'Epileptic' speeding case dropped
'Epileptic' speeding case dropped
Author
Discussion

roosevelt

Original Poster:

396 posts

292 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
Full Story; http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/cumbria/7407953...

"He said his foot hit the accelerator when he turned to check on his wife.."

Explain that...!

Soton Pug

374 posts

226 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
This was covered a couple of weeks ago, opened a right old can of worms....

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
Soton Pug said:
This was covered a couple of weeks ago, opened a right old can of worms....
Why ?

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Soton Pug said:
This was covered a couple of weeks ago, opened a right old can of worms....
Why ?
Probably because of the fact that the chap accepted that he was speeding, yet claimed he should be exempt because he was speeding whilst tending to his fitting wife.

Under pressure from the press and the news that Nick Freeman would be defending (for free), Cumbria Police wilted and let the chap off.

The proper procedure, in my opinion, would be for the case to be heard and if the Magistrates felt sympathetic to his mitigation, he could have been given a discharge at that point.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
vonhosen said:
Soton Pug said:
This was covered a couple of weeks ago, opened a right old can of worms....
Why ?
Probably because of the fact that the chap accepted that he was speeding, yet claimed he should be exempt because he was speeding whilst tending to his fitting wife.

Under pressure from the press and the news that Nick Freeman would be defending (for free), Cumbria Police wilted and let the chap off.

The proper procedure, in my opinion, would be for the case to be heard and if the Magistrates felt sympathetic to his mitigation, he could have been given a discharge at that point.
Alternatively the proper procedure would have been (as it was not too long ago) for the Police to recognise that a minor technical transgression occured due to a medical event and it would not be in the public interest to prosecute.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
s2art said:
10 Pence Short said:
vonhosen said:
Soton Pug said:
This was covered a couple of weeks ago, opened a right old can of worms....
Why ?
Probably because of the fact that the chap accepted that he was speeding, yet claimed he should be exempt because he was speeding whilst tending to his fitting wife.

Under pressure from the press and the news that Nick Freeman would be defending (for free), Cumbria Police wilted and let the chap off.

The proper procedure, in my opinion, would be for the case to be heard and if the Magistrates felt sympathetic to his mitigation, he could have been given a discharge at that point.
Alternatively the proper procedure would have been (as it was not too long ago) for the Police to recognise that a minor technical transgression occured due to a medical event and it would not be in the public interest to prosecute.
35mph in a residential limit is a fair target to police. Especially if it's being done whilst the driver is distracted. Or to put it another way, if you'd been another driver caught that day, but you hadn't been distracted by a passenger, you'd now have 3 points on your licence and be £60 lighter. Would you feel it was fair that another driver got off for the same offence and you didn't?

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
s2art said:
10 Pence Short said:
vonhosen said:
Soton Pug said:
This was covered a couple of weeks ago, opened a right old can of worms....
Why ?
Probably because of the fact that the chap accepted that he was speeding, yet claimed he should be exempt because he was speeding whilst tending to his fitting wife.

Under pressure from the press and the news that Nick Freeman would be defending (for free), Cumbria Police wilted and let the chap off.

The proper procedure, in my opinion, would be for the case to be heard and if the Magistrates felt sympathetic to his mitigation, he could have been given a discharge at that point.
Alternatively the proper procedure would have been (as it was not too long ago) for the Police to recognise that a minor technical transgression occured due to a medical event and it would not be in the public interest to prosecute.
Allegedly! - Streaky

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
s2art said:
10 Pence Short said:
vonhosen said:
Soton Pug said:
This was covered a couple of weeks ago, opened a right old can of worms....
Why ?
Probably because of the fact that the chap accepted that he was speeding, yet claimed he should be exempt because he was speeding whilst tending to his fitting wife.

Under pressure from the press and the news that Nick Freeman would be defending (for free), Cumbria Police wilted and let the chap off.

The proper procedure, in my opinion, would be for the case to be heard and if the Magistrates felt sympathetic to his mitigation, he could have been given a discharge at that point.
Alternatively the proper procedure would have been (as it was not too long ago) for the Police to recognise that a minor technical transgression occured due to a medical event and it would not be in the public interest to prosecute.
35mph in a residential limit is a fair target to police. Especially if it's being done whilst the driver is distracted. Or to put it another way, if you'd been another driver caught that day, but you hadn't been distracted by a passenger, you'd now have 3 points on your licence and be £60 lighter. Would you feel it was fair that another driver got off for the same offence and you didn't?
I would think that if my wife or close relative had a grand mal siezure next to me that I might be a tad distracted too. So yes, I would feel it fair.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
How strange that you feel it safer to speed whilst distracted by a fitting relative in the back seat, than with your full concentration on the road.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
How strange that you feel it safer to speed whilst distracted by a fitting relative in the back seat, than with your full concentration on the road.
How strange that you could conclude that. In fact, please indicate where that is stated or implied by anything I posted.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
s2art said:
10 Pence Short said:
vonhosen said:
Soton Pug said:
This was covered a couple of weeks ago, opened a right old can of worms....
Why ?
Probably because of the fact that the chap accepted that he was speeding, yet claimed he should be exempt because he was speeding whilst tending to his fitting wife.

Under pressure from the press and the news that Nick Freeman would be defending (for free), Cumbria Police wilted and let the chap off.

The proper procedure, in my opinion, would be for the case to be heard and if the Magistrates felt sympathetic to his mitigation, he could have been given a discharge at that point.
Alternatively the proper procedure would have been (as it was not too long ago) for the Police to recognise that a minor technical transgression occured due to a medical event and it would not be in the public interest to prosecute.
Yep, the CPS have viewed that in this particular case it was not in the public interest to proceed. It doesn't mean that in future all claims of 'I was speeding inadvertently because of an epileptic passenger' or 'I was only doing 35' will result in the same outcome. They aren't bound by the decision in this individual case

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
s2art said:
10 Pence Short said:
s2art said:
10 Pence Short said:
vonhosen said:
Soton Pug said:
This was covered a couple of weeks ago, opened a right old can of worms....
Why ?
Probably because of the fact that the chap accepted that he was speeding, yet claimed he should be exempt because he was speeding whilst tending to his fitting wife.

Under pressure from the press and the news that Nick Freeman would be defending (for free), Cumbria Police wilted and let the chap off.

The proper procedure, in my opinion, would be for the case to be heard and if the Magistrates felt sympathetic to his mitigation, he could have been given a discharge at that point.
Alternatively the proper procedure would have been (as it was not too long ago) for the Police to recognise that a minor technical transgression occured due to a medical event and it would not be in the public interest to prosecute.
35mph in a residential limit is a fair target to police. Especially if it's being done whilst the driver is distracted. Or to put it another way, if you'd been another driver caught that day, but you hadn't been distracted by a passenger, you'd now have 3 points on your licence and be £60 lighter. Would you feel it was fair that another driver got off for the same offence and you didn't?
I would think that if my wife or close relative had a grand mal siezure next to me that I might be a tad distracted too. So yes, I would feel it fair.
I'd be slowing down not speeding up, perhaps he was slowing when he was caught.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
s2art said:
10 Pence Short said:
How strange that you feel it safer to speed whilst distracted by a fitting relative in the back seat, than with your full concentration on the road.
How strange that you could conclude that. In fact, please indicate where that is stated or implied by anything I posted.
So which are you saying?

That it is wrong for people who're doing 35 in a 30 limit to be prosecuted, full stop? Or that it is wrong for people looking after fitting relatives in the back seat whilst doing 35mph in a 30 limit to be prosecuted?

Edited by 10 Pence Short on Monday 19th May 16:18

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
s2art said:
10 Pence Short said:
vonhosen said:
Soton Pug said:
This was covered a couple of weeks ago, opened a right old can of worms....
Why ?
Probably because of the fact that the chap accepted that he was speeding, yet claimed he should be exempt because he was speeding whilst tending to his fitting wife.

Under pressure from the press and the news that Nick Freeman would be defending (for free), Cumbria Police wilted and let the chap off.

The proper procedure, in my opinion, would be for the case to be heard and if the Magistrates felt sympathetic to his mitigation, he could have been given a discharge at that point.
Alternatively the proper procedure would have been (as it was not too long ago) for the Police to recognise that a minor technical transgression occured due to a medical event and it would not be in the public interest to prosecute.
Yep, the CPS have viewed that in this particular case it was not in the public interest to proceed. It doesn't mean that in future all claims of 'I was speeding inadvertently because of an epileptic passenger' or 'I was only doing 35' will result in the same outcome. They aren't bound by the decision in this individual case
Yes, common sense was applied. My beef is that these days it has to go all the way to the CPS, with all the cost and red tape involved, when we used to be able to let Plod use his common sense.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
s2art said:
10 Pence Short said:
How strange that you feel it safer to speed whilst distracted by a fitting relative in the back seat, than with your full concentration on the road.
How strange that you could conclude that. In fact, please indicate where that is stated or implied by anything I posted.
So which are you saying?

That it is wrong for people who're doing 35 in a 30 limit to be prosecuted, full stop? Or that it is wrong for people looking after fitting relatives in the back seat whilst doing 35mph in a 30 limit to be prosecuted?

Edited by 10 Pence Short on Monday 19th May 16:18
Gordon Bennet! If someone makes a minor technical transgression due to a perfectly normal human response to a major distraction then why is it the public interest to prosecute? What gain is there to society in punishing the person?

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
The Police used to do the prosecuting bit when it was required too.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
s2art said:
Gordon Bennet! If someone makes a minor technical transgression due to a perfectly normal human response to a major distraction then why is it the public interest to prosecute? What gain is there to society in punishing the person?
So why not just answer the question?

If two people in two identical cars got caught at the same place committing the same offence, which one should be let off?

The one tending to a back seat passenger, or the one paying attention to what they're doing?

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
s2art said:
Gordon Bennet! If someone makes a minor technical transgression due to a perfectly normal human response to a major distraction then why is it the public interest to prosecute? What gain is there to society in punishing the person?
So why not just answer the question?

If two people in two identical cars got caught at the same place committing the same offence, which one should be let off?

The one tending to a back seat passenger, or the one paying attention to what they're doing?
Are you having problems in comprehension? Lets make it evem more extreme. Say a wasp stung someone while they were driving, causing him to swerve (or even stab the accelerator, at 30 mph most cars would speed up 5mph ), would it be in the public interest to prosecute?

Jules360

1,949 posts

233 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
So you can be prosecuted for using a mobile phone at 10 mph, but exceeding the limit under these conditions is acceptable ?? He should have stopped the car. DWDCaA if you ask me.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
Jules360 said:
So you can be prosecuted for using a mobile phone at 10 mph, but exceeding the limit under these conditions is acceptable ?? He should have stopped the car. DWDCaA if you ask me.
Using a phone is a deliberate act, having your attention distracted due to someone having a major medical event next to you isnt.