Caught with no road tax
Author
Discussion

Mr Mot

Original Poster:

38 posts

227 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
Hi folks - this is a "friend of mine" thread (although it is genuine)

He has received a letter from the DVLA this morning requesting that he provide details of who was driving his car a month ago. It wasn't taxed at the time.

From what I can gather he bought the car after it had been stored for 18 months - the car was SORN for those 18 months.
The day in question he was sat on an industrial estate at night time in the car, not actually on the road. He had also MOT'd the car that day intending to tax the car the following day, which he did.

He received a producer and a sticker of some sort (apparently it looks as though it should have been stuck to the windscreen) the sticker states that if he buys tax within the near future no further action will be taken - obviously he did as he bought tax the following day. (it was the middle of the month so he paid for the previous 2 weeks worth retrospectively)

The producer was carried out with no problems as the car was insured and so on.

So, this letter this morning states something along the lines of - he has to provide details of who was driving the car at the time and if he doesn't he could go to court and face a £1000 fine.

My / His question - why are they taking further action when it was stated that no further action would be taken? and what is the likely out come?

It also states on the letter that it was indeed on an industrial estate - tax wouldn't be required anywhere other than if the car was on "the highway" would it?

I asked why he drove the car with no tax and his response was that because he intended to tax it the following morning that he didn't see a problem and had gone out to check the cooling system as it had over heated during the MOT.

Thanks for your time and replies folks : )





Edited by Mr Mot on Wednesday 16th April 12:46

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
More inf required.

'Producer' issued.

By whom, Plod?

How as the 'Producer' issued - stuck on the windscreen?

Does the letter from DVLA state under what legislation they require you to name the driver?

Get the full story please from 'friend' nothing seems to add up in my book.

dvd


Vesuvius 996

35,829 posts

302 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
Original Poster said:
I asked why he drove the car with no tax and his response was that because he intended to tax it the following morning that he didn't see a problem and had gone out to check the cooling system as it had over heated during the MOT.
So he drove the car in public without tax. So he committed the offence then.


esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
How did it get onto the Industrial Estate?This could still be classed as a highway I suppose..

Taita

8,021 posts

234 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
RTA applies to anything 'reasonably accessible to the public' doesn't it. Does the RTA contain bits related to Tax?

Eg thats why an ASDA car park is covered, but if it has barriers down, it doesn't, as it is not reasonably accessible.

IIRC.

Mr Mot

Original Poster:

38 posts

227 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
In response to DVD -
Yes, the producer was issued by plod, in a van with camera's on aparently. (the "caught on CCTV" type.)

Funnily enough he said that the officer seemed as though he was a new starter - it took him a long time to fill both forms out and when he went to produce his documents there was no date on the producer so he got cautioned as they obviously couldn't determine when the producer was given to him. Since then i presume they spoke to the particular officer and determined when it was issued.

Both the producer and the sticker were handed to him, in person there and then.

on the letter it states "you are required by law to give the information of who was driving"

I'll go and have a look at the letter later and see if there's anything else i can make out from it.

He isn't denying the offence, just wondering what is likely to happen i think - and why they have sent this letter after he complied with what the "sticker" requested/ordered.


Edited by Mr Mot on Wednesday 16th April 13:19

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
Bit clearer now.

Appears vehicle seen by Plod without Excise licence on road repairable at public expense.

He issued RT/1 suspecting no Excise licence then possible no other docs.

Docs question resolved when they were produced.

No Excise is a revenue offence, proceedings authorised by DVLA. Plod would submit form to DVLA to the effect vehicle seen on a road without excise. Up to DVLA to decide whether to prosecute.

I was not sure at first whether DVLA had the authority to ask for drivers details and have found that they have:

V.E.R.A 94

46 Duty to give information (1) Where it is alleged that a vehicle has been used on a road in contravention of section 29 (without Excise)
(a) the person keeping the vehicle shall give such information as he may be required to give in accordance with subsection (7) as to the identity of the driver of the vehicle or any person who used the vehicle, and

(b) any other person shall give such information as it is in his power to give and which may lead to the identification of the driver of the vehicle or any person who used the vehicle if he is required to do so in accordance with subsection (7).

(2) Where it is alleged that a vehicle has been kept on a road in contravention of section 29—

(a) the person keeping the vehicle shall give such information as he may be required to give in accordance with subsection
(7) as to the identity of the person who kept the vehicle on the road, and

(b) any other person shall give such information as it is in his power to give and which may lead to the identification of the person who kept the vehicle on the road if he is required to do so in accordance .

Sub Sec 7:
(7) A person is required to give information in accordance with this subsection if he is required to give the information by or on behalf of—
(a) a chief officer of police or, in Northern Ireland, the Chief Constable of the Royal Ulster Constabulary, or
(b) the Secretary of State. (DVLA)


Failure to to do so offence - £1000 fine. No points.

It would therefore appear to be common sense to abide by the law and write back to DVLA with the required information. At the same time it might be prudent to include the fact that the vehicle was licensed the following day as their records will show and to the beginning of the month PROVIDED there are no other occasions when use has been seen/detected by a silent check.

They may play ball as they have the revenue and NFA.

dvd


Mr Mot

Original Poster:

38 posts

227 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
bow Thanks DVD

I'm not aware of anyone that's been through the same process so who knows what will happen - i'll update the thread once my friend has a reply.

Gallen (BPH)

2,166 posts

286 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
If he had MOT'd that car that day, are you not allowed to drive it directly to and from the MOT station without mot / tax?

The key word here is "directly"... You say it was on an industrial estate? Is this where the MOT was done?

Mr Mot

Original Poster:

38 posts

227 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
Unfortunately not, he has plainly admitted to me that he took it out later on in the evening to check the cooling system.
Although it could be argued that it was being driven to the garage around the corner to be dropped off and the keys posted etc..
I'd rather advise him to just fill it in and send it off with a note explaining that he did tax it the following day and that the MOT was completed at 6pm that day so there was no way he could've taxed it.

It all seems a bit strange from what he's explained though, after he followed the "directions" on the back of the sticker he was handed.

jonlwright

1,825 posts

270 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
I believe the car has to be pre-booked into an MOT centre and then you can drive there and back with no tax.

Think best course of action would be to say it was you (sorry your 'friend' wink) driving and that the car was MOT'd that day but suffered an overheating problem and hence the reason he was on the trading estate.

Worst case scenario would be a small fine I suspect.

Mr Mot

Original Poster:

38 posts

227 months

Wednesday 16th April 2008
quotequote all
It genuinely wasn't myself - I'm the kind of person that would just admit it : )

I've just managed to get my hands on the letter - the offence was reported as 9pm, there's no way he can claim that he was driving it back home i guess.

It also states that driving the vehicle whilst untaxed is contrary to section 29 of the vehicle excise and registration act 1994.

As well as stating that it is an offence under section 46 of the vehicle excise and registration act 1994 to not supply the details of who was using or keeping the vehicle at the time of the alleged offence - no one was actually driving the vehicle at the time and it was off the actual road by offices in an industrial estate. Has an actual offence been committed with no one driving it and it being on a private block paved office car park?


Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Thursday 17th April 2008
quotequote all
If the vehicle is 'off' a road repairable at public expense i.e. like the driveway of a private house etc. then Excise Duty can not be claimed. But it can when the vehicle is being driven on a 'public' road to and fro to that location.

Me thinks when Plod issued the RT/1 someone has stated that they drove the vehicle to that location on a 'road'.

Or, DVLA are asking for an admisssion on paper to that they can use at Court to prove driver?

dvd