Gridlock and Road Rage: Channel 4: Set your recorders
Gridlock and Road Rage: Channel 4: Set your recorders
Author
Discussion

Sgt Bilko

Original Poster:

1,929 posts

246 months

Friday 23rd May 2008
quotequote all
C4
Thursday 29 May
9pm

Cutting Edge: Gridlock and Road Rage



Millions of drivers find themselves trapped in traffic jams each year. And it's getting worse, with commuting times doubling since 2003 (source: Peninsula). The result is road rage: wasted time, exasperation and frayed tempers.

Cutting Edge follows long suffering commuters and meets the teams trying to improve the situation: we get a rare glimpse of the Highways Agency, an unloved army of civil servants in bunkers who're able to close a motorway at the touch of a button.

They have the tricky task of keeping the roads moving, using overhead signs to tell everyone when a lane is closed, or the whole road. The agency wants to avoid gridlock.

And spare a thought for the objects of drivers' wrath – the road workers who stand accused of causing the jams. With only a "stop/go" board for protection, they risk abuse and even bombardments of eggs from passing motorists.

About the jams

Driving people crazy
Tony is a long-distance mortgage salesman from Essex who has the unenviable task of battling through the M25 on a daily basis. “My relationship with the roads is hate” he says calmly as he sets off on a five hour round trip that takes in such delights as the M25 “car park” and the infamous Dartford Tunnel during evening rush hour.

But while he rages against the system, the system itself is watching him. All the time, he’s being filmed by a small army of Highways Agency civil servants from their secretive bunker in South Mimms.

The Highways Agency
It’s from high-tech centres like this one that the signs, signals and road blocks on Europe’s most congested motorway network are controlled, and it’s people like Louise Boothman from the North-West centre who are trying to keep the traffic moving. She admits to getting a stomach-ache when she sees jams on her stretch of the network and sometimes it falls to her to close motorways too: “It’s a novelty to close the M6, not many people can say they’ve done that in their lives...”

Why do we love our cars?
So what is it about people and their cars? Why do drivers put themselves through the wringer every day?

Author Phillip Ball points out that cars have been sold to us as images of power, freedom and control in a world where no one else exists. In fact, cars do the opposite – they imprison us in a world full of other people.

Luckily there are people like Jamie Shaw around who can decorate vehicles with every gadget under the sun – not just sat navs and heated seats, but TV and DVD players too.

Reasons for jams
This probably comes as little comfort to those people travelling clockwise on the M25. The Highways Agency have received a call to say there's some debris in the road, and although this is unconfirmed they must take drastic action, slowing down fives miles of motorway with a "rolling road block" in search of it. After an exhaustive trawl, nothing can be found, and hundreds of cars are finally allowed on their way.

Out on the road in Gloucester is a long-suffering team of road workers whose swivelling 'stop-and-go' boards are to drivers as red rags are to bulls. While protecting the gangs fixing the roads behind them, they get daily abuse and missiles from drivers, much to their annoyance.

"I don't walk into their offices and spit in their faces, do I?" says one. "They want it both ways" says another. "They want nice clear roads, but aren't prepared to wait for them."

Road rage
Let's hope they don't run into Matthew, a lorry driver from Liverpool. His fury extends way beyond roadworks, to those he shares the road with, particularly women drivers, learner drivers, those who go very fast, and those who go too slowly, the young, the old (or 'coffin dodgers') – in fact pretty much anyone who gets in his way.

Phantom jams
But what about so-called traffic jams that appear out of 'nowhere' – no accident, no roadworks, no debris on the road? Mathematician Dr. Eddie Wilson, who studies traffic, explains how steadily moving lanes of cars can suddenly slow to crawl, for no apparent reason. And he's one person who actively seeks out tailbacks, all in the name of research.

robwales

1,427 posts

241 months

Friday 23rd May 2008
quotequote all
Missed the programme unfortunately. It's next week.
Never had any rage at road workers, and I can't imagine that I would. But I am fortunate enough to have only ever been in one motorway traffic jam, and that was only for 20mins.
People love their cars and use them every day because they need them and cars provide us with independence and freedom.
I do hate any road user that impedes my progress though.

Sgt Bilko said:
C4
Phantom jams
But what about so-called traffic jams that appear out of 'nowhere' – no accident, no roadworks, no debris on the road? Mathematician Dr. Eddie Wilson, who studies traffic, explains how steadily moving lanes of cars can suddenly slow to crawl, for no apparent reason. And he's one person who actively seeks out tailbacks, all in the name of research.
This microsimulation of road traffic might be interesting (it was posted previously in another thread): http://www.mtreiber.de/MicroApplet

Edited by robwales on Friday 23 May 22:30

Brink

1,505 posts

239 months

Friday 23rd May 2008
quotequote all
Wave theory can be applied to motorway and dual-C traffic...

Fat Richie

1,271 posts

249 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Brink said:
Wave theory can be applied to motorway and dual-C traffic...
I saw a programme about this a couple of years ago, beleive they call it shockwaving - plenty of that on the M5 southbound earlier this evening.

Battenburg Bob

8,858 posts

223 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Fat Richie said:
Brink said:
Wave theory can be applied to motorway and dual-C traffic...
I saw a programme about this a couple of years ago, believe they call it shockwaving - plenty of that on the M5 southbound earlier this evening.
M5 was horrendous all day. I can only summise that the end of some peoples bonnets must be very interesting, because a lot of them don't seem to look past it. )

Ravell

1,181 posts

243 months

Sunday 25th May 2008
quotequote all
Gridlock and Road Rage said:
Author Phillip Ball points out that cars have been sold to us as images of power, freedom and control in a world where no one else exists. In fact, cars do the opposite – they imprison us in a world full of other people.
Let me guess, everyone taking the bus is the answer? rolleyes

Sounds like the program might be quite biased, bit I'll still give it a watch.

I've never been angry at roadworkers. Seems rather silly.

Seesure

1,230 posts

270 months

Sunday 25th May 2008
quotequote all
It's the road works that annoy me most.....

Mile after mile of cones, and just occasionally you might find somebody doing some work. Why can't the cones be only used in the immediate area of where work is actually being done.

I'm convinced that some govermental politician must have a significant share holding in a cone manufacturing company.

With the introduction of 40mph limits on road works to supposedly protect the work force it slows things down even more.

But if these limits are supposedly to protect the workforce why are they active 24x7 when the work force is never to be seen ?

Frederick

5,910 posts

251 months

Sunday 25th May 2008
quotequote all
Seesure said:
It's the road works that annoy me most.....

Mile after mile of cones, and just occasionally you might find somebody doing some work. Why can't the cones be only used in the immediate area of where work is actually being done.

With the introduction of 40mph limits on road works to supposedly protect the work force it slows things down even more.

But if these limits are supposedly to protect the workforce why are they active 24x7 when the work force is never to be seen ?
I guess they cone off whole swathes of DC/M-Way because when the traffic is moving at 70+, it would be a bit dangerous to have a section of cones pop up out of nowhere, even more so with a bloke digging a hole right behind them...

The 40mph limits isn't too bad, however the 30s from 70s are a pain in the arse. 40 is a much more "natural" speed to drive at if you are decelerating in a group from 70mph. 30 seems like walking pace.

As for the 24-7 thing, I don't know however I guess that if you came up against a contraflow at 70mph, you could (either being half asleep, inattentive or just plain unlucky) plough through the contraflow, into whatever works are being done - if it was a bridge replacement you could become rather unstuck!

Agreed they should raise the limits while work isn't being done - but certainly if it's major roadworks, not to full M-Way speed.

Sgt Bilko

Original Poster:

1,929 posts

246 months

Sunday 25th May 2008
quotequote all
Roadworks speed limits are something to do with tmporary traffic regulation order. You cannot specify "times during a day" only "from xxxx hours on xx/xx/xx to xxxx hours on xx/xx/xx". Also, there is a minimum legal requirement to signpost the changes and changing these daily, at exactly the correct time would be a nightmare.

Flintstone

8,644 posts

278 months

Sunday 25th May 2008
quotequote all
Sgt Bilko said:
Also, there is a minimum legal requirement to signpost the changes and changing these daily, at exactly the correct time would be a nightmare.
Why? All a contractor has to do is send someone out to flip the signs over or open. Weigh up the cost and inconvenience of that against the MASSIVE cost and inconvenience to road users and it's a no brainer.

Swoxy

2,842 posts

241 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
On in ten minutes!

carrotchomper

18,334 posts

235 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
Feck me, the guy in the tipper lorry is a bit of a muppet, n c'est-pas?

Chrispy Porker

17,764 posts

259 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
carrotchomper said:
Feck me, the guy in the tipper lorry is a bit of a muppet, n c'est-pas?
One of several on this programme.

fluffnik

20,156 posts

258 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
Sgt Bilko said:
Roadworks speed limits are something to do with tmporary traffic regulation order. You cannot specify "times during a day" only "from xxxx hours on xx/xx/xx to xxxx hours on xx/xx/xx". Also, there is a minimum legal requirement to signpost the changes and changing these daily, at exactly the correct time would be a nightmare.
Then the system is not fit for purpose.

Sack the incompetents.

All of them.

TrevorH

1,359 posts

315 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
They can manage it on the M25 variable speed limit section in reaction to the traffic levels. How hard is it to do it in roadworks? It doesn't have to be at set times.

DAVEVO9

3,469 posts

298 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
carrotchomper said:
Feck me, the guy in the tipper lorry is a bit of a muppet, n c'est-pas?
Grade 1 kock! just got his LGV by the looks of things and only a matter of time before he gets banned

mph999

2,780 posts

251 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
DAVEVO9 said:
carrotchomper said:
Feck me, the guy in the tipper lorry is a bit of a muppet, n c'est-pas?
Grade 1 kock! just got his LGV by the looks of things and only a matter of time before he gets banned
And he classed himself a good driver ...

Lets see, no hands on wheel, eating, not looking where you are going, no seatbelt ...

Problem with most of these 'professional drivers' is quite simply, they're not.

Martin

Peter Ward

2,097 posts

287 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
TrevorH said:
They can manage it on the M25 variable speed limit section in reaction to the traffic levels. How hard is it to do it in roadworks? It doesn't have to be at set times.
Let's guess.... it's cheaper to have metal signs and constant limits than to implement variable limit signs in an intelligent way?

I'm sure that no assessment of impact is made when roadworks speed limits are chosen. The focus is on the perceived additional safety of the workforce, not the horrendous delays to the traffic. After all, if delays were costed properly they would justify a huge investment into roads and we wouldn't want that would we?

Sgt Bilko

Original Poster:

1,929 posts

246 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
Peter Ward said:
The focus is on the perceived additional safety of the workforce, not the horrendous delays to the traffic.
Perceived! These guys work within 1 meter of live moving traffic with only a small rope to stop them stepping back into the path of an artic. You try doing that with traffic doing 70mph and see if 50mph is safer.

Like said last night, "People want nice roads, but aren't prepared to wait for them".

Guybrush

4,364 posts

237 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
The Dartford crossing was mentioned as a regular congestion spot. Sadly, if our "leaders" were really concerned about fuel wastage, they'd abandon the toll collection as it's been paid for already. But £££ is more important, and fuel saving is suddenly not on the agenda.