speeding advice please
Author
Discussion

Boxylady

Original Poster:

205 posts

226 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
Our company has a works car. Last year three people had access to the car and during that time a speeding ticket for 40mph in a 30 area was issued. They couldnt prove who was driving and since then all three members of staff have left. We have tried explaining this to the courts, including sending letters to each of the ex employees and copies of these to the courtwith an accompanying letter. We have now been fined £1470 including a £15 victim contribution when here is no victim involved. We want to appeal against the decision but dont know if we have a leg to stand on. The law says you SHOULD have records of who drives the cars (we didnt before but do now) but it doesnt say you MUST. Any advice please on how to appeal and on what grounds.

Swoxy

2,842 posts

241 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
I think you need to take legal advice from a recommended motoring solicitor.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
+1. Sounds like you made all the efforts to show diligence, so you should have a strong case.

TPS

1,860 posts

244 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
Boxylady said:
Our company has a works car. Last year three people had access to the car and during that time a speeding ticket for 40mph in a 30 area was issued. They couldnt prove who was driving and since then all three members of staff have left. We have tried explaining this to the courts, including sending letters to each of the ex employees and copies of these to the courtwith an accompanying letter. We have now been fined £1470 including a £15 victim contribution when here is no victim involved. We want to appeal against the decision but dont know if we have a leg to stand on. The law says you SHOULD have records of who drives the cars (we didnt before but do now) but it doesnt say you MUST. Any advice please on how to appeal and on what grounds.
It could end up costing you a lot more in legal fees etc for you to go to court again only to be found guilty.

The facts are that
1)your company car was caught being driven above the speed limit by someone.
2)you failed to keep a record of drivers
3)you failed to provide a named driver for the offence.

not a good base to start an appeal on is it.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
TPS said:
Boxylady said:
Our company has a works car. Last year three people had access to the car and during that time a speeding ticket for 40mph in a 30 area was issued. They couldnt prove who was driving and since then all three members of staff have left. We have tried explaining this to the courts, including sending letters to each of the ex employees and copies of these to the courtwith an accompanying letter. We have now been fined £1470 including a £15 victim contribution when here is no victim involved. We want to appeal against the decision but dont know if we have a leg to stand on. The law says you SHOULD have records of who drives the cars (we didnt before but do now) but it doesnt say you MUST. Any advice please on how to appeal and on what grounds.
It could end up costing you a lot more in legal fees etc for you to go to court again only to be found guilty.

The facts are that
1)your company car was caught being driven above the speed limit by someone.
2)you failed to keep a record of drivers
3)you failed to provide a named driver for the offence.

not a good base to start an appeal on is it.
There is no law mandating that driver records are kept. The onus is to show reasonable diligence in identifying the driver. This they seem to have done.

mmm-five

12,400 posts

315 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
TPS said:
Boxylady said:
Our company has a works car. Last year three people had access to the car and during that time a speeding ticket for 40mph in a 30 area was issued. They couldnt prove who was driving and since then all three members of staff have left. We have tried explaining this to the courts, including sending letters to each of the ex employees and copies of these to the courtwith an accompanying letter. We have now been fined £1470 including a £15 victim contribution when here is no victim involved. We want to appeal against the decision but dont know if we have a leg to stand on. The law says you SHOULD have records of who drives the cars (we didnt before but do now) but it doesnt say you MUST. Any advice please on how to appeal and on what grounds.
It could end up costing you a lot more in legal fees etc for you to go to court again only to be found guilty.

The facts are that
1)your company car was caught being driven above the speed limit by someone.
2)you failed to keep a record of drivers
3)you failed to provide a named driver for the offence.

not a good base to start an appeal on is it.
The facts are:
1) Allegedly caught speeding - innocent until proven guilty remember!
2) They know which individuals had access to the car - just not who was driving at the time - that would require a driving log book which is not a legal requirement (even if it is recommended, remember the police don't follow their own APCO rules as they state they are 'only guidelines').
3) They provided all the names of the drivers for the offence, it's up to the prosecution to prove which one did it (refer to point 1).

Unfortunately though I think it will cost you a lot to challenge it and may just be worth writing it off.

Boxylady

Original Poster:

205 posts

226 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
Ive just been onto a traffic lawyer and he reckons we arent liable due to the fact we presented as much info about the offence to the courts and that we wrote to the ex employese etc. So I have penned an appeal on those grounds. I really am not happy about being penalised so heavily. Thanks for all your comments guys.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
1) Allegedly caught speeding - innocent until proven guilty remember!
The alleged speeding offence is of little relevance now - the company was charged with failing to provide driver details.

mmm-five said:
2) They know which individuals had access to the car - just not who was driving at the time - that would require a driving log book which is not a legal requirement (even if it is recommended, remember the police don't follow their own APCO rules as they state they are 'only guidelines').
But they were not able to confirm who was driving at the time, hence the summons.

And since the company did not keep a log of drivers, it would be required to demonstrate that a failure to keep such records was reasonable in addition to detailing what steps had been taken to attempt to identify the driver.

mmm-five said:
3) They provided all the names of the drivers for the offence, it's up to the prosecution to prove which one did it (refer to point 1).
That's not correct. The prosecution would simply be required to prove that a lawful request for driver details pursuant to s.172 RTA 1988 was served on the accused and that the accused failed to comply with the requirements of that request.

It would then fall to the defendant to avail themselves of any statutory defence or mitigate a guilty plea, as appropriate..

Kevin 996C4

13,895 posts

311 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
SS2. said:
And since the company did not keep a log of drivers, it would be required to demonstrate that a failure to keep such records was reasonable in addition to detailing what steps had been taken to attempt to identify the driver.
Is there actually a legal requirement to keep records of drivers of company pool cars? If so, what Act? I do not remember seeing it anywhere yet.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
Kevin 996C4 said:
Is there actually a legal requirement to keep records of drivers of company pool cars? If so, what Act? I do not remember seeing it anywhere yet.
There is no statutory requirement to keep a log, only an implied responsibility:

s.172 RTA 1988 said:
(6) Where the alleged offender is a body corporate, or in Scotland a partnership or an unincorporated association, or the proceedings are brought against him by virtue of subsection (5) above or subsection (11) below, subsection (4) above shall not apply unless, in addition to the matters there mentioned, the alleged offender shows that no record was kept of the persons who drove the vehicle and that the failure to keep a record was reasonable.

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
The Court was obviosuly not satisfies with the defence put forward hence the conviction.

As stated no carved stone that records have to be kept but some 18 months -2 years ago, bloke appealed to Teesside Crown Court under similar circumstances. The Judge threw it out and stated that where multiple driver involved a record shopuld be kept, which on reflection does make sense if one is to comply with the law.

dvd

Mr POD

5,153 posts

223 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
It pretty much states in My T&C's that a record of who has the keys will be kept by the company (actually plant manager's PA in a diary) and should you need to give let someone else drive whilst the keys are in your keeping, it is your responsibility to keep a record of who and what time they had the keys in thier posession.

Should a NIP come to the company you will either have to state who had the keys at that time, or be disapplined for failing to keep proper records. That's big companies for you.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
Dwight VanDriver said:
The Court was obviosuly not satisfies with the defence put forward hence the conviction.

As stated no carved stone that records have to be kept but some 18 months -2 years ago, bloke appealed to Teesside Crown Court under similar circumstances. The Judge threw it out and stated that where multiple driver involved a record shopuld be kept, which on reflection does make sense if one is to comply with the law.

dvd
So you have a few guys who go out in a car, they can share the driving. What are you supposed to record? Surely that the possible drivers were Mr X , Y and Z

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
s2art said:
TPS said:
Boxylady said:
Our company has a works car. Last year three people had access to the car and during that time a speeding ticket for 40mph in a 30 area was issued. They couldnt prove who was driving and since then all three members of staff have left. We have tried explaining this to the courts, including sending letters to each of the ex employees and copies of these to the courtwith an accompanying letter. We have now been fined £1470 including a £15 victim contribution when here is no victim involved. We want to appeal against the decision but dont know if we have a leg to stand on. The law says you SHOULD have records of who drives the cars (we didnt before but do now) but it doesnt say you MUST. Any advice please on how to appeal and on what grounds.
It could end up costing you a lot more in legal fees etc for you to go to court again only to be found guilty.

The facts are that
1)your company car was caught being driven above the speed limit by someone.
2)you failed to keep a record of drivers
3)you failed to provide a named driver for the offence.

not a good base to start an appeal on is it.
There is no law mandating that driver records are kept. The onus is to show reasonable diligence in identifying the driver. This they seem to have done.
But importantly the court didn't take that view of it.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
s2art said:
Dwight VanDriver said:
The Court was obviosuly not satisfies with the defence put forward hence the conviction.

As stated no carved stone that records have to be kept but some 18 months -2 years ago, bloke appealed to Teesside Crown Court under similar circumstances. The Judge threw it out and stated that where multiple driver involved a record shopuld be kept, which on reflection does make sense if one is to comply with the law.

dvd
So you have a few guys who go out in a car, they can share the driving. What are you supposed to record? Surely that the possible drivers were Mr X , Y and Z
The company can have a log book with each vehicle & then a requirement that each driver enters their details on the log showing the times they were driving it.

TPS

1,860 posts

244 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
Its not that hard to keep a record and i have said it on here before.All you need as Von has said is a book in the car with date,drivers name,start and end time of journey and start and finish mileage to keep a true record.Then all you have to do is make sure it is being filled out.
People say i can not be bothered to spend time doing this but they would rather spend time in court or paying fines.

Edited by TPS on Wednesday 23 April 19:00

fluffnik

20,156 posts

258 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
The company can have a log book with each vehicle & then a requirement that each driver enters their details on the log showing the times they were driving it.
Why?

S172 is a nasty bit of fascist twuntery, we should all strive to have it, and its supporters, overthrown.

fluffnik

20,156 posts

258 months

Wednesday 23rd April 2008
quotequote all
TPS said:
People say i can not be bothered to spend time doing this but they would rather spend time in court or paying fines.
They shouldn't need to do either, they don't work for plod or prosecution.