Insurance question - don't think I'm to blame but...
Insurance question - don't think I'm to blame but...
Author
Discussion

broadhat

Original Poster:

718 posts

244 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
Hi All

I had an incident yesterday in a hire car and although I don't believe I'm to blame, when I informed my insurance company I could hear them rubbing their hands when it comes to renewal...

I picked up a hire car (Alfa 146 on 135k miles) yesterday afternoon from an independent as my car is being serviced today. I received two verbal confirmations that I was covered on their insurance (also able to drive 3rd party on mine)

About 10 miles into my journey home on a motorway a huge crash from underneath and smoke out the back. I managed to coast to a stop safely however I had seen the car behind me veer sharply to the left. I ran back (others already calling 999) and his car was overturned 20 foot down in a ditch but the driver - only person in car - was already out and walking around completely fine. Trafpol on scene in about 3 mins followed by passing ambulance and 5 fire engines. Paramedics checked out the driver and were happy he was OK.

The trafpol was great but told me that it would be classified as an accident (thought they didn't happen anymore?) and although they wouldn't investigate further as there were no injuries the other driver's insurance would come after me.

Whilst I can understand this to a point, I could also argue there's no fault on my side - other driver was too close/not paying attention/over-reacted.

When I spoke with my insurance I confirmed I was informing them for information only and not making a claim. I asked about what happens at renewal time and they told me I would have to declare it as an incident. They also told me I would have to inform the garage's insurance which makes sense.

Whilst I'm just glad the other driver was fine and hate having to cover my backside, I don't want to accept any blame but recall from PH that insurance companies can take the easiest route to settlement and may accept partial blame on my side. If this is accurate, I'd like to make that as difficult as possible for them.

From a legal perspective, am I to blame? Will this be classed as a no-fault claim?

Hmmm, another thought. The garage don't seem too concerned but what should my reaction be if they try and make me pay for the car? Not happy I killed an Alfa but I don't want to end up paying for it either.

Any thoughts?

Thanks!


WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
broadhat said:
Hi All

I had an incident yesterday in a hire car and although I don't believe I'm to blame, when I informed my insurance company I could hear them rubbing their hands when it comes to renewal...

I picked up a hire car (Alfa 146 on 135k miles) yesterday afternoon from an independent as my car is being serviced today. I received two verbal confirmations that I was covered on their insurance (also able to drive 3rd party on mine)

About 10 miles into my journey home on a motorway a huge crash from underneath and smoke outthe back. I managed to coast to a stop safely however I had seen the car behind me veer sharply to the left. I ran back (others already calling 999) and his car was overturned 20 foot down in a ditch but the driver - only person in car - was already out and walking around completely fine. Trafpol on scene in about 3 mins followed by passing ambulance and 5 fire engines. Paramedics checked out the driver and were happy he was OK.

The trafpol was great but told me that it would be classified as an accident (thought they didn't happen anymore?) and although they wouldn't investigate further as there were no injuries the other driver's insurance would come after me.

Whilst I can understand this to a point, I could also argue there's no fault on my side - other driver was too close/not paying attention/over-reacted.

When I spoke with my insurance I confirmed I was informing them for information only and not making a claim. I asked about what happens at renewal time and they told me I would have to declare it as an incident. They also told me I would have to inform the garage's insurance which makes sense.

Whilst I'm just glad the other driver was fine and hate having to cover my backside, I don't want to accept any blame but recall from PH that insurance companies can take the easiest route to settlement and may accept partial blame on my side. If this is accurate, I'd like to make that as difficult as possible for them.

From a legal perspective, am I to blame? Will this be classed as a no-fault claim?

Hmmm, another thought. The garage don't seem too concerned but what should my reaction be if they try and make me pay for the car? Not happy I killed an Alfa but I don't want to end up paying for it either.

Any thoughts?

Thanks!

Garage may decide to mend for themselves. I do not think their NCB affected as I think they will be paying up more or less full whacks as business expense. However, their insurers could try to recoup from the insurance company of the person who rammed into BACK of you. I do not think he has leg to stand on as he hit the REAR of this car as I understand the post here. You will have to declare as incident for 5 years - und insurers will try any excuse to load anything banghead If your insurers do load (und it difficult to establish as I hear that premiums will be increasing by 10% in the next year anyway ranting) - but all I can suggest ist to shoppe around for bestest deal at renewal time.

broadhat

Original Poster:

718 posts

244 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
WildCat said:
However, their insurers could try to recoup from the insurance company of the person who rammed into BACK of you. I do not think he has leg to stand on as he hit the REAR of this car as I understand the post here.
Thanks for that - however he didn't hit me. Should have made that clearer! There was no contact between our cars at all.

A quick summary would be: big cloud of smoke out the back of my car, car behind lost control and left the road. At the time he didn't talk about debris or anything like that. Just that he couldn't see and that was all.

Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
Maybe I'm missing something but what was the cause of the noise/smoke/debris*?

Did your vehicle malfunction? If it did was it foreseeable or preventable? If so the vehicle owners (the garage) may have a part to play in this.

Did you hit something? You can hardly be held at fault if it were unavoidable.

Why did the third party swerve and crash? Too close? Not paying attention?

Too many variables and not enough information at the moment but for now I'd be denying liability if I were you (you certainly shouldn't admit to anything unless you want your insurance invalidated).







  • If any.

broadhat

Original Poster:

718 posts

244 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
No idea what happened to the car I was driving. Big bang, lots of smoke out the back and in cabin. Don't believe I ran over anything. Can't see how/why I would admit liability but the point is how will the insurance companies view it and is there anything I can do to protect myself from them apportioning blame to me?

eta: the garage say they only had the car 3 days. It was a P reg on 135k miles. They had looked over it as they gave it a new radiator.

Edited by broadhat on Friday 2nd May 13:22

havoc

33,525 posts

266 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
Not even sure why you reported it, but there we go...

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
Mechanical failure that could not have been forseen ? There can be no negligence.

Elliott v Chiew - although that was a deflated tyre. Same thing.

broadhat

Original Poster:

718 posts

244 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
havoc said:
Not even sure why you reported it, but there we go...
Reported as trafpol made us exchange details and I had a call from a hire car company first thing who said my details were supplied by his insurance company.

Didn't want to be in a position where my insurance says 'why didn't you tell us?'

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
broadhat said:
WildCat said:
However, their insurers could try to recoup from the insurance company of the person who rammed into BACK of you. I do not think he has leg to stand on as he hit the REAR of this car as I understand the post here.
Thanks for that - however he didn't hit me. Should have made that clearer! There was no contact between our cars at all.

A quick summary would be: big cloud of smoke out the back of my car, car behind lost control and left the road. At the time he didn't talk about debris or anything like that. Just that he couldn't see and that was all.
Then it backfire for some reason. Perhaps a cylinder und piston fail? carburretor fail in older car?

Did you notice any noise in engine or a thudding coming from engine? or any sound which sound like exhaust on way out as it may even be this simple? Just before this happen? It does sound as if this car has a problem with gasket or cylinder und may have been burning oil. scratchchin In which case - this NOT your fault und you must insist that you get full report from garage protect your bank balances here. rolleyes

broadhat

Original Poster:

718 posts

244 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
There was no prior warning about the failure - no knockings, rattlings or bumps. Just a sudden bang. Sounds like a sensible precaution to get a report from the garage though, thanks.

Had a call from the bloke who trashed his car. He was only insured 3rd party so that's a 3 grand Golf he's lost. Alternatively he spent £3k saving his life.

He accepts there was nothing I could have done, he was just hoping he might have some redress against the garage supplying me with a faulty car. Told him there's probably no joy down that road as they looked it over and replaced the radiator. Harsh lessons.

gazza285

11,262 posts

239 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
136k on a 146? Usually gone bang way before then.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
if the car behind didnt hit you AND nothing fell off your car causing him to swerve i cant see how it'd be your fault he decided to park in a ditch.
it'll be interesting to hear the outcome of this one.

Mad Moggie2

784 posts

237 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
broadhat said:
There was no prior warning about the failure - no knockings, rattlings or bumps. Just a sudden bang. Sounds like a sensible precaution to get a report from the garage though, thanks.

Had a call from the bloke who trashed his car. He was only insured 3rd party so that's a 3 grand Golf he's lost. Alternatively he spent £3k saving his life.

He accepts there was nothing I could have done, he was just hoping he might have some redress against the garage supplying me with a faulty car. Told him there's probably no joy down that road as they looked it over and replaced the radiator. Harsh lessons.
As my wife - Wildy suggested - get a full report from this garage. A leaky radiator causes the engine to overheat. I do not think it causes a smokey belchy backfire rolleyes That's something else as my wife pointed out here. They missed something here. Get and demand a full report for insurers and pass on to the other guy here.


Am ex-BRAKE member. In the early days of BRAKE - we hit dodgy garages with knock out blows. If they missed something - and loaned a sub-standard vehicle - then they deserve a huge hit!

broadhat

Original Poster:

718 posts

244 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
Mad Moggie2 said:
broadhat said:
There was no prior warning about the failure - no knockings, rattlings or bumps. Just a sudden bang. Sounds like a sensible precaution to get a report from the garage though, thanks.

Had a call from the bloke who trashed his car. He was only insured 3rd party so that's a 3 grand Golf he's lost. Alternatively he spent £3k saving his life.

He accepts there was nothing I could have done, he was just hoping he might have some redress against the garage supplying me with a faulty car. Told him there's probably no joy down that road as they looked it over and replaced the radiator. Harsh lessons.
As my wife - Wildy suggested - get a full report from this garage. A leaky radiator causes the engine to overheat. I do not think it causes a smokey belchy backfire rolleyes That's something else as my wife pointed out here. They missed something here. Get and demand a full report for insurers and pass on to the other guy here.


Am ex-BRAKE member. In the early days of BRAKE - we hit dodgy garages with knock out blows. If they missed something - and loaned a sub-standard vehicle - then they deserve a huge hit!
They told me they looked over the car when they got it a few days before they loaned it to me and replaced the radiator then - clearly a dodgy radiator wouldn't do that. When I picked up my car today (sounding better than ever!) they mentioned that the altenator was 'grumbly' Could an alternator fail in a big cloud of smoke? I've requested a report, but it's not exactly independent is it?

F i F

49,031 posts

282 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
If a collision occurs due to a mechanical failure it is a strictly allowable and legally recognised defence if the vehicle has been serviced in accordance with the manufacturer's recommendations.

As far as OP is concerned then providing he made a normal pre driving check, eg lights tyres etc before accepting the loan vehicle then imo he has nothing to worry about.

As far as the garage is concerned they have the issue of what they did with this once over.

As far as OP's next insurance premium is concerned is a moot point. In theory the premium should be simply assessed on the risk, but as we all know insurance companies are sharks in suits. Therefore be aware that come renewal time it may be well worth while doing a comprehensive search round the market.

I can recommend following the advice in moneysavingexpert. Religiously following the advice every step of the way I got a quote for daughter down from 1800 to 745 including breakdown cover. She had been quoted up to £4k. Is it any wonder that people with bangers drive around with no insurance?

Edited by F i F on Saturday 3rd May 08:01

Jasandjules

72,691 posts

260 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
Hooli said:
if the car behind didnt hit you AND nothing fell off your car causing him to swerve i cant see how it'd be your fault he decided to park in a ditch.
it'll be interesting to hear the outcome of this one.
That way my first thought. Golf driver should be driving at a speed and distance to take evasive actions safely. What would he have done had you had to instigate an emergency stop?

IF your exhaust didn't hit him, he just yanked the wheel when he saw smoke, that isn't your fault, but it does call his driving skills into question.

_daveR

6,146 posts

258 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
Im going to watch this thread with interest. Personally I cannot believe the OP is liable in any way for the numpty in the Golf not paying attention and then over reacting.
Best of luck to the OP, I hope common sense prevails.