Public Order Act 1986
Author
Discussion

bite-me

Original Poster:

524 posts

258 months

Wednesday 28th May 2008
quotequote all

Does a dwelling mean a house? or a building say for example in a public place like a club ?


ta
(2) An offence under this section may be committed in a public or a private place, except that no offence is committed where the words or behaviour are used, or the writing, sign or other visible representation is displayed, by a person inside a dwelling and the person who is harassed, alarmed or distressed is also inside that or another dwelling.

Nedrick

404 posts

222 months

Wednesday 28th May 2008
quotequote all
Hi. Dwelling means a dwelling, i.e. somewhere you live. It may or may not include communal areas etc and this would be determined on the evidence available as to its use. It would include a tent IF it was a dwelling at that time. Hope this helps.

The Tea Boy

4,129 posts

266 months

Wednesday 28th May 2008
quotequote all
Nedrick said:
Hi. Dwelling means a dwelling, i.e. somewhere you live. It may or may not include communal areas etc and this would be determined on the evidence available as to its use. It would include a tent IF it was a dwelling at that time. Hope this helps.

pretty much as above, a dwelling is an inhabitable area of space AFAIK

matt

satchbot

1,916 posts

227 months

Wednesday 28th May 2008
quotequote all
For the purposes of the Public Order Act 1986, the term 'dwelling' means:
Any structure or part of a structure occupied as a person's home or as other living accommodation (whether the occupation is separate or shared with others) but does not include any part not so occupied, and for this purpose 'structure' includes a tent, caravan, vehicle, vessel or other temporary or moveable structure. Section 8 Public Order Act 1986.


Mg6b

6,649 posts

294 months

Wednesday 28th May 2008
quotequote all
Public place can be anywhere including any building that entry is by payment or otherwise if the public have access to it. Pubs, clubs and bars are public places even though they may be private property. Communal areas such as stairways and hallways in blocks of flats or apartments are public areas and not dwellings even though they are within a private building. Private clubs that cater for members only may not be public places. This does not include dwellings which has already been explained above.

bite-me

Original Poster:

524 posts

258 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
thankxs guy's

so a club is classified as a public place as it is not a dwelling.

Whilst it is not exclusive for members only (i.e. pay and enter) or become a member.

therefore "public order" would apply


Nedrick

404 posts

222 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
Public place is a whole different kettle of fish. The best way to think of it is 'Do the general public have access on payment or otherwise?'. So a cinema when it is open is a pubic place even if you have to pay, but once it shuts it no longer is. Arguments happen if it has unrestricted access even though it is closed such as a park closed at night but with no gates...

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
A dwelling can be a public place at times and a dwelling at others (e.g. National Trust properties) - Streaky

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
bite-me said:
thankxs guy's

so a club is classified as a public place as it is not a dwelling.

Whilst it is not exclusive for members only (i.e. pay and enter) or become a member.

therefore "public order" would apply
You are getting your definitions a bit mixed. The specific section referred to does not require a place to be a public place for the offence to be committed only that it should not be a dwelling.

The problem with the definitions, such as a public place, is that they can vary from act to act. Premises, for instance, can mean a field for some drugs offences.

So club premises is probably not a public place but it is also not a dwelling.

Mg6b

6,649 posts

294 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
bite-me said:
thankxs guy's

so a club is classified as a public place as it is not a dwelling.

Whilst it is not exclusive for members only (i.e. pay and enter) or become a member.

therefore "public order" would apply
The ethos of the public order act was not to address domestic disputes within families etc. That is why dwelling is specified in the act.

However. If one of the people who the conduct is aimed at or who is harassed alarmed or distressed by the conduct is outside that dwelling and the person committing the act is inside it, the offence is complete.

Two people in opposite houses both in dwellings making obscene gestures at each other cannot come within the scope of the POA as they are both in a dwelling albeit different ones.

Affray can be committed anywhere and only one person indulging in that conduct is necessary. Dwellings do not come into Affray. This is part of the POA.

A private club means exactly that. Only members can enter. Payment on the door does not imply membership as there is in implication that anyone can pay the money to gain entry at that particular moment from the general public who walk past.

Private club is about vetted members who apply and wait for acceptance by the club before they can join and use those facilities. No public are allowed other than as guests of the members.

I hope that explains it for you.






Edited by Mg6b on Thursday 29th May 10:09

Mg6b

6,649 posts

294 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
So club premises is probably not a public place but it is also not a dwelling.
Derek.
we treat clubs as in 'Chicago's' drinking dens as a public places even though the punters pay to get in.
CPS have so far agreed that this is the case when it kicks off and someone is gripped up for unruliness.

When the punters have left. The premises revert to private but not a dwelling.
As you are aware, POA offences can be committed in public or private.

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
Mg6b said:
Derek Smith said:
So club premises is probably not a public place but it is also not a dwelling.
Derek.
we treat clubs as in 'Chicago's' drinking dens as a public places even though the punters pay to get in.
CPS have so far agreed that this is the case when it kicks off and someone is gripped up for unruliness.

When the punters have left. The premises revert to private but not a dwelling.
As you are aware, POA offences can be committed in public or private.
I used to teach (although not very well) intepretation of statutes to CID courses and some others and, because I knew I was a bit confused, I went to CPS with some 40-odd questions. I can't remember the actual number, but they were definitive on about five. In the end all I did was teach the fact that definitions are often not definitive. I took two periods on public place and one criticism was that they were more confused after the course than before and I thought, well, a successful lesson. Mind you, I used to start the series of lessons by asking everyone to define a particular legal word or phrase. If, at the end of my input they could still define it is as few words then I knew I had failed.

I remember one statute where the word 'entry' was used as a place. This irritated me no end as not only had I never heard the word used that way before, nor had anyone in my office. In the end a chap from Liverpool explained it and actually got a photograph of one. It is, evidently, a 'northern' word. I didn't know they had laws in Liverpool.

But I take your point about these clubs. It's all a question of fact, isn't it.

Jasandjules

72,703 posts

260 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
With all due respect, if law was as simple as this means that, then there would be little need for lawyers to argue it all out. Very little is ever clear cut IMHO.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
... I remember one statute where the word 'entry' was used as a place. This irritated me no end as not only had I never heard the word used that way before, nor had anyone in my office. In the end a chap from Liverpool explained it and actually got a photograph of one. It is, evidently, a 'northern' word. I didn't know they had laws in Liverpool.
Unless clearly defined in the interpretation, dialect words have no place in statute. In local bye law, possibly, but not in national statute - Streaky

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
Derek Smith said:
... I remember one statute where the word 'entry' was used as a place. This irritated me no end as not only had I never heard the word used that way before, nor had anyone in my office. In the end a chap from Liverpool explained it and actually got a photograph of one. It is, evidently, a 'northern' word. I didn't know they had laws in Liverpool.
Unless clearly defined in the interpretation, dialect words have no place in statute. In local bye law, possibly, but not in national statute - Streaky
It was Victorian legislation and the word had fallen out of common use apart from hup north and, probably, the Isle of Wight.

bite-me

Original Poster:

524 posts

258 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
oh dear frown (confused)

the sceanrio is this Derek,

I go to a club, which has paying members but is not exclucivly for members. Anyone can come off the street and pay and come in.

it is a dance club. if a person at that club is harresed/langauge etc does that come under the public order act.




Derek Smith said:
bite-me said:
thankxs guy's

so a club is classified as a public place as it is not a dwelling.

Whilst it is not exclusive for members only (i.e. pay and enter) or become a member.

therefore "public order" would apply
You are getting your definitions a bit mixed. The specific section referred to does not require a place to be a public place for the offence to be committed only that it should not be a dwelling.

The problem with the definitions, such as a public place, is that they can vary from act to act. Premises, for instance, can mean a field for some drugs offences.

So club premises is probably not a public place but it is also not a dwelling.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
streaky said:
Derek Smith said:
... I remember one statute where the word 'entry' was used as a place. This irritated me no end as not only had I never heard the word used that way before, nor had anyone in my office. In the end a chap from Liverpool explained it and actually got a photograph of one. It is, evidently, a 'northern' word. I didn't know they had laws in Liverpool.
Unless clearly defined in the interpretation, dialect words have no place in statute. In local bye law, possibly, but not in national statute - Streaky
It was Victorian legislation and the word had fallen out of common use apart from hup north and, probably, the Isle of Wight.
Gawd, strewth, cor blimey, love a duck, Derek ... I hadn't realised you were in the job that long ago!wink - Streaky

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
bite-me said:
oh dear frown (confused)

the sceanrio is this Derek,

I go to a club, which has paying members but is not exclucivly for members. Anyone can come off the street and pay and come in.

it is a dance club. if a person at that club is harresed/langauge etc does that come under the public order act.
Being confused shows you understand it to an extent.

However, 'yes' is the simple answer. It may or may not be a public place, depending on which bit of legislation you are referring to, but it is most certainly not a dwelling.

There was an interesting bit of case law which said, in essence, that whether a place was in public depended on whether or not the public was there or likely to be there at the specific time. Making it even more cloudy.

streaky said:
Gawd, strewth, cor blimey, love a duck, Derek ... I hadn't realised you were in the job that long ago!wink - Streaky
Now that’s not very nice.

I do love the wording of some of the old legislations. Wilfully, openly, lewdly and obscenely; almost an art form.

When I was a busy little PC I used to have the occasional afternoon session put by for me at our local magistrates court. I once brought up two rather obscure bits of case law in my submissions and one, dating back to the Luddites, rather threw the clerk.

The following dedicated afternoon the clerk, who rejoiced in the name of Trout, said to me in front of the magistrates but before the court really started: Has PC Smith got any case law he wishes to bring to my attention? I could delve into the archives now if he wishes, rather than delay the hearings.

He was a subtle type of chap. We once had an argument about fraudulent use of an excise licence. He said something to the magistrates which was wrong and me, being less than up and running with the niceties of court etiquette, contradicted him. He slapped me down quite firmly but the magistrate asked Trout about the stated case I’d quoted. Not being able to resist putting the boot in I said that it was in Stones, which was tantamount to saying he should have known about it.

The court inspector took me to one side afterwards and explained the powers inherent in the position of clerk of the court. I was much nicer to him after that. But he wasn’t to me.

Chrispy Porker

17,764 posts

259 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
bite-me said:
oh dear frown (confused)

the sceanrio is this Derek,

I go to a club, which has paying members but is not exclucivly for members. Anyone can come off the street and pay and come in.

it is a dance club. if a person at that club is harresed/langauge etc does that come under the public order act.




Derek Smith said:
bite-me said:
thankxs guy's

so a club is classified as a public place as it is not a dwelling.

Whilst it is not exclusive for members only (i.e. pay and enter) or become a member.

therefore "public order" would apply
You are getting your definitions a bit mixed. The specific section referred to does not require a place to be a public place for the offence to be committed only that it should not be a dwelling.

The problem with the definitions, such as a public place, is that they can vary from act to act. Premises, for instance, can mean a field for some drugs offences.

So club premises is probably not a public place but it is also not a dwelling.
I am old. Bear with me.
What is a 'dance club'?
a. Where people go after the pubs have shut for sex drugs and rock n roll?
b. Where parents take their children for ballet lessons?
c. Something I have yet to encounter.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
bite-me said:
oh dear frown (confused)

the sceanrio is this Derek,

I go to a club, which has paying members but is not exclucivly for members. Anyone can come off the street and pay and come in.

it is a dance club. if a person at that club is harresed/langauge etc does that come under the public order act.




Derek Smith said:
bite-me said:
thankxs guy's

so a club is classified as a public place as it is not a dwelling.

Whilst it is not exclusive for members only (i.e. pay and enter) or become a member.

therefore "public order" would apply
You are getting your definitions a bit mixed. The specific section referred to does not require a place to be a public place for the offence to be committed only that it should not be a dwelling.

The problem with the definitions, such as a public place, is that they can vary from act to act. Premises, for instance, can mean a field for some drugs offences.

So club premises is probably not a public place but it is also not a dwelling.
I am old. Bear with me.
What is a 'dance club'?
a. Where people go after the pubs have shut for sex drugs and rock n roll?
b. Where parents take their children for ballet lessons?
c. Something I have yet to encounter.
CP - you, Derek and I would have known such an establishment as the "Palais" wink - Streaky

ETA:

PS - with apologies to Derek if I've made him too old again smile - S

PPS - and to you too CP - S

Edited by streaky on Thursday 29th May 21:51