Driver's u-turn in fatal M4 crash
Discussion
From the BBC here: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/south_west/735503...
BBC said:
A man who did a U-turn on the M4 and drove for five miles in the wrong lane before a head-on crash in which a man died has been jailed for four years.
Thomas Davies, 38, from Llanybydder, Carmarthenshire, had never driven on a motorway and ignored frantic warnings.
He had previously admitted causing the death of Jeffrey Green, 64, of Dyfatty, Swansea, by dangerous driving.
The judge at Swansea Crown Court said no term could erase the anguish of Mr Green's relatives.
The court heard that on 29 September last year Davies, also known as Danny, drove his mother to Morriston Hospital in Swansea to visit his brother.
On leaving he took the wrong turn and ended up on the eastbound carriageway where he continued until he passed Port Talbot.
Realising his mistake, he performed a U-turn and started heading west in the eastbound lane.
Janet Gedrych, prosecuting, said: "All of the witnesses noted the man was travelling calmly and steadily without any apparent recognition that he was doing anything wrong."
The court was shown clips from cameras showing Davies travelling between 45 - 50mph the wrong way down the outside lane.
Motorists on both sides of the carriageway attempted to signal to him, and some who were travelling west on the correct side of the road sped ahead in a bid to alert drivers on the eastbound carriageway.
Davies travelled five-and-a-half miles before crashing head-on with Mr Green's car.
His passengers Paul and Christine Evans both suffered extensive and permanent injuries.
Self-employed jeweller Mr Evans, 51, suffered a fractured skull, lost the sight in one eye and the court was told it was doubtful he would ever work again.
It is unlikely Mrs Evans, 57, will ever walk again, the court heard.
Davies' mother, 67, also sustained serious injuries and was unconscious in hospital for 13 days. Davies suffered minor injuries.
He told police he was not used to roads, was concerned he was running out of petrol and was looking for a roundabout to get back into the correct lane.
Ms Gedrych said Mr Green's widow Barbara was on medication and "since Jeffrey's death she does not see any point in life".
Remorse
Huw Rees, defending, said his client had shown remorse.
Extracts from a psychiatric report read out in court said that Davies "exhibited features of intellectual impairment" and "shows deficits of fully understanding the consequences of his actions".
Mr Rees said Davies "literally did not know how dangerous his actions were".
He said although Davies had held a licence for 11 years, he had never driven on anything but single carriageway roads.
Judge Christopher Morton said: "A life can't be measured in terms of a prison sentence."
He said no term could ever erase "the anguish of those relatives of the deceased".
Davies is to serve half the term in prison and the remainder on licence.
He has already surrendered his licence and was banned from driving for five years.
Are motorway accidents such as these increasing? Or just being reported more? I wonder whether the ongoing justification for not including motorways (or even DCs!) in driving tests can be justified. In addition, there seems to be a subtle indication here (this is the PC BBC) that the guy was ESN or whatever the correct term is now. Should there be an IQ test element of the driving test?Thomas Davies, 38, from Llanybydder, Carmarthenshire, had never driven on a motorway and ignored frantic warnings.
He had previously admitted causing the death of Jeffrey Green, 64, of Dyfatty, Swansea, by dangerous driving.
The judge at Swansea Crown Court said no term could erase the anguish of Mr Green's relatives.
The court heard that on 29 September last year Davies, also known as Danny, drove his mother to Morriston Hospital in Swansea to visit his brother.
On leaving he took the wrong turn and ended up on the eastbound carriageway where he continued until he passed Port Talbot.
Realising his mistake, he performed a U-turn and started heading west in the eastbound lane.
Janet Gedrych, prosecuting, said: "All of the witnesses noted the man was travelling calmly and steadily without any apparent recognition that he was doing anything wrong."
The court was shown clips from cameras showing Davies travelling between 45 - 50mph the wrong way down the outside lane.
Motorists on both sides of the carriageway attempted to signal to him, and some who were travelling west on the correct side of the road sped ahead in a bid to alert drivers on the eastbound carriageway.
Davies travelled five-and-a-half miles before crashing head-on with Mr Green's car.
His passengers Paul and Christine Evans both suffered extensive and permanent injuries.
Self-employed jeweller Mr Evans, 51, suffered a fractured skull, lost the sight in one eye and the court was told it was doubtful he would ever work again.
It is unlikely Mrs Evans, 57, will ever walk again, the court heard.
Davies' mother, 67, also sustained serious injuries and was unconscious in hospital for 13 days. Davies suffered minor injuries.
He told police he was not used to roads, was concerned he was running out of petrol and was looking for a roundabout to get back into the correct lane.
Ms Gedrych said Mr Green's widow Barbara was on medication and "since Jeffrey's death she does not see any point in life".
Remorse
Huw Rees, defending, said his client had shown remorse.
Extracts from a psychiatric report read out in court said that Davies "exhibited features of intellectual impairment" and "shows deficits of fully understanding the consequences of his actions".
Mr Rees said Davies "literally did not know how dangerous his actions were".
He said although Davies had held a licence for 11 years, he had never driven on anything but single carriageway roads.
Judge Christopher Morton said: "A life can't be measured in terms of a prison sentence."
He said no term could ever erase "the anguish of those relatives of the deceased".
Davies is to serve half the term in prison and the remainder on licence.
He has already surrendered his licence and was banned from driving for five years.
I think some steps are being made at covering more information on motorways in the Theory test. This guy passed his test before theory tests were introduced, let alone hazard perception tests. The DSA re looking at incorporating practical motorway elements to the test i believe. To answer you question, i think more of these are occurring, probably because more and more people are driving every year.
Guam said:
Well at least the muppet wasnt exceeding the speed limit so Brake should be happy with this poster boy for road safety
you joke, but remember their response to the woman doing 10mph on the M32 weaving around the place...I would not be surprised if they didn't come out and say that drivers should drive at appropriate speeds to expect some idiot to be doing 50mph in the outside lane IN THE WRONG DIRECTION...
you have to wonder how these people function in society if they cannot grasp basic concepts!
I fail to understand how they can make such errors. It not like motorways or dual carriaageways are "new concepts" 
I have always known from early age that certain user groups are not allowed on motorways und that two or more lanes of vehicles travel at faster speeds in same direction.
If you make error - it not a problem. There are exits which allow the safe return to correct direction in any case.
Personally .. I would have given this village idiot the full 14 years
I suppose he must have had "learning difficulties" of some sort
Und yes.. you are right. BRAKE will come out with the mealy mouthed nonsense over lowering speed limits to accommodate these folk who must, by virtue of not being aware of such basic rules, be way below the intelligence required to drive a vehicle und who should not even be allowed to drive in first place.

I have always known from early age that certain user groups are not allowed on motorways und that two or more lanes of vehicles travel at faster speeds in same direction.

If you make error - it not a problem. There are exits which allow the safe return to correct direction in any case.

Personally .. I would have given this village idiot the full 14 years

I suppose he must have had "learning difficulties" of some sort

Und yes.. you are right. BRAKE will come out with the mealy mouthed nonsense over lowering speed limits to accommodate these folk who must, by virtue of not being aware of such basic rules, be way below the intelligence required to drive a vehicle und who should not even be allowed to drive in first place.

for gods sake if he had learning dificulties (or however it was phrased in the report) he shouldnt have got a licence to start with. driving isnt easy so shouldnt be possible to anyone of that below average intelligence. so what if it makes his life more difficult, i think hes just proved why it should be so.
even a complete arse with the IQ of something i scrape off my shoe could work out you dont drive the wrong way down the motorway.
even a complete arse with the IQ of something i scrape off my shoe could work out you dont drive the wrong way down the motorway.
heebeegeetee said:
>>and some who were travelling west on the correct side of the road sped ahead in a bid to alert drivers on the eastbound carriageway.<<
Well I trust these were dealt with firmly. This shows that speed kills and i expect a forest of cameras forthwith.
why would they need to speed to pass a car quoted as doing 40-50mph?Well I trust these were dealt with firmly. This shows that speed kills and i expect a forest of cameras forthwith.
I know I'll get flamed but I am a bit confused over the sentencing here. If he has such bad learning difficulties that he doesn't know he was doing wrong then surely it's not a malicious act, what's the point of jailing him apart from it may make the victims feel better. By the same token he gets a 5 year ban which is effectively only 3 years, only a lifetime ban in such a case is sufficient as he is clearly a danger on the road.
falcemob said:
I know I'll get flamed but I am a bit confused over the sentencing here. If he has such bad learning difficulties that he doesn't know he was doing wrong then surely it's not a malicious act, what's the point of jailing him apart from it may make the victims feel better. By the same token he gets a 5 year ban which is effectively only 3 years, only a lifetime ban in such a case is sufficient as he is clearly a danger on the road.
Because even if he has such a low intelligence (though how he passed the theory und practical tests 11 years ago has to be pure fluke) - the loss of liberty should tell him he did something very wrong here. He should be banned from even riding a bicycle unsupervised on a public road for life too though

Ja.. Agree. There should be some intelligence/aptitude test on application for a provisional licence. Attitude?
Can be ephemeral at times.. discuss. 
falcemob said:
I know I'll get flamed but I am a bit confused over the sentencing here. If he has such bad learning difficulties that he doesn't know he was doing wrong then surely it's not a malicious act, what's the point of jailing him apart from it may make the victims feel better. By the same token he gets a 5 year ban which is effectively only 3 years, only a lifetime ban in such a case is sufficient as he is clearly a danger on the road.
Can ignorance ever be a valid defence?Agree though, not sure what a jail sentence achieves here. Does he need to be made an example of so that other people won't be so stupid?
It depends what the motivations for a prison sentence are.
1, If it's purely for revenge, in this case it's justified.
2, If it's to keep a dangerous person away from the public, I'm not so sure as the driving ban (should be life IMO) serves that purpose.
3, If it's for rehabilitation it won't work and he should never be allowed to drive again, see No.2.
1, If it's purely for revenge, in this case it's justified.
2, If it's to keep a dangerous person away from the public, I'm not so sure as the driving ban (should be life IMO) serves that purpose.
3, If it's for rehabilitation it won't work and he should never be allowed to drive again, see No.2.
This retard should be locked up for the maximum term available... If it's 14 years, then so be it, if they can lock him up for life (and it means life) then so be it.
NOBODY and I mean NOBODY should be allowed to trot out the "I didn't know about motorways" line and expect it to be taken seriously
Lock this idiot up for good, he doesn't deserve to enjoy any more of his own life, just like he's taken the life away from the other people
NOBODY and I mean NOBODY should be allowed to trot out the "I didn't know about motorways" line and expect it to be taken seriously
Lock this idiot up for good, he doesn't deserve to enjoy any more of his own life, just like he's taken the life away from the other people
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




