Insurance for learners
Author
Discussion

simford

Original Poster:

21 posts

261 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
ie Me!

Any idea what the law regarding insurance for a learner is, there's a few points I'm unsure about.

1stly. Can a car be insured on two policies at once? I've found an insurer who will cover me 3rd party with my provisional license on the missus Megane for a very short term basis (£15 for 24hrs cover) Can I legally go for this cover, without affecting or even mentioning it to her insurer? The quote to add me as a provisional driver to her policy was an extra £400, far too much for just a couple of days worth of practise.

2ndly. What about insurance for my 'supervising' passenger (which won't be my missus, as she hasn't been driving long enough)? Do they have to be insured on the car as well? If so, does it have to be the same policy as mine, or would they be covered by the 'drive any other vehicle as 3rd party' part of their own Fully Comp policy.

3rdly. Should I have an accident (I don't intend to though), who's policy would be the one to pay out? Me as the driver, or the 'supervising' passenger, who is 'in charge' of the vehicle?

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
I think the answers to your first 2 questions are ..no and because of that the answer to your third is...it depends who has insured the car...HTH

Burrow01

1,989 posts

223 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
esselte said:
I think the answers to your first 2 questions are ..no and because of that the answer to your third is...it depends who has insured the car...HTH
I've insured other peoples cars for short term periods with Norwich Union - as I understand it if I crashed whilst driving, claim would be against my insurance, if they were driving it would be under theirs - you are insuring a named person to drive the car, rather than the vehicle itself

I've also had other people drive my car on the same type of short term insurance, as they were not covered by my policy

Pete

Edited by Burrow01 on Wednesday 14th May 19:31

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
Burrow01 said:
esselte said:
I think the answers to your first 2 questions are ..no and because of that the answer to your third is...it depends who has insured the car...HTH
I've insured other peoples cars for short term periods with Norwich Union - as I understand it if I crashed whilst driving, claim would be against my insurance, if they were driving it would be under theirs - you are insuring a named person to drive the car, rather than the vehicle itself

Pete
Ah OK,I thought a car could onlny have one insurance policy taken out on it.Obviously insuring the driver is a different matter....

Edited by esselte on Wednesday 14th May 19:38

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
When my other half was learning, the insurance was in her name and I was on a second driver.

It wasnt that expensive either.


Swoxy

2,842 posts

241 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
You need Young Marmalade.

Noger

7,117 posts

280 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
Burrow01 said:
esselte said:
I think the answers to your first 2 questions are ..no and because of that the answer to your third is...it depends who has insured the car...HTH
I've insured other peoples cars for short term periods with Norwich Union - as I understand it if I crashed whilst driving, claim would be against my insurance, if they were driving it would be under theirs - you are insuring a named person to drive the car, rather than the vehicle itself

I've also had other people drive my car on the same type of short term insurance, as they were not covered by my policy

Pete

Edited by Burrow01 on Wednesday 14th May 19:31
Well, you are not insuring the car per se, as you have no insurable interest in it. As you say, you are insuring yourself as a driver against being sued for Third Party Liabilties.

Due to "Driving other cars" cover, every car in the UK has millions of potential people who could drive it and still be insured for that use.

So I think the answers are :-

1) Yes, sort of. It might work for third party. Insuring something belonging to someone else (i.e. for Accidental Damage) might be trickier.

2) Never heard of "supervisor" insurance, and I suspect it doesn't exist (happy to be proved wrong). You are in control as a learner, not them. Your negligence.

3) Yours. But bear in mind the MID will still show their Insurer not yours - so any TP may go to them first.

Their insurer still has a statutory liabilty to pay the claim under the RTA, so it has the potential to be a bit messy.


mph999

2,780 posts

251 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all



1stly. Can a car be insured on two policies at once? I've found an insurer who will cover me 3rd party with my provisional license on the missus Megane for a very short term basis (£15 for 24hrs cover) Can I legally go for this cover, without affecting or even mentioning it to her insurer? The quote to add me as a provisional driver to her policy was an extra £400, far too much for just a couple of days worth of practise.

Yes, I've insured other cars on my policy so I can drive.

2ndly. What about insurance for my 'supervising' passenger (which won't be my missus, as she hasn't been driving long enough)? Do they have to be insured on the car as well? If so, does it have to be the same policy as mine, or would they be covered by the 'drive any other vehicle as 3rd party' part of their own Fully Comp policy.

The supervisor must be insured to drive the vehicle.

3rdly. Should I have an accident (I don't intend to though), who's policy would be the one to pay out? Me as the driver, or the 'supervising' passenger, who is 'in charge' of the vehicle?

Yours, as you are the driver.

Edited by mph999 on Thursday 15th May 23:39

N Dentressangle

3,453 posts

253 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Swoxy said:
You need Young Marmalade.
What a great site. Good find!

hardcorehobbit

1,103 posts

226 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Swoxy said:
You need Young Marmalade.
That hasn't been worth it in ages. The price for insurance now is sky rocketing. It's about £500 more than this time last year. Not to mention the ridiculous prices of the used and nearly new cars.



OP, you can insure a car again in your name for however long you want. AFAIK. Short term cover should be fine.

The 'supervisor' DOES NOT need to have cover on that car, they simply need to have a driving licence for 3 years and be over 21.

5lab

1,949 posts

227 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
have you tried dayinsure.co.uk?

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
mph999 said:
1stly. Can a car be insured on two policies at once? I've found an insurer who will cover me 3rd party with my provisional license on the missus Megane for a very short term basis (£15 for 24hrs cover) Can I legally go for this cover, without affecting or even mentioning it to her insurer? The quote to add me as a provisional driver to her policy was an extra £400, far too much for just a couple of days worth of practise.

Yes, I've insured other cars on my policy so I can drive.

2ndly. What about insurance for my 'supervising' passenger (which won't be my missus, as she hasn't been driving long enough)? Do they have to be insured on the car as well? If so, does it have to be the same policy as mine, or would they be covered by the 'drive any other vehicle as 3rd party' part of their own Fully Comp policy.

The supervisor must be insured to drive the vehicle.

3rdly. Should I have an accident (I don't intend to though), who's policy would be the one to pay out? Me as the driver, or the 'supervising' passenger, who is 'in charge' of the vehicle?

Yours, as you are the driver.

Edited by mph999 on Thursday 15th May 23:39
If any payout for damage is down o the learner's insurance then why does the "supervisor" have to have insurance for the car...just curious..smile

Burrow01

1,989 posts

223 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Noger said:
Burrow01 said:
esselte said:
I think the answers to your first 2 questions are ..no and because of that the answer to your third is...it depends who has insured the car...HTH
I've insured other peoples cars for short term periods with Norwich Union - as I understand it if I crashed whilst driving, claim would be against my insurance, if they were driving it would be under theirs - you are insuring a named person to drive the car, rather than the vehicle itself

I've also had other people drive my car on the same type of short term insurance, as they were not covered by my policy

Pete

Edited by Burrow01 on Wednesday 14th May 19:31
Well, you are not insuring the car per se, as you have no insurable interest in it. As you say, you are insuring yourself as a driver against being sued for Third Party Liabilties.

Due to "Driving other cars" cover, every car in the UK has millions of potential people who could drive it and still be insured for that use.

So I think the answers are :-

1) Yes, sort of. It might work for third party. Insuring something belonging to someone else (i.e. for Accidental Damage) might be trickier.

2) Never heard of "supervisor" insurance, and I suspect it doesn't exist (happy to be proved wrong). You are in control as a learner, not them. Your negligence.

3) Yours. But bear in mind the MID will still show their Insurer not yours - so any TP may go to them first.

Their insurer still has a statutory liabilty to pay the claim under the RTA, so it has the potential to be a bit messy.
1) Norwich Union will insure you for accidental damage to the car you are driving. It specifies in the policy that any payment for accidental damage will be made to the owner of the vehicle, not the insured.