Man Gets Off at 122mph
Author
Discussion

neelyp

Original Poster:

1,703 posts

242 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
Interesting story, happened close to me.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/tayside_and_ce...

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
. . and exactly the sort of story to fuel the anti speed campaigners and with good reason.

You can't justify this kind of driving behaviour. This guy was lucky.

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
Once again the press talk about him getting off on a technicality. Obviously they don't know what speed he was doing any more than the police knew. He didn't get off anything. He had no case to answer.

Indeed, if they *knew* he was doing 122mph he would have been found guilty. But they didn't. He could have been doing 60mph. I think you can hear any car doing 60mph from half a mile away.

The correct headline should read "Police attempt to pervert the course of justice by charging a man with 122mph using known unreliable machine".

In any case, BRAKE would testify that if he'd really been doing twice the safety-limit he'd have veered off the road and crashed.

Presumably the police will now go back through their records and refund/undo all other cases involving this particular dodgeyscope from when it first went out of calibration.

SM

neelyp

Original Poster:

1,703 posts

242 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
Believe me this is not the road to be doing those kind of speeds, there have been countless accidents at normal speeds.

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
mark69sheer said:
You can't justify this kind of driving behaviour. This guy was lucky.
How fast was he going? I couldn't tell from the report.

SM

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
If these speed doo-dahs are not calibrated properly - then they are not going to be accurate.

scratchchin A lot of people may have been wrongly accused und penalised by this failure on their part.

It means the gadget"ist not always right"!wink


He probably above lolly - but not as fast as they were making out..wink

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
neelyp said:
Believe me this is not the road to be doing those kind of speeds, there have been countless accidents at normal speeds.
Which kinds of speeds? Again, I can't tell what kind of speed he was doing from the report. Neither could the judge.

SM

Edited by supermono on Thursday 8th May 07:36

Guybrush

4,364 posts

237 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
mark69sheer said:
. . and exactly the sort of story to fuel the anti speed campaigners and with good reason.

You can't justify this kind of driving behaviour. This guy was lucky.
Why do you say that? Was he driving dangerously? I didn't spot an indication of that from the story, other than the road being described as "notorious", whatever that means in relation to exceeding the speed limit.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
neelyp said:
Believe me this is not the road to be doing those kind of speeds, there have been countless accidents at normal speeds.
Which kinds of speeds? Again, I can't tell what kind of speed he was doing from the report. Neither could the judge.

SM

Edited by supermono on Thursday 8th May 07:36
He knew he was going fast he probably was going 120 plus but he escaped conviction as the seed had no certificate produced (does not mean it was not calibrated as the officer said).

Personal does not bother me as Im sure he will be just as silly again. Maybe even too silly.

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
neelyp said:
Believe me this is not the road to be doing those kind of speeds, there have been countless accidents at normal speeds.
But they did not know how fast he was going. It also surprises me that the police could not offer a professional opinion either.

At that speed - he cover about 45 yard per second. Perhaps fiddling about with a hair drier prevent forming an opinion scratchchin

neelyp

Original Poster:

1,703 posts

242 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
Guybrush said:
mark69sheer said:
. . and exactly the sort of story to fuel the anti speed campaigners and with good reason.

You can't justify this kind of driving behaviour. This guy was lucky.
Why do you say that? Was he driving dangerously? I didn't spot an indication of that from the story, other than the road being described as "notorious", whatever that means in relation to exceeding the speed limit.
The stretch of road this happened on is a wide (almost four cars at a squeeze wide), straight for probably a mile, nice right hand curve and then more or less straight for another half mile to a roundabout.
Unfortunately it also has a staggered crossroad with chevron right turn lane (been a couple of right bad ones here), an entrance from an eatery and travel lodge, another entrance from the right (there always seems to be accidents here) and then another entrance from a garden centre.

It's not a road to speed on.

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
Guybrush said:
mark69sheer said:
. . and exactly the sort of story to fuel the anti speed campaigners and with good reason.

You can't justify this kind of driving behaviour. This guy was lucky.
Why do you say that? Was he driving dangerously? I didn't spot an indication of that from the story, other than the road being described as "notorious", whatever that means in relation to exceeding the speed limit.
It may not have been dangerous allthough another has suggested that was too fast for the type of road.

What I mean is . . wether he was 100 or 120 on a 60mph road its so far above the speed limit that it only adds to the 'speed kills' lobby.
If he had been in a Focus zetec then yes the story may have had more credibility against the scamera system but he was in a Focus St which we all know is capable of those speeds.

I suggest the owner in the story should take up trackdays or some other form of motorsport.

Assuming despite the officers lack of certificate the device was operating correctly then that 122mph would have been a speedo reading of 130mph to the pilot who 'didn't realise he was going so fast'... and you think his brain is calibrated any better than the speed gun?

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
mark69sheer said:
Guybrush said:
mark69sheer said:
. . and exactly the sort of story to fuel the anti speed campaigners and with good reason.

You can't justify this kind of driving behaviour. This guy was lucky.
Why do you say that? Was he driving dangerously? I didn't spot an indication of that from the story, other than the road being described as "notorious", whatever that means in relation to exceeding the speed limit.
It may not have been dangerous allthough another has suggested that was too fast for the type of road.

What I mean is . . wether he was 100 or 120 on a 60mph road its so far above the speed limit that it only adds to the 'speed kills' lobby.
If he had been in a Focus zetec then yes the story may have had more credibility against the scamera system but he was in a Focus St which we all know is capable of those speeds.

I suggest the owner in the story should take up trackdays or some other form of motorsport.

Assuming despite the officers lack of certificate the device was operating correctly then that 122mph would have been a speedo reading of 130mph to the pilot who 'didn't realise he was going so fast'... and you think his brain is calibrated any better than the speed gun?
You would have thought he may have a rough idea of his speed though wouldn't you.

If he really had no idea, you wonder what else he missed.

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
OMG. I just used the random number generator on my calculator and found he was actually doing 142mph. The guy was really lucky not to have been seriously injured. Believe me, that is not the kind of speeds you want to be doing on any 60mph road. Never mind one that's notorious. I'm incensed smile

SM

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
OMG. I just used the random number generator on my calculator and found he was actually doing 142mph. The guy was really lucky not to have been seriously injured. Believe me, that is not the kind of speeds you want to be doing on any 60mph road. Never mind one that's notorious. I'm incensed smile

SM
Calm down. I know your annoyed he got off but there really is nothing you can do about it now. Maybe you could join your local speedwatch campaign?wink

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
Did he crash?

No. Then he clearly can't have been speeding.

Case closed. biggrin

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
mark69sheer said:
Guybrush said:
mark69sheer said:
. . and exactly the sort of story to fuel the anti speed campaigners and with good reason.

You can't justify this kind of driving behaviour. This guy was lucky.
Why do you say that? Was he driving dangerously? I didn't spot an indication of that from the story, other than the road being described as "notorious", whatever that means in relation to exceeding the speed limit.
It may not have been dangerous allthough another has suggested that was too fast for the type of road.

What I mean is . . wether he was 100 or 120 on a 60mph road its so far above the speed limit that it only adds to the 'speed kills' lobby.
If he had been in a Focus zetec then yes the story may have had more credibility against the scamera system but he was in a Focus St which we all know is capable of those speeds.

I suggest the owner in the story should take up trackdays or some other form of motorsport.

Assuming despite the officers lack of certificate the device was operating correctly then that 122mph would have been a speedo reading of 130mph to the pilot who 'didn't realise he was going so fast'... and you think his brain is calibrated any better than the speed gun?
You would have thought he may have a rough idea of his speed though wouldn't you.

If he really had no idea, you wonder what else he missed.
This worries me on part of both driver und the police.

"driver allegedly did not know he was going that fast" per the report.

But the police officer could not say in the court that his professional opinion without the benefit of a speed doo-dah to verify was that he was well in excess of the speed limit. It twice the lolly allegedly. It hardly rockety science to judge on that basis whistle

So could the officer not tell the judge that regardless of the missed certificate this guy was OTT in speed or was he unable to say for sure .. in which case this speed was not 120mph but more 80 mph which make a difference between ban und fine/points. Perhaps because they so adamant it 120 mph without proof und this ist in the dangerous ban zone field.. the judge throw out of court.

It prove the best way still ist to have our police "larkin und lurkin' around" in VISIBLE carswink


Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
WildCat said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
mark69sheer said:
Guybrush said:
mark69sheer said:
. . and exactly the sort of story to fuel the anti speed campaigners and with good reason.

You can't justify this kind of driving behaviour. This guy was lucky.
Why do you say that? Was he driving dangerously? I didn't spot an indication of that from the story, other than the road being described as "notorious", whatever that means in relation to exceeding the speed limit.
It may not have been dangerous allthough another has suggested that was too fast for the type of road.

What I mean is . . wether he was 100 or 120 on a 60mph road its so far above the speed limit that it only adds to the 'speed kills' lobby.
If he had been in a Focus zetec then yes the story may have had more credibility against the scamera system but he was in a Focus St which we all know is capable of those speeds.

I suggest the owner in the story should take up trackdays or some other form of motorsport.

Assuming despite the officers lack of certificate the device was operating correctly then that 122mph would have been a speedo reading of 130mph to the pilot who 'didn't realise he was going so fast'... and you think his brain is calibrated any better than the speed gun?
You would have thought he may have a rough idea of his speed though wouldn't you.

If he really had no idea, you wonder what else he missed.
This worries me on part of both driver und the police.

"driver allegedly did not know he was going that fast" per the report.

But the police officer could not say in the court that his professional opinion without the benefit of a speed doo-dah to verify was that he was well in excess of the speed limit. It twice the lolly allegedly. It hardly rockety science to judge on that basis whistle

So could the officer not tell the judge that regardless of the missed certificate this guy was OTT in speed or was he unable to say for sure .. in which case this speed was not 120mph but more 80 mph which make a difference between ban und fine/points. Perhaps because they so adamant it 120 mph without proof und this ist in the dangerous ban zone field.. the judge throw out of court.

It prove the best way still ist to have our police "larkin und lurkin' around" in VISIBLE carswink
Not sure what the law is in Scotland on that. Down here he could still have been done for at least excess speed.

I still think un-marked cars are more usefull. You never know when one is about and you can target bad driving rather than speeding.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Did he crash?

No. Then he clearly can't have been speeding.

Case closed. biggrin
if you believe the gubberment claptrap then yes thats 100% true.

its bloody rare to find a road you can do the speeds he was accused at safely, so i doubt it was appropriate if he was doing those speeds.
i still say speeding as an offence should be replaced with 'excess speed'. doesnt matter what the number on the dial/stick is, if your too fast for the conditions then its dangerous & needs dealing with. exceeding a number pulled out of a hat & adjusted so the scamerati can up their profits is not a way to judge safety.

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Thursday 8th May 2008
quotequote all
Hooli said:
its bloody rare to find a road you can do the speeds he was accused at safely,
Really? I see roads like that all the time. Where do you drive? Only inside the M25? You need to get out more smile

SM