Day in court....
Discussion
In light of the other thread I have been posting on (and the fella due in court tomorrow!) - can someone who has been there and done it, or has insider knowledge of how the courts work please let me know what to expect?
I have Vesuvius advice from another thread - which is obviously a great start. However from the summons I have received it appears I have the following choice:-
When it goes to court, will I get the chance to speak? Will I get the chance to put my own statement across? Or do I only get this if I object to the statement?
I have Vesuvius advice from another thread - which is obviously a great start. However from the summons I have received it appears I have the following choice:-
- To accept the coppers statement - even though it is not true - in which case he does not have to turn up in court
- To object to the coppers statement - but then copper has to attend, and costs will spiral. I know I will be found guilty - so I will have to pay for any additional costs.
When it goes to court, will I get the chance to speak? Will I get the chance to put my own statement across? Or do I only get this if I object to the statement?
If the statement of the PC wrongly gives evidence of an offence then it is up to you, depending whether or not the offence was committed, to accept or plead Not Guilty. As you say a NG plea should ensure the attendance of PC who will be called into the witness box and after his evidence, you or your brief will be given the opportunity to cross examine.
In a Guilty plea obviously this will not apply as no witnesses will be called. However, the Clerk of the Court, should give you your five minutes for mitigation purposes and this will be either on oath after which you can be questioned, or a statement made from the well of the Court, not under oath and upon which you can be asked no questions. During either, if the matter you wish to raise is pertinent then you can raise
errors in Plod statement. Clerk may remind you however that you should have pleaded NG.
If you are going down the Guilty road make sure you advise the Clerk that you have factors to be put forward.
Be aware that there will be (or should be) a Court Duty Solicitor present who, if he isn't too busy, may settle some of your doubts.
dvd
In a Guilty plea obviously this will not apply as no witnesses will be called. However, the Clerk of the Court, should give you your five minutes for mitigation purposes and this will be either on oath after which you can be questioned, or a statement made from the well of the Court, not under oath and upon which you can be asked no questions. During either, if the matter you wish to raise is pertinent then you can raise
errors in Plod statement. Clerk may remind you however that you should have pleaded NG.
If you are going down the Guilty road make sure you advise the Clerk that you have factors to be put forward.
Be aware that there will be (or should be) a Court Duty Solicitor present who, if he isn't too busy, may settle some of your doubts.
dvd
Edited by Dwight VanDriver on Wednesday 16th April 07:42
Fats25 said:
There does not seem to be an option to plead guilty, but question the validity of the statement.
You are describing a Newton Hearing. These are effectively mini-trials to decide on matters which might effect sentencing ie they are carried out when a defendant pleads guilty to the charge(s) brought, but disputes the facts as presented. In the present case, for instance, you would accept that you were speeding (and would be prepared to enter a guilty plea, accordingly), but at a speed much lower than has been alleged. To make an application for a hearing, you could compose for the court a letter which states that you are willing to enter a guilty plea but that you dispute the prosecution's version of events.
What I would say is this; as has been said, there is the facility to stand in the dock, provide some mitigation and answer questions to the Magistrates. It may be a time to bring up issues with the evidence of the police officer, but if it was me, I wouldn't push that too hard. The Police officer isn't there to offer his answers to your allegations and the Magistrates may well remind you that you're pleading guilty and should have had a trial if you didn't agree with the evidence.
If the parts you disagree with are relatively minor, I would sit tight, accept them and move on. By arguing over small points it may come across as sour grapes which won't help with leniency. After all, you seem willing to plead guilty to the offence itself.
If the evidence you disagree with is substantial and would have a large material effect on the potential sentence, yet you're still pleading guilty to the speeding element, you should be able to request a Newton Hearing. This is a hearing where your guilt is not in doubt, but witnesses can be called and evidence tested. I would only consider this if you were confident that you were able to demonstrate the evidence was false. If it simply comes down to a police officer's word against yours, I would seriously ask you what chance you may have. From the legal advice I have had, where defendants have had Newton Hearings and there was not a good reason for doing so, Magistrates and Judges take a dim view and are less inclined to show leniency.
If the parts you disagree with are relatively minor, I would sit tight, accept them and move on. By arguing over small points it may come across as sour grapes which won't help with leniency. After all, you seem willing to plead guilty to the offence itself.
If the evidence you disagree with is substantial and would have a large material effect on the potential sentence, yet you're still pleading guilty to the speeding element, you should be able to request a Newton Hearing. This is a hearing where your guilt is not in doubt, but witnesses can be called and evidence tested. I would only consider this if you were confident that you were able to demonstrate the evidence was false. If it simply comes down to a police officer's word against yours, I would seriously ask you what chance you may have. From the legal advice I have had, where defendants have had Newton Hearings and there was not a good reason for doing so, Magistrates and Judges take a dim view and are less inclined to show leniency.
You guys (as usual!) have pretty much hit the nail on the head.
I don't dispute the offence, or even the speed. It happened. I have to suck it up and accept the punishment. The piece he has wrong is this...
He makes it out as if it was my statement - when in fact it was his questions, and my answers. There is a huge difference. From reading his statement, the copper is not very bright (although I am not going to say that!).
As I have said, I was speeding, and as such (perhaps morally) - I feel I should plead guilty. At the end of the day it is a guy doing his job, and not a camera.
As long as I get a chance to speak, then I plan on giving my own statement of events, then any mitigating circumstance, followed by a plea to keep my licence!
So from the above - I plan on pleading guilty, and having my 5 mins to talk, followed by pants down and punishment. Does that make sense?
I don't dispute the offence, or even the speed. It happened. I have to suck it up and accept the punishment. The piece he has wrong is this...
- He states that he saw me on the M26 and observed that I was exceeding speed limit. I was.
- He then states that he followed me onto the M20 where he observed at 0.25 mile intervals that I was doing a constant 105mph. I wasn't. I may have joined the M20 at that speed, but when I reached the motorway there was lots of traffic, and I am not filtering at those speeds. He then pulled me over approx 2 miles later, when I was sitting at 70.
He makes it out as if it was my statement - when in fact it was his questions, and my answers. There is a huge difference. From reading his statement, the copper is not very bright (although I am not going to say that!).
As I have said, I was speeding, and as such (perhaps morally) - I feel I should plead guilty. At the end of the day it is a guy doing his job, and not a camera.
As long as I get a chance to speak, then I plan on giving my own statement of events, then any mitigating circumstance, followed by a plea to keep my licence!
So from the above - I plan on pleading guilty, and having my 5 mins to talk, followed by pants down and punishment. Does that make sense?
Fats25 said:
I don't dispute the offence, or even the speed. It happened.
In that case, there seems little point in applying for a Newton Hearing. If you don't dispute the key facts of the case, then this would serve no purpose other than to escalate the prosecution's costs.For damage limitation, if a guilty plea is entered at the first reasonable opportunity, the magistrates are directed to reduce the sentence (ie the fine) by up to one third.
You will be offered the opportuinty to speak / mitigate before the magistrates decide on the sentence. With this in mind, the advice offered by Vesuvius is sound - dress smartly, be polite and contrite and hope that the bench is sympathetic.
Best of luck..

Edited by SS2. on Wednesday 16th April 09:24
Quick update from todays court.
Firstly thanks to those for the advice re the appearance, and generally standing out from others that were in court today - especially the guy about my age that was nipping outside to drink his Kestral super whilst waiting his turn.
To summarise - I was stopped for speeding in October, and I have never denied it. Was going very fast - summons arrived last Tuesday stating 105 mph on a motorway. This was my first piece of luck.
Turned up at court today - Pleaded Guilty - and then stated my version of events, also with a character witness from my copper mate, and a statement about joining local IAM (for bikes). Was asked for any reasons why I should not be disqualified, as I was looking at a disqual - and stated that i was presently seeking new employment, and that it would be advantageous to keep licence.
They retired to the room for 5 mins, then when they came back said that they were please to see that I had sought advanced road riding training, prior to the summons coming through, and that it had shown responsibility.
Verdict - 6 Points - £35 costs, £15 criminal injuries, and £250 fine.
I am a lucky boy.
Although as P1esk says on another recent thread - I don't feel that lucky......... but that is another conversation!
Again - Thanks for those that offered help and advice. Going out on the bike now to celebrate!
Firstly thanks to those for the advice re the appearance, and generally standing out from others that were in court today - especially the guy about my age that was nipping outside to drink his Kestral super whilst waiting his turn.
To summarise - I was stopped for speeding in October, and I have never denied it. Was going very fast - summons arrived last Tuesday stating 105 mph on a motorway. This was my first piece of luck.
Turned up at court today - Pleaded Guilty - and then stated my version of events, also with a character witness from my copper mate, and a statement about joining local IAM (for bikes). Was asked for any reasons why I should not be disqualified, as I was looking at a disqual - and stated that i was presently seeking new employment, and that it would be advantageous to keep licence.
They retired to the room for 5 mins, then when they came back said that they were please to see that I had sought advanced road riding training, prior to the summons coming through, and that it had shown responsibility.
Verdict - 6 Points - £35 costs, £15 criminal injuries, and £250 fine.
I am a lucky boy.
Although as P1esk says on another recent thread - I don't feel that lucky......... but that is another conversation!
Again - Thanks for those that offered help and advice. Going out on the bike now to celebrate!
Fats25 said:
Quick update from todays court.
Firstly thanks to those for the advice re the appearance, and generally standing out from others that were in court today - especially the guy about my age that was nipping outside to drink his Kestral super whilst waiting his turn.
To summarise - I was stopped for speeding in October, and I have never denied it. Was going very fast - summons arrived last Tuesday stating 105 mph on a motorway. This was my first piece of luck.
Turned up at court today - Pleaded Guilty - and then stated my version of events, also with a character witness from my copper mate, and a statement about joining local IAM (for bikes). Was asked for any reasons why I should not be disqualified, as I was looking at a disqual - and stated that i was presently seeking new employment, and that it would be advantageous to keep licence.
They retired to the room for 5 mins, then when they came back said that they were please to see that I had sought advanced road riding training, prior to the summons coming through, and that it had shown responsibility.
Verdict - 6 Points - £35 costs, £15 criminal injuries, and £250 fine.
I am a lucky boy.
Although as P1esk says on another recent thread - I don't feel that lucky......... but that is another conversation!
Again - Thanks for those that offered help and advice. Going out on the bike now to celebrate!
I would say that's a good result.Firstly thanks to those for the advice re the appearance, and generally standing out from others that were in court today - especially the guy about my age that was nipping outside to drink his Kestral super whilst waiting his turn.
To summarise - I was stopped for speeding in October, and I have never denied it. Was going very fast - summons arrived last Tuesday stating 105 mph on a motorway. This was my first piece of luck.
Turned up at court today - Pleaded Guilty - and then stated my version of events, also with a character witness from my copper mate, and a statement about joining local IAM (for bikes). Was asked for any reasons why I should not be disqualified, as I was looking at a disqual - and stated that i was presently seeking new employment, and that it would be advantageous to keep licence.
They retired to the room for 5 mins, then when they came back said that they were please to see that I had sought advanced road riding training, prior to the summons coming through, and that it had shown responsibility.
Verdict - 6 Points - £35 costs, £15 criminal injuries, and £250 fine.
I am a lucky boy.
Although as P1esk says on another recent thread - I don't feel that lucky......... but that is another conversation!
Again - Thanks for those that offered help and advice. Going out on the bike now to celebrate!
Fats25 said:
Quick update from todays court.
Firstly thanks to those for the advice re the appearance, and generally standing out from others that were in court today - especially the guy about my age that was nipping outside to drink his Kestral super whilst waiting his turn.
To summarise - I was stopped for speeding in October, and I have never denied it. Was going very fast - summons arrived last Tuesday stating 105 mph on a motorway. This was my first piece of luck.
Turned up at court today - Pleaded Guilty - and then stated my version of events, also with a character witness from my copper mate, and a statement about joining local IAM (for bikes). Was asked for any reasons why I should not be disqualified, as I was looking at a disqual - and stated that i was presently seeking new employment, and that it would be advantageous to keep licence.
They retired to the room for 5 mins, then when they came back said that they were please to see that I had sought advanced road riding training, prior to the summons coming through, and that it had shown responsibility.
Verdict - 6 Points - £35 costs, £15 criminal injuries, and £250 fine.
I am a lucky boy.
Although as P1esk says on another recent thread - I don't feel that lucky......... but that is another conversation!
Again - Thanks for those that offered help and advice. Going out on the bike now to celebrate!
Thats what accepting responsibility for actions and taking positive steps to improve your driving gets you. Shame you got the points etc. You seem to have learnt from this the moment your were stopped. Firstly thanks to those for the advice re the appearance, and generally standing out from others that were in court today - especially the guy about my age that was nipping outside to drink his Kestral super whilst waiting his turn.
To summarise - I was stopped for speeding in October, and I have never denied it. Was going very fast - summons arrived last Tuesday stating 105 mph on a motorway. This was my first piece of luck.
Turned up at court today - Pleaded Guilty - and then stated my version of events, also with a character witness from my copper mate, and a statement about joining local IAM (for bikes). Was asked for any reasons why I should not be disqualified, as I was looking at a disqual - and stated that i was presently seeking new employment, and that it would be advantageous to keep licence.
They retired to the room for 5 mins, then when they came back said that they were please to see that I had sought advanced road riding training, prior to the summons coming through, and that it had shown responsibility.
Verdict - 6 Points - £35 costs, £15 criminal injuries, and £250 fine.
I am a lucky boy.
Although as P1esk says on another recent thread - I don't feel that lucky......... but that is another conversation!
Again - Thanks for those that offered help and advice. Going out on the bike now to celebrate!
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


