GATSOs Disappearing in West Lothian
GATSOs Disappearing in West Lothian
Author
Discussion

jezzaaa

Original Poster:

1,951 posts

290 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2008
quotequote all
Chaps - two GATSO cameras have been uprooted...one at the Edinburgh end of the A71 and another one on the A71 dual carriageway as you go through Sighthill.

Conversely, at the Calder/Livingston End of the A71, there's now one of those digital Watchman cameras on the very tall pillar.

So are we seeing the end of no-film GATSO's?? Do the watchman ones have the same issue with the direction of travel...i.e. can it only get you from behind (so to speak)?

Cheers,
J.


MK4 Slowride

10,028 posts

239 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2008
quotequote all
Maybe people are stealing them for scrap metal.

KB_S1

5,967 posts

260 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2008
quotequote all
I suspect there will be a SPECS setup in the area very soon.

They realised that lowering a lot of the limits was doing nothing to improve safety.

jezzaaa

Original Poster:

1,951 posts

290 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2008
quotequote all
KB_S1 said:
I suspect there will be a SPECS setup in the area very soon.

They realised that lowering a lot of the limits was doing nothing to improve safety.
Oh god please don't say that...what a nightmare frown

tvrgit

8,490 posts

283 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2008
quotequote all
KB_S1 said:
I suspect there will be a SPECS setup in the area very soon.

They realised that lowering a lot of the limits was doing nothing to improve safety.
The accident record on the A71 dropped significantly when the 50 mph limit was introduced.

forza whites

2,555 posts

226 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2008
quotequote all
They are being replaced with depleted uranium firing 30mm cannons......activated between 1 & 3 mph over the set limit....


jezzaaa said:
Chaps - two GATSO cameras have been uprooted...one at the Edinburgh end of the A71 and another one on the A71 dual carriageway as you go through Sighthill.

Conversely, at the Calder/Livingston End of the A71, there's now one of those digital Watchman cameras on the very tall pillar.

So are we seeing the end of no-film GATSO's?? Do the watchman ones have the same issue with the direction of travel...i.e. can it only get you from behind (so to speak)?

Cheers,
J.

Digby

8,358 posts

277 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2008
quotequote all
tvrgit said:
The accident record on the A71 dropped significantly when the 50 mph limit was introduced.
This road?

"Dualling A71 from Edinburgh City Boundary to Calder Junction. This scheme was
developed for road safety reasons"

"Dualling would be very expensive and would facilitate car based commuting in a corridor with substantial
potential for bus and rail based park and ride. A review of the scheme has been carried out and has led to the recommendation that this scheme should no longer be pursued as a Council proposal"

So, make it 50 mph, add cameras and cash on in, simple. In fact, wasn't this the same road which saw accident rates fall simply because they fitted a central reservation at some point? Also, a bit of googling reveals it is one of the roads which the AA suggested was also made safer due to better surfacing, better lighting, drink drive and seat belt campaigns etc and others said a simple roundabout would have helped stop accidents.How much of accident reduction was due to the new speed limit i wonder?

I also notice it had a speed camera (now removed due to complaints?) which caused major upset by being placed in the middle of an acceleration zone between two limits.As you approached the national speed limit sign, just in front of it was a scamera which would fine people for going faster than the lower limit they were leaving.All in the name of safety of course.



Edited by Digby on Tuesday 22 April 20:31

terminator001

3 posts

223 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2008
quotequote all
There must be some techy out there that can manufacture a detector that can cause a mailfunction on all systems somehow. If anyone knows of any such thing let me know.

tvrgit

8,490 posts

283 months

Tuesday 22nd April 2008
quotequote all
Digby said:
tvrgit said:
The accident record on the A71 dropped significantly when the 50 mph limit was introduced.
This road?

"Dualling A71 from Edinburgh City Boundary to Calder Junction. This scheme was
developed for road safety reasons"

"Dualling would be very expensive and would facilitate car based commuting in a corridor with substantial
potential for bus and rail based park and ride. A review of the scheme has been carried out and has led to the recommendation that this scheme should no longer be pursued as a Council proposal"

So, make it 50 mph, add cameras and cash on in, simple. In fact, wasn't this the same road which saw accident rates fall simply because they fitted a central reservation at some point? Also, a bit of googling reveals it is one of the roads which the AA suggested was also made safer due to better surfacing, better lighting, drink drive and seat belt campaigns etc and others said a simple roundabout would have helped stop accidents.How much of accident reduction was due to the new speed limit i wonder?

The 50 limit was in place long before (at least 10 years before) that review report you quote from (by which time transport policy had changed significantly).

The speed camera (singular) also followed a long time after the 50 limit (and that was actually in the 40 limit just at the east end of the 50 stretch where all the students were crossing the road from the university to the bus stops). As far as I know, it was never intended as a "cash cow" - it was there to deter high speeds where those youngsters were crossing, and it worked.

The central reservation is only at that eastern end - and yes that did help reduce accidents there, mainly because the old alignment was absolutely crap and went through the wee village there, which is now bypassed.

Most of the road is still single carriageway, unlit.

I know all about the better marking / better signs / better surfacing campaign that was carried out in the late 1980's. At the time, this was my area...

I also know about the circumstances relating to the high number of fatal accidents that were occuring at that time, but I am not going to discuss those circumstances here, not even after all this time. Suffice to say that many people who died on this "killer road" as it was reported in the press at the time, were not necessarily speeding, they just made silly mistakes which proved fatal (not necessarily always to the person who made the mistake). We resisted lowering the speed limit for years, for that reason. We were seen as harsh, but we were trying to solve the problem, not just reduce the consequences.

After I left, the pressure from "political masters" gathered more pace and the 50 mph speed limit was brought in, I think (but I'm not sure because I'd left) against professional advice. In fairness, there have been a lot fewer accidents since then, but you're right, it's hard to tell how much of that resulted from the speed limit and how much from the "signs and lines" and enforcement campaigns just before that.


streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
forza whites said:
They are being replaced with depleted uranium firing 30mm cannons......activated between 1 & 3 mph over the set limit....
Well, they'll get ripped out ... DU is a 'elf-n-safety hazard wink , ask the tankers in GW1 frown - Streaky

Pot Bellied Fool

2,264 posts

268 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
terminator001 said:
There must be some techy out there that can manufacture a detector that can cause a mailfunction on all systems somehow. If anyone knows of any such thing let me know.
You mean something that generates say, electromagnetic pulses?

Ooh,look... http://www.plans-kits.com/kits.html

I'd quite like to see one of these in action. From a distance...

ylee coyote

420 posts

267 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
now thats a good site

EMP rifle anyone ?

jezzaaa

Original Poster:

1,951 posts

290 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
tvrgit said:
Digby said:
tvrgit said:
The accident record on the A71 dropped significantly when the 50 mph limit was introduced.
This road?

"Dualling A71 from Edinburgh City Boundary to Calder Junction. This scheme was
developed for road safety reasons"

"Dualling would be very expensive and would facilitate car based commuting in a corridor with substantial
potential for bus and rail based park and ride. A review of the scheme has been carried out and has led to the recommendation that this scheme should no longer be pursued as a Council proposal"

So, make it 50 mph, add cameras and cash on in, simple. In fact, wasn't this the same road which saw accident rates fall simply because they fitted a central reservation at some point? Also, a bit of googling reveals it is one of the roads which the AA suggested was also made safer due to better surfacing, better lighting, drink drive and seat belt campaigns etc and others said a simple roundabout would have helped stop accidents.How much of accident reduction was due to the new speed limit i wonder?

The 50 limit was in place long before (at least 10 years before) that review report you quote from (by which time transport policy had changed significantly).

The speed camera (singular) also followed a long time after the 50 limit (and that was actually in the 40 limit just at the east end of the 50 stretch where all the students were crossing the road from the university to the bus stops). As far as I know, it was never intended as a "cash cow" - it was there to deter high speeds where those youngsters were crossing, and it worked.

The central reservation is only at that eastern end - and yes that did help reduce accidents there, mainly because the old alignment was absolutely crap and went through the wee village there, which is now bypassed.

Most of the road is still single carriageway, unlit.

I know all about the better marking / better signs / better surfacing campaign that was carried out in the late 1980's. At the time, this was my area...

I also know about the circumstances relating to the high number of fatal accidents that were occuring at that time, but I am not going to discuss those circumstances here, not even after all this time. Suffice to say that many people who died on this "killer road" as it was reported in the press at the time, were not necessarily speeding, they just made silly mistakes which proved fatal (not necessarily always to the person who made the mistake). We resisted lowering the speed limit for years, for that reason. We were seen as harsh, but we were trying to solve the problem, not just reduce the consequences.

After I left, the pressure from "political masters" gathered more pace and the 50 mph speed limit was brought in, I think (but I'm not sure because I'd left) against professional advice. In fairness, there have been a lot fewer accidents since then, but you're right, it's hard to tell how much of that resulted from the speed limit and how much from the "signs and lines" and enforcement campaigns just before that.
Tvrgit my friend, how are you doing? Remember that parking incident you gave me advice about? Well, I never heard from them again after sending that second letter asking them again to name the driver!! Still owe you a beer or three mate!

SirSimon

6,811 posts

234 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all

I know for a fact that one of the Camera's was laying at the side of the road where the Average Speed Camera's are. But it seems to have gone missing now.

tvrgit

8,490 posts

283 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
jezzaaa said:
Tvrgit my friend, how are you doing? Remember that parking incident you gave me advice about? Well, I never heard from them again after sending that second letter asking them again to name the driver!! Still owe you a beer or three mate!
I was down there the other day, the signs are still up and I was wondering how you got on. Good to hear that they saw sense.

tvrgit

8,490 posts

283 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
SirSimon said:
I know for a fact that one of the Camera's was laying at the side of the road where the Average Speed Camera's are. But it seems to have gone missing now.
There are no average speed cameras on the A71 - just the one fixed camera, the new one referred to in the OP.

SirSimon

6,811 posts

234 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
tvrgit said:
SirSimon said:
I know for a fact that one of the Camera's was laying at the side of the road where the Average Speed Camera's are. But it seems to have gone missing now.
There are no average speed cameras on the A71 - just the one fixed camera, the new one referred to in the OP.
A720, Sorry should have said.