Sale of Goods Act
Author
Discussion

R32

Original Poster:

401 posts

283 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
I know this is non motoring related, but there seem to be some very knowledgable people on here so hopefully someone can help.

I've returned some faulty computer memory to the shop where I bought it over a month ago. They tested it in the shop and confirmed it was faulty. However as they did not have any replacements in stock, it would have to be sent back to their 'supplier' for repair.

Now I've waited 30 working days and contacted them and they say they are willing to offer me a refund of £15 less that I originally paid (£85). Apparently this is correct under the sale of goods act if I have had some 'benefit from the goods' (4 months).

I've never come across this before, whenever I've taken other goods back that are faulty I've normally had a full refund. So, is their offer fair, and should I accept?

Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
Hismile

I own a computer shop and the answer is no you should not accept there "offer"

Its faulty, they admitted that so its FULL refund time...

If they try and deny that, tell them you are off to Trading Standards to report them, that should get their attention....

All the best Brett smile

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
If it's faulty and the shop has admitted as much then they will get their refund from their supplier and so should refund you in full.As for "repairing" memory...I don't think it'll happen.....

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
That seems a bit random. Chancers I bet.

Your rights under the Act is for the item to last a reasonable amount of time.

It has not done so, so you have returned it for replacement or repair. The seemingly cannot replace it, or repair it, so thus they should refund what you paid for it, not an amount they see is 'fair'.

I would inform them this, and if they want to call on a part of the Act then perhaps they can highlight the part which personally does not make sense to me!

R32

Original Poster:

401 posts

283 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
Hmm reading the Sale of Goods act highlights on the web though, seems to suggest they may be correct:

"Under the Sale of Goods Act, the retailer must either repair or replace the goods 'within a reasonable time but without causing significant inconvenience'. If the seller doesn't do this, you are entitled to claim either:

reduction on the purchase price, or
your money back, minus an amount for the usage you've had of the goods (called 'recision')."


This 'recision' term is what they have quoted in the eMail back to be.

They key here seems to be what length of time has elapsed where I am deemed to have accepted the goods. From what I'm reading 4 months may well be long enough for that to be true.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
Was it working when you bought it?

R32

Original Poster:

401 posts

283 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
Was it working when you bought it?
Yes it was. The memory worked for around 4 months before failing.

Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
R32 said:
10 Pence Short said:
Was it working when you bought it?
Yes it was. The memory worked for around 4 months before failing.
Hi smile

Its a matter of how long is acceptable...i.e how long it "SHOULD" last..

Memory usually lasts for years and if its only lasted 4 months its NOT reasonable....

Memory CANNOT be repaired by the way....and as the shop WILL get a full refund or replacement from its supplier , so should you....

If its "branded" memory (Kingston, OCZ,Geil etc) you could contact the memory manufacturer direct, I am sure any of the big memory companies will replace it (but not refund)

All the best Brett smile

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
Trading Standards have their fingers on the pulse in relation to such matters.

Have a word with your local office ( its free). I think you may find that goods have to be of merchantable quality and going duff after only four months is not so.

As I say they can give you it from the horses mouth.

dvd

Jasandjules

72,688 posts

260 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
If a product goes wrong within six months the burden of proof effectively switches to the seller to prove that it was of "merchantable quality" (in old speak - i.e. how I was taught...)...

Whilst you have had the benefit of the item, it's gone wrong. They have the ability to offer a refund or repair. I'd demand a full refund.

7db

6,060 posts

261 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
You had some benefit - are you arguing that you shouldn't pay for it, or that it has no value?

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
7db said:
You had some benefit - are you arguing that you shouldn't pay for it, or that it has no value?
Equally he has been inconvenienced by goods not of merchantable quality.

R32

Original Poster:

401 posts

283 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
7db said:
You had some benefit - are you arguing that you shouldn't pay for it, or that it has no value?
Not quite sure how to answer this. Obviously I've had some benefit from it for 4 months, and ideally I'd be happy with a replacement or repaired item. However they cant supply a replacment as its not stocked any more and it doesn't look like it can be repaired, so the only option I have available to me is a refund-£15 'benefit'.


tigger1

8,485 posts

252 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
R32 said:
7db said:
You had some benefit - are you arguing that you shouldn't pay for it, or that it has no value?
Not quite sure how to answer this. Obviously I've had some benefit from it for 4 months, and ideally I'd be happy with a replacement or repaired item. However they cant supply a replacment as its not stocked any more and it doesn't look like it can be repaired, so the only option I have available to me is a refund-£15 'benefit'.
You paid £85 for memory 4 months ago, they offer you £70 now...as a refund.

You didn't say what sort / how much memory, but in 4 months the price will have dropped. You may well get "like-for-like" for £70 by now.

7db

6,060 posts

261 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
s2art said:
7db said:
You had some benefit - are you arguing that you shouldn't pay for it, or that it has no value?
Equally he has been inconvenienced by goods not of merchantable quality.
The law doesn't seem to price in his inconvenience or other consequential losses. It rarely does.

7db

6,060 posts

261 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
R32 said:
so the only option I have available to me is a refund-£15 'benefit'.
I think you have three options:-

i) take their offer
ii) complain to TS
iii) take an action

It does rather depend on how much you value your time. I'd be taking the money and not dealing with them again.

TS are nice in theory, but I've had little luck with them in practice.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
7db said:
s2art said:
7db said:
You had some benefit - are you arguing that you shouldn't pay for it, or that it has no value?
Equally he has been inconvenienced by goods not of merchantable quality.
The law doesn't seem to price in his inconvenience or other consequential losses. It rarely does.
I would have thought this aspect is factored in to the equation regarding how long you had use of the goods and what would be the expected lifespan. Hence if it only lasted a few weeks the norm is to get a full refund even though you have had some use of it.

HRG

72,863 posts

270 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
The price of memory is going down at the moment. You can probably order an equivalent item for £70 now anyway. If that's the case, what's the problem?

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
7db said:
R32 said:
so the only option I have available to me is a refund-£15 'benefit'.
I think you have three options:-

i) take their offer
ii) complain to TS
iii) take an action

It does rather depend on how much you value your time. I'd be taking the money and not dealing with them again.

TS are nice in theory, but I've had little luck with them in practice.
Agreed.

TS may chase them up, but it does look like in effect they are compliant. It is just whether it is truly impossible for them to replace it. I would suggest that it is but it is easier and simpler for them to refund you. £15 does seem like a figure pulled out of the air, and to be frank for £15 they have lost your future custom.

Can you get the memory for £70? If so I would take the money and buy it elsewhere. The 'endgame' is that you got what you wanted.

R32

Original Poster:

401 posts

283 months

Monday 14th April 2008
quotequote all
HRG said:
The price of memory is going down at the moment. You can probably order an equivalent item for £70 now anyway. If that's the case, what's the problem?
Well the memory I ordered isn't available any more (Kingston 2G Hyper X 800mhz CL3 3-3-3-10). Looking on the site I bought it from they only have Kingston CL4 memory at around the same price I paid for the CL3 memory.

I think the least hassle option for me is to accept the offer. Thanks for the advice folks smile