"Speed Kills" Advertising
Author
Discussion

durbster

Original Poster:

12,144 posts

253 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
I don't know if this has been brought up before, but would there be any point reporting the "Speed Kills" advertising to the ASA, as it is essentially an untruth?

I don't mean the TV ads because they focus on particular statistics, but posters such as plastered on the side of a bus I saw the other day that said "SPEEDING WILL KILL", is surely an entirely baseless statement. Somehow, I doubt Tesco would be allowed to put up an ad up saying, "BUY OUR CABBAGES OR YOU WILL DIE".

Do Government 'messages' have to conform to the ASA guidelines?

Jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
I've reported it.

I think you can guess what the reply was.

alphadog

2,049 posts

264 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
It's like those 'Speeding - What's your excuse?' posters.

I always think 'Because of the stupidly low limit you imposed on that good road that used to be NSL, you @!$$@$s!'mad

tigger1

8,485 posts

252 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
I've reported it.

I think you can guess what the reply was.
"F*ck off and stop speeding"?

durbster

Original Poster:

12,144 posts

253 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
The ASA are an independent organisation though aren't they? Or did they just refuse to open the can of worms? smile

Jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
tigger1 said:
"F*ck off and stop speeding"?
Slightly more polite, however I did point out that I had a clean license, so more along the lines of "all Govt stats show speed kills"...

jwo

989 posts

280 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
it's the sudden stop that kills...

this piffle advertising unfortunately hoodwinks the majority of the population who have no passion/understanding about driving etc. we are in the minority...

justamin

189 posts

237 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
It always amazes me that more people are duped into buying a ladder from B&Q etc when they still sell them without warning's stating "Climbing ladders kills!"

Its the falling from an unsafe ladder that kills...... biggrin

NobleGuy

7,133 posts

246 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
Some flourescent signs were put up on the lamposts near where I live.
I cut them down. This is turning into re-education China style and I'm not having it.
Plus it's bks.

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
I speed every single day to some greater or lesser degree and I am still here after 27 years of doing just that.

had I smoked pot or taken heroin for 27 years I may not be here.
Certainly if I had smoked my existence could be doubtful.

If I ate a kilogram of chocolate every day for 27 year I would probably dead or near death now so in that case chocolate is more dangerous than speeding.

lack of road planning. An ability to read the conditions and driving beyond your abilities or while distracted, tired or not concentrating are the reasons you get killed or kill someone else.

Speed per se doesn't neccessarily kill , certainly not in the same way that cigarette manufacturers have to tell consumers that the product will cause their earlier untimely death.

I certainly know that manufacturers don't yet have to put a sticker on cars saying THIS CAR WILL KILL YOU!

You are quite correct. In the established criteria for advertising the Speed Kills campaign certainly bends the 'Truthful' and 'Honest' part of the 'Legal,decent,honest,truthful' criteria for advertising standards.

In the case of the Bentley crashed by the thieves the other day and ploughed into by the following three police vehicles there was definately some speeding going on by four cars and yet not one person died...

hmmmmmm,,,

rs1952

5,247 posts

290 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
justamin said:
It always amazes me that more people are duped into buying a ladder from B&Q etc when they still sell them without warning's stating "Climbing ladders kills!"

Its the falling from an unsafe ladder that kills...... biggrin
Falling from a ladder is harmless. Its the landing thats the problem .....

Markbishop

173 posts

276 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
The ad that really annoys me is the girl who gets run over and says: 'Hit me at 40mph and there's an 80 percent chance I'll die. Hit me at 30mph and there's an 80 percent chance I'll live' or whatever the percentages are.

Shouldn't it be saying: 'Parents, teach your kids not to step into the road'?

When I was a kid we had Dave Prowse on TV and touring the schools as the Green Cross Code man. A few years earlier they had Tufty delivering a similar message. I'm not sure anyone's doing it today: at any rate, I don't see them on TV. Instead, they're fed the worrying message that if a car mows them down, it must be the driver's fault for going too fast...

g_stacey

644 posts

264 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
[quote=Markbishop]The ad that really annoys me is the girl who gets run over and says: 'Hit me at 40mph and there's an 80 percent chance I'll die. Hit me at 30mph and there's an 80 percent chance I'll live' or whatever the percentages are.

Annoys me as well. Is it saying its alright to hit her at 30?

G

Just_a_guide

251 posts

235 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
g_stacey said:
Markbishop said:
The ad that really annoys me is the girl who gets run over and says: 'Hit me at 40mph and there's an 80 percent chance I'll die. Hit me at 30mph and there's an 80 percent chance I'll live' or whatever the percentages are.

Annoys me as well. Is it saying its alright to hit her at 30?

G
no thats why the 20 mph limits is coming to a road near you soon.

WilliBetz

694 posts

253 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
The appeal of the message presumably lies in its simplicity, and therein lies its danger too.

Don't the writers of these pithy sound bites pause for a moment to consider the implication of their messages - that legal speeds are safe and devoid of risk?

How about "COULD YOU STOP?" as an alternative?

jwo

989 posts

280 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
g_stacey said:
Markbishop said:
The ad that really annoys me is the girl who gets run over and says: 'Hit me at 40mph and there's an 80 percent chance I'll die. Hit me at 30mph and there's an 80 percent chance I'll live' or whatever the percentages are.

Annoys me as well. Is it saying its alright to hit her at 30?

G
It really annoys me that she is in the road not on the pavement.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
g_stacey said:
Markbishop said:
The ad that really annoys me is the girl who gets run over and says: 'Hit me at 40mph and there's an 80 percent chance I'll die. Hit me at 30mph and there's an 80 percent chance I'll live' or whatever the percentages are.
Annoys me as well. Is it saying its alright to hit her at 30?

G
No of course it isn't. Why do you wish to draw that conclusion?

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
WilliBetz said:
The appeal of the message presumably lies in its simplicity, and therein lies its danger too.

Don't the writers of these pithy sound bites pause for a moment to consider the implication of their messages - that legal speeds are safe and devoid of risk?

How about "COULD YOU STOP?" as an alternative?
Wouldn't that bring out the "I've got fancy brakes" brigade?

Mattt

16,664 posts

249 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
herewego said:
g_stacey said:
Markbishop said:
The ad that really annoys me is the girl who gets run over and says: 'Hit me at 40mph and there's an 80 percent chance I'll die. Hit me at 30mph and there's an 80 percent chance I'll live' or whatever the percentages are.
Annoys me as well. Is it saying its alright to hit her at 30?

G
No of course it isn't. Why do you wish to draw that conclusion?
Blair/Gordon/Borisout said that his daughter had just stepped into the road last week, and when he pulled her back and questioned her, her response was along the lines of "It's ok, they'll only be doing 30" due to these ads.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Friday 18th April 2008
quotequote all
Mattt said:
herewego said:
g_stacey said:
Markbishop said:
The ad that really annoys me is the girl who gets run over and says: 'Hit me at 40mph and there's an 80 percent chance I'll die. Hit me at 30mph and there's an 80 percent chance I'll live' or whatever the percentages are.
Annoys me as well. Is it saying its alright to hit her at 30?

G
No of course it isn't. Why do you wish to draw that conclusion?
Blair/Gordon/Borisout said that his daughter had just stepped into the road last week, and when he pulled her back and questioned her, her response was along the lines of "It's ok, they'll only be doing 30" due to these ads.
Where did you read this, do you have a reference?