North Wales Police Again
Author
Discussion

welsh blackbird

Original Poster:

692 posts

275 months

Monday 19th May 2008
quotequote all
http://www.dailypost.co.uk/news/north-wales-news/2...

Ex-Cop took on North Wales Police over speeding fine
May 19 2008 by Steve Bagnall, Daily Post


Bob Mcmillan

A FORMER police advanced motorcycle instructor who fought for 13 months to prove his innocence over a speeding charge has had his case thrown out.

North Wales Police are now investigating a complaint by furious Bob McMillan after he claimed the case should never have gone to court.

Mr McMillan, who was also a former general manager of Honda UK Motorcycle, is sure he and two friends were not over the speed limit when they were stopped on the A4212 in April last year.

The 60-year-old has reported North Wales Police to the Independents Police Complaints Commission.

It took Mr McMillan, also a former police advanced car driver with Staffordshire Constabulary, over a year of battling before the CPS threw the case out.

But he insists he and his two friends were innocent of the speeding charge when they were stopped near Fron Goch between Bala and Trawsfynydd.

Mr McMillan and one of his friends decided to battle the case, but the other decided to take the penalty points fearing a long legal battle. The IPCC have referred the case back to NWP.

Mr McMillan, who has also operated speed trap equipment himself, claimed he was worried about the police evidence used against him and he also obtained video footage taken by the police helicopter used to charge him.

It was claimed the three had been speeding as a convoy at about 83mph.

Mr McMillan, who also won a Prince Michael Award for a motorbike safety course, claimed the video had been edited, was focused on another unknown sole rider travelling in the opposite direction, and at no point showed the three riders speeding.

Mr McMillan believes the unknown motorcyclist travelling in the opposite direction was speeding and was clocked by a speed trap (Vascar) officer and video operator while in the helicopter.

He believes the decision to give the three motorbikes that speed – 83mph – was made to boost numbers caught speeding.

Mr McMillan, who moved from Harlech to near Oswestry, said: “I want to make it clear that this is not an anti-police rant, having spent 10 years as a patrol officer and being proud of that time.

“I have denied this speeding allegation from the time that I was stopped.”

He and his wife have dedicated themselves to proving the allegation false.

Mr McMillan added: “We have spent hundreds and hundreds of hours and hundreds of pounds to prove this.

“It was not the £60 fine or three points on the licence but the principle.”

“I was defending myself because I had nothing to hide and there is no possibility that any of the points gained would make me lose my licence.

A NWP spokeswoman confirmed they were investigating a formal complaint

She said: “North Wales Police in consultation with the Crown Prosecution Service have decided to discontinue speeding offence cases which were due to be heard at Dolgellau Magistrates Court on June 10.

“The cases involved the use of speed detection equipment carried on board the force helicopter.

“The decision to discontinue proceedings is based purely on administrative matters that were identified that were not completed satisfactorily.

“North Wales Police emphasise that this decision has nothing to do with the tactics used involving use of the helicopter, and the helicopter will in future still be a tactical option in operational policing matters.”

An IPCC spokesman said: “As in cases like these we have forwarded the case to North Wales Police – that was on March 10.

“It is up to them to record the complaint and investigate themselves.

“If Mr McMillan is unhappy with the outcome he can appeal to ourselves.”




Jasandjules

72,695 posts

260 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
We can but hope that the cash cow will soon be sent to the abbatoir.

EU_Foreigner

2,838 posts

257 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
What a waste of resources again. Using an expensive helicoptor to check for speeding? More lives would be saved using it to ferry ill patients to hospital.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
EU_Foreigner said:
What a waste of resources again. Using an expensive helicoptor to check for speeding? More lives would be saved using it to ferry ill patients to hospital.
It is a disgrace that Police forces are using tax funded helicopters for these kind of operations, yet Air Ambulances are paid for by charity and struggle to even survive.

Jasandjules

72,695 posts

260 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
EU_Foreigner said:
What a waste of resources again. Using an expensive helicoptor to check for speeding? More lives would be saved using it to ferry ill patients to hospital.
Rubbish... If you drive at just 3mph over a speed limit, 2 children, a fluffy rabbit and a chincilla immediately die. biggrin

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
EU_Foreigner said:
What a waste of resources again. Using an expensive helicoptor to check for speeding? More lives would be saved using it to ferry ill patients to hospital.
It is a disgrace that Police forces are using tax funded helicopters for these kind of operations, yet Air Ambulances are paid for by charity and struggle to even survive.
The NHS have decided that money from their (not unsubstantial) budget is better spent elsewhere & the Police have decided that helicopters offer value for money from their budget.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
10 Pence Short said:
EU_Foreigner said:
What a waste of resources again. Using an expensive helicoptor to check for speeding? More lives would be saved using it to ferry ill patients to hospital.
It is a disgrace that Police forces are using tax funded helicopters for these kind of operations, yet Air Ambulances are paid for by charity and struggle to even survive.
The NHS have decided that money from their (not unsubstantial) budget is better spent elsewhere & the Police have decided that helicopters offer value for money from their budget.
I do understand your defence of your employers, and the reasoniing behind it.

But, as a human being, do you honestly believe it is morally acceptable that a Police helicopter is used for speed enforcement, paid for by the tax payer, when Air Ambulances are not paid for by the tax payer?

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
vonhosen said:
10 Pence Short said:
EU_Foreigner said:
What a waste of resources again. Using an expensive helicoptor to check for speeding? More lives would be saved using it to ferry ill patients to hospital.
It is a disgrace that Police forces are using tax funded helicopters for these kind of operations, yet Air Ambulances are paid for by charity and struggle to even survive.
The NHS have decided that money from their (not unsubstantial) budget is better spent elsewhere & the Police have decided that helicopters offer value for money from their budget.
I do understand your defence of your employers, and the reasoniing behind it.

But, as a human being, do you honestly believe it is morally acceptable that a Police helicopter is used for speed enforcement, paid for by the tax payer, when Air Ambulances are not paid for by the tax payer?
The NHS have to manage their budget & it's a huge budget. If the helicopter offers value for money for them within it then they'll spend on it, if it doesn't they won't.
As far as the Police are concerned helicopters are a resource that offers value for money IMHO. If it's in the air it's use should be prioritised, if officers on the ground need it's support & it isn't doing something more important it should be used. If it isn't currently engaged/assigned in anything else it should use it's time pro-actively. I've never heard of ours being used for targeted speed enforcement, but if there's nothing more important at that particular time I don't care if it is used to assist in it.
The reality though is that it will not be used for much if any speed enforcement because it's needed for more important things.

Edited by vonhosen on Tuesday 20th May 09:54

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
vonhosen said:
10 Pence Short said:
EU_Foreigner said:
What a waste of resources again. Using an expensive helicoptor to check for speeding? More lives would be saved using it to ferry ill patients to hospital.
It is a disgrace that Police forces are using tax funded helicopters for these kind of operations, yet Air Ambulances are paid for by charity and struggle to even survive.
The NHS have decided that money from their (not unsubstantial) budget is better spent elsewhere & the Police have decided that helicopters offer value for money from their budget.
I do understand your defence of your employers, and the reasoniing behind it.

But, as a human being, do you honestly believe it is morally acceptable that a Police helicopter is used for speed enforcement, paid for by the tax payer, when Air Ambulances are not paid for by the tax payer?
Hmmm asking Von for a personal view...interesting....scratchchin

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
10 Pence Short said:
vonhosen said:
10 Pence Short said:
EU_Foreigner said:
What a waste of resources again. Using an expensive helicoptor to check for speeding? More lives would be saved using it to ferry ill patients to hospital.
It is a disgrace that Police forces are using tax funded helicopters for these kind of operations, yet Air Ambulances are paid for by charity and struggle to even survive.
The NHS have decided that money from their (not unsubstantial) budget is better spent elsewhere & the Police have decided that helicopters offer value for money from their budget.
I do understand your defence of your employers, and the reasoniing behind it.

But, as a human being, do you honestly believe it is morally acceptable that a Police helicopter is used for speed enforcement, paid for by the tax payer, when Air Ambulances are not paid for by the tax payer?
The NHS have to manage their budget & it's a huge budget. If the helicopter offers value for money for them within it then they'll spend on it, if it doesn't they won't.
As far as the Police are concerned helicopters are a resource that offers value for money IMHO. If it's in the air it's use should be prioritised, if officers on the ground need it's support & it isn't doing something more important it should be used. If it isn't currently engaged/assigned in anything else it should use it's time pro-actively.
Like being sat on the ground, ready to go to the right place, rather than burning up £4000 an hour of taxpayers money supporting North Wales police's anti-speed politics?

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
The NHS have to manage their budget & it's a huge budget. If the helicopter offers value for money for them within it then they'll spend on it, if it doesn't they won't.
As far as the Police are concerned helicopters are a resource that offers value for money IMHO. If it's in the air it's use should be prioritised, if officers on the ground need it's support & it isn't doing something more important it should be used. If it isn't currently engaged/assigned in anything else it should use it's time pro-actively. I've never heard of ours being used for targeted speed enforcement, but if there's nothing more important at that particular time I don't care if it is used to assist in it.
The reality though is that it will not be used for much if any speed enforcement because it's needed for more important things.
Von, that isn't an opinion, it's an explanation. One your employers would be proud of.

I asked for your opinion.

Do you think it is morally acceptable that a helicopter is used to catch people speeding and is paid for by the state when Air Ambulances are not?

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
10 Pence Short said:
vonhosen said:
The NHS have to manage their budget & it's a huge budget. If the helicopter offers value for money for them within it then they'll spend on it, if it doesn't they won't.
As far as the Police are concerned helicopters are a resource that offers value for money IMHO. If it's in the air it's use should be prioritised, if officers on the ground need it's support & it isn't doing something more important it should be used. If it isn't currently engaged/assigned in anything else it should use it's time pro-actively. I've never heard of ours being used for targeted speed enforcement, but if there's nothing more important at that particular time I don't care if it is used to assist in it.
The reality though is that it will not be used for much if any speed enforcement because it's needed for more important things.
Von, that isn't an opinion, it's an explanation. One your employers would be proud of.

I asked for your opinion.

Do you think it is morally acceptable that a helicopter is used to catch people speeding and is paid for by the state when Air Ambulances are not?
I've said I don't have a problem morally with it in light of the above.

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
You're probably in a very small minority, then.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
vonhosen said:
10 Pence Short said:
vonhosen said:
10 Pence Short said:
EU_Foreigner said:
What a waste of resources again. Using an expensive helicoptor to check for speeding? More lives would be saved using it to ferry ill patients to hospital.
It is a disgrace that Police forces are using tax funded helicopters for these kind of operations, yet Air Ambulances are paid for by charity and struggle to even survive.
The NHS have decided that money from their (not unsubstantial) budget is better spent elsewhere & the Police have decided that helicopters offer value for money from their budget.
I do understand your defence of your employers, and the reasoniing behind it.

But, as a human being, do you honestly believe it is morally acceptable that a Police helicopter is used for speed enforcement, paid for by the tax payer, when Air Ambulances are not paid for by the tax payer?
The NHS have to manage their budget & it's a huge budget. If the helicopter offers value for money for them within it then they'll spend on it, if it doesn't they won't.
As far as the Police are concerned helicopters are a resource that offers value for money IMHO. If it's in the air it's use should be prioritised, if officers on the ground need it's support & it isn't doing something more important it should be used. If it isn't currently engaged/assigned in anything else it should use it's time pro-actively.
Like being sat on the ground, ready to go to the right place, rather than burning up £4000 an hour of taxpayers money supporting North Wales police's anti-speed politics?
I've never seen/heard of a helicopter taking with the sole express purpose of performing speed enforcement. If it's in the air it's already burning fuel & in that case it's better that it's doing something rather than nothing when doing so.

Mr POD

5,153 posts

223 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
No mention of racism then :

Bob McMillan is clearly not Welsh, and living in Harlech is an easy target for the Anti-English Police Force in North Wales.

My Mother (a retired civil servant) was done for speeding, on her way to a mothers union meeting. Despite speaking to the officers in Welsh they knew her to be of English extract and threw the book at her. (that's her excuse anyhow)

Jules360

1,949 posts

233 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
10 Pence Short said:
EU_Foreigner said:
What a waste of resources again. Using an expensive helicoptor to check for speeding? More lives would be saved using it to ferry ill patients to hospital.
It is a disgrace that Police forces are using tax funded helicopters for these kind of operations, yet Air Ambulances are paid for by charity and struggle to even survive.
The NHS have decided that money from their (not unsubstantial) budget is better spent elsewhere & the Police have decided that helicopters offer value for money from their budget.
Value for money ? Do you mean profitable? All is now clear ....

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
Jules360 said:
vonhosen said:
10 Pence Short said:
EU_Foreigner said:
What a waste of resources again. Using an expensive helicoptor to check for speeding? More lives would be saved using it to ferry ill patients to hospital.
It is a disgrace that Police forces are using tax funded helicopters for these kind of operations, yet Air Ambulances are paid for by charity and struggle to even survive.
The NHS have decided that money from their (not unsubstantial) budget is better spent elsewhere & the Police have decided that helicopters offer value for money from their budget.
Value for money ? Do you mean profitable? All is now clear ....
Would the number of ambulances they would have to lose/swap in order to fund the helicopter, result in a net gain or loss in respect of service provided ?
The answer I suspect is that ambulance services have looked at that & decided that they are better off with more ambulances & a charitable helicopter, than funding a helicopter from their budget & sacrificing those ambulances.

jaf01uk

1,943 posts

227 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
JustinP1 said:
vonhosen said:
10 Pence Short said:
vonhosen said:
10 Pence Short said:
EU_Foreigner said:
What a waste of resources again. Using an expensive helicoptor to check for speeding? More lives would be saved using it to ferry ill patients to hospital.
It is a disgrace that Police forces are using tax funded helicopters for these kind of operations, yet Air Ambulances are paid for by charity and struggle to even survive.
The NHS have decided that money from their (not unsubstantial) budget is better spent elsewhere & the Police have decided that helicopters offer value for money from their budget.
I do understand your defence of your employers, and the reasoniing behind it.

But, as a human being, do you honestly believe it is morally acceptable that a Police helicopter is used for speed enforcement, paid for by the tax payer, when Air Ambulances are not paid for by the tax payer?
The NHS have to manage their budget & it's a huge budget. If the helicopter offers value for money for them within it then they'll spend on it, if it doesn't they won't.
As far as the Police are concerned helicopters are a resource that offers value for money IMHO. If it's in the air it's use should be prioritised, if officers on the ground need it's support & it isn't doing something more important it should be used. If it isn't currently engaged/assigned in anything else it should use it's time pro-actively.
Like being sat on the ground, ready to go to the right place, rather than burning up £4000 an hour of taxpayers money supporting North Wales police's anti-speed politics?
I've never seen/heard of a helicopter taking with the sole express purpose of performing speed enforcement. If it's in the air it's already burning fuel & in that case it's better that it's doing something rather than nothing when doing so.
Whoooosh! straight over the head, you must be a whizz at parties with your installed views on everything, sorry but I have been restraining myself for far too long to these politically correct benign statements, are you not capable of thinking for yourself? You ARE allowed a personal point of view and as you have a disclaimer on your profile why don't you express it, not just on this topic.
And by the way the helicopters are operated by ambulance services who although are part of the NHS as a whole have a miniscule budget compared to hospitals, Scotland has the only government funded air ambulance service in europe and Wales being so intent on their war on the motorist wouldn't surprise me in the slightest if they tasked it with doin speed checks, but if they are then they might want to train the guys operating the gear how it works! rolleyes
Gary

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Would the number of ambulances they would have to lose/swap in order to fund the helicopter, result in a net gain or loss in respect of service provided ?
The answer I suspect is that ambulance services have looked at that & decided that they are better off with more ambulances & a charitable helicopter, than funding a helicopter from their budget & sacrificing those ambulances.
I'm sure if you asked people on the street would they prefer to pay for a force helicopter to catch speeding motorists and provide footage for Police Camera Action! or have X number of extra Police on the street, they'd prefer the extra Police. Much in the same way as if you asked them would they prefer their tax to be spent on NHS middle managers, or an Air Ambulance, they would have a clear answer.

Jules360

1,949 posts

233 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Jules360 said:
vonhosen said:
10 Pence Short said:
EU_Foreigner said:
What a waste of resources again. Using an expensive helicoptor to check for speeding? More lives would be saved using it to ferry ill patients to hospital.
It is a disgrace that Police forces are using tax funded helicopters for these kind of operations, yet Air Ambulances are paid for by charity and struggle to even survive.
The NHS have decided that money from their (not unsubstantial) budget is better spent elsewhere & the Police have decided that helicopters offer value for money from their budget.
Value for money ? Do you mean profitable? All is now clear ....
Would the number of ambulances they would have to lose/swap in order to fund the helicopter, result in a net gain or loss in respect of service provided ?
The answer I suspect is that ambulance services have looked at that & decided that they are better off with more ambulances & a charitable helicopter, than funding a helicopter from their budget & sacrificing those ambulances.
I would therefore suggest that the Police budget is too high in comparison and that the money should be given to the NHS. Since its a value for money exercise, what price on a life saved by swift dispatch to hospital?