just got fined.
Discussion
Went to Islington a few weeks ago for a friends birthday driving up the road to his house and came to a part of the road where on either side of the road the traffic is directed between the pavement and a set of bollards with a speed bump. and there’s a larger gap in the middle with hatching. Now the M3 grounds on most speed bumps and due to the width of the section of road being very thin i couldn't even approach at an angle.
Therefore I went through the middle of the road which is hatched, presumably for vehicles which are to wide to go through the speed control. Personally I don't really think it justifies a £60 (or £120 if i don't pay it two weeks) fine for simply avoiding damaging my car. I can be seen from the photos that there were no other cars around and therefore I had nothing to gain.
Has anyone every argued this and been successful? or should I just pay it and add this to the list of reasons i don't like going to London?
Therefore I went through the middle of the road which is hatched, presumably for vehicles which are to wide to go through the speed control. Personally I don't really think it justifies a £60 (or £120 if i don't pay it two weeks) fine for simply avoiding damaging my car. I can be seen from the photos that there were no other cars around and therefore I had nothing to gain.
Has anyone every argued this and been successful? or should I just pay it and add this to the list of reasons i don't like going to London?
Is it a choice of a fixed penalty or court appearance, or is it a civil matter only?
If you could prove that your car would come to harm if you used the speed hump, it might mitigate well against the penalty for a criminal matter, and give you grounds to negotiate if it's a civil one.
I would imagine, if it's civil, that the council would rather not have it highlighted that their road furniture was damaging cars and have to deal with the potential action from other road users.
If you could prove that your car would come to harm if you used the speed hump, it might mitigate well against the penalty for a criminal matter, and give you grounds to negotiate if it's a civil one.
I would imagine, if it's civil, that the council would rather not have it highlighted that their road furniture was damaging cars and have to deal with the potential action from other road users.
Once again I'm outraged that our once world leading country has been reduced to raising money by sitting gimps in front of CCTV monitors. How cynical. Create an obstruction then film/fine people harmlessly avoiding it.
Please PLEASE send your account to the papers. These scum need shutting down.
SM
Please PLEASE send your account to the papers. These scum need shutting down.
SM
blueyes said:
I had two E30 M3s.
Never had a problem with speed humps.
Perhaps they are making them bigger.
E30 would have been fine but the E36 grounds out alot, Never had a problem with speed humps.
Perhaps they are making them bigger.
The ferry a couple of weeks ago was interesting thought i might end up pulling the cats off, its not to bad if you approch the speed bumps at an angle. Its is lowered but only my a tiny amount, I think eibach quote 10 or 15mm
andye30m3 said:
blueyes said:
I had two E30 M3s.
Never had a problem with speed humps.
Perhaps they are making them bigger.
E30 would have been fine but the E36 grounds out alot, Never had a problem with speed humps.
Perhaps they are making them bigger.
The ferry a couple of weeks ago was interesting thought i might end up pulling the cats off, its not to bad if you approch the speed bumps at an angle. Its is lowered but only my a tiny amount, I think eibach quote 10 or 15mm

Whether your particular car is affected or not, one can imagine a situation where a car somewhere cannot go over a speed hump. This case seems to imply that in this situation you have no leeway other than to turn round and use another route. When there's a gaping hole right next to you then that's hard to stomach.
It's good that these humps are monitored by CCTV to ensure that nobody misuses the gaping hole. Presumably the CCTV operator is incented on the number of people he prosecutes, and perhaps his salary is paid out of the fines (as most of TfL's must be paid for out of congestion charge fines). That way, he makes sure nobody with a nice car gets away with the heinous crime of using the gaping hole when they could simply damage their car instead.
Get a 4x4... oh no, that's not the right answer. Well get a jacking kit for your BMW instead
. Might ruin the handling but it will do wonders for the looks....
It's good that these humps are monitored by CCTV to ensure that nobody misuses the gaping hole. Presumably the CCTV operator is incented on the number of people he prosecutes, and perhaps his salary is paid out of the fines (as most of TfL's must be paid for out of congestion charge fines). That way, he makes sure nobody with a nice car gets away with the heinous crime of using the gaping hole when they could simply damage their car instead.
Get a 4x4... oh no, that's not the right answer. Well get a jacking kit for your BMW instead
. Might ruin the handling but it will do wonders for the looks....herewego said:
A standard car should not ground on regulation height humps. Has the car been lowered?
Sorry, but I don't agree with that.One might have a car that is perfectly legal and suitable for normal road use, but if it has an unusually low front apron or skirt (or whatever we call it) damage may be sustained when it arrives at a speed hump, and drivers should not be presented with this problem.
We should be getting rid of speed humps, and most of the other so-called traffic calming clutter, and dealing with the small(ish) minority of road users that lead people to want this rubbish in the first place - then it needn't be inflicted on the rest of us.
Yes, I appreciate that we get a lot of this approach to problems, but I get fed up of the decently behaved majority being inconvenienced by measures introduced in an attempt to deal with a relatively small number of idiots.
Best wishes all,
Dave.
herewego said:
A standard car should not ground on regulation height humps. Has the car been lowered?
Hogwash. My standard GT2 often scrapes the lower black bit under the front spoiler. And I ease up onto/over humps as slowly as humanly possible.I'm tempted to claim on my insurance for it and name (for example) my gym as the perpetrators of the damage. You can hear it chatter over their humps.
SM
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



