Small Claims Court Advice please...
Small Claims Court Advice please...
Author
Discussion

masterbaiter

Original Poster:

11 posts

238 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
Regretfully I am going to have to take a former friend to court as he has failed to return some goods to me. All gone a bit tits up and the friendship is completely over now.

I need some advice as to whether I can get some written evidence heard. I know this is generally frowned upon by the judge but my witness literally is several hundred miles away and it would not be cost effective to get him to court in person. He is fully prepared to make himself available to the court by telephone to verify his statement and to have any questions asked by the plaintiff or judge.

His evidence is not absolutely vital but will make the case a lot more telling for me. If anyone could let me know the score it would be appreciated.

I wouldn't mind a few minutes of someone legals time if they would be happy to spare it too. Would need to say they don't mind being contacted ijn a reply and i will mail them vai my real id as you may appreciate for reasons of sensitivity i don't want to say too much on here

Cheers all.

Jasandjules

72,695 posts

260 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
A sworn affidavit? Is that what you have in mind? Any solicitor should be able to do it?!?!

masterbaiter

Original Poster:

11 posts

238 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
No not really what I had in mind (and kind of defeats the idea of small claims/costs etc) this would just be aa written statement but wondering if the court would admit as evidence providing my witness was available on the end of the phone.

Jasandjules

72,695 posts

260 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
Not really. The court won't be looking to make a phone call IMHO.

A statement at the bottom of the letter which says "the above facts are true to the best of my knowledge and belief" may help however.


r129sl

9,518 posts

234 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Telephone is a non-starter. The courts are not set up for this and besides, it could be anyone on the end of the line. They make all sorts of noises about video conferences but it's not on the cards for a small claims hearing.

A signed witness statement verified by a statement of truth is admissible as hearsay evidence notwithstanding the maker of the statement is not called to speak to it. The weight the judge attaches to the statement depends upon--among many other things--the reasons why the maker of the statement cannot come. If the maker of the statement is hundreds of miles away, that is not a bad reason, but it is not the best, either: witness expenses are available, after all.