New Driver Act Question
Author
Discussion

Slinky

Original Poster:

15,704 posts

280 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
Your advice please folks:

Scenario is this, B-i-L (still within 2 year NDA period at present) was popped for speeding shortly after insuring first car, attended court and was awarded 5 points for his transgression.

Several months later, B-i-L crashes a car, writing it off and closing a road due to obstruction and the need for attendance from all 3 blue light services.. B-i-L cautioned on scene for DWDCA. Car recovered and examined, car found to have defects in relation to steering and brakes.

Summons now received for car defects, court date looming..

Question: Sentencing guidelines (and discussions with Ma slinky) dictate a potential ban, however, as B-i-L is still within 2 year probationary period, the DVLA will revoke the license at 6 points. If B-i-L is handed a "totting" ban by the courts does the DVLA license revocation also occur?

Everything is incontestable in terms of guilt and B-i-L is aware of the bigger issues, but is obviously concerned over how long he is going to be away from driving..

Cheers in advance,

slinky


peterguk V6 KWK

2,622 posts

248 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
Slinky said:
B-i-L popped for speeding shortly after insuring first car, ......awarded 5 points for his transgression.

Several months later, B-i-L crashes a car, writing it off and closing a road due to obstruction

the need for attendance from all 3 blue light services.......B-i-L cautioned on scene for DWDCA.

Car recovered and examined, car found to have defects in relation to steering and brakes.

Summons now received for car defects, court date looming..



but is obviously concerned over how long he is going to be away from driving..
Hopefully, long enough to grasp a real understanding of this driving lark..

HTH

Slinky

Original Poster:

15,704 posts

280 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
peterguk V6 KWK said:
Slinky said:
B-i-L popped for speeding shortly after insuring first car, ......awarded 5 points for his transgression.

Several months later, B-i-L crashes a car, writing it off and closing a road due to obstruction

the need for attendance from all 3 blue light services.......B-i-L cautioned on scene for DWDCA.

Car recovered and examined, car found to have defects in relation to steering and brakes.

Summons now received for car defects, court date looming..



but is obviously concerned over how long he is going to be away from driving..
Hopefully, long enough to grasp a real understanding of this driving lark..

HTH
Yes, that bit has already been covered, thanks for your assistance.. Now, anyone got any thoughts on my question?

Edited by Slinky on Tuesday 20th May 22:38

The Black Duke

1,642 posts

224 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
If your points do not tot up to 12 points after the court has dealt with you and you are not given a ban then you will be off the road for however long it will take you to pass your tests again. In theory if you could get a theory on the Monday and a test on the Tuesday you could be back driving on the Tuesday.
Hope that helps.

^Slider^

2,874 posts

280 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
My view is that when he hits 6 points then license revoked by DVLA. However should a ban occur for totting up then both parts come into play so he will be disqualified for a year as well as having to retake his test due to revokation as withn the 2 year period.

Slinky

Original Poster:

15,704 posts

280 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Thanks slider, that was my suspicion but searching the net seemed fruitless last night...

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Slider

Muse mode on......

He is going to Court with 5 points on his Licence.

If he is disqualified points are wiped out for offences he will be up for. So still only 5 points on Licence

See Section 44 (1) RT Offenders Act 1988 - either disqualified or points awarded, not a combination of both?.

Is it not the case he cannot be awarded points for one of the offences if they invoke discretionary disqualification on any of the others (Martin v DPP 2000 and Scots case (Ahmed v Mcleod 2000 - due care case, disqualified until test passed which resulted in they couldn't award points on a No insurance charge).

My feelings are that they will not disqualify but load the points to invoke the New Driver revocation.

Muse off.......

Wonder if SS has any imput on this one?????

dvd


SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Slinky said:
If B-i-L is handed a "totting" ban by the courts does the DVLA license revocation also occur?
By 'totting ban', I presume you are referring to period of disqualification (minimum 6 months) following an accumulation of 12 or more points within any three year period ?

Since an effect of a disqualification is that the driver's licence is treated as though it was revoked (s.37(1) RTOA 1988), and since a totting disqualification would be imposed before a [New Driver] licence revocation, then a totter's licence cannot at the same time be revoked under the New Driver's Act.

Slinky

Original Poster:

15,704 posts

280 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
SS2. said:
Slinky said:
If B-i-L is handed a "totting" ban by the courts does the DVLA license revocation also occur?
By 'totting ban', I presume you are referring to period of disqualification (minimum 6 months) following an accumulation of 12 or more points within any three year period ?
yes
SS2. said:
Since an effect of a disqualification is that the driver's licence is treated as though it was revoked (s.37(1) RTOA 1988), and since a totting disqualification would be imposed before a [New Driver] licence revocation, then a totter's licence cannot at the same time be revoked under the New Driver's Act.
Understood, many thanks SS2

SplatSpeed

7,491 posts

282 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
dodgy brakes 3 pts end of lisence sorry

The Black Duke

1,642 posts

224 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
As I said then????????????????????????????

Said in plain language without the bull!!

Edited by Mr Will on Wednesday 21st May 11:27

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
The Black Duke said:
As I said then?
Maybe. But, IMO, you hadn't really answered Slinky's question..

Slinky said:
Question: If B-i-L is handed a "totting" ban by the courts does the DVLA license revocation also occur?
The Black Duke said:
If your points do not tot up to 12 points after the court has dealt with you and you are not given a ban then you will be off the road for however long it will take you to pass your tests again. In theory if you could get a theory on the Monday and a test on the Tuesday you could be back driving on the Tuesday.
And please could you remove some of the ??? from your previous post - its louses up the page width....;)

^Slider^

2,874 posts

280 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Dwight VanDriver said:
Slider

Muse mode on......

He is going to Court with 5 points on his Licence.

If he is disqualified points are wiped out for offences he will be up for. So still only 5 points on Licence

See Section 44 (1) RT Offenders Act 1988 - either disqualified or points awarded, not a combination of both?.

Is it not the case he cannot be awarded points for one of the offences if they invoke discretionary disqualification on any of the others (Martin v DPP 2000 and Scots case (Ahmed v Mcleod 2000 - due care case, disqualified until test passed which resulted in they couldn't award points on a No insurance charge).

My feelings are that they will not disqualify but load the points to invoke the New Driver revocation.

Muse off.......

Wonder if SS has any imput on this one?????

dvd
But is the revokation an administrative one by DVLA and not a court imposed ban.

I appreciate they cant Ban and give points but if he gets given 7 points taking him to 12, then the points given will add up to the disqualification.

So by the fact he has exceeded the 6 points the license will be revoked, but would turn into a TT code for a ban for totting up.

Surely they have to give the points before giving the Totting up ban thus taking him over the 6 points for new drivers?

Rather than say a ban for drink drive and 6 points for no insurance which is usually a ban and no furtehr penalty for the insurance.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
^Slider^ said:
Surely they have to give the points before giving the Totting up ban thus taking him over the 6 points for new drivers?
A totting up ban is immediate upon sentencing and is imposed by the court; a licence revocation (as you mentioned) is an administrative process and is imposed by submission of the offender's licence to the SoS and by written notice to the offender some time after the points have been awarded.

And because an effect of a disqualification is that the licence concerned is treated as being revoked, that licence cannot at the same time be revoked under the conditions of the new driver's legislation.

Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988 said:
37. Effect of order of disqualification.

(1) Where the holder of a licence is disqualified by an order of a court, the licence shall be treated as being revoked with effect from the beginning of the period of disqualification.
Road Traffic New Drivers Act 1995 said:
2. Surrender of licences.

(1) Subsection (2) applies where;

(a) a person is the holder of a licence;
(b) he is convicted of an offence involving obligatory endorsement;
(c) the penalty points to be taken into account under section 29 of the [1988 c. 53.] Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988 on that occasion number six or more;
(d) the court makes an order falling within section 44(1)(b) of that Act in respect of the offence;
(e) the person’s licence shows the date on which he became a qualified driver, or that date has been shown by other evidence in the proceedings; and
(f) it appears to the court, in the light of the order and the date so shown, that the offence was committed during the person’s probationary period.

(2) Where this subsection applies, the court must send to the Secretary of State;
(a) a notice containing the particulars required to be endorsed on the counterpart of the person's licence in accordance with the order referred to in subsection (1)(d); and

(b) on their production to the court, the person's licence and its counterpart.

^Slider^

2,874 posts

280 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Thanks for that SS2

The Black Duke

1,642 posts

224 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
SS2. said:
The Black Duke said:
As I said then?
Maybe. But, IMO, you hadn't really answered Slinky's question..

Slinky said:
Question: If B-i-L is handed a "totting" ban by the courts does the DVLA license revocation also occur?
The Black Duke said:
If your points do not tot up to 12 points after the court has dealt with you and you are not given a ban then you will be off the road for however long it will take you to pass your tests again. In theory if you could get a theory on the Monday and a test on the Tuesday you could be back driving on the Tuesday.
And please could you remove some of the ??? from your previous post - its louses up the page width....;)
Sorry about the ????

I agree with you I didn't answer the whole question completley.


Slinky

Original Poster:

15,704 posts

280 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Cheers guys, that pretty much ties up what we needed to know, thanks for your input..

slinky

Slinky

Original Poster:

15,704 posts

280 months

Thursday 12th June 2008
quotequote all
B-i-L just left court..

3 points & £135 including costs, taking him to 8 points and bringing into play the NDA..

Thanks again for your help folks..

slinky

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Thursday 12th June 2008
quotequote all
I'm sure you are aware that BIL should shortly receive a notice from the DVLA advising him of the date upon which his licence will be revoked and that he can continue to drive up to that date.

Slinky

Original Poster:

15,704 posts

280 months

Thursday 12th June 2008
quotequote all
SS2. said:
I'm sure you are aware that BIL should shortly receive a notice from the DVLA advising him of the date upon which his licence will be revoked and that he can continue to drive up to that date.
Indeed... again, thanks for your help on this one SS2.

He went into court sure that he was going to lose his license, regardless of which method was utilised, so is as happy as he can be with the result.

By all accounts the Mag's were very grateful for him turning up!

Hopefully now he'll appreciate that owning a car and driving/maintaining it is quite a serious affair and shouldn't be looked on with the disregard that it has in the past.

slinky