Common sense prevails
Author
Discussion

odyssey2200

Original Poster:

18,650 posts

240 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/1918081/Driver-cle...


Personally I would have been too ashamed af being cought listening to Riverdance in the first place that I would have probably paid up and getmecoat

But

Well done that man, and well done judge

Sheriff JWPepper

3,851 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
Why is it a victory for common sense?

fatjon

2,299 posts

244 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
If you neeed to ask you prove what many already suspect.

Sheriff JWPepper

3,851 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
fatjon said:
If you neeed to ask you prove what many already suspect.
You may be willing to jump to the conclusion that a newspaper article wants you to, I don't, so hence the question.

HRG

72,863 posts

270 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
Sheriff JWPepper said:
fatjon said:
If you neeed to ask you prove what many already suspect.
You may be willing to jump to the conclusion that a newspaper article wants you to, I don't, so hence the question.
The article says his music was at a volume where he could hear the WPC giving him directions.

Common sense yes

odyssey2200

Original Poster:

18,650 posts

240 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
Judge kicked it out.

Sadly not before 6 bayliffs visits, even thought he had opted to plead not guilty.

So guilty until proven innocent?
Using Bayliffs to enforce something that a judge had not yet ruled on?

The guy was in the radio today and conformed all of the above.

This type of useless ste is another reason why Gordon is getting a kicking today IMHO.



Edited by odyssey2200 on Friday 2nd May 15:02

Sheriff JWPepper

3,851 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
odyssey2200 said:
Judge licked it out.
Quoted for posterity. tongue out

Sheriff JWPepper

3,851 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
odyssey2200 said:
Sadly not before 6 bayliffs visits, even thought he had opted to plead not guilty.

So guilty until proven innocent?
Using Bayliffs to enforce something that a judge had not yet ruled on?

The guy was in the radio today and conformed all of the above.

This type of useless ste is another reason why Gordon is getting a kicking today IMHO.
Did they explain why it was not brought before a court before the costs started to mount up?

HRG

72,863 posts

270 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
Sheriff JWPepper said:
odyssey2200 said:
Sadly not before 6 bayliffs visits, even thought he had opted to plead not guilty.

So guilty until proven innocent?
Using Bayliffs to enforce something that a judge had not yet ruled on?

The guy was in the radio today and conformed all of the above.

This type of useless ste is another reason why Gordon is getting a kicking today IMHO.
Did they explain why it was not brought before a court before the costs started to mount up?
Failure to understand the BOR perhaps?

odyssey2200

Original Poster:

18,650 posts

240 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
Sheriff JWPepper said:
odyssey2200 said:
Judge licked it out.
Quoted for posterity. tongue out
rofl


whoooops

typo!
rofl

getmecoat

JamesZS

541 posts

227 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
Sheriff JWPepper said:
Why is it a victory for common sense?
I share this confusion... where is the common sense element.

The article states that the person given the ticket stated that he could hear the PC talking.
I reserve judgement on the offence as I don't know the facts, neither do any of us (having not heard the volume of the music)... however I can't see how this is common sense prevailing?

HRG

72,863 posts

270 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
JamesZS said:
Sheriff JWPepper said:
Why is it a victory for common sense?
I share this confusion... where is the common sense element.

The article states that the person given the ticket stated that he could hear the PC talking.
I reserve judgement on the offence as I don't know the facts, neither do any of us (having not heard the volume of the music)... however I can't see how this is common sense prevailing?
Perhaps that says more about your understanding of common sense?

TTwiggy

11,884 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
JamesZS said:
Sheriff JWPepper said:
Why is it a victory for common sense?
I share this confusion... where is the common sense element.

The article states that the person given the ticket stated that he could hear the PC talking.
I reserve judgement on the offence as I don't know the facts, neither do any of us (having not heard the volume of the music)... however I can't see how this is common sense prevailing?
I'd imagine that it's because in a society where one can increasingly be fined for pretty much anything, on the basis of one person's word (and this is not exclusive to Bib, as many councli offials are capable of hitting you in the wallet) and then have the fun of a state using all its power to ensure that you don't try and wriggle out of it by having the audacity to plead 'not guilty', a Judge has looked at the case and thought 'you know what, maybe this should have been sorted out by the old fashioned principle of conversation?' - ie. copper says 'sorry, could you turn that down a bit, I can't really hear you' to which MOP replies 'oh sorry, I didn't realise how loud it was' - they both have a bit of a laugh and go on their seperate ways...

odyssey2200

Original Poster:

18,650 posts

240 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
TTwiggy said:
JamesZS said:
Sheriff JWPepper said:
Why is it a victory for common sense?
I share this confusion... where is the common sense element.

The article states that the person given the ticket stated that he could hear the PC talking.
I reserve judgement on the offence as I don't know the facts, neither do any of us (having not heard the volume of the music)... however I can't see how this is common sense prevailing?
I'd imagine that it's because in a society where one can increasingly be fined for pretty much anything, on the basis of one person's word (and this is not exclusive to Bib, as many councli offials are capable of hitting you in the wallet) and then have the fun of a state using all its power to ensure that you don't try and wriggle out of it by having the audacity to plead 'not guilty', a Judge has looked at the case and thought 'you know what, maybe this should have been sorted out by the old fashioned principle of conversation?' - ie. copper says 'sorry, could you turn that down a bit, I can't really hear you' to which MOP replies 'oh sorry, I didn't realise how loud it was' - they both have a bit of a laugh and go on their seperate ways...
YEP!!!!clap

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
odyssey2200 said:
TTwiggy said:
JamesZS said:
Sheriff JWPepper said:
Why is it a victory for common sense?
I share this confusion... where is the common sense element.

The article states that the person given the ticket stated that he could hear the PC talking.
I reserve judgement on the offence as I don't know the facts, neither do any of us (having not heard the volume of the music)... however I can't see how this is common sense prevailing?
I'd imagine that it's because in a society where one can increasingly be fined for pretty much anything, on the basis of one person's word (and this is not exclusive to Bib, as many councli offials are capable of hitting you in the wallet) and then have the fun of a state using all its power to ensure that you don't try and wriggle out of it by having the audacity to plead 'not guilty', a Judge has looked at the case and thought 'you know what, maybe this should have been sorted out by the old fashioned principle of conversation?' - ie. copper says 'sorry, could you turn that down a bit, I can't really hear you' to which MOP replies 'oh sorry, I didn't realise how loud it was' - they both have a bit of a laugh and go on their seperate ways...
Unless of course that's how it started and the chap started arguing the point from the off that it was not too loud. Maybe he is the one lacking common sense and politeness towards others. Loud music in a car can really impact upon some peoples quality of life. Not all car drivers act or drive with consideration towards others.


YEP!!!!clap

odyssey2200

Original Poster:

18,650 posts

240 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
Wow! never expected a BiB to get arsey cos the little man won and spoiled Plods game!rolleyes


TTwiggy

11,884 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
odyssey2200 said:
TTwiggy said:
JamesZS said:
Sheriff JWPepper said:
Why is it a victory for common sense?
I share this confusion... where is the common sense element.

The article states that the person given the ticket stated that he could hear the PC talking.
I reserve judgement on the offence as I don't know the facts, neither do any of us (having not heard the volume of the music)... however I can't see how this is common sense prevailing?
I'd imagine that it's because in a society where one can increasingly be fined for pretty much anything, on the basis of one person's word (and this is not exclusive to Bib, as many councli offials are capable of hitting you in the wallet) and then have the fun of a state using all its power to ensure that you don't try and wriggle out of it by having the audacity to plead 'not guilty', a Judge has looked at the case and thought 'you know what, maybe this should have been sorted out by the old fashioned principle of conversation?' - ie. copper says 'sorry, could you turn that down a bit, I can't really hear you' to which MOP replies 'oh sorry, I didn't realise how loud it was' - they both have a bit of a laugh and go on their seperate ways...
Unless of course that's how it started and the chap started arguing the point from the off that it was not too loud. Maybe he is the one lacking common sense and politeness towards others. Loud music in a car can really impact upon some peoples quality of life. Not all car drivers act or drive with consideration towards others.


YEP!!!!clap
well, we'll never know will we? We'll just have to take the decision of a court of law and Judge on this one...

odyssey2200

Original Poster:

18,650 posts

240 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
I would be as bold as to suggest that the fact he was listening to Riverdance would give you a clue as to the man!

Not like he was playing 50cent or drum and bass st?


rewc

2,187 posts

264 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
The Police Officer obviously thought the music was loud enough to cause offence and issued the FPN. Why couldn't she prove it to the satisfaction of the court? Surely the criteria a Police Officer should use prior to issuing a FPN is " if it were to go to court could I prove beyond reasonable doubt that a crime has been committed"?

odyssey2200

Original Poster:

18,650 posts

240 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
maybe she had the hump cos he interrupted her as she was reaching that crucial stage!

Coitus interruptus, perhaps.