which one/who's? As the car will be in bits, should I have the clutch done and gearbox uprated(standard 5 speed)Or is this unnecessary at the moment as the engine will not have to come out to have this done when it is needed.

NobleGuy

7,133 posts

244 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
When I had mine done the garage inspected the gearbox and clutch. They mentioned each were both still in good nick and estimated they had a good 25K+ miles in them still. Mine's done 27K miles.

I went for the Quaife ATB LSD - around £600 with (within reason) a lifetime guarantee. Part number is on the Wiki.

NobleGuy

7,133 posts

244 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
Bad luck btw. Never nice when you just know it's going to be expensive.

MadMacMcMad

Original Poster:

1,267 posts

283 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
Cheers.
Just waiting for John at Plans to let me know the damage to my mortgage fund.
I will follow his advise, but the thinking is new 5 speed G/Box, Clutch, LSD. Also might shot peen the box internals incase I want more power as I am at the limit of the standard 5 speed box now.

node

732 posts

229 months

NobleGuy

7,133 posts

244 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
MadMacMcMad said:
Cheers.
Just waiting for John at Plans to let me know the damage to my mortgage fund.
I will follow his advise, but the thinking is new 5 speed G/Box, Clutch, LSD. Also might shot peen the box internals incase I want more power as I am at the limit of the standard 5 speed box now.
You might not need a full gearbox and clutch replacement. I managed to skulk home slowly (wasn't too far away luckily) when I did the diff and managed to save the gearbox/clutch.

Ash 996 GT2

3,836 posts

270 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
MadMacMcMad said:
Cheers.
Just waiting for John at Plans to let me know the damage to my mortgage fund.
I will follow his advise, but the thinking is new 5 speed G/Box, Clutch, LSD. Also might shot peen the box internals incase I want more power as I am at the limit of the standard 5 speed box now.
You must go 6 speed and have it shot peened. Not only will the shot peening make it stronger, it has much less drag, more HP to the wheels smile

Trust me, I had it done and it showed on the rolling road.

Can not see the pont of having LSD and 5 speed. Also, get the M400 linkage, transforms the car like you will not beleive.

Smooth changes, no more "calling all gears".

Call me if you want to chat about it, you should still have my number, if not, mail me via my profile I will send you my mobile.

Kind regards

Ash.

alex s

2,105 posts

265 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
Ash, why can you not see the point in having the 5 speed and LSD??

The only weak point in the 5 speed is the open diff, I have never heard of an lsd equipped 5 speed failing, where as the 6 speed has been known to let go in 5th!!

Also back to the real world here, the cost differance between just installing a lsd in his current 5 speed and upgrading to a 6 speed is massive, for the 6 speed from plans with the mods you suggest is going to be well over 6K, as it requires various other bits changed (wishbones, new speedo senders and fitting, fuel tank etc.)
If he is not going for big power, then a good condition 5 speed with LSD will be more than up to the job. and save him a LOT of money.


MadMacMcMad

Original Poster:

1,267 posts

283 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
Alex
That is what I intend to do. I am deliberating shot peening the 5 Speed, but may be pointless unless I intend taking it over 400HP and over 360ft lb's.

I am looking forward to LSD. Open diff is a pain off the lights!

NobleGuy

7,133 posts

244 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
Beware of that understeer. If no-one had mentioned it prior to me getting the car back I would maybe have thought there was something wrong with the car still. Completely used to it now and there's probably not that much difference in reality, but at the time...

Ash 996 GT2

3,836 posts

270 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
alex s said:
Ash, why can you not see the point in having the 5 speed and LSD??

The only weak point in the 5 speed is the open diff, I have never heard of an lsd equipped 5 speed failing, where as the 6 speed has been known to let go in 5th!!

Also back to the real world here, the cost differance between just installing a lsd in his current 5 speed and upgrading to a 6 speed is massive, for the 6 speed from plans with the mods you suggest is going to be well over 6K, as it requires various other bits changed (wishbones, new speedo senders and fitting, fuel tank etc.)
If he is not going for big power, then a good condition 5 speed with LSD will be more than up to the job. and save him a LOT of money.
Good point, that will teach me to read before I type.

I thought the gearbox had gone as well, which is why I did not see the point.

I would still do the shot peen, it will have a lot less drag and changing will be quicker and slicker. Also, less drag more BHP to the wheels.

If its out, do it.

I had mine done at the Gearboxman and they did a great job.

OK, Next post please for me to miss read!

Keep em coming wink

MadMacMcMad

Original Poster:

1,267 posts

283 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
This is getting scarily expensive.
New 5 speed, Clutch, LSD, crank seal cause it's seeping and I'm already into £4.6K.
With shot peening I am looking at another £700+
Realistically I'll have no change from 6K.

Does it really need the shot peening?

Ash 996 GT2

3,836 posts

270 months

Tuesday 15th April 2008
quotequote all
MadMacMcMad said:
This is getting scarily expensive.
New 5 speed, Clutch, LSD, crank seal cause it's seeping and I'm already into £4.6K.
With shot peening I am looking at another £700+
Realistically I'll have no change from 6K.

Does it really need the shot peening?
Where did you get the quote for that?

Did you try Gearboxman?

No, you don't need it, it is a "like to have".