Insurance & police wasting money?
Insurance & police wasting money?
Author
Discussion

skeggysteve

Original Poster:

5,724 posts

248 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
My son had his mobile stolen the other day, so he calls the insurance company, they want a crime number.

So he rings the local police they take his name and contact number (mobile) and say someone will ring back later that day.

Five minutes later they ring back - 20 minute call asking all sorts of questions which no doubt are related to government statistic gathering but finally gave him the crime number which was all he wanted/needed.

Then 2 days later he gets a letter from the police "We are sorry you have been a victim of crime etc.etc etc"
and here is the crime number that we gave you earlier.

So why do insurance companies insist on a crime number when they must know how much police time and money it wastes?

Why do the police put up with it?

Why send out a pointless letter?

BiB thoughts would be interesting.


Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
skeggysteve said:
My son had his mobile stolen the other day, so he calls the insurance company, they want a crime number.

So he rings the local police they take his name and contact number (mobile) and say someone will ring back later that day.

Five minutes later they ring back - 20 minute call asking all sorts of questions which no doubt are related to government statistic gathering but finally gave him the crime number which was all he wanted/needed.

Then 2 days later he gets a letter from the police "We are sorry you have been a victim of crime etc.etc etc"
and here is the crime number that we gave you earlier.

So why do insurance companies insist on a crime number when they must know how much police time and money it wastes?

Why do the police put up with it?

Why send out a pointless letter?

BiB thoughts would be interesting.
Indeed.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
skeggysteve said:
My son had his mobile stolen the other day, so he calls the insurance company, they want a crime number.

So he rings the local police they take his name and contact number (mobile) and say someone will ring back later that day.

Five minutes later they ring back - 20 minute call asking all sorts of questions which no doubt are related to government statistic gathering but finally gave him the crime number which was all he wanted/needed.

Then 2 days later he gets a letter from the police "We are sorry you have been a victim of crime etc.etc etc"
and here is the crime number that we gave you earlier.

So why do insurance companies insist on a crime number when they must know how much police time and money it wastes?
If they are paying out then the phone becomes their property, they want it if it's found & need the fact it's stolen with the Police & a reference number should their be any dispute. It's a paper trail.

skeggysteve said:
Why do the police put up with it?
They've no choice. There is evidence of & allegation of a crime, they are duty bound to record that.

skeggysteve said:
Why send out a pointless letter?
No doubt it also had a victim support letter with it. It's evidence of referrals.


skeggysteve

Original Poster:

5,724 posts

248 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Thanks for the reply Von.

OK I understand what you are saying about the insurance companies and paper trials but it just seems like a waste of time and money for the theft of a mobile phone.

"Why do the police put up with it?"

I could understand if it was crime against a person or someone breaking into a persons home, but for a mobile phone?

"...pointless letter.."

Sorry but I don't understand what you mean about 'evidence of referrals'.

Von, if your are a serving police officer, do you think the system. with regards to crime numbers, could be better/changed, to free up police time & money for more important things?

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
skeggysteve said:
Thanks for the reply Von.

OK I understand what you are saying about the insurance companies and paper trials but it just seems like a waste of time and money for the theft of a mobile phone.

"Why do the police put up with it?"

I could understand if it was crime against a person or someone breaking into a persons home, but for a mobile phone?

"...pointless letter.."

Sorry but I don't understand what you mean about 'evidence of referrals'.

Von, if your are a serving police officer, do you think the system. with regards to crime numbers, could be better/changed, to free up police time & money for more important things?
To be honest they're not wasting a lot of time on it.

They have no choice but to record them. They are not allowed to only record detections, they have to record unresolved crimes also, or it is not a true reflection of what's happening. Of course there is the intelligence issue of where crimes are happening. If a lot of people are getting their phones dipped in a certain area then the Police can target that area.

insanojackson

6,029 posts

275 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
It might be a novel idea but perhaps they actually wanted to investigate the theft??? thats why they asked questions?? in my force all crimes reported get investigated. Also the amount of phones reported stolen that actually have been lost,sold,stolen etc etc by the owner is massive!

AndyRw

740 posts

240 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
insanojackson said:
It might be a novel idea but perhaps they actually wanted to investigate the theft???
Exactly, it's a screening process. This is the kind of job I deal with as a response officer (along with those I pick up from emergency and priority calls and self-generated jobs). Like Von says, they are obliged to record the crime and the necessary detail. The first step is to assess the information to see whether there are any investigatory leads which could identify an offender, which means asking quite a few questions. If anything you tell them suggests there is something to follow up, it gets passed to an officer like me. If not, it gets filed without reaching us.

It does get results - a short while ago I had a mobile phone theft allocated to me which happened in a pub. Passed to me as the victim thought the pub had CCTV - which it did - and I recognised the offender who was seen on it. Quick arrest, mobile recovered and offender charged. At the same time those jobs which have no leads are weeded out at an early stage.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
Don't worry. No doubt the government will soon follow the model they have established with credit card fraud, and will transfer the onus for "investigation" to the service or network suppliers.

Next, car theft will become the investigative province of the manufacturer.

Wherever responsibility for investigation can be transferred into the private sector, thereby reducing the cost of the police, this government will do it.

Streaky

PS - of course, any money saved will not go towards settling the police pay dispute, but will instead be used to provide close protection for all MPs when visiting their local kebab shop - S

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
I totally agree with the whole crime number bullcrap.
One of my dissolusionments with the police is that I reported many crimes over the years. Generally around five per year and I had enough crime numbers sent to wallpaper my living room with.
However I also had an equal number of NFA letters despite on many occasions witnesses or suspects being in abundance.

I also have been through a follow up to a reported crime last year when a white van stopped outside my house and the driver got out and proceeded to steal from a palette of block paving in my front garden.

I chased him off and got his reg number , phoned the police to report so they could possibly see him driving around.

Next day an officer appeared at my door. Quite frankly I didn't understand why.
I had disturbed a criminal before anything was taken and made others aware so basically I thought it was job done.
I only understood why when I had to spend 40 minutes making a statement . 5 minutes of which were the facts of the events and the rest filling in ethnic bullcrap data for the police computer.

I guess the insurance companies insist on a crime number to prevent fraudulent claims. They wrongly assume that if you have to contact the police to report something it will prevent you from making a bogus insurance claim.

The system should be scrapped.

It works the other way too. I got the impression that the police felt that giving you a crime number was enough to satisfy their obligations even if you wanted a crime pursued or had witnesses or suspects. ie you've got your crime number , now run along.



herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
mark69sheer said:
I totally agree with the whole crime number bullcrap.
One of my dissolusionments with the police is that I reported many crimes over the years. Generally around five per year and I had enough crime numbers sent to wallpaper my living room with.
However I also had an equal number of NFA letters despite on many occasions witnesses or suspects being in abundance.

I also have been through a follow up to a reported crime last year when a white van stopped outside my house and the driver got out and proceeded to steal from a palette of block paving in my front garden.

I chased him off and got his reg number , phoned the police to report so they could possibly see him driving around.

Next day an officer appeared at my door. Quite frankly I didn't understand why.
I had disturbed a criminal before anything was taken and made others aware so basically I thought it was job done.
I only understood why when I had to spend 40 minutes making a statement . 5 minutes of which were the facts of the events and the rest filling in ethnic bullcrap data for the police computer.
Could you expand on that. Why would it take 35 mins to tell them the offender was white(or whatever)?

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
One question that could be asked is whether a private company, one that is required to show a profit, would follow this procedure.

Let's assume a nominal figure of 20 mobile phones reported as stolen each day. I've no justification for that figure, and for a force the size of my old one I would suggest it is rather low.

Whilst a phone call does not take much time, nor the filling of one envelope, the infrastructure to support these services is phenominal.

Firstly, there is the time taken on the call itself. Manning levels on a switchboard are in some way related to demand (although not in my force, it was budget led). These calls increase the workload and while the person is dealing with this one, they are not dealing with a punter who needs the service. Further, the more calls the more sophisticated the system needed to deal with them.

So a phone call comes in, it is given to a controller who accepts it. They then have to go through the: Name, address, etc information exercise and 90 seconds later the call is terminated and the report is sent to the relevant department. So one controller spends half an hour on such calls each day. This time has to be doubled when one accepts that each controller working a 37 hour week spends 20 hours taking calls - the figure of 20 hrs per week taking calls is generous, I've done the stats. So such calls take up 5% of one controller's time. Not a lot. If one assume a controller gets £16000 (picked for ease of calculation) it means that it only requires £800 a year. I accept that as calls increase the technical support side has to increase as well, but that's beyond my ability to calculate.

Then the serial goes to the clerk, then to the person who fills the envelope - can you see where I'm going with this?

And that's only for mobile phones in one force area.

It can, of course, be automated to a great extent. Once the serial is complete, all the rest is completed via internal systems without any input from police staff. But that ain't cheap either. In fact, it's expensive and, when HMG changes the system, as it does on a fornightly basis, it is expensive again to change the programme. I remember a perfectly adequate system in my force having to be radically altered - eventually replaced - because of an alteration in the way stats were collatted. HMG did not fund it of course.

Having worked in a control room and tried to cut waste I can assure you that most calls that come into a force 'switchboard' are not resourced, i.e. the police do nothing policey about them. However, stats must be collected or else there would be no stats. And if there were no stats, how could we tell how efficient a force is? Of course, the resources wasted on collecting stats . . .

As I say, a private company would have switchboard staff who were better than any firewall and would live by the motto, they shall not pass.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
I wonder if the phone companies could be persuaded to stop insuring the phones.

DPX

1,027 posts

231 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
Mixed feelings on this , if the back room systems are set up and they have some sort of good query then it should be possonble to find trends of thefts , area hot sports , and any sort of pattern than could lead to a little pro-ative policework and catch the "man with the swag". ( Opps Sorry P.C. Person carrying large bio-degradable carrying tool that contains contents that may not belong to the said person ) .

Some of these logging systems have the power and the data to produce some very clever clues once the correct search patterns are entered.

I suspect that tesco knows more about people than the PNC

Edited by DPX on Thursday 22 May 10:06

stepej

445 posts

271 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
And if there were no stats, how could we tell how efficient a force is?
As we all know stats can be made to show anything depending on how they are presented

The true measure is how safe i feel walking down the street or in my own home or whether i feel i can let my children out of my sight for any length of time.

I for one would much rather the money spent on collecting & collating these bloody statistics was spent on policing the streets.
ffs, i got a survey from west yorks police last month signed Chief Superintendent 'Head of Corporate Review'. Please tell me he does more all day than his title suggests

Chrispy Porker

17,764 posts

259 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
herewego said:
mark69sheer said:
I totally agree with the whole crime number bullcrap.
One of my dissolusionments with the police is that I reported many crimes over the years. Generally around five per year and I had enough crime numbers sent to wallpaper my living room with.
However I also had an equal number of NFA letters despite on many occasions witnesses or suspects being in abundance.

I also have been through a follow up to a reported crime last year when a white van stopped outside my house and the driver got out and proceeded to steal from a palette of block paving in my front garden.

I chased him off and got his reg number , phoned the police to report so they could possibly see him driving around.

Next day an officer appeared at my door. Quite frankly I didn't understand why.
I had disturbed a criminal before anything was taken and made others aware so basically I thought it was job done.
I only understood why when I had to spend 40 minutes making a statement . 5 minutes of which were the facts of the events and the rest filling in ethnic bullcrap data for the police computer.
Could you expand on that. Why would it take 35 mins to tell them the offender was white(or whatever)?
In my day the statement would have been 10 minutes, then the tea and biccies for half an hour. Much more sensible.

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
herewego said:
mark69sheer said:
I totally agree with the whole crime number bullcrap.
One of my dissolusionments with the police is that I reported many crimes over the years. Generally around five per year and I had enough crime numbers sent to wallpaper my living room with.
However I also had an equal number of NFA letters despite on many occasions witnesses or suspects being in abundance.

I also have been through a follow up to a reported crime last year when a white van stopped outside my house and the driver got out and proceeded to steal from a palette of block paving in my front garden.

I chased him off and got his reg number , phoned the police to report so they could possibly see him driving around.

Next day an officer appeared at my door. Quite frankly I didn't understand why.
I had disturbed a criminal before anything was taken and made others aware so basically I thought it was job done.
I only understood why when I had to spend 40 minutes making a statement . 5 minutes of which were the facts of the events and the rest filling in ethnic bullcrap data for the police computer.
Could you expand on that. Why would it take 35 mins to tell them the offender was white(or whatever)?
In my day the statement would have been 10 minutes, then the tea and biccies for half an hour. Much more sensible.
If only we could go back to those days.

The word 'offended' or may cause 'offence' is bandied around a lot to justify certain ethnic actions.

I am by no means BNP or National front.
I detest white trailer trash just as equally as some Nigerian email scammer etc etc

However I feel 'offended' whenever I have to disclose my race in any official documentation.

If there is to be no racial discrimination then surely my colour is irrelevent.

I always get made to feel as if I am somehow privileged and responsible for the worlds ill based purely on the fact I am white British.

Why should I disclose my ethnicity when we are to be told this week that poitive discrimination is going to be applied to the labour market.

If disclosing the fact I am white could disadvantage my children and their chance of getting to university then I feel 'offended; to be asked , in fact forced to reveal my bacjground.

Chrispy Porker

17,764 posts

259 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
You are not 'forced'.
There is a box for 'subject declines'
All forms I have seen when race or sexuality are asked, include that option.
Get a grip Mark, for goodness sake.

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
You are not 'forced'.
There is a box for 'subject declines'
All forms I have seen when race or sexuality are asked, include that option.
Get a grip Mark, for goodness sake.
Possibly in the police forms but there is definately been debate regarding the filling in of forms for schools and universities where declining to answer those questions is seen as a negative act.

As for there being 'a box' for subject declines in reality it doesn't work like that.

I was asked questions rather than given a form to fill in myself so if I am not verbally given the option not to answer then I feel compelled to answer the questions.

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
You can, or course, be whatever 'race' you wish as there is no way to define it. Hale Berry is, according to her and her publicist, black yet I have an Irish relative who looks blacker. He reckons he's of Spanish descent - something to do with the Armada - so he's called The Wop by all his friends. I might be British, but that doesn't give a clue to my race as there is no British 'race'. So be black. Or Chinese, although, of course, Chinese is not a 'race'.

I have a Caucasian American friend who claimed, just because she was irritated, to be a native American, i.e. what we called American Indians. It all got a bit out of hand and threats of police action and refusals to let her visit Canada, where she didn’t want to go anyway, were negated by the fact that no one could prove otherwise. She’s got a security file though. I wonder what her ‘race’ is given as in it.

You can, if you really want to be clever, be a number of 'races'. Say you are black and Inuit, with a bit of Mediterranean thrown in. You will probably go down in the 'mixed race' box but then object to that by saying that everyone is of mixed race and you are being picked on because you are black. And then, when all the enquiries are over and you've been given an apology but no one knows for what, say your Inuit ancestors are also miffed and want an apology as well.

But, of course, none of us are mixed race as we can all trace our ancestry back to a single female and a single male, at least according to recent DNA research.

It's all rather silly. We're people.

Nazi Germany could not define race, South Africa under apartheid failed as well despite reams and reams of instructions on how to do so but this country, in its efforts for positive discrimination, seem to think they’ve got it cracked.

So the police have to waste time collecting data on the racial make-up of those they come into contact with despite the fact that no one knows what it means.

There are a number of sex-unspecific people in Brighton and often, when they are arrested – not a frequent occurrence as, as a group, they seem generally quite law-abiding – they often demand to be searched by a specific sex of officer. This can generate quite a surprise for those so tasked. An inspector tried to get some form of definitive guidance from the Home Office but failed. It seems the police must ‘take into consideration’ the person’s own ideas of their sex. Legally, a person born a man remains a man even if the relative bits that make him a man are removed. We’ve had, so to speak, people suggest that their CRO is incorrect and they are, in fact, and always were female. “No, it’s Georgina, not George. And most people call me Gina anyway.” they say, standing there with their cleavage and short skirt. And it is extremely difficult to tell otherwise. In my day it was easier – women danced backwards – but I’m told it is a bit more technical than that.

But I suppose data collecting and collating gives employment to those not able to hold down a proper job.

Chrispy Porker

17,764 posts

259 months

Thursday 22nd May 2008
quotequote all
mark69sheer said:
Chrispy Porker said:
You are not 'forced'.
There is a box for 'subject declines'
All forms I have seen when race or sexuality are asked, include that option.
Get a grip Mark, for goodness sake.
Possibly in the police forms but there is definately been debate regarding the filling in of forms for schools and universities where declining to answer those questions is seen as a negative act.

As for there being 'a box' for subject declines in reality it doesn't work like that.

I was asked questions rather than given a form to fill in myself so if I am not verbally given the option not to answer then I feel compelled to answer the questions.
PLease tell me how 'disclosing' that you are white ( is it not obvious when looking at you ? is it a secret? ) is going to obstruct your children from going to university.
My daughter went to uni.
No-one asked me what colour I was, on a form or in person.

If you really feel that strongly when someone asks you your race can I suggest the late Spike Milligans answer

'Human'.