Police crackdowns - But are value for our money?
Police crackdowns - But are value for our money?
Author
Discussion

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
Rather they do that then sit with hairdryers next to the road.

XMG5

Original Poster:

1,082 posts

258 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
XMG5 said:
Bath Chronicle 1st May 2008

"A high performance sports car was seized by police near Bath in a regionwide crackdown on crime.Across the Avon and Somerset force area police, with the help of sniffer dogs, made 14 arrests in a day of action as part of their long-term Operation Relentless initiative.

More than 100 officers linked up with other enforcement agencies in an exercise to target offenders on wheels.

Operation Relentless used Automated Number Plate Recognition to identify wanted vehicles. ANPR involves taking an image of the number plate which is then run through various computer databases.

Nearly 400 vehicles were stopped and 64,360 registration plates scanned at sites at Junction 18 of the M4 at Tormarton, the Second Severn Crossing, Michaelwood and Taunton Deane services on the M5, and Podimore services on the A303.

At Tomarton, police stopped 95 vehicles and seized five - including the Porsche, which was uninsured.

Three men were arrested - one for driving while disqualified, one for being wanted on warrant and one who was a registered sex offender for failing to notify a change of address."

Logistically speaking, is this value for money?
scratchchin

Edited by XMG5 on Thursday 1st May 13:19

Jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
Getting uninsured and disqualified drivers off the road is good value for money IMHO yes.


EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
Amazing ... I must have known what you were about to post smile

XMG5

Original Poster:

1,082 posts

258 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
Sorry EU Foreigner

I was amending when you posted.

XMG5

Original Poster:

1,082 posts

258 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Getting uninsured and disqualified drivers off the road is good value for money IMHO yes.
But that's my point, look again at the numbers involved. Compare the number of BiB committed, number of vehicles scanned, number of vehicles stopped and number of arrests. Now look at what the arrests are for. One is a Sex Offender failing to comply with his conditions, one is for no Insurance and one was wanted on a warrant. is that worth the cost of 100 BiB's for the day? That's without the cost of the man-hours spent planning it.

When do we see 100 BiBs on the street. Answer: Never, they are allegedly writing up files on all the criminals that are being caught. But how are these vast numbers of criminals being caught if there are no BiBs on the streets because of the paperwork.....and so it goes on, chicken and egg-like.

I personally don't think the 'return' on the investment in time and manpower in the above example to be good value for public money.

Edited by XMG5 on Thursday 1st May 13:15

davido140

9,617 posts

257 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
XMG5 said:
Jasandjules said:
Getting uninsured and disqualified drivers off the road is good value for money IMHO yes.
But that's my point, look again at the numbers involved. Compare the number of BiB involved, number of vehicles scanned and number of arrests. Now look at what the arrests are for. One is a Sex Offender failing to comply with his conditions, one is for no Insurance and one was wanted on a warrant. is that worth the cost of 100 BiB's for the day? That's without the cost of the man-hours spent planning it.

When do we see 100 BiBs on the street. Answer: Never, they are allegedly writing upo files on all the criminals that are being caught. But how are these vast numbers of criminals being caught if there are no BiBs on the streets because of the paperwork.....and so it goes on, chicken and egg-like.

I personally don't think the 'return' on the investment in time and manpower in the above example shows value for public money.
Good point, these "crack downs" are just bloody big PR stunts IMO.

It is however just 1 day for the vast majority of the BiB involved, sure some were busy planning for weeks in advance, but most were just drafted in for the day.

provided they are kept relatively "secret" prior to the operation, (so the local scrotes dont know that today is the day for nicking a car as they are all on the Mway) I cant see it affecting policing in the area one way or the other.

Jasandjules

72,690 posts

260 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
14 Arrests, 5 cars off the road which shouldn't be there, for just one day's work. I don't think that's bad really, and if you ever got hit by an uninsured driver, you may think the same?

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
it is a tough call, I am all up for having 1 or 2 police cars scanning passing cars and stopping them if it gets uninsured un taxed or other forms of illegal drivers off the road but over 100 coppers being involved and only 14 arrests doesnt represent good value for money as far as i can see.

It always surprises me how many coppers need to be at these 'events' which they call massive clamp downs. I used to work at Michaelwood services on the M5 and once a year the police would stop and search nealy every car coming into the services during the weekend of Glastonbury festival and it would involve 50+ police officers and for all the searching - - includeing letting sniffer dogs in the cars and spending a fair amount of time per car the best results were a group of people going to glastonbury with some weed on them.

Watching a police fly on the wall documentary the other day and it was showing the build up to a series of dawn raids on suspected drug dealers... the police smashed there way into 5 houses in one they arrested a entire family and only found tiny tiny amount of heroin. Again it just didnt seem to be worth the number of officers involved.

Personnaly i think crackdowns could be better executed, i agree with having teams of officers which specialise in a certain area go out on missions as it were but sometimes you cant help but think maybe the DVLA should have its own police force. I could be wrong here but isnt the marvelous DVLA computer meant to track anyone without tax/mot/insurance so then the DVLA could deal with the issue thus freeing up officers to tackle other issues


telecat

8,528 posts

272 months

Thursday 1st May 2008
quotequote all
It's a "fishing" operation. Not "Intelligence" driven because they don't have the officers on the "ground" to gather it. Sounds like even the drug raid mentioned earlier didn't get the attention prior to the event it deserved.