Speeding and overtaking
Author
Discussion

raf_gti

Original Poster:

4,258 posts

237 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
Thought I would ask a quick question which has been bugging me for a while.

Assuming the road is safe and there are no obvious dangers up ahead what speed is permissable for an overtaking manouvere? If on a A/B road the car in front is doing approx 50-55 and I want to get past as quickly what is my margin of 'overspeed' allowed to be? Even in my trusty Passat TDi it is very easy to reach 70 or so at the drop of a hat, especially if there more cars that can be safely passed in the manouvere.

Is there a definitive answer to this or if stopped, would it be to the discretion of the PC?

Steve

julian64

14,325 posts

285 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
Overtaking is, has, and always will be totally illegal.

Whats changed is the quality of the police officer watching you do it.

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
If you drive between York and Filey on the back road after Stamford bridge there is only one long straight available to overtake on after you have been held up by a granny for the last 12 miles.

Guess where the police put their speed trap?

There's your answer.

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
A particular member on here explains that speeding for any reason is a sign of poor driving. He should be along shortly to explain why.

SM

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
julian64 said:
Overtaking is, has, and always will be totally illegal.

Whats changed is the quality of the police officer watching you do it.
Overtaking is legal. However you are limited to the upper limit for the road which should be part of your consideration.

If to make a safe overtake you have to exceed the limit then the overtake is not on. "I was overtaking" is not an offence to excess speed.

The reality is that whether any enforcement is about will form part of any planning.

As for the quality of todays officer your right, its gone up and they are on average less interested than ever in traffic matters.

Do a quick overtake may attract attention, even a stop but the chances of any action is greatly diminished from when a few years back there were far greater numbers of officers doing traffic and speed enforcement.

In the past 10 years I have actually seen an improvement in the average 'quality' of candidate coming through. There are far fewer that need 'binning' compared to when I first joined.

raf_gti

Original Poster:

4,258 posts

237 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
julian64 said:
Overtaking is, has, and always will be totally illegal.

Whats changed is the quality of the police officer watching you do it.
Care to explain the illegality further?


julian64

14,325 posts

285 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
julian64 said:
Overtaking is, has, and always will be totally illegal.

Whats changed is the quality of the police officer watching you do it.
Overtaking is legal. However you are limited to the upper limit for the road which should be part of your consideration.

If to make a safe overtake you have to exceed the limit then the overtake is not on. "I was overtaking" is not an offence to excess speed.

The reality is that whether any enforcement is about will form part of any planning.

As for the quality of todays officer your right, its gone up and they are on average less interested than ever in traffic matters.

Do a quick overtake may attract attention, even a stop but the chances of any action is greatly diminished from when a few years back there were far greater numbers of officers doing traffic and speed enforcement.

In the past 10 years I have actually seen an improvement in the average 'quality' of candidate coming through. There are far fewer that need 'binning' compared to when I first joined.
Twaddle. I'll come and sit in your car. If you can do a single overtake without breaking the speed limit or being completely dangerous I'll publically appologise to you.

Till then you a a fairy, living in fairy land with a large hat emblazoned with the words 'I'm a fairy' on it.

julian64

14,325 posts

285 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
raf_gti said:
julian64 said:
Overtaking is, has, and always will be totally illegal.

Whats changed is the quality of the police officer watching you do it.
Care to explain the illegality further?
Illegality- def, the art of making von appear on a thread

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
julian64 said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
julian64 said:
Overtaking is, has, and always will be totally illegal.

Whats changed is the quality of the police officer watching you do it.
Overtaking is legal. However you are limited to the upper limit for the road which should be part of your consideration.

If to make a safe overtake you have to exceed the limit then the overtake is not on. "I was overtaking" is not an offence to excess speed.

The reality is that whether any enforcement is about will form part of any planning.

As for the quality of todays officer your right, its gone up and they are on average less interested than ever in traffic matters.

Do a quick overtake may attract attention, even a stop but the chances of any action is greatly diminished from when a few years back there were far greater numbers of officers doing traffic and speed enforcement.

In the past 10 years I have actually seen an improvement in the average 'quality' of candidate coming through. There are far fewer that need 'binning' compared to when I first joined.
Twaddle. I'll come and sit in your car. If you can do a single overtake without breaking the speed limit or being completely dangerous I'll publically appologise to you.

Till then you a a fairy, living in fairy land with a large hat emblazoned with the words 'I'm a fairy' on it.
As I said you have to bring into your planning the speed limit for the road. If the person is travelling at 50 in a 50 then you should not be overtaking them. If they are travelling at 30 then you can. I did it the other day on a dual carriageway near me. On country roads its quite possible to overtake someone travelling at 30 or 40 when the national limit applies.

It makes no odds if you believe me or not or whether your making appropriate overtakes taking into account the surrounding conditions (one of which is the limit on the road or enforcement being present).

Its more than possible to make safe overtakes within posted limits. I did one about two weeks ago, I could go and do one right now if I picked the right part of the road. Any competent driver can.

spikeyhead

20,656 posts

228 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
julian64 said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
julian64 said:
Overtaking is, has, and always will be totally illegal.

Whats changed is the quality of the police officer watching you do it.
Overtaking is legal. However you are limited to the upper limit for the road which should be part of your consideration.

If to make a safe overtake you have to exceed the limit then the overtake is not on. "I was overtaking" is not an offence to excess speed.

The reality is that whether any enforcement is about will form part of any planning.

As for the quality of todays officer your right, its gone up and they are on average less interested than ever in traffic matters.

Do a quick overtake may attract attention, even a stop but the chances of any action is greatly diminished from when a few years back there were far greater numbers of officers doing traffic and speed enforcement.

In the past 10 years I have actually seen an improvement in the average 'quality' of candidate coming through. There are far fewer that need 'binning' compared to when I first joined.
Twaddle. I'll come and sit in your car. If you can do a single overtake without breaking the speed limit or being completely dangerous I'll publically appologise to you.

Till then you a a fairy, living in fairy land with a large hat emblazoned with the words 'I'm a fairy' on it.
I've managed numerous overtakes without being dangerous or exceeding the speed limit. I've also exceeded the limit regularly to minimize the time exposed to danger.

Scamper

732 posts

253 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
No, you are not allowed to legally overtake anyone, at anytime unless you can pay the overtaking tax which comes with a free 3pt penalty.....

I cannot think of any circumstances where a safe overtake would not exceed the speed limit (unless overtaking a stationary obstacle...). Therefore every overtake is illegal..HTH

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
If its clear enough then I have a confession to make.

If someone has held me up for ages and ages I sometimes admit that I will overtake them within the speed limit so that it takes ages for me to get past. (Obviously only when I can see the road ahead is clear for miles.)

This usually results in them stuck on my bumper for a change as strangely despite doing 35mph for twenty miles as soon as you overtake them they suddenly wake up and drive at 60.

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
As for the quality of todays officer your right,
On the subject of laws; the laws of grammar in particular, the contraction of you are is "you're". The apostrophe represents the missing "a". The word "your" is different entirely meaning something belonging to you. Whilst the OP is certain to have a right, it doesn't make sense in this context.

eta: there's only one today. I think you mean "today's"
SM

Edited by supermono on Wednesday 14th May 13:19

Distant

2,508 posts

224 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
Scamper said:
No, you are not allowed to legally overtake anyone, at anytime unless you can pay the overtaking tax which comes with a free 3pt penalty.....

I cannot think of any circumstances where a safe overtake would not exceed the speed limit (unless overtaking a stationary obstacle...). Therefore every overtake is illegal..HTH
Tractor, milk float, bicycle?......

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
supermono said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
As for the quality of todays officer your right,
On the subject of laws; the laws of grammar in particular, the contraction of you are is "you're". The apostrophe represents the missing "a". The word "your" is different entirely meaning something belonging to you. Whilst the OP is certain to have a right, it doesn't make sense in this context.

SM
That is what happens when I type fast, I often swap your for you're and there for their, along with a few other things. I forget that this is Grammarheads.com.

Its an over reliance on spell checks and computers and forgetting to read what I have typed.

Edited by Mr_annie_vxr on Wednesday 14th May 13:22

julian64

14,325 posts

285 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
julian64 said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
julian64 said:
Overtaking is, has, and always will be totally illegal.

Whats changed is the quality of the police officer watching you do it.
Overtaking is legal. However you are limited to the upper limit for the road which should be part of your consideration.

If to make a safe overtake you have to exceed the limit then the overtake is not on. "I was overtaking" is not an offence to excess speed.

The reality is that whether any enforcement is about will form part of any planning.

As for the quality of todays officer your right, its gone up and they are on average less interested than ever in traffic matters.

Do a quick overtake may attract attention, even a stop but the chances of any action is greatly diminished from when a few years back there were far greater numbers of officers doing traffic and speed enforcement.

In the past 10 years I have actually seen an improvement in the average 'quality' of candidate coming through. There are far fewer that need 'binning' compared to when I first joined.
Twaddle. I'll come and sit in your car. If you can do a single overtake without breaking the speed limit or being completely dangerous I'll publically appologise to you.

Till then you a a fairy, living in fairy land with a large hat emblazoned with the words 'I'm a fairy' on it.
As I said you have to bring into your planning the speed limit for the road. If the person is travelling at 50 in a 50 then you should not be overtaking them. If they are travelling at 30 then you can. I did it the other day on a dual carriageway near me. On country roads its quite possible to overtake someone travelling at 30 or 40 when the national limit applies.

It makes no odds if you believe me or not or whether your making appropriate overtakes taking into account the surrounding conditions (one of which is the limit on the road or enforcement being present).

Its more than possible to make safe overtakes within posted limits. I did one about two weeks ago, I could go and do one right now if I picked the right part of the road. Any competent driver can.
You did a safe overtake two weeks ago and you want to give me that as an example of what you think is appropriate. Are you having a laugh?

You talk about country roads as if you drive them. I happen to live down country roads and they are a darn sight more dangerous to overtake on than normal roads because of the vision problems and opportunities involved, not less as you imply.

With all due respect I have four cars, all of a lot more power than the ones on your profile. I tend to overtake once or twice on every journey not once every two weeks. If I limited myself to not exceeding the speed limit on an overtake, I wouldn't overtake even in my cars let alone the ones you claim to be able to do it safely in.

So you'll excuse me when you talk about being a competent driver and what you can do, and I reply .......scratchchin

jwo

989 posts

280 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
Seems a bit of a daft question really...

Breaking the speed limit is breaking the speed limt - whether this is done whilst overtaking or not doesn't matter.

However, to limit ted, best to drop a few cogs and be off!

If the person in front of you is going slower than you and you overtake then so be it.

The key thing be whether it was completed safely!!

cs02rm0

13,966 posts

222 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
Distant said:
Scamper said:
No, you are not allowed to legally overtake anyone, at anytime unless you can pay the overtaking tax which comes with a free 3pt penalty.....

I cannot think of any circumstances where a safe overtake would not exceed the speed limit (unless overtaking a stationary obstacle...). Therefore every overtake is illegal..HTH
Tractor, milk float, bicycle?......
Clearly, you are a fairy, living in fairy land with a large hat emblazoned with the words 'I'm a fairy' on it. Tractors, pah, whoever saw one of them in real life? wink

. o O ( Learner drivers, runners, scooters, grannies... )

Edited by cs02rm0 on Wednesday 14th May 13:41

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
You can legally overtake on double whites if the vehicle you want to pass is doing 15mph or less.
However I have come round some corners to find twits on my side overtaking in just such circumstances.

To the numpties! You are still supposed to make sure it's safe

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
That is what happens when I type fast, I often swap your for you're and there for their, along with a few other things.
I sympathise totally. A similar thing happened to me the other day -- I was driving and concentrating on the basic thrust of what I was doing (getting safely from a-b) when I mistakenly displayed the wrong number on the speedo. Cost me 60 quid though. Your equally significant transgression came for free.

SM