Fiddling the timing to earn revenue from RLCs
Discussion
techdirt.com said:
Just last month there was the latest in a rather long line of reports noting that red light cameras tend to increase the number of accidents because people slam on their brakes to stop in time, leading to rear-ending accidents.
Time and time again studies have shown that if cities really wanted to make traffic crossings safer there's a very simple way to do so: increase the length of the yellow light and make sure there's a pause before the cross traffic light turns green (this is done in some places, but not in many others).
Tragically, it looks like some cities are doing the opposite! ... six US cities have been caught decreasing the length of the yellow light below the legal limits in an effort to catch more drivers running red lights and increasing revenue. This is especially disgusting. These cities are actively putting more people in danger of serious injury or death solely for the sake of raising revenue -- while claiming all along that it's for safety purposes.
Is it any surprise that one of the six cities is Dallas? ..., just last month Dallas decided it wasn't going to install any more red light cameras because fewer tickets had hurt city revenue.
OK, it's in the USA ... but why do I keep thinking this is something TfL would do?Time and time again studies have shown that if cities really wanted to make traffic crossings safer there's a very simple way to do so: increase the length of the yellow light and make sure there's a pause before the cross traffic light turns green (this is done in some places, but not in many others).
Tragically, it looks like some cities are doing the opposite! ... six US cities have been caught decreasing the length of the yellow light below the legal limits in an effort to catch more drivers running red lights and increasing revenue. This is especially disgusting. These cities are actively putting more people in danger of serious injury or death solely for the sake of raising revenue -- while claiming all along that it's for safety purposes.
Is it any surprise that one of the six cities is Dallas? ..., just last month Dallas decided it wasn't going to install any more red light cameras because fewer tickets had hurt city revenue.
Streaky
Amber light duration in the UK is set down by Parliament - local authorities have no power to set it at anthing other than 2 seconds red/amber and 3 seconds "leaving amber". So TfL or anybody else would have to go to Parliament (not saying that they wouldn't, just that it's not as easy as turning a switch).
However TRL have recently carried out research into varying the amber period (albeit on high-speed roads) and concluded that the system should remain as it is. There is little chance of Pariament making changes to the current legal requirement.
However TRL have recently carried out research into varying the amber period (albeit on high-speed roads) and concluded that the system should remain as it is. There is little chance of Pariament making changes to the current legal requirement.
tvrgit said:
Amber light duration in the UK is set down by Parliament - local authorities have no power to set it at anthing other than 2 seconds red/amber and 3 seconds "leaving amber".
Under the guidance of Ken Livingstone, TfL and other parts of London's local government have occasionally (and more often) set themself above or outside the law ... with Ken everlastingly excusing their actions under the pretext of saving the planet or fighting racism.What makes you think TfL would not break the law (I mean some of them must drive cars
)?These days, an organisation that breaks the law (apart from H&S and anything that OfThingy can use to generate revenue to the Exchequer) ) gets away with relatively little penalty and less embarrassment ... especially if it's a government organisation
.treaky
Can't stop them breaking the law if that's what they want to do.
I would hope though that anybody "in the know", caught by a red light camera where the amber had been shortened illegally, would not only get their FPN overturned but every other one at that same site.
Even more important, god forbid, I would hope that anybody seriously injured as a result of a collision at any junction with non-standard amber timings would sue the individual who made that decision (in addition to the corporate body responsibe for employing him) for every single penny he had, and then some more...
Only the congenitally stupid would leave themselves in that position. No wait, hang on... I see your point...
I would hope though that anybody "in the know", caught by a red light camera where the amber had been shortened illegally, would not only get their FPN overturned but every other one at that same site.
Even more important, god forbid, I would hope that anybody seriously injured as a result of a collision at any junction with non-standard amber timings would sue the individual who made that decision (in addition to the corporate body responsibe for employing him) for every single penny he had, and then some more...
Only the congenitally stupid would leave themselves in that position. No wait, hang on... I see your point...
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


