New dad escapes fine for speeding
New dad escapes fine for speeding
Author
Discussion

rewc

Original Poster:

2,187 posts

264 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all

A DRIVER who was caught speeding to hospital while his wife was in labour in the passenger seat has been spared a fine.

Chris Walton was front page news in the Bournemouth Daily Echo after he was snapped driving seven miles per hour over the 30mph limit by a camera at Constitution Hill in Parkstone.

He had been driving his wife, who was in the final stages of labour, to Poole maternity unit just before 5am last August.

Mr Walton, from Ashley Heath, refused to accept the three penalty points issued to him by post and appeared at Wimborne Magistrates Court in March.

He was told the court did not have the legal expertise to deal with his plea and the case was postponed.

But at Bournemouth Magistrates Court on Friday, the 36-year-old program manager, who pleaded guilty but argued mitigating circumstances, was given an absolute discharge by magistrates.


The court heard Mr Walton's wife, Wendy, was 12 days overdue when she went into labour at 3.45am on August 22 and was instructed by the midwife at Poole Hospital to get in the car and get to the hospital.

Mr Walton told the court that with their previous child the labour had lasted 10-12 hours so the couple were not unduly panicked.

But nearing the end of their early morning car journey, the labour quickly intensified.

After they had passed the Frizzell roundabout, Mrs Walton told him the pain was getting worse and that she could feel the baby's head coming out.

Mr Walton said: "I was worried. I have no medical skills and my main thought was to get to the hospital as quickly and safely as I could. Wendy was telling me in no uncertain terms that she was in a lot of pain.

"In hindsight we could have used an alternative but there didn't seem to be any need when we left the house. We thought it would be a similar experience to last time."

Speaking after the ruling, Chris said: "I am relieved that someone finally listened to me and that justice and common sense has prevailed.

"But I'm disappointed I had to bring in a solicitor to help me be heard - all because I was told in March it wasn't an emergency, when clearly as the ruling proves, it was."


eldar

25,363 posts

227 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
Common sense prevails, for once.

Jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
I'm sure once upon a time this wouldn't have even got to court...

TheCarpetCleaner

7,294 posts

233 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
Jasandjules said:
I'm sure once upon a time this wouldn't have even got to court...
Absolutely!
As it should be. Sadly not any more frown

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
I once went to hospital with an employee who had amputated four fingers in one of our saws.
I knew to get them reattatched time was vital so instead of an ambulance it was decided to drive him straight to casualty.
I sped to get to the hospital.
When I arrived in casualty I went to book my charge in whereupon the receptionist asked me to take a seat... I don't think so..I replied holding up the four loose digits... she gasped and pointed me straight towards the empty cubicle.

tigger1

8,485 posts

252 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
I'm sure once upon a time this wouldn't have even got to court...
Once upon a time *if* he'd been spotted, he might even have got himself an escort to the labour unit.

I've just had a quick look on another website and found this explanation: -

Taken from www.motorlawanswers.co.uk
Somebody on that site said:
Q) I was caught speeding but it was a genuine emergency. Can I plead guilty but argue a special reasons defence? I received a distress call that a relative was seriously ill.

A) Firstly, it should be noted that Special Reasons is not a defence. It follows a guilty finding and is used to convince the Court not to impose a punishment because, whilst the offence has been committed, the circumstances were such that it would be wrong to impose a punishment.

In order for your Special Reasons argument to succeed, you will have to show that there was no alternative but to drive in the manner that you did and that your emergency must be “real, not nebulous, nor manufactured”. If it is anticipated, it is not an emergency and further you will have to show that the issue could not have been resolved by other means, for example, calling for an ambulance etc.

In some circumstances, a genuine emergency can amount to a defence of “duress of necessity/circumstances” which would result in acquittal.

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

235 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
Well he could of kept within the speed limit BUT

Then he would let himself be open to the charge of attending a birth without a license which is now also illegal

Fan bloody tastic

mph999

2,780 posts

251 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
Well he could of kept within the speed limit BUT

Then he would let himself be open to the charge of attending a birth without a license which is now also illegal

Fan bloody tastic
... you serious, bl**dy stupid country.

Still, I though if a vechile was being used as a ambulance it was a defence ?

Martin

paranha

633 posts

273 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
How much longer do the sensible majority of people in this country put up with this hourly braindead rubbish???????????.I did the same 30+ years ago at 05-00, and in those days we had brainsense bib,s and COURTS.

No doubt Von will be along to show us the error of our ways--good job his mum wasnt too late for his entrance on this world stage.

forza whites

2,555 posts

226 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
Another real world case of a how very limited standalone uncollaborated cameras really are.

Althought clearly it shouldn't have come to this, am glad to hear you got the correct decision in the end. Good on you for not wavering and being pressurized and bullied into accepting the points/fine.

caiss4

1,947 posts

228 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
I read the OP and felt a real sense of deja-vu. Almost exactly the same circumstances at the birth of my second child. Fortunately it was pre-GATSO but I would have been in court for a ban as my speed was way over the limit. Arrived at the hospital at 06.10 and Sarah entered the world at 06.16....

As others have said thank goodness common sense prevailed.

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
TheCarpetCleaner said:
Guam said:
Jasandjules said:
I'm sure once upon a time this wouldn't have even got to court...
Absolutely!
As it should be. Sadly not any more frown
+1

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
He still has a conviction he must declare though, just no points for it.

Finlandia

7,818 posts

262 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
odyssey2200 said:
TheCarpetCleaner said:
Guam said:
Jasandjules said:
I'm sure once upon a time this wouldn't have even got to court...
Absolutely!
As it should be. Sadly not any more frown
+1
Plus one more

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
He still has a conviction he must declare though, just no points for it.
You just couldn't help yourself could you?
you had to piss on someone parade didn't yourolleyes

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
Simply putting the facts forward, so that people are aware of them.

Edited by vonhosen on Sunday 27th April 18:40

driverrob

4,847 posts

234 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
Some years ago I rushed an injured horse-rider to hospital in Oxford at illegal speeds and through the taxi/bus only centre of town. (I was half-hoping for a police escort but there's never a cop around when you need one.) Someone else's health always comes before personal thoughts of prosecution for speeding at times like that, doesn't it?

Mad Moggie2

784 posts

237 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
He still has a conviction he must declare though, just no points for it.
But somehow I do not think the insurers will load .. nor will he have any points accumalting to tot-up wink

When Wildy was expecting the last one .. I was worried. She's more delicate after that incident and we are off the beaten track.. I can deliver . but she would have probably needed medical assistance of the sort only a hospital can provide afterwards She has history of speedy labout (naturally laugh) and a tendency to produce at around the 8 month stage..


As it happened - I called for an escort .. but reached the hospital first and no camvans in sight .. laugh


But yikes All our kittens have been rather robust babies .. right "handfuls of bother" like their mother rolleyes

I think this was a good result and yes, Jules .. I agree once upon a time .. you got a police escort. We did with the first one laugh

Next.. time .. The twins popped out in the hospital car park .. eek ...

So you never know. Each pregnancy and labour is unique though. I am sure this child will have some proud paternal reminiscences of all this at 18th/21st/engagement/wedding parties to come laugh

I will make a toast beerdrinkparty to wet the baby's head and celebrate a decent common sense result anyway.

p1esk

4,914 posts

227 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Simply putting the facts forward, so that people are aware of them.

Edited by vonhosen on Sunday 27th April 18:40
Good grief. A one liner, and still it needed editing. laugh

You're right though. Let's have a straight story, which in this case seems to have made some sensible allowance for the circumstances.

Best wishes all,
Dave.

catso

16,570 posts

298 months

Sunday 27th April 2008
quotequote all
I recall when I was about 11, I broke my elbow playing football - nasty break the joint was bent backwards, anyway on the way to the Hospital my Dad was driving fast and got stopped by a bike cop, once he explained what had happened the cop told my Dad to follow him and proceeded to give us a fast escort through red lights etc to the infirmary. I suspect that nowadays this would not be likely.