Justice system "disgraceful & corrupt" MPs told
Justice system "disgraceful & corrupt" MPs told
Author
Discussion

paranha

Original Poster:

633 posts

273 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/ne...

Edited by paranha on Wednesday 23 April 09:34

havoc

33,523 posts

266 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
Always has been. No worse here than anywhere else (probably better than many countries...).

Doesn't make it right, but how do you stop it??? Practically, and without destroying the system that DOES do a lot of good...

Chrispy Porker

17,763 posts

259 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
I thought it was the politicians who were corrupted by money and power...
I have neither...


Edited by Chrispy Porker on Wednesday 23 April 12:04

Jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
Sadly, we actually have a fairly good legal system when contrasted with other countries.. Not perfect, not by a long stretch, but amongst the best in the world, if not the best.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Sadly, we actually have a fairly good legal system when contrasted with other countries.. Not perfect, not by a long stretch, but amongst the best in the world, if not the best.
Or so we like to think. People say similar things about the NHS. The reality is that the British justice system favours the rich and very poor (or at least those who can get legal aid). Its none too fair for the middle classes, and the presumption of innocent until proven guilty is being watered down. Probably the Yanks have the most rigorous system, but the same problem with wealth applies.

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Sadly, we actually have a fairly good legal system when contrasted with other countries.. Not perfect, not by a long stretch, but amongst the best in the world, if not the best.
As long as you are neither the victim nor a witness. When one considers how much it costs each and every taxpayer it damn well should be considerably better than it is.

Victims are treated abominably. I was involved in a case where an 18-year-old girl was raped, buggered and then had the bloke’s dick stuck down her throat. She collapsed on the id parade, curled into a foetal position and stayed that way for seven minutes. There was a 90 minute legal argument at the court case over whether she could have a screen between her and the person who raped her. The defence’s sole strategy (there was DNA evidence, ample that the whole series of sexual assaults was against the kid’s will, damning circumstantial evidence) was to try and make the girl to say something that they could make some play on. The suggestion by the police of a video link was ignored.

When she turned up in court I asked for a room for her and her FLO. This was refused. I commandeered a lawyer’s room and they tried to throw her out.

The system cares little for victims and the only thing one can say is they are treated marginally better than prosecution witnesses are.

The main problem is that the truth is of no concern. It’s a game, a farce more like, where the little pieces are moved around with little or no regard for their own concerns or welfare.

It is incredibly inefficient. I’ve been at court for four days in one trial yet never called. Still, there was one happy aspect in that I made friends with a number of other witnesses who were also retained with no suggestion that they would eventually be called.

I’ve had one case where the defence brought up objection after objection, got the case put back so many times that they claimed that as there had been over 18 months since the first hearing and the defendant was under 21 it was cruel to continue with the case.

I’ve had a case where the defendant turned up, was told by his brief that we had all our witnesses present so it would be best if he went out again. He was arrested, taken to court but we were unable to get two of our witnesses to court (one worked abroad) so the judge gave us a deadline which we were unable to meet so the job was pulled.

A bloke is beaten by a kid who is a member of an extended family of CROs. When the court case comes up, three family members, all young heavies, are brought to the court by the brief who positions them outside the main entrance.

And I’ve got many, many more.

Such as an ESN chap who kills two children. The very expensive defence solicitor and barrister, paid for by some red top rag, challenge the evidence of identification, one item of which was the wrist watch worn by the murderer. Then this chap who is too stupid to tie his own shoelaces raised his left arm in court to demonstrate that not only was he not wearing a watch but that it could be plainly seen that there was no mark of a watch.

The prosecution were not allowed to adduce evidence to contradict this.

What a clever chap, eh. An IQ in double figures yet he could plan long term and, not only that, knew the effect this would have on the jury. He later attempted to kill another child via the same MO and was convicted.

Still, whilst he was inside I bet he played a lot of chess.

And I could go on and on and on.

Courts are the best thing in the world for lawyers and other hanger’s on. For everyone else, especially victims, it is a trial.

The thing is that whilst everyone agrees that an innocent person being found guilty is a travesty of justice, it is also a travesty when, despite there being ample evidence to convict, a guilty person gets off because of trickery.

King of Dings

437 posts

223 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
Hello 'Kettle' my name is....'pot'

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
King of Dings said:
Hello 'Kettle' my name is....'pot'
I did not say that the policing system in this country is the best in the world. Further, even had I, it would not negate the points above. I am by no means complacent about the standard of policing. What I was hinting at, and not too subtly I hope, is that I agree that the justice system in this country is, as the heading says, disgraceful and corrupt.

Jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
Mr Smith, I can assure you that my post was in no way meant to indicate that I believe the UK "Justice" system to be just, equitable or indeed fair and reasonable at all times, I have far too much experience of it for that.

I've been near to tears due to things I've witnessed in the criminal courts, which were most certainly neither fair nor just. Humans are involved, and humans make stupid decisions.

However, the sad fact is that the UK System has a fair number of checks and balances in place to operate in such a way as to be "Better" than most other jurisdictions in the world. That simply indicates how poor the legal system is in other parts of the world.