PC Avoids Car Ban - What a Shock......
PC Avoids Car Ban - What a Shock......
Author
Discussion

NobleGuy

Original Poster:

7,133 posts

246 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
"A police firearms officer who invented a high-speed chase to escapre prosecution for speeding at 89mph in a 70mph zone has been spared a driving ban. PC Richard Holding, 45, of Liskeard, Cornwall, was fined £450 with £500 costs after magistrates in Plymouth were told he was suffering PTSD after serving with the TA in Iraq, which had left him 'irrational'".

Not a massive crime in many respects, but with MOPs going to prison for trying to escape 3 points by pretending someone else was driving, how does this do anything but build the 'one law for one...' argument.

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
well thats him out of a job then. if PTSD has left him irrational there is no way he should be a firearms officer.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
NobleGuy said:
"A police firearms officer who invented a high-speed chase to escapre prosecution for speeding at 89mph in a 70mph zone has been spared a driving ban. PC Richard Holding, 45, of Liskeard, Cornwall, was fined £450 with £500 costs after magistrates in Plymouth were told he was suffering PTSD after serving with the TA in Iraq, which had left him 'irrational'".

Not a massive crime in many respects, but with MOPs going to prison for trying to escape 3 points by pretending someone else was driving, how does this do anything but build the 'one law for one...' argument.
I guess they believed the PTSD story. If he served in Iraq I would be sympathetic too.

Edited by s2art on Thursday 15th May 13:48

ukwill

10,290 posts

238 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
s2art said:
NobleGuy said:
"A police firearms officer who invented a high-speed chase to escapre prosecution for speeding at 89mph in a 70mph zone has been spared a driving ban. PC Richard Holding, 45, of Liskeard, Cornwall, was fined £450 with £500 costs after magistrates in Plymouth were told he was suffering PTSD after serving with the TA in Iraq, which had left him 'irrational'".

Not a massive crime in many respects, but with MOPs going to prison for trying to escape 3 points by pretending someone else was driving, how does this do anything but build the 'one law for one...' argument.
I guess they believed the PTSD story. If he served in Iraq I would be sympathetic too.

Edited by s2art on Thursday 15th May 13:48
I'd be sympathetic too. Whilst carefully taking his gun off him. For good.

NobleGuy

Original Poster:

7,133 posts

246 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
Wondered if anyone else would see the irony of the mitigating circumstances.

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
Even Nick Freeman couldn't think of that one??????

dvd

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
The police dealt with him and he went to court. What a court does is not within there control.

From experience within my force I was supprised to see him not dealt with for perverting. Based on his dishonesty in the matter I would expect his job to be gone. Without full knowing Circs of his PTSD its difficult to judge but he I would hope no longer has a gun or will get one back. If the PTSD is genuine I hope he is looked after.

Stories like this do make it look one rule etc except the police did not put it under the carpet and the defence he used would be open to anyone with similar background. However he has still been convicted of speeding its the efforts made that appear to have been excused. Knowing someone who had PTSD its bloody awful and changed him a Lot.

MilnerR

8,273 posts

289 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
The police dealt with him and he went to court. What a court does is not within there control.

From experience within my force I was supprised to see him not dealt with for perverting. Based on his dishonesty in the matter I would expect his job to be gone. Without full knowing Circs of his PTSD its difficult to judge but he I would hope no longer has a gun or will get one back. If the PTSD is genuine I hope he is looked after.

Stories like this do make it look one rule etc except the police did not put it under the carpet and the defence he used would be open to anyone with similar background. However he has still been convicted of speeding its the efforts made that appear to have been excused. Knowing someone who had PTSD its bloody awful and changed him a Lot.
Very true, what is the situation regarding mens rea in relation to PCofJ? I suppose if you were coerced or forced to do it you would get away with it, I guess if you were unable to judge if your actions were wrong you would also have a defense. Although if a trained copper had lost the ability to tell right from wrong then he should have been kicked out of the force, or promoted, whichever's cheapest.....

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
MilnerR said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
The police dealt with him and he went to court. What a court does is not within there control.

From experience within my force I was supprised to see him not dealt with for perverting. Based on his dishonesty in the matter I would expect his job to be gone. Without full knowing Circs of his PTSD its difficult to judge but he I would hope no longer has a gun or will get one back. If the PTSD is genuine I hope he is looked after.

Stories like this do make it look one rule etc except the police did not put it under the carpet and the defence he used would be open to anyone with similar background. However he has still been convicted of speeding its the efforts made that appear to have been excused. Knowing someone who had PTSD its bloody awful and changed him a Lot.
Very true, what is the situation regarding mens rea in relation to PCofJ? I suppose if you were coerced or forced to do it you would get away with it, I guess if you were unable to judge if your actions were wrong you would also have a defense. Although if a trained copper had lost the ability to tell right from wrong then he should have been kicked out of the force, or promoted, whichever's cheapest.....
If an officer does it now days( not always I knew a DS who was convicted of it) loses there job. In fact even if they are dishonest but no perverting shown in a court case they will most likely lose their job. However PTSD makes it difficult. Its a factor outside their control so it may and in this case has impacted upon courses of action. PTSD is a treatable recognised condition that they could not sack you for although you could get pensioned out. As I said knew an officer who was fine then it hit him. Screwed him up big time.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
89 in a 70 wouldnt even see court for a MOP would it? Let alone be a ban.

Chrispy Porker

17,763 posts

259 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
He won't get a medical unless the condition is 'permanent'.
ie 'For ever'. (case stated)

hugoagogo

23,438 posts

264 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
89 in a 70 wouldnt even see court for a MOP would it? Let alone be a ban.
no, but perverting the course of justice would, which is the pointwink

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
89 in a 70 wouldnt even see court for a MOP would it? Let alone be a ban.
I think it was the story he invented that got him into court...

Chrispy Porker

17,763 posts

259 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
I don't see how he invented a chase 'to escape prosecution' and was prosecuted.

Surely he tried to escape prosecution, but did not succeed.

It's not a shock that he was not banned. Few would be for 89 in a 70.

I would be surprised if there were not further repercussions though.

Edited by Chrispy Porker on Thursday 15th May 16:38

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
I don't see how he invented a chase 'to escape prosecution' and was prosecuted.

Surely he tried to escape prosecution, but did not succeed.

It's not a shock that he was not banned. Few would be for 89 in a 70.

I would be surprised if there were not further repercussions though.

Edited by Chrispy Porker on Thursday 15th May 16:38
I think the thought behind the post is that if a MoP had tried to tell a porky similar to this to attempt to evade a speeding fine they may well have been charged with PCJ? Which doesn't appear to have happened here...

hugoagogo

23,438 posts

264 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
I don't see how he invented a chase 'to escape prosecution' and was prosecuted.

Surely he tried to escape prosecution, but did not succeed.
he invented the chase 'to escape the prosecution'

like if i bought a gun to kill gordon brown, even if i was caught walking up downing street with it and didn't kill him, that's still why i bought it

Edited by hugoagogo on Thursday 15th May 16:54

Jasandjules

72,695 posts

260 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
Is it just me or will there be a pension off on grounds on ill-health..

Can't believe he avoided a PCJ.

Chrisgr31

14,300 posts

286 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
To be honest it just shows what the impact of the current fixation with speed is having.

Yes he was speeding but of course could see that he would potentially be investigated and presumably subject to investigation for the neinous crime of exceeding an arbitray speed limit. He therefore sought to avoid that, and then found himself in even more trouble.

I would expect other officers have been untruthful when cuaght speeding and have got away with it. Others are probably facing similar investigations.

Its garbage and is already brought about by the false mantra about speeding.

SplatSpeed

7,491 posts

282 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
Hooli said:
well thats him out of a job then. if PTSD has left him irrational there is no way he should be a firearms officer.
you would think

DPX

1,027 posts

231 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
like if i bought a gun to kill gordon brown, even if i was caught walking up downing street with it and didn't kill him, that's still why i bought it

don't bother he has lots of little holes in his feet by himself.