In Court a Week Today
Discussion
Hi people, im looking for some advice on a speeding matter. all details are on pepipoo, but there have been a few developements today which i need some clarification on, as im not familiar with the judicial process or court paper work and what it means. thanks for you help.
thread on pepipoo
http://forums.pepipoo.com/index.php?showtopic=2789...
thread on pepipoo
http://forums.pepipoo.com/index.php?showtopic=2789...
Were you speeding? If the BiB have formed the opinion you were speeding this is enough evidence though it may be difficult to agree on what speed other than you were in excess of the limit.
Did you ask for the calibration certificate? Maybe you would have been better to have gone for a Newton Hearing.
Did you ask for the calibration certificate? Maybe you would have been better to have gone for a Newton Hearing.
that doesnt appear to be fair though, because surely he would have to have evidence to back up his allegations, i mean otherwise he could have jus made it up, i mean he had a sc with him, a statement has not been submitted by him, this is strange as 2 witnesses are better than one in my opinion, i just dont understand what the cps have based their case on. it is not even a written statement the police officer has submitted, jus a template filled in with my details etc.
many thanks norton 300
many thanks norton 300
Of the various methods used to detect speeding one available to Bib is 'the follow'
Having formed the opinion a person is exceeding the speed limit he needs corroboration by law and should follow you at a constant distance over least 2.10th mile and note the minimum/max speeds shown on his speedo between points that may be loosely described. If limit exceeded then a stop can follow. bear in mind he has further corroboration in the presence of the SC. Note the earlier comment about 2 being better than 1.
You mention 3 miles and over which gives ample distance to settle behind and do a check. It may well be then when you pulled out of the Garage he was on a fast run and as you accelerated away (noted use of the offside (fast) lane he dropped on you.
That shown on the summons after details of the offence is the legislation - the law in detail that has been infringed.
The fact that the wrong model has been stated is inconsequential and will not result in charge being dropped.
From the speed the officer quoted then 100 at NSL is an automatic Court referral without the option of a FPN.
Seems you have two options.
(1) Plead guilty, raise Newton hearing and accept, or
(2) Advise Court that you wish to plead not Guilty and ask for dislosure of all the evidence in the case. Errors should be apparent on which to argue.
If you are entering a NG plea and undefended by a Brief then recommend you attend your local Court one day and listen/watch a few cases to see the order of play and what occurs.
dvd
Having formed the opinion a person is exceeding the speed limit he needs corroboration by law and should follow you at a constant distance over least 2.10th mile and note the minimum/max speeds shown on his speedo between points that may be loosely described. If limit exceeded then a stop can follow. bear in mind he has further corroboration in the presence of the SC. Note the earlier comment about 2 being better than 1.
You mention 3 miles and over which gives ample distance to settle behind and do a check. It may well be then when you pulled out of the Garage he was on a fast run and as you accelerated away (noted use of the offside (fast) lane he dropped on you.
That shown on the summons after details of the offence is the legislation - the law in detail that has been infringed.
The fact that the wrong model has been stated is inconsequential and will not result in charge being dropped.
From the speed the officer quoted then 100 at NSL is an automatic Court referral without the option of a FPN.
Seems you have two options.
(1) Plead guilty, raise Newton hearing and accept, or
(2) Advise Court that you wish to plead not Guilty and ask for dislosure of all the evidence in the case. Errors should be apparent on which to argue.
If you are entering a NG plea and undefended by a Brief then recommend you attend your local Court one day and listen/watch a few cases to see the order of play and what occurs.
dvd
Edited by Dwight VanDriver on Thursday 29th May 08:34
This may not be wholly relevant, but there is almost always an issue where a police officer says they, "Had to drive at 100+ mph to catch the accused."
That does not indicate the speed of the vehicle in front, but simply reflects the initial speed of the police vehicle and the distance it was behind at the start of the 'chase'.
The trouble is, the Courts hear the speed given and think that was the speed the accused was doing. Sadly, too many defence solicitors let this pass unchallenged.
Streaky
That does not indicate the speed of the vehicle in front, but simply reflects the initial speed of the police vehicle and the distance it was behind at the start of the 'chase'.
The trouble is, the Courts hear the speed given and think that was the speed the accused was doing. Sadly, too many defence solicitors let this pass unchallenged.
Streaky
What was the proximity of that first marker from the petrol station? I seem to get the impression it was rather close. I assume you have some sort of timed and dated proof of having been there and a 320 isn't very fast. Maybe you could draw out some sort of a diagram showing how your car would perform from a standing start against those markers worked with WOT? Speed at passing first, speed at passing second, prove that you couldn't have possibly averaged 100?
Won't that weaken his assertion that he'd followed you?
SM
Won't that weaken his assertion that he'd followed you?
SM
Similar thing happened to me.
was pulled over and told I was followed for 0.4 miles and averaged between 92 and 98. no video evidence, they told me this was checked using their callibrated speedo. I was given a FPN which had a speed of 95 noted down.
Now I was sure I wasnt going that fast, but I knew I was definately over 70, so I accepted the FPN as I was in fact guilty of speeding, so would have next to no chance in court.
was pulled over and told I was followed for 0.4 miles and averaged between 92 and 98. no video evidence, they told me this was checked using their callibrated speedo. I was given a FPN which had a speed of 95 noted down.
Now I was sure I wasnt going that fast, but I knew I was definately over 70, so I accepted the FPN as I was in fact guilty of speeding, so would have next to no chance in court.
Hi Norton,
Sorry to hear about your situation, and from what Ive read so far you're facing an uphill battle.
Just a few questions:
1) Have you had any correspondence with the CPS where you're requested evidence of the calibration on the Volvo's speedo?
2) Do you still have the receipt from the garage that you pulled out from initially? If so, how far from the entrance to the garage was it 'till you were stopped?
3) At what point did you see the Police Volvo in your rear view mirror? And was he approaching you at speed?
If you are knowledgeable and confidant in cross-examination in court you MAY be able to find some room for manouver, however I think you might want to capitulate.
Sorry to hear about your situation, and from what Ive read so far you're facing an uphill battle.
Just a few questions:
1) Have you had any correspondence with the CPS where you're requested evidence of the calibration on the Volvo's speedo?
2) Do you still have the receipt from the garage that you pulled out from initially? If so, how far from the entrance to the garage was it 'till you were stopped?
3) At what point did you see the Police Volvo in your rear view mirror? And was he approaching you at speed?
If you are knowledgeable and confidant in cross-examination in court you MAY be able to find some room for manouver, however I think you might want to capitulate.
justamin said:
Hi Norton,
Sorry to hear about your situation, and from what Ive read so far you're facing an uphill battle.
Just a few questions:
1) Have you had any correspondence with the CPS where you're requested evidence of the calibration on the Volvo's speedo?
2) Do you still have the receipt from the garage that you pulled out from initially? If so, how far from the entrance to the garage was it 'till you were stopped?
3) At what point did you see the Police Volvo in your rear view mirror? And was he approaching you at speed?
If you are knowledgeable and confidant in cross-examination in court you MAY be able to find some room for manouver, however I think you might want to capitulate.
Thanks everybody for your responses.Sorry to hear about your situation, and from what Ive read so far you're facing an uphill battle.
Just a few questions:
1) Have you had any correspondence with the CPS where you're requested evidence of the calibration on the Volvo's speedo?
2) Do you still have the receipt from the garage that you pulled out from initially? If so, how far from the entrance to the garage was it 'till you were stopped?
3) At what point did you see the Police Volvo in your rear view mirror? And was he approaching you at speed?
If you are knowledgeable and confidant in cross-examination in court you MAY be able to find some room for manouver, however I think you might want to capitulate.
1 i received an evidence disclosure from the CPS yesterday stating that the would only be using the officers statement and he will be attending court on the day. i phoned the CPS today because there was no mention of the calibration certificates in the correspondence they sent me, the CPS lawyer told me that they had been requested but so far have not been produced, fingers crossed they cant by thursday. can you clarify something for me, the letter was dated 15th may, but was date stamped in the post office on 27th, 12 days after it was written. i still have the envelope in case i need it.
2. im not to sure whether i paid cash or used a card, so im goin to look at my bank statements. i already asked the garage owner for cctv footage but they only keep it on a 2 week cycle unfortunately. i was stopped approximately 4 miles from the garage junction where i pulled out from. but the officers statement says he began 'pacing' me approx a mile away from the garage. why did he only 'pace' me for 0.4 miles when he was apparently behind me for several mile, surely the longer the 'pace' the stronger the case against me. the point im making is that he never followed me where he said he did on his statement, i was doing 50mph when he closed up on me at speed nearly 4 miles away from the garage and approx 2.6 to 3 miles where he alleges to have paced me. hence why he jus estimates my alleged speed on his statement, and for it to be exactly 100mph and not in a range of say 80-100mph suprises me.
3. i was the only car on the dual carriageway as it was 9pm an dark. i seen a set of head lights in my rear view mirror, i realised the person was travelling at an excessive speed so began signalling to make my way over so they could pass, before i knew it they were right up my arse and then i could see it wsa a police car because of the light bar. he was at no time behind me at a equal distance but merely closed up on me. he follwed me into the inside lane and matched my speed of 50mph.
what does capitulate mean? i presume reconsider my plea? it makes my blood boil because i know the officer in incorrect in his version of events.
i really appreciate everybodys inputs, i cannot afford to have a solicitor so this is my only form of legal advice. so thanks everybody. also on the day of the hearing would i be eligible for the duty solictor, jus for a some support in the court room
thanks guys
norton
If it was a follow at that speed there should be some inf in the officers statement that after the event he tested the speedo of the vehicle over a measured mile by stopwatch or rolling road. If that isn't there then how can they prove speedo of Plodmobile accurate.
Get to Court early Norton, seek out the Court Duty Solicitor, he may offer help/ advice or even take you case on board.
dvd
Get to Court early Norton, seek out the Court Duty Solicitor, he may offer help/ advice or even take you case on board.
dvd
Although there are small differences in yours and the officer's opinions on what happened and exactly where it happened, these aren't really defences against the allegation.
If you go to Magistrates and start arguing over which part of a 4 miles stretch you were followed and whether or not the speedo was calibrated, you run the risk of annoying the bench and finding yourself in deeper waters.
I would only plead not guilty and argue if you feel you have enough of a case to completely discredit the allegation of speeding. Otherwise you will be found guilty.
You have recourse to plead guilty and dispute the speed- which is what I suggest you do if you really don't believe you were speeding to the extent the officer says you were.
What you should really consider is if it's better for you to plead guilty to the entire allegation and mitigate to get a smaller penalty. With your description of the case so far that would be my way of looking at it.
If you go to Magistrates and start arguing over which part of a 4 miles stretch you were followed and whether or not the speedo was calibrated, you run the risk of annoying the bench and finding yourself in deeper waters.
I would only plead not guilty and argue if you feel you have enough of a case to completely discredit the allegation of speeding. Otherwise you will be found guilty.
You have recourse to plead guilty and dispute the speed- which is what I suggest you do if you really don't believe you were speeding to the extent the officer says you were.
What you should really consider is if it's better for you to plead guilty to the entire allegation and mitigate to get a smaller penalty. With your description of the case so far that would be my way of looking at it.
Dwight VanDriver said:
If it was a follow at that speed there should be some inf in the officers statement that after the event he tested the speedo of the vehicle over a measured mile by stopwatch or rolling road. If that isn't there then how can they prove speedo of Plodmobile accurate.
Get to Court early Norton, seek out the Court Duty Solicitor, he may offer help/ advice or even take you case on board.
dvd
thanks everyone for your replys,Get to Court early Norton, seek out the Court Duty Solicitor, he may offer help/ advice or even take you case on board.
dvd
what im sayin is he never at one point during the dual carriageway did he follow me for 0.4 miles at an equal distance to ascertain my speed. im not stupid i was the only car on the dual carriageway, and IF i was to be travelling at those speeds i would sure as hell but aware of a car travellin behind me as i would suspect it was police.
does he have to do this measured mile as procedure? the officer has not submitted a written statement i was expecting. it is just a fill in the blanks type of form used by north wales police. so does not actually give in any detail of what actually happened. also there is no mention of such info in the officers pnb to say he travelled a measured mile.
also jus another couple of pointers, when in the car, i was not told what speed he alleged me to be doin, he gave me a choice of cofpn or court. when i challenged the officer he said oh well doesnt matter now let the judge decide. does this bear any significance because i was not actually presented with any evidence in the car to back up the officers claims and the feeling i got was he was tryin to get me to accept a cofpn because he said he couldnt force a cofpn on me. which i thought was strange because if he was certain i was speeding and say doing 57 mph what would he have done? issued a cofpn.
i know eveyone is sayin jus plead guilty you were speeding etc, but i find it hard to explain to everyone the situation an the way i see it.
hopefully you can clarify the points raised for me.
You just keep playing the "if" game. Either you were speeding or you weren't. If you can you need to convince the magistrates/DJ that you were not doing 100 mph. Sounds like you got pulled by traffic who would almost certainly have a video in the car. If that is the case request it is viewed. If not then the evidence should be looked at by someone who understands it (not wishing to patronise but you sound like you are in need of a solicitor)
57 for example makes no difference an endorsable FPN cannot be issued without agreement(the reciever has to sign).
57 for example makes no difference an endorsable FPN cannot be issued without agreement(the reciever has to sign).
norton3000 said:
Dwight VanDriver said:
If it was a follow at that speed there should be some inf in the officers statement that after the event he tested the speedo of the vehicle over a measured mile by stopwatch or rolling road. If that isn't there then how can they prove speedo of Plodmobile accurate.
Get to Court early Norton, seek out the Court Duty Solicitor, he may offer help/ advice or even take you case on board.
dvd
thanks everyone for your replys,Get to Court early Norton, seek out the Court Duty Solicitor, he may offer help/ advice or even take you case on board.
dvd
what im sayin is he never at one point during the dual carriageway did he follow me for 0.4 miles at an equal distance to ascertain my speed. im not stupid i was the only car on the dual carriageway, and IF i was to be travelling at those speeds i would sure as hell but aware of a car travellin behind me as i would suspect it was police.
does he have to do this measured mile as procedure? the officer has not submitted a written statement i was expecting. it is just a fill in the blanks type of form used by north wales police. so does not actually give in any detail of what actually happened. also there is no mention of such info in the officers pnb to say he travelled a measured mile.
also jus another couple of pointers, when in the car, i was not told what speed he alleged me to be doin, he gave me a choice of cofpn or court. when i challenged the officer he said oh well doesnt matter now let the judge decide. does this bear any significance because i was not actually presented with any evidence in the car to back up the officers claims and the feeling i got was he was tryin to get me to accept a cofpn because he said he couldnt force a cofpn on me. which i thought was strange because if he was certain i was speeding and say doing 57 mph what would he have done? issued a cofpn.
i know eveyone is sayin jus plead guilty you were speeding etc, but i find it hard to explain to everyone the situation an the way i see it.
hopefully you can clarify the points raised for me.
i was not speeding, there was no video in the car, was nothin in the car. at the roadside he shown me nothin. the reason i keep pointing out the fact he never follwed me at the points is because i feel i need to convince the bench that he di not follow procedures, and follow me correctly, the only time he was behind me at an equal distance was when he had caught up with me.
does it seem strange that the sc hasnt submitted a statement? surely it would back the officers claims up if their stories matched!!! my point being they wont!!! so would work for my case rather than against.
so the officer never done a measured mile after the event and recorded in pnb, this doesnt matter then?
i wish i could afford a solictor but unfortunatly i cant, do i have entitlement to the duty solictor on the day? sorry to come across as i dont know what im talking about, i dont. but im really gratefull you guys have taken the time to reply
thanks norton 3000
does it seem strange that the sc hasnt submitted a statement? surely it would back the officers claims up if their stories matched!!! my point being they wont!!! so would work for my case rather than against.
so the officer never done a measured mile after the event and recorded in pnb, this doesnt matter then?
i wish i could afford a solictor but unfortunatly i cant, do i have entitlement to the duty solictor on the day? sorry to come across as i dont know what im talking about, i dont. but im really gratefull you guys have taken the time to reply
thanks norton 3000
Edited by norton3000 on Friday 30th May 19:02
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


