Question about being stopped at the roadside?
Discussion
Hi there just wondering if anyone could help me, my younger brother was stopped last night at 11.20pm near our home. He was told he had been stopped because the car was flagged up as having no insurance. my brother explained that the policy was changed from the 12/04/08 as his old policy expired. The explained he wasnt on the insurance database and futhermore they wanted to breathalyse him. He agreed and this was negative. They gave him a producer and then did something ive never heard of before probably silly but they took his fingerprints. He never asked why this was and never asked if he minded having this done and assumed it was something they did as hes never had a producer before.
I checked with the control room this morning and they said officers had the power to do this by the roadside but i was really under the impression that the person had to volunteer this information? Can someone clarify this for me.
Thankyou xx
I checked with the control room this morning and they said officers had the power to do this by the roadside but i was really under the impression that the person had to volunteer this information? Can someone clarify this for me.
Thankyou xx
saw something about this on one of those 'police, stop, road, war, street,' programs
The scanner doesn't keep your prints, but runs through the plod database to see if you're a wanted naughty lad.
They used it on someone who they thought was pretending to be someone else, and it took about 30 secs to bring up the photo of him, with his real name, and anything else interesting.
Good stuff I reckon to be honest.
The scanner doesn't keep your prints, but runs through the plod database to see if you're a wanted naughty lad.
They used it on someone who they thought was pretending to be someone else, and it took about 30 secs to bring up the photo of him, with his real name, and anything else interesting.
Good stuff I reckon to be honest.
Edited by bryan35 on Tuesday 15th April 11:22
sabina1986 said:
Hi again thanks for your answers just to clarify they took the prints on an ink pad and made my brother put them on the back of the police officers copy of the producer? I hope this helps.
That's not the system under test, neither is it normal. There's something wrong with or missing from your brother's account - StreakyI thougt that they wern't allowed to do this which is way i asked the control centre why this was done? She said the law was changed 2 years ago to allow the police to do this.
I don't mean to be trivial over the whole thing but it just seems so silly that somone who has comitted no offence and has been courteous and polite should be subjected to give them fingerprints which god knows what they will do with for no apparent reeason!
I don't mean to be trivial over the whole thing but it just seems so silly that somone who has comitted no offence and has been courteous and polite should be subjected to give them fingerprints which god knows what they will do with for no apparent reeason!
I assume your brother came back "no trace" when the various checks were done at the roadside. Rather than arresting him to confirm his ID, the fingerprint was taken so that if he fails to produce his documents, he can (potentially) be ID'd by the fingerprint on the back of the form.
If this is the area I think it is, your brother will have signed a consent form for the print(s) before it was taken.
I think it's only one or two prints that are taken. If brother produces, form is destroyed (along with the prints), they are not retained on a database.
I seem to remember you previously posting a question here on behalf of your brother. Maybe you should get him signed up on PH, then we'll get the story straight from the horse's mouth, as it were.
If this is the area I think it is, your brother will have signed a consent form for the print(s) before it was taken.
I think it's only one or two prints that are taken. If brother produces, form is destroyed (along with the prints), they are not retained on a database.
I seem to remember you previously posting a question here on behalf of your brother. Maybe you should get him signed up on PH, then we'll get the story straight from the horse's mouth, as it were.
This doesn't seem to fit in with Project Lantern
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/6170070.stm
As Dibble states they may well have gone ahead with drivers permission to establish ID later if no docs produced. I am not aware, and stand to be corrected, that they had authority at law, other than no objection from driver,to do this.
Under Project Lantern it was promised that such prints would not be retained. Those in this case could be and as Streaky points out illegal.
dvd
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/6170070.stm
As Dibble states they may well have gone ahead with drivers permission to establish ID later if no docs produced. I am not aware, and stand to be corrected, that they had authority at law, other than no objection from driver,to do this.
Under Project Lantern it was promised that such prints would not be retained. Those in this case could be and as Streaky points out illegal.
dvd
DVD
I think there's two separate things here - Lantern is being piloted - it is basically a portable reader that compares roadside prints with those held on file by NAFIS.
Many forces take (with consent) fingerprints when issuing HORT1s - usually one digit, using a small ink pad, and the print is taken on the back of the form.
I'm a bit out of the loop on this, so if I remember, I'll check into it when I'm back at work.
I think there's two separate things here - Lantern is being piloted - it is basically a portable reader that compares roadside prints with those held on file by NAFIS.
Many forces take (with consent) fingerprints when issuing HORT1s - usually one digit, using a small ink pad, and the print is taken on the back of the form.
I'm a bit out of the loop on this, so if I remember, I'll check into it when I'm back at work.
The OP indicated that permission was not asked (and so not formally given) and it appears that more than one finger was printed. Both unusual - Streaky
PS - thanks to DVD for the reminder that it's Project Lantern. I couldn't get 'Searchlight' out of my mind ... but that was something else entirely
- S
PS - thanks to DVD for the reminder that it's Project Lantern. I couldn't get 'Searchlight' out of my mind ... but that was something else entirely
- SEdited by streaky on Tuesday 15th April 22:37
streaky said:
The OP indicated that permission was not asked (and so not formally given) and it appears that more than one finger was printed. Both unusual - Streaky
PS - thanks to DVD for the reminder that it's Project Lantern. I couldn't get 'Searchlight' out of my mind ... but that was something else entirely
- S
But the OP is telling us a second hand tale, isn't she? Even if her brother was asked to consent, he might have said he wasn't...PS - thanks to DVD for the reminder that it's Project Lantern. I couldn't get 'Searchlight' out of my mind ... but that was something else entirely
- SGranted, she may be exactly right in what she says. It's another of those "We'll probably never know" threads.
Dibble said:
streaky said:
The OP indicated that permission was not asked (and so not formally given) and it appears that more than one finger was printed. Both unusual - Streaky
But the OP is telling us a second hand tale, isn't she? Even if her brother was asked to consent, he might have said he wasn't...Granted, she may be exactly right in what she says. It's another of those "We'll probably never know" threads.
fluffnik said:
Martin_Hx said:
Yep if you have nothing to hide ! Sounds like a good idea to me, catch the feckers
I have nothing to hide but I object to being forced to show it.Being (I might claim) a respectable and civilised individual I am naturally a supporter of the police, and I wouldn't want to handicap them in their pursuit of criminals, but at the same time I'm not happy about being regarded with such suspicion as a matter of course, when it is most likely to be triggered by nothing more than a slight problem with my use of a motor vehicle.
I don't wish to exaggerate this aspect, but if too many people get the feeling that they're going to be under suspicion whenever the police show interest in them, it may cause alienation that can do more harm than good. We don't want to end up with the feeling that the police are on one side (the government and themselves) and the rest of us are on the other side.
Best wishes all,
Dave.
Edited by p1esk on Thursday 17th April 06:45
p1esk said:
I don't wish to exaggerate this aspect, but if too many people get the feeling that they're going to be under suspicion whenever the police show interest in them, it may cause alienation that can do more harm than good. We don't want to end up with the feeling that the police are on one side (the government and themselves) and the rest of us are on the other side.
I think most people feel this happened some time ago.Well thanks for all your replies on this just to clarify a few things people have asked.
My brother had his thumb and index finger from each hand printed using a small ink pad on to the back of the P.C's copy of the producer. He was on his own at the time and having no previous convictions, offences or ever been in trouble for anything before (except the accusations of street racing as per I explained in another thread which was dropped due to lack of evidence)he did not wanting to appear un-coperative and when they advised him they would take these prints he did not question it as he knew no better.
As mentioned before I am not opposed to the idea of people who have commited crimes being caught and punised, but I do feel as though the world is becoming more of a 'big brother' enviroment than ever before.
I have asked my brother whether he was asked permission and he said no it was explained as though this was part of the procedure.
I would indeed ask him to sign up but he does struggle with dyslexia and sometimes its easier for me to type for him (although my spelling can be just as bad so appologies for that!)
My brother had his thumb and index finger from each hand printed using a small ink pad on to the back of the P.C's copy of the producer. He was on his own at the time and having no previous convictions, offences or ever been in trouble for anything before (except the accusations of street racing as per I explained in another thread which was dropped due to lack of evidence)he did not wanting to appear un-coperative and when they advised him they would take these prints he did not question it as he knew no better.
As mentioned before I am not opposed to the idea of people who have commited crimes being caught and punised, but I do feel as though the world is becoming more of a 'big brother' enviroment than ever before.
I have asked my brother whether he was asked permission and he said no it was explained as though this was part of the procedure.
I would indeed ask him to sign up but he does struggle with dyslexia and sometimes its easier for me to type for him (although my spelling can be just as bad so appologies for that!)
He may have been asked to provide the finger prints on the back of the form if he had no other photo id with him, so he was unnable to confirm his ID, the prints will not go on a database they will stay on the form and only be used if he were to fail to produce and turn up at court saying, "it wasnt me i wasnt there" then they have the prints to either confirm or deny the presence of the accused in court.
Slider.
You have a larger library than me.
As far as I can make out Section 61 Pace (fingerprints) was amended by 116/7 SOCPA to include taking of prints at the road side where offence suspected (fail to produce DL on demand) and ID in doubt. But surely this was in connection with the use of the Electronic Finger Print Checker as mentioned in Lantern which are discarded.
In the case reported the print was actually taken and RETAINED at the time and because there could be no record that it was done (like a PNC check)could be fed into system.
Possibly is above board as why would Plod carry an ink pad about with him unless it is one bought by himself from WH Smith to prove false details if this occurred.
Any further information would be appreciated as I am just trying to understand........
To the poster who deplores taking of prints under such circumstances. Be aware that it seems to be a common view that giving false details to Plod is a norm to get off matters. If people told the truth such procedures would not be required.
dvd
You have a larger library than me.
As far as I can make out Section 61 Pace (fingerprints) was amended by 116/7 SOCPA to include taking of prints at the road side where offence suspected (fail to produce DL on demand) and ID in doubt. But surely this was in connection with the use of the Electronic Finger Print Checker as mentioned in Lantern which are discarded.
In the case reported the print was actually taken and RETAINED at the time and because there could be no record that it was done (like a PNC check)could be fed into system.
Possibly is above board as why would Plod carry an ink pad about with him unless it is one bought by himself from WH Smith to prove false details if this occurred.
Any further information would be appreciated as I am just trying to understand........
To the poster who deplores taking of prints under such circumstances. Be aware that it seems to be a common view that giving false details to Plod is a norm to get off matters. If people told the truth such procedures would not be required.
dvd
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


