Caught 100m from sign?
Author
Discussion

Toffer

Original Poster:

1,528 posts

292 months

Monday 28th April 2008
quotequote all
Please can you help me?

An old (40 something redface)college friend was caught speeding in her Ford Focus CMax 1.6 diesel automatic rolleyes, by a camera van on the A427 heading West from Corby towards Oundle at a place called Upper Benefield.

The camera van was parked on the opposite side (Eastbound) of the road to my friends direction of travel, in a 30mph restricted area, 100m from the 30mph sign indicating the start of the 30mph zone and the end of the de-restricted 60mph road. frown

As she decelerated, from 60mph to 30mph, my friend spotted the van, but had been caught on camera at 40mph.

My friend had her digital camera with her and took photographs of the road, the signs and the camera van in situ.

My friend has since received notification of her offence (didn't slow down quite quickly enough irked)

I have two questions please:-
1. Is there any latitude in this type of instance? scratchchin
2. Should my friend go to court with her photos and appeal for a bit of commonsense to prevail? judge

Thank you for your help! smile

Toffer

Jasandjules

72,691 posts

260 months

Monday 28th April 2008
quotequote all
No latitude IF she was caught doing 40 100m AFTER the 30 sign (which is how I read your post) - bottom line, at the 30 sign, you need to be doing 30 to avoid a donation to the MP Pension Fund. You are supposed to slow down BEFORE the 30 sign and accelerate to NSL after the NSL sign.


vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Monday 28th April 2008
quotequote all
Yep the limit changes at the sign.

HRG

72,863 posts

270 months

Monday 28th April 2008
quotequote all
Camera on The Benefields weeping That's sacrilidge

7db

6,060 posts

261 months

Monday 28th April 2008
quotequote all
I was blatting up there on Sunday. Hardly sacrilegious to enforce the 30 limits up there where there are so many NSLs that you can get going in...

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
The positioning of the scamera and the distance at which the offence was detected are important here. Your friend needs to see the photograph of the offence. If the scamera was 100m inside the 30 limit and the distance shown in greater than 100m, then there is a defence (even if the distance shown is 101m and it would be impossible to decelerate to 30 in one metre). Otherwise, otherwise. Calculating the exact location of the scamera is vital if only a few metres difference between its location and the capture distance, but if the photograph shows the offence was captured at 500m and the scamera was clearly (even) 200m inside the 30 limit, there should be no issue - Streaky

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
But when they place a scam so close to a lolly change - it does rather reinforce the opinion that it "nowt to do wi' safety" rolleyes

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
WildCat said:
But when they place a scam so close to a lolly change - it does rather reinforce the opinion that it "nowt to do wi' safety" rolleyes
Indeed. Especially with the fashion of moving the limits a few hundred metres out into the countryside either side of the village.

Actually this is a great example of the way our lives are being ruined by people with no understanding of what they're doing. I believe the late Paul Smith wrote a great piece explaining that by moving the limit signs out into the country drivers arrived at the original zone faster than before. Apparently it's a psychological thing. They slow for the sign as normal but then upon noticing that there's no more of a hazard than just before, they'll creep up their speed again.

Obviously the camera businesses have cottoned on to this so set up in the hot spot just after the limit change for a useful boost in profits. The OP's friend might well have fallen victim to this.

SM

PottyMouth

470 posts

227 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
The camera can be set to ONLY detect up to a set distance. So in this case the operator will(presumably) have set it to start detecting at the 30 signs, or even some distance inside them.

Andy Zarse

10,870 posts

278 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
PottyMouth said:
The camera can be set to ONLY detect up to a set distance. So in this case the operator will(presumably) have set it to start detecting at the 30 signs, or even some distance inside them.
News to me!? confused

Care to explain more?

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
WildCat said:
But when they place a scam so close to a lolly change - it does rather reinforce the opinion that it "nowt to do wi' safety" rolleyes
It reinforces the fact that you the sign means "maximum speed of 30mph", not "start slowing to 30mph after passing"

Peter Ward

2,097 posts

287 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
WildCat said:
But when they place a scam so close to a lolly change - it does rather reinforce the opinion that it "nowt to do wi' safety" rolleyes
It reinforces the fact that you the sign means "maximum speed of 30mph", not "start slowing to 30mph after passing"
True, that's the letter of the law. It is legal to enforce the 30 limit at the point it starts (although not in Germany of course smile ).

However, the purpose of the 30 limit is to enhance road safety. Road safety is not actually enhanced by placing a 30 limit 1/2 mile from the start of the village proper, as is so often the case now. As indicated above, people slow down, then notice that they're still in the country, and tend to speed up again. The net result is that by the time they reach the village they're now doing more than 30, hence reducing safety rather than increasing it.

If the camera van operator wants to enhance safety, he should be at a point within the village where excessive speed is potentially dangerous, and NOT just inside the limit while still out in the country. I therefore submit that placing a van in the position indicated is more to do with revenue than safety.

Andy Zarse

10,870 posts

278 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
Your submission is correct, Peter.

IanMorewood

4,309 posts

279 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
The positioning of the scamera and the distance at which the offence was detected are important here. Your friend needs to see the photograph of the offence. If the scamera was 100m inside the 30 limit and the distance shown in greater than 100m, then there is a defence (even if the distance shown is 101m and it would be impossible to decelerate to 30 in one metre). Otherwise, otherwise. Calculating the exact location of the scamera is vital if only a few metres difference between its location and the capture distance, but if the photograph shows the offence was captured at 500m and the scamera was clearly (even) 200m inside the 30 limit, there should be no issue - Streaky
Yep but that means going to court and getting costs at the least slapped on top of any fine and points.

tamore

10,120 posts

315 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
Peter Ward said:
thewurzel said:
WildCat said:
But when they place a scam so close to a lolly change - it does rather reinforce the opinion that it "nowt to do wi' safety" rolleyes
It reinforces the fact that you the sign means "maximum speed of 30mph", not "start slowing to 30mph after passing"
True, that's the letter of the law. It is legal to enforce the 30 limit at the point it starts (although not in Germany of course smile ).

However, the purpose of the 30 limit is to enhance road safety. Road safety is not actually enhanced by placing a 30 limit 1/2 mile from the start of the village proper, as is so often the case now. As indicated above, people slow down, then notice that they're still in the country, and tend to speed up again. The net result is that by the time they reach the village they're now doing more than 30, hence reducing safety rather than increasing it.

If the camera van operator wants to enhance safety, he should be at a point within the village where excessive speed is potentially dangerous, and NOT just inside the limit while still out in the country. I therefore submit that placing a van in the position indicated is more to do with revenue than safety.
but..... but..... that would suggest that the primary function of some cameras is to raise revenue, and not increase road safety. you should check what your saying as that surely can't be the case.

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
Peter Ward said:
However, the purpose of the 30 limit is to enhance road safety. Road safety is not actually enhanced by placing a 30 limit 1/2 mile from the start of the village proper
It is when there are so many people who treat the 30 sign as a "start slowing down" sign. It gives them 1/2 mile to slow down in before it becomes so much of an issue.

Jasandjules

72,691 posts

260 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
It is when there are so many people who treat the 30 sign as a "start slowing down" sign. It gives them 1/2 mile to slow down in before it becomes so much of an issue.
Actually, I'd be inclined to agree with you in theory, however, in my experience, all it does is dissuade people from slowing down. If the limits were sensibly placed, I think people would be more inclined to follow them. For example, in a local village, the NSL sign is about 300 yards after any house, with fields on both sides, but can you guess from which point people accelerate?

Andy Zarse

10,870 posts

278 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
Peter Ward said:
However, the purpose of the 30 limit is to enhance road safety. Road safety is not actually enhanced by placing a 30 limit 1/2 mile from the start of the village proper
It is when there are so many people who treat the 30 sign as a "start slowing down" sign. It gives them 1/2 mile to slow down in before it becomes so much of an issue.
And people need half a mile to slow down from 60 to 30? It's pointless and annoying, and human nature being as it is, people will ignore the law if they see it's foolish. I'm not suggesting that people speeding is a good thing, but this sort of idiotic placement of speed limits and the enforcement of obviously cash raising purposes brings the whole thing into disrepute. And what's worse, it does absolutely nothing to tackle the current poor level of driving standards in the UK.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
thewurzel said:
It is when there are so many people who treat the 30 sign as a "start slowing down" sign. It gives them 1/2 mile to slow down in before it becomes so much of an issue.
Actually, I'd be inclined to agree with you in theory, however, in my experience, all it does is dissuade people from slowing down. If the limits were sensibly placed, I think people would be more inclined to follow them. For example, in a local village, the NSL sign is about 300 yards after any house, with fields on both sides, but can you guess from which point people accelerate?
Why do you think they changed it ?
Because when the limit was at the start of village itself people sailed on through above the limit.

Jasandjules

72,691 posts

260 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Why do you think they changed it ?
Because when the limit was at the start of village itself people sailed on through above the limit.
Actually, I happen to know exactly why they changed it. It was because the councillor happens to live in the last house in the village, and she didn't like to hear the cars accellerating, so she had the sign moved a few hundred yards along, which took it slightly round the bend, which has large hedgerows, and dampens the noise.. At least, that's the local gossip. She is also looking to change another speed limit, which just happens to be near her daughters house.... biggrin

Next.