Hit a pedestrian's arm - report to plod or not
Hit a pedestrian's arm - report to plod or not
Author
Discussion

BertBert

Original Poster:

21,347 posts

242 months

Wednesday 30th April 2008
quotequote all
Runner ran into the road without looking. Car's door mirror hit ped's arm. Car stopped. Runner a bit shaken, not specifically hurt, admitted to running out without looking (gassing to runner-chums). All happy, everyone goes on their way.

Report to plod or not?

Bert

Greendubber

15,391 posts

234 months

Wednesday 30th April 2008
quotequote all
I would if I were you, just in case 'runner' has a sudden change of heart!.

Double Play

70 posts

281 months

Wednesday 30th April 2008
quotequote all
For Chrissakes report it!

Davel

8,982 posts

289 months

Wednesday 30th April 2008
quotequote all
Certainly report it.

^Slider^

2,874 posts

280 months

Wednesday 30th April 2008
quotequote all
Possibly injury RTC so must report to police within 24 hours.

If he wakes up in the morining with bruising and soreness he will attend the police station. I suggest you get down there and report the collision.

Burgmeister

2,206 posts

241 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
or he may have genuinely thought "im a twerp, will look next time." thats certainly what i would do.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
Report it. Do you have runner's name/address/insurance company (only joking on the last)?

It's very possible that he - egged on by his fellow runners - will report it. It's possible that his version will now be different and it will now be your fault. It's possible that his fellow runners will back up a new account of the accident.

Whilst your passenger (if you had one) would not be an independent witness, several runners accompanying the one you hit might be (BiB to comment on this ... if acceptable as independent witnesses, then surely this is iniquitous). If so, you will find yourself like the proverbial dog with four trees. Not reporting the accident will compound any such problem.

Streaky

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
Report it. Do you have runner's name/address/insurance company (only joking on the last)?

It's very possible that he - egged on by his fellow runners - will report it. It's possible that his version will now be different and it will now be your fault. It's possible that his fellow runners will back up a new account of the accident.

Whilst your passenger (if you had one) would not be an independent witness, several runners accompanying the one you hit might be (BiB to comment on this ... if acceptable as independent witnesses, then surely this is iniquitous). If so, you will find yourself like the proverbial dog with four trees. Not reporting the accident will compound any such problem.

Streaky
Oddly they may count depending on how many and relation etc to injured chap. Interesting point.

Anyway fully agree to cover yourself report. Its technically an offence not to and always best to get your version down. Make sure you take your DL and ins etc to the station with you as its all needed.

insanojackson

6,027 posts

275 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
just ring up and report it "for info" as your not certain he is injured its not technically a reportable accident, nothing wrong with ringing up and asking them to creat an incident log "for info" just in case the runner turns up later and tries to claim you have made off.

If i was dealing with that situation i wouldnt take a full report from you, just log it in case of repercussions, a report could be taken at a later date if the runner came forward. this would save everyone concerned a little time

Balmoral Green

42,561 posts

279 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
How does reporting this cover you? As if getting in 1st with your version of events gives you the upper hand? It could be seen as the actions of a guilty conscience and you just end up making a mountain out of a molehill and incriminating yourself over something about which they very likely would not have known about and have been none the wiser. If you are innocent of anything, and it is just as you have said, why do anything? If it was nothing, do nowt, anything else suggests otherwise.

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
This happened to me a few years ago. I was appraoching a roundabout to turn rught, so was in teh RH lane. 3 or 4 vehicles in LH land including a transit box van. As I appraoched the roundabout, a runner ran out from in front of the transit. I had no chance and knocked her forward about 10 ft, and to the ground. I absolutely st myself, and got out just as she was getting up. She apologised, and ran off.

Oh, and I didn't report it.

Edited by fatboy b on Thursday 1st May 09:16

insanojackson

6,027 posts

275 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
Balmoral Green said:
How does reporting this cover you? As if getting in 1st with your version of events gives you the upper hand? It could be seen as the actions of a guilty conscience and you just end up making a mountain out of a molehill and incriminating yourself over something about which they very likely would not have known about and have been none the wiser. If you are innocent of anything, and it is just as you have said, why do anything? If it was nothing, do nowt, anything else suggests otherwise.
it doesnt cover your version of events but it does help you comply with the road traffic act and your duty to report accidents!

Balmoral Green

42,561 posts

279 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
If clipping an elbow with a door mirror constitutes an accident, fair enough.

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
I wouldn't bother reporting.

My wife's car and another car were hit by a woman driving a car too fast to stop for parked cars on her side. She attempted to pass even though my wife was coming the other way. She couldn't squeeze through the gap and hit the parked car and my wifes' wing mirror.

She initially stopped but when asked for insurance details she drove off.

We reported the incident to the police and they came to see us.
Are you going to prosecute her I asked since she hadn't reported the accident.
No they said... she told us she didn't realise she had hit anything.

oh really I said.. at which point I produced a carboard box and inside were both her wing mirrors that had come off after she had hit both the parked car and my wifes' car.

She still didn't get prosecuted for failing to stop or report.
I presume the police must have accepted that noone would even notice their car was suddenly minus both wing mirrors after banging its way through a gap that didn't exist.


Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
mark69sheer said:
I wouldn't bother reporting.

My wife's car and another car were hit by a woman driving a car too fast to stop for parked cars on her side. She attempted to pass even though my wife was coming the other way. She couldn't squeeze through the gap and hit the parked car and my wifes' wing mirror.

She initially stopped but when asked for insurance details she drove off.

We reported the incident to the police and they came to see us.
Are you going to prosecute her I asked since she hadn't reported the accident.
No they said... she told us she didn't realise she had hit anything.

oh really I said.. at which point I produced a carboard box and inside were both her wing mirrors that had come off after she had hit both the parked car and my wifes' car.

She still didn't get prosecuted for failing to stop or report.]



Cps won't run just fts unless over factors like no insurance etc. In your case the job would be a non runner. In this incident my concern would be the runners change of mind more than failure to report. The failure to report would / could add weight to any differing version of the crash.


I presume the police must have accepted that noone would even notice their car was suddenly minus both wing mirrors after banging its way through a gap that didn't exist.

7db

6,060 posts

261 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
I don't think this is reportable under RTA. No damage or injury sustained - not reportable. Driver stopped. No person reasonably requiring him to produce asking him to produce.

Still - I'd report it just in case.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
7db said:
I don't think this is reportable under RTA. No damage or injury sustained - not reportable ...
But injury might have occured - e.g. hairline fracture of radius or ulna (assuming forearm). Bruising would come out overnight, plus pain. X-ray at hospital reveals fracture. Runner reports but driver hasn't. It's not worth the risk - Streaky

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
7db said:
I don't think this is reportable under RTA. No damage or injury sustained - not reportable ...
But injury might have occured - e.g. hairline fracture of radius or ulna (assuming forearm). Bruising would come out overnight, plus pain. X-ray at hospital reveals fracture. Runner reports but driver hasn't. It's not worth the risk - Streaky
Agreed. Once the where there is blame there is a claim adverts have shown a few times matey might change his mind.

p1esk

4,914 posts

227 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
Bert - if I were you I would report it. I don't see how you can be disadvantaged by doing so, and I feel it would put you in a better position if the runner subsequently decides he has a problem that he wishes to pursue.

Best wishes all,
Dave.

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
streaky said:
7db said:
I don't think this is reportable under RTA. No damage or injury sustained - not reportable ...
But injury might have occured - e.g. hairline fracture of radius or ulna (assuming forearm). Bruising would come out overnight, plus pain. X-ray at hospital reveals fracture. Runner reports but driver hasn't. It's not worth the risk - Streaky
Agreed. Once the where there is blame there is a claim adverts have shown a few times matey might change his mind.
Sadly .. folk do think in terms of compo.. what can I gain? banghead

Did this runner und his mates take your reg details .. name.. addresss.. ?

I would just go to police station with all documents und just say exactly what happen und stress young man went on his way without giving you any details anyway.. assuring he was OK. But you just want to be sure you within the law here... just in case.


Keep us informed of what happen next. PH ist a bit like a "soap opera with the cliff hanger ending" at times rofl