Advice on Fixed Penalty
Author
Discussion

po54

Original Poster:

16 posts

222 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
Just after some advice about a fixed penalty I got a couple of days ago. Doing the school run, 12-15mph along a road full of speed bumps and the wife rings me - I answer and am on the phone for about 1 minute. Next thing I know an unmarked car is behind me with the grill all lite up blue and flashing - 3 points and £60. Fair enough I was on my phone, no excuses for that. The thing is looking at the paperwork this morning I see the officer has put the wrong address on the form 349 as where the offence took place. Now I admit I did wrong and I suppose I should be punished BUT it was a slow clear road, kids were all still in school, no other traffic except the volvo behind me with the fancy grill lights and I wasn't exactly causing any danger, SO if there is a way of getting off with it I'd like to! I already have 6 points from 2 years ago so not getting another 3 would be nice.

Thanks

P.S. Before I get slated as being a menace and poor driver, I have held my licence since 1986 and the 6 points I got in 2006 were my first ever, 3 for 33 in a 30 by a camera hidden behind a bus stop and 3 for 82 in a 70 on motorway by an unmarked car, again clear dry summer day and an almost empty straight road. Never had an accident either driving 20k a year, but will soon have 9 points and be close to loosing my licence!

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
Would the officer stand up in court and give evidence that you were on your phone? Yes he would.

Would the fact that he made a small mistake on the exact location influence the Magistrates? I doubt it.

Small clerical errors on paperwork are rarely the 'loopholes' that people think they are. Generally if the allegation is correct and there are no large holes in the case then room is allowed for them.

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
po54 said:
P.S. Before I get slated as being a menace and poor driver, I have held my licence since 1986 and the 6 points I got in 2006 were my first ever, 3 for 33 in a 30 by a camera hidden behind a bus stop and 3 for 82 in a 70 on motorway by an unmarked car, again clear dry summer day and an almost empty straight road. Never had an accident either driving 20k a year, but will soon have 9 points and be close to loosing my licence!
Are both these real,if so then the first is outside acpo guidelines and the second I'm very surprised at...didn't think plod would be too bothered with <85-90 on M/W...

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
PO54

Your have these options

1. Accept the mistake and pay the fine.

OR

2. Ignore the ticket because of the mistake. In which case because they have not received a response from you in 28 days (or time stipulated on ticket) FPN will be registered as a fine against you and increased by 50%.

OR

3. Write back to say that you do not accept the FPN because of the error. In this case they will issue a summons and have the matter dealt with at a Court. The error has little bearing on the offence to Mags can ignore/correct.

Certain details will have been noted at the time which will lead to your correct address.

dvd


Flute

48 posts

225 months

Monday 12th May 2008
quotequote all
Ignoring the FPN and receiving a summons will cost you extra money in court costs as it involves an appearance. The Prosecution will ask for a sum around £35 (that's the figure in our area anyway) it's a matter for the bench as to whether they award it or not.

The Prosecution will probably just apply to amend the summons in any event. It's up to the bench of course as to whether they allow the application.

Writing to the police and pointing out the error may just have the effect of them issuing another notice correcting the first defect or maybe just writing a letter about it.

If you ignore it a summons will be issued and it will cost you extra money.

Hope this helps...

The Black Duke

1,642 posts

224 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
One of my Colleagues fought a similar case last year with regard to a drink driving offence. The BiB sited the wrong car, wrong colour and wrong location.
IE BiB said it was a Citroen Xsara and it was a C4 they said the car was silver when it was light metallic blue. They also said the driver was seen driving along a certain street. It should have been a certain road. Ie Black Duke Road not Black Duke Street.

It was apparently at two o'clock in the morning and the accused was apparently seen at the wheel.

Needless to say they got off although they blew 106!!!

Not saying this is good but I just wish the BiB would try a little harder to fill in the correct info in their reports.

Jasandjules

72,694 posts

260 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
I think you've pretty much been caught bang to rights. You committed the offence, and your telephone records would so indicate, a minor detail like the exact position will be ignored by the mags in light of the testimony of the officer concerned (and the fact that it is a minor point, it's not like you are saying it wasn't you, or that you were in fact simply scratching your ear etc), and you'll get done and pay more as a result of attempting to defend what is an almost unwinnable case.

IMHO.

po54

Original Poster:

16 posts

222 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
OK, thanks for all the help.