Theft/damage blacklist ... regardless of truth
Theft/damage blacklist ... regardless of truth
Author
Discussion

streaky

Original Poster:

19,311 posts

280 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
BBC website said:
Workers accused of theft or damage could soon find themselves blacklisted on a register to be shared among employers. It will be good for profits but campaigners say innocent people could find it impossible to get another job.

To critics it sounds like a scenario from some Orwellian nightmare.

An online database of workers accused of theft and dishonesty, regardless of whether they have been convicted of any crime, which bosses can access when vetting potential employees.

But this is no dystopian fantasy. Later this month, the National Staff Dismissal Register (NSDR) is expected to go live. Individuals would be treated as criminals, even though the police have never been contacted

Organisers say that major companies including Harrods, Selfridges and Reed Managed Services have already signed up to the scheme. By the end of May they will be able to check whether candidates for jobs have faced allegations of stealing, forgery, fraud, damaging company property or causing a loss to their employers and suppliers.

Workers sacked for these offences will be included on the register, regardless of whether police had enough evidence to convict them. Also on the list will be employees who resigned before they could face disciplinary proceedings at work.

The project has attracted little publicity. But the BBC News website can reveal that trade unions and civil liberties campaigners are warning that it leaves workers vulnerable to the threat of false accusations.

TUC policy officer Hannah Reed says that while criminal activity in the workplace can never be condoned, she fears such a system is open to abuse.

WHAT WILL GET YOU ON IT
  • Theft or attempted theft of money, merchandise or property from company, suppliers or customers
  • Falsification or forgery of documents
  • Fraudulently obtaining money, services or information
  • Damaging company property
"The TUC is seriously concerned that this register can only lead to people being shut out from the job market by an employer who falsely accuses them of misconduct or sacks them because they bear them a grudge. Individuals would be treated as criminals, even though the police have never been contacted.

"The Criminal Records Bureau was set up to assist employers to make safe appointments when recruiting staff to work with vulnerable groups. The CRB already provides appropriate and properly regulated protection for employers. Under the new register, an employee may not be aware they have been blacklisted or have any right to appeal."

James Welch, the legal director of human rights group Liberty, also says that he is concerned that the register does not offer sufficient redress to the falsely accused.

"This scheme appears to bypass existing laws which protect employees by limiting the circumstances when information about possible criminal activity can be shared with potential employers."

The register is an initiative of Action Against Business Crime (AABC), which was established as a joint venture between the Home Office and the British Retail Consortium "to set up and maintain business crime reduction partnerships". The Home Office says it stopped funding the scheme last year, having granted it almost £1m during its first three years. A Home Office spokeswoman says the register is a "commercial scheme" and it was not consulted.

Set up by Surrey-based firm Hicom Business Solutions, the database will allow employers to search for potential workers by name, address, date of birth, national insurance number and previous employer.

Records on individuals - accessible online via an encrypted password system - will be kept for a five-year period and can include photos.

Mike Schuck, chief executive of AABC, says that theft by members of staff costs the British economy billions of pounds each year and rejects the notion that the register is a blacklist.

He says that all participating companies will be obliged to abide by the Data Protection Act and that workers named on the database, maintained by AABC, will have the right to change their entries if they are inaccurate.

Should a dispute take place between an employee and an employer about whether an incident occurred, Mr Schuck adds, the worker will be able to appeal to the Information Commissioner's Office.

"We are limiting access to the database to employers who can comply with the Information Commissioner's employment practices code," he says. "We're not going to allow Mr Smith's hardware store. We're quite open about this. People will be told when they apply for jobs that they may be checked as part of the application process.

"Theft in the workplace hurts staff as much as employers because it puts everyone under suspicion."

Nonetheless, many workers may get a nasty surprise when old allegations return to haunt them when they next apply for a job.
Now, who would like to cast the first stone?

Streaky

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
BBC website said:
Workers accused of theft or damage could soon find themselves blacklisted on a register to be shared among employers. It will be good for profits but campaigners say innocent people could find it impossible to get another job.

To critics it sounds like a scenario from some Orwellian nightmare.

An online database of workers accused of theft and dishonesty, regardless of whether they have been convicted of any crime, which bosses can access when vetting potential employees.

But this is no dystopian fantasy. Later this month, the National Staff Dismissal Register (NSDR) is expected to go live. Individuals would be treated as criminals, even though the police have never been contacted

Organisers say that major companies including Harrods, Selfridges and Reed Managed Services have already signed up to the scheme. By the end of May they will be able to check whether candidates for jobs have faced allegations of stealing, forgery, fraud, damaging company property or causing a loss to their employers and suppliers.

Workers sacked for these offences will be included on the register, regardless of whether police had enough evidence to convict them. Also on the list will be employees who resigned before they could face disciplinary proceedings at work.

The project has attracted little publicity. But the BBC News website can reveal that trade unions and civil liberties campaigners are warning that it leaves workers vulnerable to the threat of false accusations.

TUC policy officer Hannah Reed says that while criminal activity in the workplace can never be condoned, she fears such a system is open to abuse.

WHAT WILL GET YOU ON IT
  • Theft or attempted theft of money, merchandise or property from company, suppliers or customers
  • Falsification or forgery of documents
  • Fraudulently obtaining money, services or information
  • Damaging company property
"The TUC is seriously concerned that this register can only lead to people being shut out from the job market by an employer who falsely accuses them of misconduct or sacks them because they bear them a grudge. Individuals would be treated as criminals, even though the police have never been contacted.

"The Criminal Records Bureau was set up to assist employers to make safe appointments when recruiting staff to work with vulnerable groups. The CRB already provides appropriate and properly regulated protection for employers. Under the new register, an employee may not be aware they have been blacklisted or have any right to appeal."

James Welch, the legal director of human rights group Liberty, also says that he is concerned that the register does not offer sufficient redress to the falsely accused.

"This scheme appears to bypass existing laws which protect employees by limiting the circumstances when information about possible criminal activity can be shared with potential employers."

The register is an initiative of Action Against Business Crime (AABC), which was established as a joint venture between the Home Office and the British Retail Consortium "to set up and maintain business crime reduction partnerships". The Home Office says it stopped funding the scheme last year, having granted it almost £1m during its first three years. A Home Office spokeswoman says the register is a "commercial scheme" and it was not consulted.

Set up by Surrey-based firm Hicom Business Solutions, the database will allow employers to search for potential workers by name, address, date of birth, national insurance number and previous employer.

Records on individuals - accessible online via an encrypted password system - will be kept for a five-year period and can include photos.

Mike Schuck, chief executive of AABC, says that theft by members of staff costs the British economy billions of pounds each year and rejects the notion that the register is a blacklist.

He says that all participating companies will be obliged to abide by the Data Protection Act and that workers named on the database, maintained by AABC, will have the right to change their entries if they are inaccurate.

Should a dispute take place between an employee and an employer about whether an incident occurred, Mr Schuck adds, the worker will be able to appeal to the Information Commissioner's Office.

"We are limiting access to the database to employers who can comply with the Information Commissioner's employment practices code," he says. "We're not going to allow Mr Smith's hardware store. We're quite open about this. People will be told when they apply for jobs that they may be checked as part of the application process.

"Theft in the workplace hurts staff as much as employers because it puts everyone under suspicion."

Nonetheless, many workers may get a nasty surprise when old allegations return to haunt them when they next apply for a job.
Now, who would like to cast the first stone?

Streaky
Well known fact amongst retailers that a significant portion of theft is by employee.

streaky

Original Poster:

19,311 posts

280 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
streaky said:
BBC website said:
Workers accused of theft or damage could soon find themselves blacklisted on a register to be shared among employers. It will be good for profits but campaigners say innocent people could find it impossible to get another job.

To critics it sounds like a scenario from some Orwellian nightmare.

An online database of workers accused of theft and dishonesty, regardless of whether they have been convicted of any crime, which bosses can access when vetting potential employees.

But this is no dystopian fantasy. Later this month, the National Staff Dismissal Register (NSDR) is expected to go live. Individuals would be treated as criminals, even though the police have never been contacted

Organisers say that major companies including Harrods, Selfridges and Reed Managed Services have already signed up to the scheme. By the end of May they will be able to check whether candidates for jobs have faced allegations of stealing, forgery, fraud, damaging company property or causing a loss to their employers and suppliers.

Workers sacked for these offences will be included on the register, regardless of whether police had enough evidence to convict them. Also on the list will be employees who resigned before they could face disciplinary proceedings at work.

The project has attracted little publicity. But the BBC News website can reveal that trade unions and civil liberties campaigners are warning that it leaves workers vulnerable to the threat of false accusations.

TUC policy officer Hannah Reed says that while criminal activity in the workplace can never be condoned, she fears such a system is open to abuse.

WHAT WILL GET YOU ON IT
  • Theft or attempted theft of money, merchandise or property from company, suppliers or customers
  • Falsification or forgery of documents
  • Fraudulently obtaining money, services or information
  • Damaging company property
"The TUC is seriously concerned that this register can only lead to people being shut out from the job market by an employer who falsely accuses them of misconduct or sacks them because they bear them a grudge. Individuals would be treated as criminals, even though the police have never been contacted.

"The Criminal Records Bureau was set up to assist employers to make safe appointments when recruiting staff to work with vulnerable groups. The CRB already provides appropriate and properly regulated protection for employers. Under the new register, an employee may not be aware they have been blacklisted or have any right to appeal."

James Welch, the legal director of human rights group Liberty, also says that he is concerned that the register does not offer sufficient redress to the falsely accused.

"This scheme appears to bypass existing laws which protect employees by limiting the circumstances when information about possible criminal activity can be shared with potential employers."

The register is an initiative of Action Against Business Crime (AABC), which was established as a joint venture between the Home Office and the British Retail Consortium "to set up and maintain business crime reduction partnerships". The Home Office says it stopped funding the scheme last year, having granted it almost £1m during its first three years. A Home Office spokeswoman says the register is a "commercial scheme" and it was not consulted.

Set up by Surrey-based firm Hicom Business Solutions, the database will allow employers to search for potential workers by name, address, date of birth, national insurance number and previous employer.

Records on individuals - accessible online via an encrypted password system - will be kept for a five-year period and can include photos.

Mike Schuck, chief executive of AABC, says that theft by members of staff costs the British economy billions of pounds each year and rejects the notion that the register is a blacklist.

He says that all participating companies will be obliged to abide by the Data Protection Act and that workers named on the database, maintained by AABC, will have the right to change their entries if they are inaccurate.

Should a dispute take place between an employee and an employer about whether an incident occurred, Mr Schuck adds, the worker will be able to appeal to the Information Commissioner's Office.

"We are limiting access to the database to employers who can comply with the Information Commissioner's employment practices code," he says. "We're not going to allow Mr Smith's hardware store. We're quite open about this. People will be told when they apply for jobs that they may be checked as part of the application process.

"Theft in the workplace hurts staff as much as employers because it puts everyone under suspicion."

Nonetheless, many workers may get a nasty surprise when old allegations return to haunt them when they next apply for a job.
Now, who would like to cast the first stone?

Streaky
Well known fact amongst retailers that a significant portion of theft is by employee.
Further "well-known fact" that there are no honest employees ... hence my "cast the first stone". Hands up anyone on PH who has never stolen from or defrauded their employer (Biro, sheet of paper, telephone call, extra minutes on break, dodgy overtime/expense claim, etc.) - Streaky

fastcarl

254 posts

251 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
if anysuch allegations were untrue, surely that would be defamation of character, even libal poaaibly.


carl

Chrispy Porker

17,763 posts

259 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
Indeed.
If one were sacked for an offence one did not commit surely that would be unfair dismissal, and would result in a compensation claim??

streaky

Original Poster:

19,311 posts

280 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
Indeed.
If one were sacked for an offence one did not commit surely that would be unfair dismissal, and would result in a compensation claim??
There are many situations where a compensation claim cannot be made, e.g. dismissed within probationary period - Streaky

black-k1

12,817 posts

260 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
Chrispy Porker said:
Indeed.
If one were sacked for an offence one did not commit surely that would be unfair dismissal, and would result in a compensation claim??
There are many situations where a compensation claim cannot be made, e.g. dismissed within probationary period - Streaky
There are also many occasions when it's one persons word against another and, for the employee, there just aren't the resources to fight.

This is truly frightening!

andy400

11,853 posts

262 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
fastcarl said:
if anysuch allegations were untrue, surely that would be defamation of character, even libal poaaibly.


carl
True or not, shirley one should be able to prove such allegations before making them public, else opening oneself up to all sorts of litigation?

Digby

8,358 posts

277 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
Further "well-known fact" that there are no honest employees ... hence my "cast the first stone". Hands up anyone on PH who has never stolen from or defrauded their employer (Biro, sheet of paper, telephone call, extra minutes on break, dodgy overtime/expense claim, etc.) - Streaky
Being totally honest here, i don't think i have knowingly done anything like you mention.That is despite being in a position several times to get away with decent piles of cash with no chance of ever being caught.Am i stupid? biggrin
Then again, maybe it depends who you work for as to what they look apon as being honest.The company i work for now know i almost never take the full break i am allowed for example, so if i do take an extra 10 mins here or there because something cropped up or i got stuck chatting to someone etc, they are not the slightest bit interested.There is no doubt i have 'taken' pens, but only to use at work, so if they came home with me, they went back to work with me too and stayed with me until they ran out.
I have used the company phone a couple of times in the last year, but again, they don't mind as long as you don't take the pee.

I have known of people stealing all sorts of things though.One guy used to regularly take the toilet rolls and milk for example! It puts you in an awkward position too things like this as they may be great work mates etc and all round decent people, but you end up wondering whether you should grass them up, have a quite word or ignore it all together.The outcome can easily wreck a decent working enviroment no matter what you decide.In my experience, the same people who will take some free loo rolls home are often the same type of people who will shout at you in the street if they see you drop your wallet though, or they will tell the shop keepers that they have given them too much change etc.Most odd!

Edited by Digby on Friday 9th May 19:49

fastcarl

254 posts

251 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
andy400 said:
fastcarl said:
if anysuch allegations were untrue, surely that would be defamation of character, even libal poaaibly.


carl
True or not, shirley one should be able to prove such allegations before making them public, else opening oneself up to all sorts of litigation?
that was the next thing i was going to say,i would imagine any employer who puts someones name on such a list without the backup of a criminal conviction or a police caution would be in the thick and slimey,


carl

DucatiGary

7,765 posts

256 months

Friday 9th May 2008
quotequote all
i saw this last week, first thing on my mind was a numpty director i sacked twice a few years ago and only let back in because she was living with the main shareholder, gladly i sold out and im no longer asociated.

she would gladly go through and file complaints against all the staff she hated (there was lots (read lots)) and gladly rubbish the names of others just becuase she could.

silly bugger of the highest order, this wont work and im speaking as a company owner and employer.

fastcarl

254 posts

251 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
of course it won't work, the first time someones name is rubbished without proof etc, the the company or person responsible for the liable will be shafted from behind. as they should be,


carl

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
fastcarl said:
if anysuch allegations were untrue, surely that would be defamation of character, even libal poaaibly.


carl
My first thought. Anyone found innocent could then sue their employer for libel, which, if the slur costs them future employment, could lead to substantial damages.

Would be a stupid employer to add to the register without proof.

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
Thing is I imagine, in the terms and conditions of the service will be some form of NDA
Doesn't supercede the law. Look at R v Ellis for more information.

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
Agreed and all NDA's have a get out clause on legal action power of court etc (all those I have signed anyhow)

Dont really see given that what the benefits would be to anyone to use the service smile
Any terms which precluded any right to legal recourse would be deemed invalid anyways.

I suspect the idea is sound in principal, but in practice it could be a disaster, many companies don't prosecute in staff theft circumstances in any event, doesn't look good for them.

And yes, a S7 DPA request would soon sort out what info was held on you.

streaky

Original Poster:

19,311 posts

280 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Guam said:
Agreed and all NDA's have a get out clause on legal action power of court etc (all those I have signed anyhow)

Dont really see given that what the benefits would be to anyone to use the service smile
Any terms which precluded any right to legal recourse would be deemed invalid anyways.

I suspect the idea is sound in principal, but in practice it could be a disaster, many companies don't prosecute in staff theft circumstances in any event, doesn't look good for them.

And yes, a S7 DPA request would soon sort out what info was held on you.
An exemption might be claimed under S29:

DPA1998 said:
29 Crime and taxation
(1) Personal data processed for any of the following purposes—
(a) the prevention or detection of crime,
(b) the apprehension or prosecution of offenders, or
...,
are exempt from ... section 7 in any case to the extent to which the application of those provisions to the data would be likely to prejudice any of the matters mentioned in this subsection.
and it would be up to the ICO/Tribunal to adjudicate.

Streaky

Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Saturday 10th May 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
Hands up anyone on PH who has never stolen from or defrauded their employer (Biro, sheet of paper, telephone call, extra minutes on break, dodgy overtime/expense claim, etc.) - Streaky
Where's von?

streaky

Original Poster:

19,311 posts

280 months

Sunday 11th May 2008
quotequote all
Digby said:
streaky said:
Further "well-known fact" that there are no honest employees ... hence my "cast the first stone". Hands up anyone on PH who has never stolen from or defrauded their employer (Biro, sheet of paper, telephone call, extra minutes on break, dodgy overtime/expense claim, etc.) - Streaky
Being totally honest here, i don't think i have knowingly done anything like you mention.That is despite being in a position several times to get away with decent piles of cash with no chance of ever being caught.Am i stupid? biggrin
Then again, maybe it depends who you work for as to what they look apon as being honest.The company i work for now know i almost never take the full break i am allowed for example, so if i do take an extra 10 mins here or there because something cropped up or i got stuck chatting to someone etc, they are not the slightest bit interested.There is no doubt i have 'taken' pens, but only to use at work, so if they came home with me, they went back to work with me too and stayed with me until they ran out.
I have used the company phone a couple of times in the last year, but again, they don't mind as long as you don't take the pee.
You appear to be arguing that the thefts were OK as (a) there was no intent to permanently deprive, and (b) your employer accepts theft and fraud. So, (1) how did you replace the electricity (;)), (2) is this acceptance enshrined in policy, and (3) where is the line drawn and who draws it? Rhetorical questions only, no answers needed - Streaky

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Sunday 11th May 2008
quotequote all
Streaky, no exemption to the DPA was permitted in R v Ellis (HoL decision IIRC) - and that was for people who HAD been convicted and served jail time. Not just people who were accused.