Lazer Guns, and rain... Are they type approved for this???
Discussion
As the title staes, are the Lazer guns used by plod (LTI20:20 etc) type approved to be used in the rain? I see to remember some time ago that the light reflection back to the unit was distorted in the rain, therefore the possibilty of an incorrect reading was possible...
Thanks in advance
Mr F
Thanks in advance
Mr F
Doesn't the laser gun mesure the doplar shift in the light reflected by the car. If so, a raindrop or any other material that would refract and scatter the light would be unlikely to return to the device and it seems pretty much impossible that it would be usable for any sort of reading at all.
No idea if that's really the case. But that's just what logic tells me.
No idea if that's really the case. But that's just what logic tells me.
slow_poke said:
How about using it through the windscreen of the car? I see that a lot over here with the Gardai.
The ACPO Code of Practice for Operational Use of Road Enforcement Technology (2004 v2.3) states: "The beam must not be projected through glass or mirrors."However, this is the infamous document that although it also states very clearly that "It is imperative that the procedures set out in this Manual are applied scrupulously" [note the reference to it being a "Manual" and to "procedures", and the use of the word "imperative" and the phrase "applied scrupulously"] seems to be regarded as "mostly harmless" [with apologies to Douglas Adams].
Streaky
ajstephe said:
I haven't been informed of anything like this certainly not with the Pro Laser that we've used, however there is no way in hell you're going to get me doing speed enforcement in this weather or rain of any sort.
So you're saying you only go out when conditions are safer, i.e. dry, good visibility etc. but you don't like enforcing the speed limit when accidents are more likely to occur through inappropriate speed, i.e. rain fog etc........ safety.......right...

MilnerR said:
ajstephe said:
I haven't been informed of anything like this certainly not with the Pro Laser that we've used, however there is no way in hell you're going to get me doing speed enforcement in this weather or rain of any sort.
So you're saying you only go out when conditions are safer, i.e. dry, good visibility etc. but you don't like enforcing the speed limit when accidents are more likely to occur through inappropriate speed, i.e. rain fog etc........ safety.......right...

SM
supermono said:
MilnerR said:
ajstephe said:
I haven't been informed of anything like this certainly not with the Pro Laser that we've used, however there is no way in hell you're going to get me doing speed enforcement in this weather or rain of any sort.
So you're saying you only go out when conditions are safer, i.e. dry, good visibility etc. but you don't like enforcing the speed limit when accidents are more likely to occur through inappropriate speed, i.e. rain fog etc........ safety.......right...

SM
streaky said:
slow_poke said:
How about using it through the windscreen of the car? I see that a lot over here with the Gardai.
The ACPO Code of Practice for Operational Use of Road Enforcement Technology (2004 v2.3) states: "The beam must not be projected through glass or mirrors."However, this is the infamous document that although it also states very clearly that "It is imperative that the procedures set out in this Manual are applied scrupulously" [note the reference to it being a "Manual" and to "procedures", and the use of the word "imperative" and the phrase "applied scrupulously"] seems to be regarded as "mostly harmless" [with apologies to Douglas Adams].
Streaky
Now, the next question is: Does the Republic have a similar Code of Practice or Type Approval process for these instruments, and how do I find out about it?
slow_poke said:
How about using it through the windscreen of the car? I see that a lot over here with the Gardai.
Windscreens affect the reading by scattering a portion of the light every which way, although the 'rules' that relate to this are only guidelines, so they can do what they want, no matter of the consequences or the truth.rain reduces the range.
Rain drops are very similar to the reflective background on a numberplate - transparent spheres, and so spherical raindrops can reflect the pulses straight back.
quick lesson in laser guns...................
44 short pulses of infrared laser light are sent in quick succession. The reflected pulses are timed and recorded along with the intensity and shape.
The gradient of the time differentials is arrived at using root mean square for best fit.
Any timings too far outside this are disregarded. In other words, translated into distance, if the readings went like this..............
174.5m 174.6m 174.7m 174.8m 32m 175.0m 175.1m 175.2
then the 32m would be disregarded as it was clearly from something else - raindrop?
if more than 13 get thrown out then error code.
If at least 30 are correct, they are all tested for consistant shape and intensity, if not, thrown out again.
If it recieves more pulses back than were sent - error JAM CODE
It if gets nothing back - no reading.
so, rain can screw things, and the greater the distance - and the heavier the rain, the more likely that errors will occur as there are more rain drops to go through.
Doesn't affect the accuracy of a reading though, unless you were tracking a raindrop blowing horizontally toward/away from you!
hope that helps
Rain drops are very similar to the reflective background on a numberplate - transparent spheres, and so spherical raindrops can reflect the pulses straight back.
quick lesson in laser guns...................
44 short pulses of infrared laser light are sent in quick succession. The reflected pulses are timed and recorded along with the intensity and shape.
The gradient of the time differentials is arrived at using root mean square for best fit.
Any timings too far outside this are disregarded. In other words, translated into distance, if the readings went like this..............
174.5m 174.6m 174.7m 174.8m 32m 175.0m 175.1m 175.2
then the 32m would be disregarded as it was clearly from something else - raindrop?
if more than 13 get thrown out then error code.
If at least 30 are correct, they are all tested for consistant shape and intensity, if not, thrown out again.
If it recieves more pulses back than were sent - error JAM CODE
It if gets nothing back - no reading.
so, rain can screw things, and the greater the distance - and the heavier the rain, the more likely that errors will occur as there are more rain drops to go through.
Doesn't affect the accuracy of a reading though, unless you were tracking a raindrop blowing horizontally toward/away from you!
hope that helps
Ravell said:
Doesn't the laser gun mesure the doplar shift in the light reflected by the car. If so, a raindrop or any other material that would refract and scatter the light would be unlikely to return to the device and it seems pretty much impossible that it would be usable for any sort of reading at all.
No idea if that's really the case. But that's just what logic tells me.
sort of correct. It 'measures' the dopplar shift in the frequency of the pulse intervals I suppose, but not the dopplar shift of the light itself. Dopplar shift of light as a percentage would be miniscule. You generally don't see cars turn red as they drive away, and blue as they drive toward you! No idea if that's really the case. But that's just what logic tells me.
@ the OP, Sorry, I'm not usually a pedant, but...
.. since when did stimulated begin with a 'z' ????
I'm not happy about the Americanisation of the English language especially the substution of s to z although I will concede in certain cases it is more appropiate eg. colonization, however there are limits.
It doesn't matter how hard anyone tries to dispose of the unique beauty of the english language no one can fu4k with acronyms, it breaks them. And that means you too!
/rant
.. since when did stimulated begin with a 'z' ????
I'm not happy about the Americanisation of the English language especially the substution of s to z although I will concede in certain cases it is more appropiate eg. colonization, however there are limits.
It doesn't matter how hard anyone tries to dispose of the unique beauty of the english language no one can fu4k with acronyms, it breaks them. And that means you too!
/rant
mattley said:
@ the OP, Sorry, I'm not usually a pedant, but...
.. since when did stimulated begin with a 'z' ????
I'm not happy about the Americanisation of the English language especially the substution of s to z although I will concede in certain cases it is more appropiate eg. colonization, however there are limits.
It doesn't matter how hard anyone tries to dispose of the unique beauty of the english language no one can fu4k with acronyms, it breaks them. And that means you too!
/rant
Much American spelling draws upon the English spelling of 300 or so years ago - Streaky.. since when did stimulated begin with a 'z' ????
I'm not happy about the Americanisation of the English language especially the substution of s to z although I will concede in certain cases it is more appropiate eg. colonization, however there are limits.
It doesn't matter how hard anyone tries to dispose of the unique beauty of the english language no one can fu4k with acronyms, it breaks them. And that means you too!
/rant
streaky said:
Much American spelling draws upon the English spelling of 300 or so years ago - Streaky
My point is that laser is an acronym and as such can never be spelt with a z in the middle.Edited by mattley on Tuesday 27th May 22:55for ppor speeling and formmmaintg.
Edited by mattley on Tuesday 27th May 22:56
mattley said:
streaky said:
Much American spelling draws upon the English spelling of 300 or so years ago - Streaky
My point is that laser is an acronym and as such can never be spelt with a z in the middle.Whilst on the subject of pedantry:
mattley said:
It doesn't matter how hard anyone tries to dispose of the unique beauty of the english language no one can fu4k with acronyms, it breaks them.
"English" should have a capital letter and "language" should have been followed by a comma
- StreakyPS - perhaps the OP is a fan of the poetry of Hank Lazer - S
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




