NCP - Paid for company annual tickets £30k+ but no spaces!!
NCP - Paid for company annual tickets £30k+ but no spaces!!
Author
Discussion

Gallen (BPH)

Original Poster:

2,166 posts

286 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
The company I work for buys £30k+ worth of annual car parking tickets from NCP on an annual basis. These tickets allow you to park in the car park, but not in the "premium" parking bays which are numbered, and sold for around £300 more as they guarantee a single person the same space each day.

NCP have recently re-painted the car park spaces for this car park, and have increased the number of "premium" car park spaces.

Since doing this, there are never any normal spaces available and employees are having to park on double yellows and yellow cross hatchings within the car park - When all these areas are used up they are forced to look elsewhere but there is no where else to park within the town. It's all "permit holders" and residents bays, or limited waiting.

I have counted on average at least 50 of these premium parking bays per day are always left empty, even when the rest of the car park is full to the extent that people with annual tickets (which cost £900 +per year each) are left to look elsewhere. If you park in a premium bay you will get a ticket. Parking on the double yellows and cross hatchings also runs the risk of a ticket, but we are forced to do so as we have paid for the annual ticket, but are not provided with a space.

One employee spoke to the NCP attendent who basically said that we should get in earlier!!!! (neglecting the fact that they have over-sold and double sold tickets).

What can we do???

We already spend over 30k+ each year- If we are forced to upgrade to premium parking it means that the company will have to pay much more.

It is worrying because I think that NCP are in breach of contract by failing to provide spaces, whilst being happy to take over £30,000 per year for the annual car park ticket - They then double sell the spaces.

NCP say that to guarantee a space we need premium parking. This can not be right??? If that is that case, then what have we paid £30,000 for???

Any help or advice appreciated.

touching cloth

11,706 posts

270 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
I am going to guess that it will be covered under the terms of whatever contract your company has with them, for a £30k charge there will be I expect a fairly detailed terms and conditions inc a SLA. It's overselling based on historical usage patterns, much like airlines do with their flights - if they only sold the actual number of spaces that were available then that would just be akin to a "premium space" for everyone, as one space would have to be available to you regardless of whether you were there to use it or not, so everyone might as well have an allocated spot - overselling is a morally dubious tactic as yes you are charging for something you might not deliver on, but ultimately if everyone insists on having a guaranteed space every day, then their pricing will as said just revert to one tier, effectively matching the premium price. The difference with the airline anology I guess being, they oversell flights but do at least have to pay compensation if they then can't deliver on their promise - seems the car park should do the same but am guessing the contract negates them of this responsibility.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
I suppose the company could reclaim the daily parking charge for each occasion someone is not able to find a space, although the annual payment is probably at a discount to the daily charge for whatever number of cars are involved. A possibility is to ask the company to set up a car sharing programme and to pay for premium spaces for the cars in that programme. This would be cheaper for everyone and provide guaranteed parking slots.

Gallen (BPH)

Original Poster:

2,166 posts

286 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
...a good idea but car sharing wouldn't work as staff are from all over Essex, Suffolk, Herts, London etc etc!

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
Sure, I wasn’t suggesting it should be mandatory or that it would suit everyone, but an incentive such as a guaranteed parking slot could pull in enough people to create some space in the car park and savings all round.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
This is a possible breach of contract issue.

Without being disruptive to the thread the devil is in the detail of the contract. If the contract states that X cars can get spaces *subject to availability* then this is what they have supplied.


JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Think about it though.

The car park is not only full, but overflowing. All that will do is allow them to fill the car park with people on a daily rate for more turnover. They probably wouldn't be hugely fussed.

joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Think about it though.

The car park is not only full, but overflowing. All that will do is allow them to fill the car park with people on a daily rate for more turnover. They probably wouldn't be hugely fussed.
OP states that 50 premium spaces are unfilled. I reckon it's a ploy to get people to upgrade to the premium package.

Gallen (BPH)

Original Poster:

2,166 posts

286 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
joewilliams said:
OP states that 50 premium spaces are unfilled. I reckon it's a ploy to get people to upgrade to the premium package.
Has to be that - Can see no other reason to expand.

Chrisgr31

14,299 posts

286 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
[quote=Gallen (BPH)]
joewilliams said:
OP states that 50 premium spaces are unfilled. I reckon it's a ploy to get people to upgrade to the premium package.
Has to be that - Can see no other reason to expand.
The owners (or original owners) of NCP didn't get very rich by chance!

Yes its a scheme to get you to upgrade to a premium space, but there's not a lot you can do about it. I would be surprised if the current contract doesn't include a clause absolving NCP of blame should their not be a space available.