Just what is the truth
Author
Discussion

crazymatelot

Original Poster:

178 posts

232 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
I have extracted some of the Dept Of Transport regulations regarding the marking of speed/safety camera enforcement vehicles, and placed it below.

Para 48.
Vehicles from which enforcement may take place should be liveried and clearly
identifiable as an enforcement vehicle. Visibility of the livery should be maintained during enforcement, e.g. where it is necessary for the doors to be open, markings or livery should be apparent to approaching traffic in the direction of enforcement. If the enforcement officer is undertaking enforcement away from the vehicle, the enforcement officer should be conspicuous by wearing high-visibility clothing.

elsewhere in these forums it is possible to read about the local constabulary monitoring the speed of trafic from Horse Boxes, Builders vans, or by simply placing a camera on a tripod in a layby and hiding around the corner. The way I read the legislation none of these activities is legal, simply because none of these so called enforcement vehicles is appropriately marked. Can one of the BIBs on here please explain to me otherwise.confused

Dibble

13,292 posts

271 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
"should" not "must".

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
Dibble said:
"should" not "must".
Like Ospre PART 1 all over again...

Battenburg Bob

8,858 posts

223 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Dibble said:
"should" not "must".
Like Ospre PART 1 all over again...
Shiver!!!


forza whites

2,555 posts

226 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
Blimey, so many English Professors on here, or are you lot the 'grammer enforcement officers'?

Dibble

13,292 posts

271 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
forza whites said:
Blimey, so many English Professors on here, or are you lot the 'grammer enforcement officers'?
I think you may mean "grammar". Or even spelling.


My initial reply was short, but basically there is no legislation that says mobile speed cameras "must" be marked or visible. Cameras can be used covertly if desired.

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
forza whites said:
Blimey, so many English Professors on here, or are you lot the 'grammer enforcement officers'?
I think Dibble was trying to say that the "cutting" you posted said "should" not "must", there is a subtle difference.....ie it doesn't really matter whether the guidelines are followed or not....

Dibble

13,292 posts

271 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
esselte said:
forza whites said:
Blimey, so many English Professors on here, or are you lot the 'grammer enforcement officers'?
I think Dibble was trying to say that the "cutting" you posted said "should" not "must", there is a subtle difference.....ie it doesn't really matter whether the guidelines are followed or not....
forza wasn't the original OP, but you're right about what I was trying to say, esselte.

My own view is that if there are guidelines, they should (must?!) be followed.

eldar

25,363 posts

227 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
Entirely pointless guidelines.

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
Dibble said:
esselte said:
forza whites said:
Blimey, so many English Professors on here, or are you lot the 'grammer enforcement officers'?
I think Dibble was trying to say that the "cutting" you posted said "should" not "must", there is a subtle difference.....ie it doesn't really matter whether the guidelines are followed or not....
forza wasn't the original OP, but you're right about what I was trying to say, esselte.

My own view is that if there are guidelines, they should (must?!) be followed.
Ooops my mistake re the OP,sorry...smile but yes guidelines should be followed but I suppose there's less comeback if they're not..

crazymatelot

Original Poster:

178 posts

232 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
Okay then, what about the ACPO guidlines which unambiguously state that traffic officers performing speed checks should do so from a position that's clearly visible to the public. Everytime an officer hides in a hedge to check traffic speed or hides behind another vehicle they are breaching such guidlines. Not in the name of safety but in the name of money.

Cat

3,134 posts

300 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
crazymatelot said:
Okay then, what about the ACPO guidlines which unambiguously state that traffic officers performing speed checks should do so from a position that's clearly visible to the public. Everytime an officer hides in a hedge to check traffic speed or hides behind another vehicle they are breaching such guidlines. Not in the name of safety but in the name of money.
The guidelines don't say they should be visible to the drivers of the vehicle whose speed is being checked just that they are visible to the public. A subtle difference.

Westy Pre-Lit

5,088 posts

234 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
What is the point in having a guide line , when a force will just interpret it for their own gain? All because 'should' was put instead of 'must'.

It just makes a mockery of the whole guide line structure.

"Oh but i read it this way, I'm in control so i can do what i jolly well like. So fk you peasant, lick my boots, I'm right again, your nicked". This guideline crap is therefore null and void as it is to ambiguous to mean anything and a pointless exercise.

I've always been told i 'should' respect the law etc.....fk it nobody told me i 'must'.

Makes you wonder why anybody does to be honest.


Edited by Westy Pre-Lit on Thursday 24th April 22:00

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
"Guidelines" provide guidance, there is no obligation to follow it. However, the ACPO "Guidelines" do contain mandatory statements.

"Should" indicates a desirable requirement - ignoring it can have no consequences.

"Must" indicates a mandatory requirement - ignoring it strongly implies the possibility of penalties.

Just because too many people do not understand the difference, doesn't mean those who draft such documents don't.

Streaky

eldar

25,363 posts

227 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
Just because too many people do not understand the difference, doesn't mean those who draft such documents don't.

Streaky
Do you mean what I think you mean, or am I confusing too many negatives?

Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
Dibble's point>>>>>>>>>>>>>


























forza whites' head >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>


bryan35

1,906 posts

272 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
from what I gather,

Devices can only be used that are type approved. Type approval is granted providing that the kit is used as per the ACPO guidelines, so theoretically if it isn't, the type approval is invalid as is the evidence.

ACPO guidelines also state that where the manufacturers and ACPO's instructions differ, ACPO takes precedence.




streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
streaky said:
"Guidelines" provide guidance, there is no obligation to follow it. However, the ACPO "Guidelines" do contain mandatory statements.

"Should" indicates a desirable requirement - ignoring it can have no consequences.

"Must" indicates a mandatory requirement - ignoring it strongly implies the possibility of penalties.

Just because too many people do not understand the difference, doesn't mean those who draft such documents don't.

Streaky
Ah yes the Civil Service approach to the "toothless" rule, long standing tradition in this country I am afraid as anyone who has EVER been involved in any government circle will attest smile

Like the difference between Sanctioned and disciplinedsmile LOL

Cheers
In my (old) world, there was a BIG difference ... allegedly! - Streaky

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
eldar said:
streaky said:
Just because too many people do not understand the difference, doesn't mean those who draft such documents don't.

Streaky
Do you mean what I think you mean, or am I confusing too many negatives?
I know that you believe you understand what you think I wrote, but I’m not sure you realise that what you read is not what I meant. smile - Streaky

BertBert

21,346 posts

242 months

Thursday 24th April 2008
quotequote all
definitions of "should"
1. aux.v. - Used to express obligation or duty:
2. aux.v. - Used to express probability or expectation:
3. aux.v. - Used to express conditionality or contingency:
4. aux.v. - Used to moderate the directness or bluntness of a statement:

It is possible that the DOT regs used "should" in meaning 2. It is almost certain that meaning 1 is meant. Unless like the HC it defines the term (which I doubt).

So in all liklihood those regs mean "must". The question is do the regs define what happens if they are not followed?

Bert