Only 3% of London street crime solved by CCTV
Discussion
A report said:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7384843.stm
Huge investment in closed-circuit TV technology has failed to cut UK crime, a senior police officer has warned.
Det Ch Insp Mike Neville said the system was an "utter fiasco" - with only 3% of London's street robberies being solved using security cameras.
Although Britain had more cameras than any other European country, he said "no thought" had gone into how to use them.
Det Ch Insp Neville heads a unit which is piloting a new database to track offenders using CCTV.
Speaking at the Security Document World Conference in London, Det Ch Insp Neville, the head of the Met's Visual Images, Identifications and Detections Office (Viido), said one of the problems was that criminals were not afraid of cameras.
He also said more training was needed for officers who often avoided trawling through CCTV images "because it's hard work".
"CCTV was originally seen as a preventative measure," the Guardian quotes him as saying.
"Billions of pounds has been spent on kit, but no thought has gone into how the police are going to use the images and how they will be used in court. It's been an utter fiasco: only 3% of crimes were solved by CCTV.
CCTV operators also needed more feedback to ensure they felt "valued", he said.
Det Ch Insp Neville's unit is now piloting a new database of CCTV images which police hope will help track and identify offenders.
The unit is also looking at ways of using software which can follow distinctive brand logos on the clothing of unidentified suspects.
In addition, from next month, his team will be putting images of suspects in muggings, rape and robbery cases on the internet.
"If criminals see that CCTV works they are less likely to commit crimes," Det Ch Insp Neville added.
There are more than 4.2 million cameras in the UK, but until Viido was set up in September 2006 there had been no dedicated police unit to deal with the collection and dissemination of CCTV evidence.
If Viido, based at Southwark Police Station, is judged to be a success it could lead to the development of specialist CCTV units across the country.
Well, he would say that, wouldn't he?Huge investment in closed-circuit TV technology has failed to cut UK crime, a senior police officer has warned.
Det Ch Insp Mike Neville said the system was an "utter fiasco" - with only 3% of London's street robberies being solved using security cameras.
Although Britain had more cameras than any other European country, he said "no thought" had gone into how to use them.
Det Ch Insp Neville heads a unit which is piloting a new database to track offenders using CCTV.
Speaking at the Security Document World Conference in London, Det Ch Insp Neville, the head of the Met's Visual Images, Identifications and Detections Office (Viido), said one of the problems was that criminals were not afraid of cameras.
He also said more training was needed for officers who often avoided trawling through CCTV images "because it's hard work".
"CCTV was originally seen as a preventative measure," the Guardian quotes him as saying.
"Billions of pounds has been spent on kit, but no thought has gone into how the police are going to use the images and how they will be used in court. It's been an utter fiasco: only 3% of crimes were solved by CCTV.
CCTV operators also needed more feedback to ensure they felt "valued", he said.
Det Ch Insp Neville's unit is now piloting a new database of CCTV images which police hope will help track and identify offenders.
The unit is also looking at ways of using software which can follow distinctive brand logos on the clothing of unidentified suspects.
In addition, from next month, his team will be putting images of suspects in muggings, rape and robbery cases on the internet.
"If criminals see that CCTV works they are less likely to commit crimes," Det Ch Insp Neville added.
There are more than 4.2 million cameras in the UK, but until Viido was set up in September 2006 there had been no dedicated police unit to deal with the collection and dissemination of CCTV evidence.
If Viido, based at Southwark Police Station, is judged to be a success it could lead to the development of specialist CCTV units across the country.
Streaky
10 Pence Short said:
A lot of the problem is down to implementation rather than the concept being flawed.
Supermarkets save millions of pounds a year by using CCTV, but they're better organised and have better scrutiny over how systems are developed.
But the supermarkets do train the cams for specifics. Like the CCTV set to cop the bloke who gets "stuck for some reason in the yellow box when the lights change und he cannot complete the right hand turn" Supermarkets save millions of pounds a year by using CCTV, but they're better organised and have better scrutiny over how systems are developed.

I took over the control room at Brighton polsta which had just had town centre CCTV installed. It revolutionised public order policing. Instead of sending police officers to 'fight, West Street' calls on the 9s we could see what was going on and send a precise response.
Whe had a tape of the incidents that were filmed just after installation and it included some really quite nasty incidents. When the tape became a bit tatty I asked my staff to create another. After a month we got two incidents, both rather pathetic.
The essence of effective use of CCTV is tight control over the camera operators (and in my particular case, very enthusiastic and intelligent staff), resources to cover incidents disclosed, and close CCTV/police control room liaison.
There is a certain displacement. Certain crimes tended to move from the CCTV area to the areas not covered but a high end gang put off robbing the main post office will not then move on to the corner shop as the takings would be so much lower.
The static, uncontrolled cameras are a waste of resources other than as deterrance but give enthusiastic controllers a set of pan/tilt/zoom cameras and they are worth every penny.
The Brighton CCTV system lost a bit of effectiveness when it was spread to remote, residential areas. There was a problem with kids congregating outside a hall. A very expensive PTZ camera was set up. Everyone in my control room said that the kids would act up for it in the first few weeks then move on to somewhere outside the camera range. And that's what happened. Useless camera.
CCTV cameras need to be set up where they can be of use.
Lawyers started to challenge identification evidence from CCTV film once we started to convict a few so we had to change to continuity. We had one rather unintelligent bod try to set fire to one CCTV camera on Marine Parade. We got an excellent close-up then, when the police got near, he moved away and sat on the bonnet of his car, convinced that his lawayer would get him off on id evidence. But the camera had followed him and the controller was able to tell the officer where the offender was.
My lot were up to greater challenges than that and managed to film a robbery whilst it was actually happening. The offeners' brief was a stoppy woman who came into the control room and demanded to see any footage so that her clients could 'get out of this place as soon as possible'. I pulled rank and showed her the film of one of the offenders pulling at the cuff of his mate when a German(?) walked past counting his money into his wallet. The two offenders follwed this chap and as he went to go into a hotel attacked him and tried to get his wallet off him. The German was made of sterner stuff and fought them off and the blokes ran away with his scarf which they threw into a skip. At the end of the film the brief had her head in her hand and I asked, wanting to be helpful, if she would like a cup of tea while I went to the cells to tell her clients to plead guilty.
And in any case, 3% is pretty good going.
Whe had a tape of the incidents that were filmed just after installation and it included some really quite nasty incidents. When the tape became a bit tatty I asked my staff to create another. After a month we got two incidents, both rather pathetic.
The essence of effective use of CCTV is tight control over the camera operators (and in my particular case, very enthusiastic and intelligent staff), resources to cover incidents disclosed, and close CCTV/police control room liaison.
There is a certain displacement. Certain crimes tended to move from the CCTV area to the areas not covered but a high end gang put off robbing the main post office will not then move on to the corner shop as the takings would be so much lower.
The static, uncontrolled cameras are a waste of resources other than as deterrance but give enthusiastic controllers a set of pan/tilt/zoom cameras and they are worth every penny.
The Brighton CCTV system lost a bit of effectiveness when it was spread to remote, residential areas. There was a problem with kids congregating outside a hall. A very expensive PTZ camera was set up. Everyone in my control room said that the kids would act up for it in the first few weeks then move on to somewhere outside the camera range. And that's what happened. Useless camera.
CCTV cameras need to be set up where they can be of use.
Lawyers started to challenge identification evidence from CCTV film once we started to convict a few so we had to change to continuity. We had one rather unintelligent bod try to set fire to one CCTV camera on Marine Parade. We got an excellent close-up then, when the police got near, he moved away and sat on the bonnet of his car, convinced that his lawayer would get him off on id evidence. But the camera had followed him and the controller was able to tell the officer where the offender was.
My lot were up to greater challenges than that and managed to film a robbery whilst it was actually happening. The offeners' brief was a stoppy woman who came into the control room and demanded to see any footage so that her clients could 'get out of this place as soon as possible'. I pulled rank and showed her the film of one of the offenders pulling at the cuff of his mate when a German(?) walked past counting his money into his wallet. The two offenders follwed this chap and as he went to go into a hotel attacked him and tried to get his wallet off him. The German was made of sterner stuff and fought them off and the blokes ran away with his scarf which they threw into a skip. At the end of the film the brief had her head in her hand and I asked, wanting to be helpful, if she would like a cup of tea while I went to the cells to tell her clients to plead guilty.
And in any case, 3% is pretty good going.
WildCat said:
10 Pence Short said:
A lot of the problem is down to implementation rather than the concept being flawed.
Supermarkets save millions of pounds a year by using CCTV, but they're better organised and have better scrutiny over how systems are developed.
But the supermarkets do train the cams for specifics. Like the CCTV set to cop the bloke who gets "stuck for some reason in the yellow box when the lights change und he cannot complete the right hand turn" Supermarkets save millions of pounds a year by using CCTV, but they're better organised and have better scrutiny over how systems are developed.

I have no idea what the detection rate for robbery in the Met is.
However any measure that detects 3% is pretty good. I suspect that is a significant number.
It depends on whether we are talking about detections as a direct result of CCTV ID, or whether these lead to further detections.
I know that if I could offer a DCI a 3% increase in robbery detection, he would bite my hand off.
I also suspect a significant amount of other offences are detected as well.
However any measure that detects 3% is pretty good. I suspect that is a significant number.
It depends on whether we are talking about detections as a direct result of CCTV ID, or whether these lead to further detections.
I know that if I could offer a DCI a 3% increase in robbery detection, he would bite my hand off.
I also suspect a significant amount of other offences are detected as well.
3% at what cost perhaps is another question? How much money is spent contrasted with how many police officers that would put on the streets.
It appears to say Street Crime, which I would assume means muggings/bag snatches, mobile phone thefts etc..
It appears to say Street Crime, which I would assume means muggings/bag snatches, mobile phone thefts etc..
Edited by Jasandjules on Tuesday 6th May 10:27
Another question is solved (ie new leads etc leading to arrest) or used to bolster evidence against those already arrested. I know we use cctv evidence in at least 25% of cases. Its also not saying what offences have been identified as they happen leading to early police intervention. I know we have alot of public order and car crime that we catch, also drink drivers, shop lifters etc.
3% seems a little low unless he means where they only have cctv stills and no other leads and in 3% of those cases people are identified.
3% seems a little low unless he means where they only have cctv stills and no other leads and in 3% of those cases people are identified.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




te quality.
- Streaky