Lunacy (IMHO) organisation from some HATO's on the M49
Discussion
Morning all,
Just thought I'd tell you all, and garner some advice some some BiB come knocking on my door soon:
Driving into work this morning, taking my usual route which always ends up me being on the M49 interchange into Bristol.
Now those who know Bristol, know that flows are a part and parcel of the motorways around us in Bristol, and as I had come down the entire M49 I was in the outer lane of the dual carraigeway sweeping around the long right hand corner into Avonmouth.
As I know traffic flows onto the M49 from the M5, I usually stay in the outer lane to make it safer.
As it was a couple of lorries joined, and a couple of cars were in front of me. I noted my speed at 55mph, and then the "Keep Right" lorry parked on the hard shoulder causing the traffic to enter the 'middle' (inner lane of the M49) lane to avoid it.
Just as we sort ourselves out, we crap ourselves, as some stupid HATO's had put about 5 cones in the road in the outer lane just past the M49/M5 south junction (in a very short sequence) to get us to swing around a borken down car on the right in the outer lane.
The Pug in front of me had enough space to flow across, however I didn't without getting tapped by the lorry who was in the lane to my left.
There wasn't enough space to brake, and so I accelerated, eyeing the first gap in the cones and deciding to slalom through as I knew the capability of the car, and knew I could gain a safer gap by going through there.
Ultimately, there was little I could do apart from the swerve - had the cones been more tightly bunched together, I might not have been writing this...
Granted, probably alarming to see, but all smoothly handed by the BMW and I safely snuck in front of the lorry, who clearly wasn't going to slow.
Mr angry HATO decided he was going to have a right old shouty at me, but obviously not being able to stop on a motorway, I had no right of reply.
What's the view here - I reckon the HATO's got it majorly wrong on that NSL corner, where they should have known visibility was limited, NEVER mind the bloody "keep right" lorry causing the traffic to bunch up on me! The cones were not spread in a way that allowed enough time to flow - especially on that section...I believe they should be worrying less about the car itself and ensuring the traffic is directed away from it - NOT by cones!
Was I right to carry out the manouvre I did - after all, it meant nobody in my boot, and nobody shunting me into Mr Angry HATO; and will I expect a knock on the door from BiB?
Here's a pic for your perusal, I'm interested to hear your thoughts - I don't believe I did anything illegal, but am considering making a call to HATO headquarters...

Just thought I'd tell you all, and garner some advice some some BiB come knocking on my door soon:
Driving into work this morning, taking my usual route which always ends up me being on the M49 interchange into Bristol.
Now those who know Bristol, know that flows are a part and parcel of the motorways around us in Bristol, and as I had come down the entire M49 I was in the outer lane of the dual carraigeway sweeping around the long right hand corner into Avonmouth.
As I know traffic flows onto the M49 from the M5, I usually stay in the outer lane to make it safer.
As it was a couple of lorries joined, and a couple of cars were in front of me. I noted my speed at 55mph, and then the "Keep Right" lorry parked on the hard shoulder causing the traffic to enter the 'middle' (inner lane of the M49) lane to avoid it.
Just as we sort ourselves out, we crap ourselves, as some stupid HATO's had put about 5 cones in the road in the outer lane just past the M49/M5 south junction (in a very short sequence) to get us to swing around a borken down car on the right in the outer lane.
The Pug in front of me had enough space to flow across, however I didn't without getting tapped by the lorry who was in the lane to my left.
There wasn't enough space to brake, and so I accelerated, eyeing the first gap in the cones and deciding to slalom through as I knew the capability of the car, and knew I could gain a safer gap by going through there.
Ultimately, there was little I could do apart from the swerve - had the cones been more tightly bunched together, I might not have been writing this...
Granted, probably alarming to see, but all smoothly handed by the BMW and I safely snuck in front of the lorry, who clearly wasn't going to slow.
Mr angry HATO decided he was going to have a right old shouty at me, but obviously not being able to stop on a motorway, I had no right of reply.
What's the view here - I reckon the HATO's got it majorly wrong on that NSL corner, where they should have known visibility was limited, NEVER mind the bloody "keep right" lorry causing the traffic to bunch up on me! The cones were not spread in a way that allowed enough time to flow - especially on that section...I believe they should be worrying less about the car itself and ensuring the traffic is directed away from it - NOT by cones!
Was I right to carry out the manouvre I did - after all, it meant nobody in my boot, and nobody shunting me into Mr Angry HATO; and will I expect a knock on the door from BiB?
Here's a pic for your perusal, I'm interested to hear your thoughts - I don't believe I did anything illegal, but am considering making a call to HATO headquarters...

Sounds like you did all you could in the circumstances.
You could argue that you should always have time to brake , however I see in this case that in reality the broken down car should have been notified earlier than just the cones around it.
An obstacle in the right hand lane needs much more careful warning than a left since right hand lane traffic invariably moves quicker and expects no stationary obstacles.
By the sound of the circumstances I wouldn't worry I doubt you would have been the only one to have been taken by surprise that day.
It may have been they had only just arrived at the stationary car and that a vehicle with flashing lights was still to be positioned ahead of the obstacle.
You could argue that you should always have time to brake , however I see in this case that in reality the broken down car should have been notified earlier than just the cones around it.
An obstacle in the right hand lane needs much more careful warning than a left since right hand lane traffic invariably moves quicker and expects no stationary obstacles.
By the sound of the circumstances I wouldn't worry I doubt you would have been the only one to have been taken by surprise that day.
It may have been they had only just arrived at the stationary car and that a vehicle with flashing lights was still to be positioned ahead of the obstacle.
neil_bolton said:
I safely snuck in front of the lorry, who clearly wasn't going to slow.
Good to know I'm not the only one who knows those Gentlemen of the Road will always rather see you dead than slow down.I wonder if he was disappointed when he saw that you "got away with it". I imagine he was rubbing his hands at the prospect of forcing you at motorway speed into a stationary car/hato/occupants who also needed wiping out...
SM
supermono said:
neil_bolton said:
I safely snuck in front of the lorry, who clearly wasn't going to slow.
Good to know I'm not the only one who knows those Gentlemen of the Road will always rather see you dead than slow down.I wonder if he was disappointed when he saw that you "got away with it". I imagine he was rubbing his hands at the prospect of forcing you at motorway speed into a stationary car/hato/occupants who also needed wiping out...
SM
"safely snuck in front of the lorry"......safe according to whom? Too many small vehicles think a truck can stop in the same space as a car and "sneak in" to the trucks braking space (which the driver has already planned for until someone cut him up!) Not arguing the merits of right or wrong here, just an alternative to thoughts laid out above.
Either way, a further incident was avoided, that at least should be pleasing to all
Big Rod said:
mark69sheer said:
You could argue that you should always have time to brake ,
I would argue that.However, tell that to the chap who would have run into the back of me.
Additionally, the gap I snuck into in front of the lorry was not through choice - I'm aware of how lorries need additional space - however, I wasn't left with a lot of choice, and when you are travelling at roughly 60 feet a second, you don't get much time to make a decision!
I'm glad to have avoided an accident, and will always look to reduce the chances of being in a situation like that again, but wondered whether or not the HATO's were unwise to offer such little warning...?
Ok, lets have a good look at this.
HATO arrives on scene to find a broken down vehicle in the outside lane of a sliproad.
They park their Jeep behind the vehicle with all rear lights flashing.
They put cones to make a taper to send vehicles from lane 2 into lane 1, To stop traffic from running in the rear of the broken down vehicle.
Everything is correct so far, the HATO's have done what they are supposed to to.
(I'll also bet that signals were set prior to the sliproad with speeds and "obstruction")
now along comes you and nearly wipes out all the cones, HATO's and orther vehicles.
I'll put money also on the fact that for whatever reason, you either didn't see the signals, (possibly because you were too close to the vehicle in front)or you just ignored them,
you obviously didn't see the HATO's lights (or again you ignored them) again possibly because you were too close to the vehicle in front, suddenly, it's all stopped in front of you! you couldn't stop in time, so you run through the cones. (now it proves that you were too close to the vehicle in front)
You are trying to put the blame on the HATO, what would you have them do?
Not park behind this broken down vehicle to give protection? not put out any sort of emergency traffic management (cones)to divert traffic away from it?
Sorry, but you come across like the usual type of inpatient driver that believes the 2 second rule, and leaving enough room doesn't apply to them.
As stated, you are supposed to be able to stop in the distance that you can see.
The HATO's have done no wrong here, you are the main culprit, with possibly a distraction by the ISU lorry if the arrow was incorrectly set (but this is unusual)
I would say, that because you missed the signals, because you missed the HATO's lights, because you didn't see the cones until you were on top of them, you wouldn't know which way any arrow was pointing!!!
HATO arrives on scene to find a broken down vehicle in the outside lane of a sliproad.
They park their Jeep behind the vehicle with all rear lights flashing.
They put cones to make a taper to send vehicles from lane 2 into lane 1, To stop traffic from running in the rear of the broken down vehicle.
Everything is correct so far, the HATO's have done what they are supposed to to.
(I'll also bet that signals were set prior to the sliproad with speeds and "obstruction")
- **The "keep right lorry" (ISU) is on the H/S just prior to the broken down vehicle.*********
now along comes you and nearly wipes out all the cones, HATO's and orther vehicles.
I'll put money also on the fact that for whatever reason, you either didn't see the signals, (possibly because you were too close to the vehicle in front)or you just ignored them,
you obviously didn't see the HATO's lights (or again you ignored them) again possibly because you were too close to the vehicle in front, suddenly, it's all stopped in front of you! you couldn't stop in time, so you run through the cones. (now it proves that you were too close to the vehicle in front)
You are trying to put the blame on the HATO, what would you have them do?
Not park behind this broken down vehicle to give protection? not put out any sort of emergency traffic management (cones)to divert traffic away from it?
Sorry, but you come across like the usual type of inpatient driver that believes the 2 second rule, and leaving enough room doesn't apply to them.
As stated, you are supposed to be able to stop in the distance that you can see.
The HATO's have done no wrong here, you are the main culprit, with possibly a distraction by the ISU lorry if the arrow was incorrectly set (but this is unusual)
I would say, that because you missed the signals, because you missed the HATO's lights, because you didn't see the cones until you were on top of them, you wouldn't know which way any arrow was pointing!!!
Edited by Gafferjim on Tuesday 13th May 14:44
TTwiggy said:
God I love this forum! I had a personal bet with myself that within 8 posts someone would give their 'expert' account of a situation that they neither saw, nor posses any facts pertaining to, in order to lay blame with the OP - thankyou, I now owe myself a beer!
isn't gafferjim a HATO?TTwiggy said:
God I love this forum! I had a personal bet with myself that within 8 posts someone would give their 'expert' account of a situation that they neither saw, nor posses any facts pertaining to, in order to lay blame with the OP - thankyou, I now owe myself a beer!
Well he is right - even taking the 'facts' as the OP stated I don't see how the situation is anything other than his fault. You should be able to stop in the distance that you can see to be clear, not the distance that you expect to be clear. The obstruction did not spontaneously pop into existence in front of him, so proper observation would have avoided the situation.Gafferjim said:
Ok, lets have a good look at this.
HATO arrives on scene to find a broken down vehicle in the outside lane of a sliproad.
They park their Jeep behind the vehicle with all rear lights flashing.
They put cones to make a taper to send vehicles from lane 2 into lane 1, To stop traffic from running in the rear of the broken down vehicle.
Everything is correct so far, the HATO's have done what they are supposed to to.
(I'll also bet that signals were set prior to the sliproad with speeds and "obstruction")
now along comes you and nearly wipes out all the cones, HATO's and orther vehicles.
I'll put money also on the fact that for whatever reason, you either didn't see the signals, (possibly because you were too close to the vehicle in front)or you just ignored them,
you obviously didn't see the HATO's lights (or again you ignored them) again possibly because you were too close to the vehicle in front, suddenly, it's all stopped in front of you! you couldn't stop in time, so you run through the cones. (now it proves that you were too close to the vehicle in front)
You are trying to put the blame on the HATO, what would you have them do?
Not park behind this broken down vehicle to give protection? not put out any sort of emergency traffic management (cones)to divert traffic away from it?
Sorry, but you come across like the usual type of inpatient driver that believes the 2 second rule, and leaving enough room doesn't apply to them.
As stated, you are supposed to be able to stop in the distance that you can see.
The HATO's have done no wrong here, you are the main culprit, with possibly a distraction by the ISU lorry if the arrow was incorrectly set (but this is unusual)
I would say, that because you missed the signals, because you missed the HATO's lights, because you didn't see the cones until you were on top of them, you wouldn't know which way any arrow was pointing!!!
Did you actually take a decent look at the picture? This is on a long sweeping right hander, of which once I'd clocked the 'keep right' lorry, ascertained what was deciding to move into my lane, adjust my distance accordingly, then look ahead, realise an obstruction, look behind, to the side, work out what I can and cannot do in the circumstances, I quickly ran out of room.HATO arrives on scene to find a broken down vehicle in the outside lane of a sliproad.
They park their Jeep behind the vehicle with all rear lights flashing.
They put cones to make a taper to send vehicles from lane 2 into lane 1, To stop traffic from running in the rear of the broken down vehicle.
Everything is correct so far, the HATO's have done what they are supposed to to.
(I'll also bet that signals were set prior to the sliproad with speeds and "obstruction")
- **The "keep right lorry" (ISU) is on the H/S just prior to the broken down vehicle.*********
now along comes you and nearly wipes out all the cones, HATO's and orther vehicles.
I'll put money also on the fact that for whatever reason, you either didn't see the signals, (possibly because you were too close to the vehicle in front)or you just ignored them,
you obviously didn't see the HATO's lights (or again you ignored them) again possibly because you were too close to the vehicle in front, suddenly, it's all stopped in front of you! you couldn't stop in time, so you run through the cones. (now it proves that you were too close to the vehicle in front)
You are trying to put the blame on the HATO, what would you have them do?
Not park behind this broken down vehicle to give protection? not put out any sort of emergency traffic management (cones)to divert traffic away from it?
Sorry, but you come across like the usual type of inpatient driver that believes the 2 second rule, and leaving enough room doesn't apply to them.
As stated, you are supposed to be able to stop in the distance that you can see.
The HATO's have done no wrong here, you are the main culprit, with possibly a distraction by the ISU lorry if the arrow was incorrectly set (but this is unusual)
I would say, that because you missed the signals, because you missed the HATO's lights, because you didn't see the cones until you were on top of them, you wouldn't know which way any arrow was pointing!!!
Edited by Gafferjim on Tuesday 13th May 14:44
I could have stopped easily.
HOWEVER: and this is the crux of the issue, it was NOT the appropriate thing to do.
My point was that the cones where not easily seen due to it being a long right hander - IMHO the HATO should have had his jeep MUCH further back, so that it could warn us, as it was, it was right on the bloody car, and left very little room.
Just because the letter of law say whatever, doesn't mean its always right, and whilst I agree that I can ALWAYS learn from an incident, I don't believe that the HATO was correct in his placement.
spikeyhead said:
OP, what would you have preferred the HATO's had done?
To have had their vehicle much further back around the corner whereupon visiblilty from approaching vehicles before the corner is greatly improved. The HATO could then ensure that traffic stays out of Lane 2, RATHER than relying on it just bloody stopping in the middle of a motorway as GafferJim seems to think is appropriate.
GafferJim, remember that the safety of the traffic flowing past the incident is JUST as important as the safety of the incident 'causer'.
Manic HATO's plonking cones down on a long corner is not what I call safe.
And to anyone else who keeps on at me about braking distance:
Anyone else fancy emergency stopping on a corner, from 55mph to nowt in not a lot of distance (that I have already said I could have safely - just - stopped in) with traffic also flowing behind you?
I don't fancy picking pieces of Merc from out the back of my BMW thats for sure.
Henceforth, I made the manouvre I did.
Anyone else fancy emergency stopping on a corner, from 55mph to nowt in not a lot of distance (that I have already said I could have safely - just - stopped in) with traffic also flowing behind you?
I don't fancy picking pieces of Merc from out the back of my BMW thats for sure.
Henceforth, I made the manouvre I did.
I'm afraid it sounds to me that you were driving too fast and too close to other vehicles for the conditions. Stuff happens on m'ways, you have to give yourself room for them.
I wonder if he was disappointed when he saw that you "got away with it". I imagine he was rubbing his hands at the prospect of forcing you at motorway speed into a stationary car/hato/occupants who also needed wiping out...
SMAs a trucker i can tell you that we're helping others to avoid accidents all the time. Some try as hard as they can sometimes to have a prang with us, and yes sometimes i've failed to get out of the way quick enough when someone has thrust their car into my wheelnuts but i always try to and usually manage to avoid them. Most drivers are blissfully unaware of the hazards they place themselves in and are totally unaware of how someone else has helped them. You're clearly one of these, 'cos you're 100% wrong.
supermono said:
neil_bolton said:
I safely snuck in front of the lorry, who clearly wasn't going to slow.
Good to know I'm not the only one who knows those Gentlemen of the Road will always rather see you dead than slow down.I wonder if he was disappointed when he saw that you "got away with it". I imagine he was rubbing his hands at the prospect of forcing you at motorway speed into a stationary car/hato/occupants who also needed wiping out...
SM
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



