6pt harnesses and the law....
6pt harnesses and the law....
Author
Discussion

s.m.h.

Original Poster:

5,733 posts

246 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
Ok, I know this is a bit of a grey area but what are the risks if youre driving a track day car - insured etc - on the road with a harness on.

I understand that there are 'e' marks on everything these days, yet only some of the 4 point belts have them.
Ive bought a Schroth belt to go in as the originals were 20 years old and wouldnt like to find out if they worked in an accident..

My arguement is, you can get a valid MOT with a 6 point harness fitted, as long as its propery secured/not frayed/rusted etc, but where does that leave you with the plod??

The MOT does not check for 'e' marks, nor does it bother to check there is an inertia system fitted.
So the car passes an MOT and as long as the insurance is ok and is taxed there shouldnt be a problem??

The Black Duke

1,642 posts

224 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
The law was constructed in order to save the lives of thousands of people who were killed on British roads before thew seat belt legislation was introduced.
So, if the spirit of the law the aim is to stop you going through your window in the event of an accident. This has been achieved.
But, to be safe I guess an E mark would help to prevent any confusion.
If you get stopped for this I would really have to question the motives of the officer who stopped you.

s.m.h.

Original Poster:

5,733 posts

246 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
Daft thing is the harnesses are FIA approved to a higher standard.(Schroth belts are owned by British Aerospace and are used by pilots though Ive no intention of flying)
I know there will be people saying theyre not as easy to use as an inertia etc etc but when the cage goes in Im not p!ssing about with a OE belt!

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
I thought the harness had to be E marked or kite marked to pass the MOT? Only a few competition harnesses are. I have retained the original lap/diagonal on mine to ensure it's road legal, although I only ever use the harness.

The Excession

11,669 posts

281 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
I was stopped a few times driving a fully liveried rally car out on public roads.

It had 6 point harnesses in and BiB never took any interest in them at all. Mainly they were just interested in the vehcle and what events I'd run in.

Most times they wanted a peak under the bonnet and conversation got onto what engine and suspension mods had been done, and discussions about handling and torque steer.

It was only a two litre Astra paperbag


I wouldn't worry. The biggest problem with wearing a full harness on the road is that you can't move your shoulders very much so it can make your observations difficult at junctions etc.

s.m.h.

Original Poster:

5,733 posts

246 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
GreenV8S said:
I thought the harness had to be E marked or kite marked to pass the MOT? Only a few competition harnesses are. I have retained the original lap/diagonal on mine to ensure it's road legal, although I only ever use the harness.
This was cut from a fairly comprehensive website on MOT's and whats tested. No mention of 'e'marks or kitemarks....
Test Description

Most vehicles after 1965 must have seat belts. Irrespective of that requirement, all seat belts fitted to any vehicle must be inspected for:

* security of seat belt mountings and locking stalks
* security and operation of the locking/release mechanism
* condition of webbing
* retraction of the belt (it is allowed to manually feed it in).

Notes: 1. For technical reasons the inertia locking mechanism is not checked. 2. On some vehicles the belt is attached to the seat, in which case the security of the seat to the vehicle would also constitute part of the seat belt check.


Oddly enought there are some cars that are sold with harnesses in, doesnt the GT2/GT3 porkers have full cage/ harness set ups as standard?

bimsb6

8,812 posts

252 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
my lad had harnesses fitted in his pug 306 (god knows why) the only issue he had was plod not being able to see he was using a seatbelt through the rear window when behind him ,so he was pulled quite often .

Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
Hi smile

I have 6 point harnesses in my Porsche and only ever got stopped once for them...same reason as someone mentioned, the officer was expecting to see a belt going off top right to the pillar...

Once stopped , he saw the 6 points and was fine about it, and yes a lot of Porsche's have harnesses although they also have the standard belts as well.

To be sensible about it, in a major crash I would MUCH rather be wearing 6 points than a normal inertia belt.....

All the best Brett smile


S. Gonzales Esq.

2,559 posts

243 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
Brett928S2 said:
To be sensible about it, in a major crash I would MUCH rather be wearing 6 points than a normal inertia belt.....
That might be the case in an older car, but anything more modern will have seat belts, pre-tensioners, airbags and crumple zones all designed to work together.

A multi-point harness can actually be a bad thing in a sudden stop (risk of basilar skull fracture), hence the use of the HANS device.

s.m.h.

Original Poster:

5,733 posts

246 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
S. Gonzales Esq. said:
Brett928S2 said:
To be sensible about it, in a major crash I would MUCH rather be wearing 6 points than a normal inertia belt.....
That might be the case in an older car, but anything more modern will have seat belts, pre-tensioners, airbags and crumple zones all designed to work together.

A multi-point harness can actually be a bad thing in a sudden stop (risk of basilar skull fracture), hence the use of the HANS device.
Obviously Im in the same group as Brett, and while I agree with S.Gon Esq about the Hans (theyre mandatory in the GT4 stuff I look after) you cant use without a helmet and if youre getting to the sorts of speeds that in your link to wiki - ratzenberger etc - then youre not on a public highway.
My wife works for one of the countrys leading head injury companies so I'm well aware (told) of the risks!!!

Though your argument about pretensioners seems a little off, as a correctly adjusted harness will prevent submarining and give a wider area to put the load through, the pretensioners simply pull the belt - 3 point - tighter to prevent what a harness does without. Only bad point is the restricted movement once strapped in though I plan to not have any switches i cant reach when in..

Having been at races where the cars have goe off in excess of 150mph and the driver walks away (and races the next day!) I cant build myself a car without fitting one.

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
I've been told that a lap/diagonal in a heavby shunt is a recipe for neck injury, and that seems pretty likely to me given the obvious asymmetry in the way the loads are applied. I'd far rather have a correctly fitted harness to spread the loads out more evenly over a larger area and start the deceleration sooner.

s.m.h.

Original Poster:

5,733 posts

246 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
GreenV8S said:
I've been told that a lap/diagonal in a heavby shunt is a recipe for neck injury, and that seems pretty likely to me given the obvious asymmetry in the way the loads are applied. I'd far rather have a correctly fitted harness to spread the loads out more evenly over a larger area and start the deceleration sooner.
My thoughts entirely. Didnt Earnhardt die because the harness broke, sending him off to one side,causing the injury that killed him?

robwales

1,427 posts

241 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
In rallying circles, many people say that harness with no roll cage is a bad idea, since if you roll the car and the roof comes down, you can't duck out of the way.

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
I did some research on this after a couple of queries from TVR Car Club members and got the following info from VOSA.

There are many variations of requirements based on the age of a vehicle and these are rather complex but the rule is that, if a vehicle is required to be fitted with an intertia reel seat belt, even one that must be 'one-handed', if a replacement belt is fitted with a fixed, i.e. not automatically retractable, full harness then if it is to a higher standard than the standard type required then the MoT tester will pass it. This 'higher standard' can be shown by a kite mark or mark.

There are other regulations that a seat belt has to comply with under construction and use regs but, if the belt is of a higher standard than the original, then the fact it is not a one-handed intertia reel type cannot be a reason to prosecute.

How one convinces an MoT tester than the belt is of a higher standard if not stamped with the E or kite mark is unknown. An FIA approved belt is not, evidently, of itself sufficient.

The method that seems to work is discussing the belt and its fitment with the MoT tester. If it passes then it would appear it conforms to the requirement of con and use. The belt must be in servicable condition of course.

There are problems when it comes to children and pregnant women.

If your car is required to have intertia belts but not one-handed operation then the above applies. If you car is only required to have static belts then it would appear that there is no requirement for and E or kite mark on a full harness.

It is my experience that if it hasn't got a E, or kite mark many testers are deaf to pleading.

clubsport

7,420 posts

289 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
I have a 911 which left the factory with a full matter fia approved cage,,no seatbelts have ever been fitted and the car has never had a problem passing an mot with the standard 6 point scroth harnesses fitted.....any problems perhaps it is worth going to an Mot station who have a clue? smile

Exige77

6,523 posts

222 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
I was told that for seatbelts to be leagal, they had to be able to be opened usising one hand by the red button ?

My Willans 4 point do this.

I was told this was a requirement of the rescue services when it was incorporated in the law.

Not an expert but that was what I was told and changed my choice of belts for this reason.

Ex77

Exige77

6,523 posts

222 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
I was told that for seatbelts to be leagal, they had to be able to be opened usising one hand by the red button ?

My Willans 4 point do this.

I was told this was a requirement of the rescue services when it was incorporated in the law.

Not an expert but that was what I was told and changed my choice of belts for this reason.

Ex77

absolutely

3,168 posts

223 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
bimsb6 said:
my lad had harnesses fitted in his pug 306 (god knows why)
Because he wanted to look cool pretending he was driving a racing car?

Sorry, I am against people pretending to be racing drivers, it gives us real racing drivers a bad reputation!

As for a 6 pt harness in a road car, it seems alot of faf just to pop to the shops, its probably better to use a 4pt.

Edited by absolutely on Monday 26th May 16:34

s.m.h.

Original Poster:

5,733 posts

246 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
absolutely said:
bimsb6 said:
my lad had harnesses fitted in his pug 306 (god knows why)
Because he wanted to look cool pretending he was driving a racing car?

Sorry, I am against people pretending to be racing drivers, it gives us real racing drivers a bad reputation!

As for a 6 pt harness in a road car, it seems alot of faf just to pop to the shops, its probably better to use a 4pt.

Edited by absolutely on Monday 26th May 16:34
Yes I would agree a 6pt in a road car is at worst a PITA, but thats not what the original question was. After many years of prepping race cars I fancy a bit of track time for myself. Rather than go half hearted I have spent roughly 5 times as much on the safety items than the original price of the car.
Sure its only an old CRX but my rule has always been to make it safe first - then faster.

Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Monday 26th May 2008
quotequote all
Hi smile

Regarding speed of putting 6 points on and off...

I use my car as a daily driver with a full race seat and 6 points, and to connect all the connectors takes ...maybe 10 seconds and to release them around 1 second as its just twist the centre fixing buckle...

I "feel" a LOT safer than if I was using a normal 3 point inertia....

And with my Racing experience...I "KNOW" I am safer in a major smash...

All the best Brett smile