Idle curiosity question...legality of...
Discussion
Whilst perusing other forums...(curiosity got the better of me...sorry!)I came across a thread where someone living in a privately owned residential estate locked the gates of the estate knowing his actions would be impounding a non-residents' vehicle which he had seen being parked on the (private) roadway outside his property(contrary to posted signs).
Now I thought it was a good way to get the point across to those 'fly' parkers who flout private no parking areas without resorting to the 'clamp/tow and charge them' routine that we all too often hear about.
My question is...what are the legal implications of what was done and would the car owner have any legal recourse against the house owner for impounding the vehicle (even though it was released the next day undamaged)?
Now I thought it was a good way to get the point across to those 'fly' parkers who flout private no parking areas without resorting to the 'clamp/tow and charge them' routine that we all too often hear about.
My question is...what are the legal implications of what was done and would the car owner have any legal recourse against the house owner for impounding the vehicle (even though it was released the next day undamaged)?
oldsoak said:
Anyone?
We think the idea stinks. What if the person has to get thier wife/friend to hospital to give birth?
Personally if you blocked me in with a car, I'd find away of having your car crushed.
(Whether or not I would is not the issue, but what if the person you've blocked in has access to a vehicle lift and a crusher?)
I would have thought a polite note, asking them to either not park there again as it's a residents only, or to get in touch with you to discuss a long term arrangement. (I know people who live in walking distance from a city centre, who have both a car parking space and a garage, who rent out the garage to a guy who then walks 1/2 a mile into the city)
oldsoak said:
My question is...what are the legal implications of what was done and would the car owner have any legal recourse against the house owner for impounding the vehicle (even though it was released the next day undamaged)?
IIRC, preventing a person accessing the public highway is a criminal offence. Whilst preventing them accessing their own private property (i.e. getting onto their own driveway) is a civil matter.Jasandjules said:
oldsoak said:
My question is...what are the legal implications of what was done and would the car owner have any legal recourse against the house owner for impounding the vehicle (even though it was released the next day undamaged)?
IIRC, preventing a person accessing the public highway is a criminal offence. Whilst preventing them accessing their own private property (i.e. getting onto their own driveway) is a civil matter.Trespass is not an "offence", it's a civil tort.
The owner of the land could attempt to sue the owner of the vehicle for trespass that is true, but the owner of the vehicle could have the land owner prosecuted on the facts as I see them in the OP. It does not have to be your own property which you are prevented from accessing the highway.
The land owner could however put up a sign at the entrance to his land which indicates vehicles may be clamped etc.. and then he can get a car clamper (registered and licensed) to come and clamp the vehicle, and charge a release fe.
The owner of the land could attempt to sue the owner of the vehicle for trespass that is true, but the owner of the vehicle could have the land owner prosecuted on the facts as I see them in the OP. It does not have to be your own property which you are prevented from accessing the highway.
The land owner could however put up a sign at the entrance to his land which indicates vehicles may be clamped etc.. and then he can get a car clamper (registered and licensed) to come and clamp the vehicle, and charge a release fe.
Edited by Jasandjules on Thursday 22 May 11:20
I'd need to know more about the circumstances.
IF this were a long running problem, the vehicle owner knew they shouldn't be there and had previously asked not to park there I've little sympathy for them if they get locked in. If it were a one off then it seems harsh.
My money's on the former in this case.
IF this were a long running problem, the vehicle owner knew they shouldn't be there and had previously asked not to park there I've little sympathy for them if they get locked in. If it were a one off then it seems harsh.
My money's on the former in this case.
Jasandjules said:
Trespass is not an "offence", it's a civil tort.
I know hence the parenthesis around the word 'Offence' Jasandjules said:
The owner of the land could attempt to sue the owner of the vehicle for trespass that is true, but the owner of the vehicle could have the land owner prosecuted on the facts as I see them in the OP.
So you seem to be implying that the vehicle owner would be within his rights to prosecute the landowner albeit that it was he who was parking illegally (Don't forget there was a sign indicating no parking)Jasandjules said:
It does not have to be your own property which you are prevented from accessing the highway.
Now this is where I'm wanting clarification....as I'm not sure it is as clean cut as you infer... Jasandjules said:
The land owner could however put up a sign at the entrance to his land which indicates vehicles may be clamped etc.. and then he can get a car clamper (registered and licensed) to come and clamp the vehicle, and charge a release fe.
There is (apparently) already a sign...although it stipulates no penalty other than parking is restricted to residents and bona-fide guests only. Again (apparently) the car owner parked contrary to the signage, left the estate to go elsewhere whereupon the resident decided to take the course of action he did locking the gates on his way out to wherever he went thus leaving the car effectively 'impounded'.I have since learned (from the other forum) that the car owner upon return to find his vehicle 'locked in' tried unsuccessfully to contact a resident to be let out...None were around, he waited nearly 2 hours before leaving a note asking a resident contact him on a certain number to arrange a time when he could collect his car whilst apologising for contravening the NO PARKING signs...Seems the resident got his point across...albeit in a sneaky and calculated way.
I'm just wondering ...if the car owner had not been so accommodating would there be any lawful means he could have utilised to exact revenge (if you will)on the person who impounded the car?
Edited by oldsoak on Thursday 22 May 11:52
Guam said:
Depends on intent I guess, if he intended to lock him in then there are issues that are highlighted above, if he just intended to lock the gates (as is his right) and the car happened to be there then tough. Car owner would have all kinds of problems seeking redress on this one imho.
Cheers
Tom
Thanks Tom..Cheers
Tom
Oh he intended it alright! He's openly bragging about his coup...but as you say there may well be avenue's of redress for the car owner but it would take some proving ...Shame really as I class the whole thing on a par with the sneaky underhand tactics employed in Brunstroms 'horse box caper'.
Cheers.
The vehicle owner would be within his rights to inform the police that someone had blocked his vehicle in and see what happens. Personally IME the police don't know many laws full stop, so they'd just say it's a civil offence and ignore it.
He could however instigate a private prosecution if he was so inclined.
IIRC the law does not stipulate that blocking access to a highway only stands if the vehicle is on your own property. The law is, I think but can't be sure, somewhat more simplistic in it's writing.
A parking is restricted sign but no penalty notice means that the owner of the vehicle did not consent to having his vehicle impounded. Had the notice stated that the doors get locked at x pm etc.. that's turning into a different matter, and if the sign mentions vehicles may be blocked in or clamped, again, we are looking at a different matter.
The owner of the vehicle could sue the person who locked in his vehicle for the tort of conversion possibly (a bit vague in my memory though, so not sure), any losses he may suffer as a result of the tort such as needing to hire another vehicle etc.. and recovering his vehicle.
It falls to what the sign says, therefore what the vehicle owner has contractually agreed to, in my opinion. If no mention of blocking/clamping etc.. then an actionable tort has been committed.
Though most people won't have a clue about that and will drive off sheepishly (and quite rightly too, one shouldn't park on someone else's land, regardless of the law).
He could however instigate a private prosecution if he was so inclined.
IIRC the law does not stipulate that blocking access to a highway only stands if the vehicle is on your own property. The law is, I think but can't be sure, somewhat more simplistic in it's writing.
A parking is restricted sign but no penalty notice means that the owner of the vehicle did not consent to having his vehicle impounded. Had the notice stated that the doors get locked at x pm etc.. that's turning into a different matter, and if the sign mentions vehicles may be blocked in or clamped, again, we are looking at a different matter.
The owner of the vehicle could sue the person who locked in his vehicle for the tort of conversion possibly (a bit vague in my memory though, so not sure), any losses he may suffer as a result of the tort such as needing to hire another vehicle etc.. and recovering his vehicle.
It falls to what the sign says, therefore what the vehicle owner has contractually agreed to, in my opinion. If no mention of blocking/clamping etc.. then an actionable tort has been committed.
Though most people won't have a clue about that and will drive off sheepishly (and quite rightly too, one shouldn't park on someone else's land, regardless of the law).
So, if I park at my local supermarket and then decide to have a pint at the bar next door. Of course I won't drive the car home, so I leave my car overnight.
What happens when, arriving back home, the girlfriend decides she needs the car to go somewhere and can't get it out of the car park because the gate has been locked due to it being one of the supermarket's non-24hr opening nights? (BTW, there are no signs warning of penalties for parking long-term as the car park is used by more than one shop, a couple of bars and a bistro').
Do I have the right to sue them for blocking access to the highway
What happens when, arriving back home, the girlfriend decides she needs the car to go somewhere and can't get it out of the car park because the gate has been locked due to it being one of the supermarket's non-24hr opening nights? (BTW, there are no signs warning of penalties for parking long-term as the car park is used by more than one shop, a couple of bars and a bistro').
Do I have the right to sue them for blocking access to the highway

Jasandjules said:
IIRC the law does not stipulate that blocking access to a highway only stands if the vehicle is on your own property. The law is, I think but can't be sure, somewhat more simplistic in it's writing.
There is a multi-storey car park near me that closes after a certain time, the barriers are lowered so that cars can neither get in or out, and I know a few people that have had to get a taxi home after leaving things a bit too late. I wouldn't think this was illegal?Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



