Driving test
Author
Discussion

TOPTON

Original Poster:

1,514 posts

267 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
I was informed the other day that my local driving test center will be closing soon and moving to the new 'super center' 40 miles away. Not sure of the date yet but what a pain that will be, not only traveling that far for tests, but also for pre test lessons. Will also add on a lot more cost to the learner for extra tavelling.
One of the reasons for moving, so I was told by an examiner is to be near a motorway as m/way driving will be included in the test in the near future.

Now that would surely mean the law would need to change also to allow learners to drive on m/ways, other wise it would be unfair to test them on something they have never done before.
I have searched the DSA website and can find nothing about it, other than "there will be no changes in 2008".

So unless my examiner friend has got it wrong, (but he doesn't usually) then things are being kept pretty secretive.

Anyone more clued up than me ???

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
i know bike tests are moving to super centers for october of this year. in order to have a large enough offroad area for new parts of the test. probably means the car test people have to move too?
not heard of updates to the car test myself, although i think it needs something doing because as it stands you dont learn to drive, you learn to pass the test.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
The thought of learners being tested on a motorway scares me more than sitting alongside my daughter whilst teaching her car control on snow-covered private roads (MOD) ... but not much more wink - Streaky

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
The thought of learners being tested on a motorway scares me more than sitting alongside my daughter whilst teaching her car control on snow-covered private roads (MOD) ... but not much more wink - Streaky
why motorway driving is easy using the 'normal method'
leave sliproad at 40mph or LESS
immediately move to lane3 only signally between lane 2 & 3 AT THE MOST
then acclerate to lane 2 + 0.0001mph unless lane 1 & 2 are empty then do 57mph
wait till 20yrds from your exit & swerve across to make it off without indication or any observations
once the easy bits are mastered then random braking & tailgating are to be mastered

Edited by Hooli on Tuesday 29th April 22:33

diddly

91 posts

292 months

Tuesday 29th April 2008
quotequote all
The purpose of "supercentres" was solely to be able to legally introduce the EU motorcycle test, including a stop/swerve at 32mph i.e over the legal 30Mph speed limit. Learners are still learner drivers until told they have passed their test, so they have no more exemption from using motorways than any other learner.
The DSA is yet another quango desperately trying to save/make money.

The Black Duke

1,642 posts

224 months

Wednesday 30th April 2008
quotequote all
I love that word "QUANGO"!!

Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

275 months

Wednesday 30th April 2008
quotequote all
If they're intending to test motorway driving that's goint to be a right pi55er for the residents of the outer Hebrides, and the far north of Scotland; they'll have to drive (and ferry) a damned sight more than 40 miles.

TOPTON

Original Poster:

1,514 posts

267 months

Wednesday 30th April 2008
quotequote all
Einion Yrth said:
If they're intending to test motorway driving that's goint to be a right pi55er for the residents of the outer Hebrides, and the far north of Scotland; they'll have to drive (and ferry) a damned sight more than 40 miles.
That's a good point. On a similar note, something that has concerned me over the years is, people from those outlying areas learn to drive and pass the test in areas where there are no major hazards, (roundabouts, traffic light crossroads, one way systems etc)then go on to drive anywhere they choose. No doubt they are talked through the situations but all the theory of hazards is no comparison to doing the real thing.

Moving the tests to these 'super centers' is certainly a financial decision by the DSA. With little or no thought towards the learner who then has to take a test somewhere they have little experience of(test fail, more money please to do it again) and spend a lot more money getting there and back.
All that extra mileage-all that extra co2 emmisions

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Wednesday 30th April 2008
quotequote all
TOPTON said:
Moving the tests to these 'super centers' is certainly a financial decision by the DSA. With little or no thought towards the learner who then has to take a test somewhere they have little experience of(test fail, more money please to do it again) and spend a lot more money getting there and back.
All that extra mileage-all that extra co2 emmisions
i did my PSV test in a area i didnt know. made it easier if anything as i was looking for hazards/road conditions etc rather than relaxing into 'i know this road'.

TOPTON

Original Poster:

1,514 posts

267 months

Wednesday 30th April 2008
quotequote all
But the difference was Hooli, you could already drive and had xx years experience of doing so before doing your PSV.

Driving in a different area/city when you can already drive can be stressful enough for some people, but learners haven't got years of experience nor are they oozing with confidence.
I am not saying learners should learn the test routes as such, but being put in an alien environment and the pressure of the test cannot be good.
I pride myself in teaching people to drive and not to 'just pass the test', although the two do meet somewhere down the line.

I would guess the majority of drivers, not just learners, placed in a city they have never driven in and in a test situation would not drive as well as they could. Its that TEST word that's the killer. I have jokingly tested some of my mates driving and that word knocks the edge off their usual confidence

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Wednesday 30th April 2008
quotequote all
TOPTON said:
But the difference was Hooli, you could already drive and had xx years experience of doing so before doing your PSV.

Driving in a different area/city when you can already drive can be stressful enough for some people, but learners haven't got years of experience nor are they oozing with confidence.
I am not saying learners should learn the test routes as such, but being put in an alien environment and the pressure of the test cannot be good.
I pride myself in teaching people to drive and not to 'just pass the test', although the two do meet somewhere down the line.

I would guess the majority of drivers, not just learners, placed in a city they have never driven in and in a test situation would not drive as well as they could. Its that TEST word that's the killer. I have jokingly tested some of my mates driving and that word knocks the edge off their usual confidence
To counter that though, it may at least take some of the appalling "just passed" drivers off the road that should never have been there in the first place. All well and good mastering how to take the junction at the end of your road, but that doesn't mean you have reached a high enough standard if you can't fathom a different junction 5 miles further down.

Personally, although driving in some places can unsettle and stress me (I feckin HATE central London), if anything I find my standard of driving tends to improve.