Freedom of speech down the plughole.
Freedom of speech down the plughole.
Author
Discussion

nigel_bytes

Original Poster:

557 posts

267 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
We're living in scary times.


Blogger fined for 'menacing' rant

The court heard Brent is charged with 19 theft offences

A blogger who "let off steam" about the way he was treated by police has been convicted of posting a grossly offensive and menacing message.

Gavin Brent, 24, from Holywell, Flintshire, was fined £150 with £364 costs by magistrates at Mold.

The court heard Brent had been charged with theft offences - which have yet to be dealt with - and posted a message about a police officer's new-born baby.

Magistrates said any reasonable person would find the comments menacing.

In February, Brent was charged with 19 offences of theft and two charges under the Proceeds of Crime Act involving internet purchases.

The court heard how detective constable Steve Lloyd conducted interviews, but was not present when Brent was charged because his wife was having a baby.

'Freedom of speech'

Prosecutor Liz Bell said someone unfortunately told Brent why the officer was absent.

Brent then ranted about his perceived mis-treatment at the hands of police and the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS).

His posting ended: "P.S. - D.C. Lloyd, God help your new-born baby".

The officer and his wife saw the message and Brent, who is unemployed, was arrested at his home. He then claimed: "You can write on websites because it's freedom of speech."

In interview, he said he felt he had been mistreated and hoped the officer would not treat his child the same way.

Brent was prosecuted under the Telecommunications Act, relating to the sending of an electronic message.

He claimed he had not meant to be offensive, had used the blog "to let off steam", but had not intended any harm.

He apologised if it was perceived as a threat, offered to remove the offending words, and to write a letter of apology.

Asked if he realised how the officer and his wife would have felt when they read his comments, he said: "I can now. I am sorry. But their interpretation is different to what I intended."

Flintshire magistrates, sitting at Mold, said the blog was articulate, detailed, specific and critical of the police and the CPS.

They said any reasonable person would find the words about the baby to be menacing in the context of the overall blog.

The blog entry has been removed

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/north_east/737363...

forza whites

2,555 posts

226 months

Friday 2nd May 2008
quotequote all
Not the way to do things obviously!

But most of our 'freedoms' have been eradicted over the passing years....
The UK has the most draconian legislation in a whole number of areas concerning so called
'freedoms'...Sign of the times really. I remember the Met Police confiscating banners and placards
from peaceful demonstrators in London (specifically on the Mall) against a Chinese State Visit.

Later in the high court the actions of the Met Police were confirmed as 'theft'...but no action
taken. And if you persist to diagree with any officer, no matter how polite and well mannered one
is, there is the old chestnut of 'breach of the peace'

Face it....

I should know...........Many moons ago I worked in the Military - Electronic Warfare.....
and jeepers some of the stuff we were asked to do!!


Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
nigel_bytes said:
We're living in scary times.


Blogger fined for 'menacing' rant

The court heard Brent is charged with 19 theft offences

A blogger who "let off steam" about the way he was treated by police has been convicted of posting a grossly offensive and menacing message.

Gavin Brent, 24, from Holywell, Flintshire, was fined £150 with £364 costs by magistrates at Mold.

The court heard Brent had been charged with theft offences - which have yet to be dealt with - and posted a message about a police officer's new-born baby.

Magistrates said any reasonable person would find the comments menacing.

In February, Brent was charged with 19 offences of theft and two charges under the Proceeds of Crime Act involving internet purchases.

The court heard how detective constable Steve Lloyd conducted interviews, but was not present when Brent was charged because his wife was having a baby.

'Freedom of speech'

Prosecutor Liz Bell said someone unfortunately told Brent why the officer was absent.

Brent then ranted about his perceived mis-treatment at the hands of police and the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS).

His posting ended: "P.S. - D.C. Lloyd, God help your new-born baby".

The officer and his wife saw the message and Brent, who is unemployed, was arrested at his home. He then claimed: "You can write on websites because it's freedom of speech."

In interview, he said he felt he had been mistreated and hoped the officer would not treat his child the same way.

Brent was prosecuted under the Telecommunications Act, relating to the sending of an electronic message.

He claimed he had not meant to be offensive, had used the blog "to let off steam", but had not intended any harm.

He apologised if it was perceived as a threat, offered to remove the offending words, and to write a letter of apology.

Asked if he realised how the officer and his wife would have felt when they read his comments, he said: "I can now. I am sorry. But their interpretation is different to what I intended."

Flintshire magistrates, sitting at Mold, said the blog was articulate, detailed, specific and critical of the police and the CPS.

They said any reasonable person would find the words about the baby to be menacing in the context of the overall blog.

The blog entry has been removed

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/north_east/737363...
Fredom of speech is not and should not be hidden behind to cause harm to another. Otherwise racist remarks or similar would be allowed. Unless the op and others think its fine to insult someone and cause them great upset or have implied threats is fine?

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
Whilst I can see the merits in the argument about free speech, I feel that an implied threat to a child would not come into that definition.

Even so, the offender got his chance in court.

Threats to police officers is a constant worry. I've been followed home - or would have been had I not noticed him - by a chap who'd been arrested for assault. I was just the review officer so hardly one to pick on I would have thought. We never did find out why he picked me.

I, like most officers, accepted that I would leave one or two people a bit anti, but if they threaten my family, that's an entirely different matter.

I would suggest that most people would, if the courts did not take a stand in the matter, take steps to defend their loved ones. The chap who followed me also threatened and followed others. His car caught fire, unfortunately when he wasn't in it, and for a while I thought a colleague of mine might have been the pyromaniac. I was quite disappointed to discover that it was one of his 'colleagues' whom he had threatened. The bloke got severely beaten as well a little later after not taking the warning into account but didn't make a complaint.

I did a review on him around five years laer and he was out of his brain on drugs, had lots and lots of various diseases and was about as derelict as the Titanic.

As an aside, the first chap I arrested actually asked me into his works canteen for a cup of tea and sticky bun when I saw him in the street a few weeks after he'd been found guilty.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
Sticky bun scratchchin

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
im sure i remember a long thread on this, damned if i can find it though.
saying what you think is one thing, threatening a plod's kids is another. by all means say you think it was unfair etc etc thats free speach, threatening people and their families isnt.

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
Brent said:
"P.S. - D.C. Lloyd, God help your new-born baby".
Why does everyone presume that this meant, "God help your new-born baby (because I intend to harm it)"?

Is it not at least as likely that this guy meant, "God help your new-born baby (because any child with a parent like you would need help)"?

The first is threatening and out of order, the second is crude and tasteless, but not in the least threatening.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
flemke said:
Brent said:
"P.S. - D.C. Lloyd, God help your new-born baby".
Why does everyone presume that this meant, "God help your new-born baby (because I intend to harm it)"?

Is it not at least as likely that this guy meant, "God help your new-born baby (because any child with a parent like you would need help)"?

The first is threatening and out of order, the second is crude and tasteless, but not in the least threatening.
Perhaps the context or framework within which it was said, leads those who have full knowledge of the case in question to take it as a threat.

flemke

23,515 posts

268 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
flemke said:
Brent said:
"P.S. - D.C. Lloyd, God help your new-born baby".
Why does everyone presume that this meant, "God help your new-born baby (because I intend to harm it)"?

Is it not at least as likely that this guy meant, "God help your new-born baby (because any child with a parent like you would need help)"?

The first is threatening and out of order, the second is crude and tasteless, but not in the least threatening.
Perhaps the context or framework within which it was said, leads those who have full knowledge of the case in question to take it as a threat.
Possible, although that wouldn't apply to the posters on this thread.wink

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
flemke said:
Brent said:
"P.S. - D.C. Lloyd, God help your new-born baby".
Why does everyone presume that this meant, "God help your new-born baby (because I intend to harm it)"?

Is it not at least as likely that this guy meant, "God help your new-born baby (because any child with a parent like you would need help)"?

The first is threatening and out of order, the second is crude and tasteless, but not in the least threatening.
I'm sure the last thread on this had a link to the blog involved. It read as the second option in that transcript to me.

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
odyssey2200 said:
ahh i forgot it was in P&P explains why i couldnt find it.

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
Hooli said:
odyssey2200 said:
ahh i forgot it was in P&P explains why i couldnt find it.
Having it posted twice still doesn't make it any less of a piss boiler does it?


IMHO there was no threat in his post.
If that was enough to get a copper worried for the safety of his child I would strongly suggest a career change.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
odyssey2200 said:
IMHO there was no threat in his post.
An opinion no doubt not based on as much information as the magistrates were privvy to & of no consequence as regards to whether he should be guilty as charged or not.

Edited by vonhosen on Saturday 3rd May 13:22

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
odyssey2200 said:
IMHO there was no threat in his post.
An opinion no doubt not based on as much information as the magistrates were privvy to & of no consequence as regards to whether he was guilty as charged or not.
WOW!

Von defends Plod shocker!!rolleyes


never saw that coming!

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
odyssey2200 said:
vonhosen said:
odyssey2200 said:
IMHO there was no threat in his post.
An opinion no doubt not based on as much information as the magistrates were privvy to & of no consequence as regards to whether he was guilty as charged or not.
WOW!

Von defends Plod shocker!!rolleyes


never saw that coming!
As opposed to odyssey2200 in post of irrelevant rubbish shocker ?

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
odyssey2200 said:
Hooli said:
odyssey2200 said:
ahh i forgot it was in P&P explains why i couldnt find it.
Having it posted twice still doesn't make it any less of a piss boiler does it?


IMHO there was no threat in his post.
If that was enough to get a copper worried for the safety of his child I would strongly suggest a career change.
indeed not. it sounded like a whinging git type blogg to me, i doubt he'd have ever done anything except call the copper a w***er to his face (when feeling brave).
IF that blog was all there was too it then im with you that the copper needs to grow some balls or become a librarian.

odyssey2200

18,650 posts

240 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
Hooli said:
odyssey2200 said:
Hooli said:
odyssey2200 said:
ahh i forgot it was in P&P explains why i couldnt find it.
Having it posted twice still doesn't make it any less of a piss boiler does it?


IMHO there was no threat in his post.
If that was enough to get a copper worried for the safety of his child I would strongly suggest a career change.
indeed not. it sounded like a whinging git type blogg to me, i doubt he'd have ever done anything except call the copper a w***er to his face (when feeling brave).
IF that blog was all there was too it then im with you that the copper needs to grow some balls or become a librarian.
I'm not too sure

Libraries can get quite nasty at times!!hehe

If someone got upset over their overdue books.......well who know what could ensue...

fluffnik

20,156 posts

258 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Fredom of speech is not and should not be hidden behind to cause harm to another. Otherwise racist remarks or similar would be allowed. Unless the op and others think its fine to insult someone and cause them great upset or have implied threats is fine?
I value the right to be offended just as highly as freedom of speech.

People should be free to express their opinions no matter how offended you, I or the notional bloke on the Clapham omnibus might be by them.

As an atheist I am grossly offended when credence is given to theist faith, but I defend the deluded's right to spout their errant nonsense... wink

Threats to cause harm or the incitement of others to do harm are another matter.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Saturday 3rd May 2008
quotequote all
fluffnik said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Fredom of speech is not and should not be hidden behind to cause harm to another. Otherwise racist remarks or similar would be allowed. Unless the op and others think its fine to insult someone and cause them great upset or have implied threats is fine?
I value the right to be offended just as highly as freedom of speech.

People should be free to express their opinions no matter how offended you, I or the notional bloke on the Clapham omnibus might be by them.

As an atheist I am grossly offended when credence is given to theist faith, but I defend the deluded's right to spout their errant nonsense... wink

Threats to cause harm or the incitement of others to do harm are another matter.
So your views on inciting racial hatred fluff?