Careless driving, Advice please?
Careless driving, Advice please?
Author
Discussion

Mr Brabus

Original Poster:

123 posts

235 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
about a month ago I was heading up a dual carriageway in right hand lane to go around lorry, a convertible shot from behind the lorry in to the right hand lane, it went around the lorry & moved back in to the left lane , I continued on in right hand lane to go past lorry & also intended to pass the convertible & slot back in to left lane before the rounabout that was up ahead.

the convertible driver decided he would not let me in front & kept speeding up everytime I tried to go past , I was unable to slot in behind the convertible as the lorry was fast approaching. I made the descision to stay in the right hand lane & go across roundabout (which was fine as both lanes were straight ahead lanes that merge on other side of roundabout). as we both were going across the rounabout I hit a patch of black ice (it was a really frosty morning) which I did not see which caused me to skid in to the left hand lane , the convertible driver swerved to avoid me & luckily no contact was made between our two cars. I manage to keep my car under control & coninue on my way.

a week ago I get a letter asking to confirm if I was the keeper of the vehicle involved in an "alleged" incident as I may be prosecuted for careless driving , I sent the letter straight back to confirm & today received a visit from a policeman but was at work so he will call again at end of week.

What you guys reckon to all of this ?

Cheers

justlivyalife

4,609 posts

238 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Was there any communication between you and the other driver at the time of the "incident"?

Mr Brabus

Original Poster:

123 posts

235 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all

No communication coz as I say there was no actual car to car contact when I skidded & I managed to get car under control & carry on up the road , I continued my journey to work as normal , When I got to work I did report the incident to the nearest police statiion just for my own piece of mind.

mph999

2,780 posts

251 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Mr Brabus said:
No communication coz as I say there was no actual car to car contact when I skidded & I managed to get car under control & carry on up the road , I continued my journey to work as normal , When I got to work I did report the incident to the nearest police statiion just for my own piece of mind.
If you hit black ice, then it's not careless driving as far as I can see ... Providing that your speed was appropriate for the conditions. OK, you caused someone to have to swerve, but not exactly through your own fault. If you hit ice at any more than a walking pace, whilst turning you will almost certainly slide ...

Martin

Mr Brabus

Original Poster:

123 posts

235 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all

The dual carrigeway is a 40mph limit (IIRC) so I was slowing down to go across the roundabout, just to clarify that it wasn't one of those really big roundabout but one of those that has room for one tree & a couple of signs in the middle.

does reporting it in at the nearest station shortly after help with regards to further enquiries?

justlivyalife

4,609 posts

238 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
I'd imagine it would certainly help you! The Police are just acting on what info they have been given, I assume, and just want to speak to you to find out your "version of events" so to speak.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
You must be mistaken, the Police only bother with exceeding the speed limit (apparently).

Mg6b

6,649 posts

294 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
mph999 said:
If you hit black ice, then it's not careless driving as far as I can see ...

Martin
Remember that every person you pass is a potential witness to the actions that took place before.

The issue might be nothing to do with the ice.
The ice incident might be the incident that brought the rest of the pre incident driving into contention.

Time will tell!


Mr Brabus

Original Poster:

123 posts

235 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Mg6b said:
mph999 said:
If you hit black ice, then it's not careless driving as far as I can see ...

Martin
Remember that every person you pass is a potential witness to the actions that took place before.

The issue might be nothing to do with the ice.
The ice incident might be the incident that brought the rest of the pre incident driving into contention.

Time will tell!
I don't quite follow

???

ypauly

15,137 posts

231 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
You must be mistaken, the Police only bother with exceeding the speed limit (apparently).
and donutshehe

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Mr Brabus said:
Mg6b said:
mph999 said:
If you hit black ice, then it's not careless driving as far as I can see ...

Martin
Remember that every person you pass is a potential witness to the actions that took place before.

The issue might be nothing to do with the ice.
The ice incident might be the incident that brought the rest of the pre incident driving into contention.

Time will tell!
I don't quite follow

???
It may not be the person you are assuming who has reported this matter to the Police.
It may be someone totally independent.
They may have considered more than the temporary loss of control as DWDCA.
It may have just been the icing on the cake so to speak.
When there is a fatal collision for instance the Police will try to trace as many witnesses as possible, not just those that witnessed the collision, but those who also can give evidence of the driving prior to the collision. They are looking to establish if it was one small error or a course of conduct.
Every person you overtake is a potentially hostile witness.

justlivyalife

4,609 posts

238 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
You must be mistaken, the Police only bother with exceeding the speed limit (apparently).
Quite possible in some areas, but not in my experience. Having had (sometimes lengthy - and not because I've been pulled) conversations with TrafPol in quite a few regions, I know very different.


Muntu

7,689 posts

230 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
justlivyalife said:
vonhosen said:
You must be mistaken, the Police only bother with exceeding the speed limit (apparently).
Quite possible in some areas, but not in my experience. Having had (sometimes lengthy - and not because I've been pulled) conversations with TrafPol in quite a few regions, I know very different.
I think VH might toowink

justlivyalife

4,609 posts

238 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Muntu said:
justlivyalife said:
vonhosen said:
You must be mistaken, the Police only bother with exceeding the speed limit (apparently).
Quite possible in some areas, but not in my experience. Having had (sometimes lengthy - and not because I've been pulled) conversations with TrafPol in quite a few regions, I know very different.
I think VH might toowink
Perhaps I should've added a smiley to my post?wink.

tvrgit

8,490 posts

283 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Mr Brabus said:
Mg6b said:
mph999 said:
If you hit black ice, then it's not careless driving as far as I can see ...

Martin
Remember that every person you pass is a potential witness to the actions that took place before.

The issue might be nothing to do with the ice.
The ice incident might be the incident that brought the rest of the pre incident driving into contention.

Time will tell!
I don't quite follow

???
Well, let's say for example that there's a line of 2 cars following a lorry at its max NSL speed limit of 40. You catch up, see a safe overtake and pass all 3 (maybe not in one go but eventually) and disappear into the distance, perhaps at a perfectly safe speed (albeit in excess of the posted limit).

A mile up the road you come to a cross roads, and being a responsible driver, you slow down a bit because you can see that junction visibility isn't good. You see a car waiting. He seems to see you. You carry on (maybe now at less than the posted limit). Nevertheless, he pulls out of the side road at the last possible moment and you can't avoid him.

As you are getting out of the car, the convoy of 3 arrives. One of them stops. The cops arrive. Your "witness" says "Yeah he passed me down the road and took off like the clappers". The other driver hears this and says "Yes he must have been clogging it because I looked carefully" (well he would say that, wouldn't he?) Who is going to believe that you slowed down for the junction? How deep is the doodah you're now in, although you've done nothing to cause the accident?

Everybody you pass, no matter how ill-informed they are, could be a bad witness if it goes wrong further up the road...


mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Tuesday 6th May 2008
quotequote all
Mr Brabus said:
about a month ago I was heading up a dual carriageway in right hand lane to go around lorry, a convertible shot from behind the lorry in to the right hand lane, it went around the lorry & moved back in to the left lane , I continued on in right hand lane to go past lorry & also intended to pass the convertible & slot back in to left lane before the rounabout that was up ahead.

the convertible driver decided he would not let me in front & kept speeding up everytime I tried to go past , I was unable to slot in behind the convertible as the lorry was fast approaching. I made the descision to stay in the right hand lane & go across roundabout (which was fine as both lanes were straight ahead lanes that merge on other side of roundabout). as we both were going across the rounabout I hit a patch of black ice (it was a really frosty morning) which I did not see which caused me to skid in to the left hand lane , the convertible driver swerved to avoid me & luckily no contact was made between our two cars. I manage to keep my car under control & coninue on my way.

a week ago I get a letter asking to confirm if I was the keeper of the vehicle involved in an "alleged" incident as I may be prosecuted for careless driving , I sent the letter straight back to confirm & today received a visit from a policeman but was at work so he will call again at end of week.

What you guys reckon to all of this ?

Cheers
just deny doing anything wrong.


It worked for a pratt who forced me off the road and into a central reservation.

His reg number was easy to remember so i got the police to see him and they came back and said he denied knowing about anything.

end of story.


10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
If I were you I would let the Policeman explain why he's there and what the allegations are. Beware that at this stage he's unlikely to divulge everything he knows, if there's more to it than meets the eye.

I wouldn't mention the argy bargy with the other driver prior to the skid at all, unless it's brought up.

Tread carefully.

Mr Brabus

Original Poster:

123 posts

235 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
If I were you I would let the Policeman explain why he's there and what the allegations are. Beware that at this stage he's unlikely to divulge everything he knows, if there's more to it than meets the eye.

I wouldn't mention the argy bargy with the other driver prior to the skid at all, unless it's brought up.

Tread carefully.
But isn't it better to explain the situation I was put in prior to the "incident" ?

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all
Mr Brabus said:
10 Pence Short said:
If I were you I would let the Policeman explain why he's there and what the allegations are. Beware that at this stage he's unlikely to divulge everything he knows, if there's more to it than meets the eye.

I wouldn't mention the argy bargy with the other driver prior to the skid at all, unless it's brought up.

Tread carefully.
But isn't it better to explain the situation I was put in prior to the "incident" ?
No, because according to your story, the previous driving had nothing to do with you skidding. Unless you want to admit that your driving was influenced by the other chap not allowing you to accelerate passed him on an icy road, so you thought you'd show him who's boss around the roundabout, nearly ending in an accident?

Collect one Careless Driving conviction and 3+ points...


Mr Brabus

Original Poster:

123 posts

235 months

Wednesday 7th May 2008
quotequote all

I can see what you're saying but he still contributed to the incident.

I did not act like a boy racer , I attempted to go past in the right hand lane as any normal person would but he decided that he did not like that & made sure he stayed side by side so I could not get back in to the left lane.

He continued to stay side by side even going across the rounabout.