Flintoff gets off.
Author
Discussion

Dodgey_Rog

Original Poster:

2,025 posts

291 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Just read in the Telegraph that Andrew Flintoff got off speeding, due to the fact his penalty notice came 2 days later than it should.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/1932082/Andrew-Fli...

When i got caught for speeding, it was about a month til my notice came through, is there any difference in the two?

I wonder how many people will appeal this in that light.

deevlash

10,442 posts

268 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Nick Freeman strikes again! biggrin

SplatSpeed

7,491 posts

282 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Speaking outside court, Mr Freeman said: "It is fundamental in any speeding case that the notice is sent and RECEIVED within 14 days."

is this statement correct????

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
SplatSpeed said:
Speaking outside court, Mr Freeman said: "It is fundamental in any speeding case that the notice is sent and RECEIVED within 14 days."

is this statement correct????
I would suggest that Mr Freeman's specialist opinion was indeed 'correct' today. smile

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
SplatSpeed said:
Speaking outside court, Mr Freeman said: "It is fundamental in any speeding case that the notice is sent and RECEIVED within 14 days."

is this statement correct????
As far as I can see it is correct if you have someone prepared to swear in court that it did not arrive in time.

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
SplatSpeed said:
Speaking outside court, Mr Freeman said: "It is fundamental in any speeding case that the notice is sent and RECEIVED within 14 days."

is this statement correct????
It must be posted so the recipient receives the NIP within 14 days in the normal course of the post, e.g. if a postal strike delayed the NIP that wouldn't be a defence.

Battenburg Bob

8,858 posts

223 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Something not right there. It has to be posted within 14 days.......not received.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Battenburg Bob said:
Something not right there. It has to be posted within 14 days.......not received.
It has to be served.

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
I love the way the words "gets off" are used. There was no case to answer, for there to be a case to answer a complete course of events have to happen:

1. He must break the speed limit
2. They must observe/record the event
3. They must properly serve the notice

Only when all three of these steps are properly completed is there a case to answer. As far as I understand it, they were not. He didn't get off, he was never on. It's a bit like the drink driving charge I "got off":

1. I was stopped when driving my car.
2. I was made to breathe into a bag.
3. There was no alcohol on my breath.

Does this mean I "got off" drink driving because just one of the three points failed?

The press love using emotive language to taint the character involved.

SM

nats1rt

228 posts

230 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
I love the way the words "gets off" are used. There was no case to answer, for there to be a case to answer a complete course of events have to happen:

1. He must break the speed limit
2. They must observe/record the event
3. They must properly serve the notice

Only when all three of these steps are properly completed is there a case to answer. As far as I understand it, they were not. He didn't get off, he was never on. It's a bit like the drink driving charge I "got off":

1. I was stopped when driving my car.
2. I was made to breathe into a bag.
3. There was no alcohol on my breath.

Does this mean I "got off" drink driving because just one of the three points failed?

The press love using emotive language to taint the character involved.

SM
You were not drinking. He was speeding. You did not break the law. He did.

He was not prosecuted as a result of a technicality. The fact you were not drinking was not a technicality, it was essential to the prosecution, as was Flintoff speeding. Therefore, he "got off".

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
SplatSpeed said:
Speaking outside court, Mr Freeman said: "It is fundamental in any speeding case that the notice is sent and RECEIVED within 14 days."

is this statement correct????
It must be posted so the recipient receives the NIP within 14 days in the normal course of the post, e.g. if a postal strike delayed the NIP that wouldn't be a defence.
It is a defense as the expected date of serving the NIP would not be expected to be within the 14 days after the offense date during a postal strike. Other means of serving would have to be used then.

Andy Zarse

10,870 posts

278 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Battenburg Bob said:
Something not right there. It has to be posted within 14 days.......not received.
It has to be served.
Von, can you define "served" for the purposes explained here?

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Andy Zarse said:
vonhosen said:
Battenburg Bob said:
Something not right there. It has to be posted within 14 days.......not received.
It has to be served.
Von, can you define "served" for the purposes explained here?
AIUT it has to be posted so as to arrive no later then 14 days from the day after the "offence" in the normal course of the post...but VH will correct this I'm sure.....

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
nats1rt said:
He was speeding.
Prove it.

burwoodman

18,718 posts

277 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
So why not simply drop the case before wasting thousands. Do they think they might win.Surely they are aware of the reliance on the 14 days.

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
burwoodman said:
So why not simply drop the case before wasting thousands. Do they think they might win.Surely they are aware of the reliance on the 14 days.
It is not their money, it is you and I's...the taxpayer. A bottomless pit of potential waste, with little or no accountability. When they finally do realise the waste has lowered funds, they just put the taxes up again.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
As is usual with PHers (and I do not exclude myself on occasion) posters have assumed a direct link between the Crown not offering any evidence and Mr Freeman's claim that the NOIP was served out of time.

There might have been other reasons that the CPS felt the case was not worth proceeding with. It might also have been that they felt the public interest would not be served in spending time and money arguing with Mr Freeman in court ... although I doubt they would hesitate if they thought there was a chance of him failing in a high-profile case.

If there is a link, I suggest it is more likely that - as appears typical when there is contention and the defence has the will to press the issue - the CPS did not wish to have the issue of service tested in court and the full light of publicity (albeit that a Magistrate's Court cannot make case law). As has been suspected here before, the issuing force/scamera pratnership might have been unable to substantiate the proper service (e.g. no evidence that the NOIP was sent in sufficient time).

The above discussion is relevant because of one particular element in the story; and that is that Mr Flintoff was driving someone else's car when he committed the offence. The RK of that vehicle would have received the initial NOIP (within 14 days or not). They must have named Mr Flintoff as the driver at the time. A NOIP would then have been sent to him ... and there is no 14 day limit on that service.

Streaky

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
As is usual with PHers (and I do not exclude myself on occasion) posters have assumed a direct link between the Crown not offering any evidence and Mr Freeman's claim that the NOIP was served out of time.

There might have been other reasons that the CPS felt the case was not worth proceeding with. It might also have been that they felt the public interest would not be served in spending time and money arguing with Mr Freeman in court ... although I doubt they would hesitate if they thought there was a chance of him failing in a high-profile case.

If there is a link, I suggest it is more likely that - as appears typical when there is contention and the defence has the will to press the issue - the CPS did not wish to have the issue of service tested in court and the full light of publicity (albeit that a Magistrate's Court cannot make case law). As has been suspected here before, the issuing force/scamera pratnership might have been unable to substantiate the proper service (e.g. no evidence that the NOIP was sent in sufficient time).

The above discussion is relevant because of one particular element in the story; and that is that Mr Flintoff was driving someone else's car when he committed the offence. The RK of that vehicle would have received the initial NOIP (within 14 days or not). They must have named Mr Flintoff as the driver at the time. A NOIP would then have been sent to him ... and there is no 14 day limit on that service.

Streaky
I agree Streaky. I think they are blinded by his displays of legal knowledge and obvious wealth:

Telegraph said:
...The lawyer, who has a Bentley pencil case, is renowned for succcessfully defending high-profile clients.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
As is usual with PHers (and I do not exclude myself on occasion) posters have assumed a direct link between the Crown not offering any evidence and Mr Freeman's claim that the NOIP was served out of time.

There might have been other reasons that the CPS felt the case was not worth proceeding with. It might also have been that they felt the public interest would not be served in spending time and money arguing with Mr Freeman in court ... although I doubt they would hesitate if they thought there was a chance of him failing in a high-profile case.

If there is a link, I suggest it is more likely that - as appears typical when there is contention and the defence has the will to press the issue - the CPS did not wish to have the issue of service tested in court and the full light of publicity (albeit that a Magistrate's Court cannot make case law). As has been suspected here before, the issuing force/scamera pratnership might have been unable to substantiate the proper service (e.g. no evidence that the NOIP was sent in sufficient time).

The above discussion is relevant because of one particular element in the story; and that is that Mr Flintoff was driving someone else's car when he committed the offence. The RK of that vehicle would have received the initial NOIP (within 14 days or not). They must have named Mr Flintoff as the driver at the time. A NOIP would then have been sent to him ... and there is no 14 day limit on that service.

Streaky
Yes that would be why the RK was at court. Freeman did the same thing for Tiff Needell didn't he, only that time the CPS prosecuted and Freeman stated in court on behalf of Needell that the NIP had not arrive in time.

OSGrooves

38 posts

250 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
nats1rt said:
He was speeding.
Prove it.
There was a picture proving that he was speeding. Just because the paperwork wasn't completed correctly doesn't mean that he wasn't speeding, just that he can't be convicted of it.