New guidance on CCTV
Discussion
Issued by the Information Commissioner, updating that issued in 2000.
Among other things, it says:
Using CCTV can be privacy intrusive, as it is capable of putting a lot of law-abiding people under surveillance and recording their movements as they go about their day to day activities. You should carefully consider whether to use it; the fact that it is possible, affordable or has public support should not be the primary motivating factor. You should take into account what benefits can be gained, whether better solutions exist, and what effect it may have on individuals.
In many cases there are better ways of tackling the requirement ... just as road engineering might be better than speed limit reduction and scamera installation.
It is important that a CCTV system produces images that are of a suitable quality for the purpose for which the system was installed. If identification is necessary, then poor quality images which do not help to identify individuals may undermine the purpose for installing the system.
Too many installed CCTV systems produce images that are useless for identification. It's amusing when the operator of the system (especially commercial, but public sector too) is shocked that the images they have are unacceptable (and commonly inadmissable too). Then they say, "Well, management won't fork out for a better system!"
CCTV must not be used to record conversations between members of the public as this is highly intrusive and unlikely to be justified. You should choose a system without this facility if possible. If your system comes equipped with a sound recording facility then you should turn this off or disable it in some other way.
There are a good many systems installed that have sound recording turned on. There are some justifications, such as in a charge suite and "audio-based alert systems, but in this latter, conversations must not be recorded, and operators should not listen in. [Note the distinction between mandatory and desirable.]
regarding disclosure, the guidance says: Disclosure of images from the CCTV system must also be controlled and consistent with the purpose for which the system was established. For example, if the system is established to help prevent and detect crime it will be appropriate to disclose images to law enforcement agencies where a crime needs to be investigated, but it would not be appropriate to disclose images of identifiable individuals to the media for entertainment purposes or place them on the internet. Images can be released to the media for identification purposes; this should not generally be done by anyone other than a law enforcement agency.
This might affect the "cops on camera" type TV programmes.
On retention, the guidance does not prescribe any specific minimum or maximum retention periods, but says that retention should reflect the organisation’s own purposes for recording images. In particular it states that: You should not keep images for longer than strictly necessary to meet your own purposes for recording them. On occasion, you may need to retain images for a longer period, where a law enforcement body is investigating a crime, to give them opportunity to view the images as part of an active investigation.
Many organisations have no policy on retention of CCTV images ... and it appears that they are frequently "not available" when there are questions raised in regard to the conduct of officials "caught on camera".
In relation to informing people that they are under CCTV surveillance, the Information Commissioner says: You must let people know that they are in an area where CCTV surveillance is being carried out. The most effective way of doing this is by using prominently placed signs at the entrance to the CCTV zone and reinforcing this with further signs inside the area. This message can also be backed up with an audio announcement, where public announcements are already used, such as in a station. Clear and prominent signs are particularly important where the cameras themselves are very discreet, or in locations where people might not expect to be under surveillance. As a general rule, signs should be more prominent and frequent where it would otherwise be less obvious to people that they are on CCTV. In the exceptional circumstance that audio recording is being used, this should be stated explicitly and prominently.
Similar requirements were in the previous guidance, but there are many examples of these being ignored.
Streaky
Among other things, it says:
Using CCTV can be privacy intrusive, as it is capable of putting a lot of law-abiding people under surveillance and recording their movements as they go about their day to day activities. You should carefully consider whether to use it; the fact that it is possible, affordable or has public support should not be the primary motivating factor. You should take into account what benefits can be gained, whether better solutions exist, and what effect it may have on individuals.
In many cases there are better ways of tackling the requirement ... just as road engineering might be better than speed limit reduction and scamera installation.
It is important that a CCTV system produces images that are of a suitable quality for the purpose for which the system was installed. If identification is necessary, then poor quality images which do not help to identify individuals may undermine the purpose for installing the system.
Too many installed CCTV systems produce images that are useless for identification. It's amusing when the operator of the system (especially commercial, but public sector too) is shocked that the images they have are unacceptable (and commonly inadmissable too). Then they say, "Well, management won't fork out for a better system!"
CCTV must not be used to record conversations between members of the public as this is highly intrusive and unlikely to be justified. You should choose a system without this facility if possible. If your system comes equipped with a sound recording facility then you should turn this off or disable it in some other way.
There are a good many systems installed that have sound recording turned on. There are some justifications, such as in a charge suite and "audio-based alert systems, but in this latter, conversations must not be recorded, and operators should not listen in. [Note the distinction between mandatory and desirable.]
regarding disclosure, the guidance says: Disclosure of images from the CCTV system must also be controlled and consistent with the purpose for which the system was established. For example, if the system is established to help prevent and detect crime it will be appropriate to disclose images to law enforcement agencies where a crime needs to be investigated, but it would not be appropriate to disclose images of identifiable individuals to the media for entertainment purposes or place them on the internet. Images can be released to the media for identification purposes; this should not generally be done by anyone other than a law enforcement agency.
This might affect the "cops on camera" type TV programmes.
On retention, the guidance does not prescribe any specific minimum or maximum retention periods, but says that retention should reflect the organisation’s own purposes for recording images. In particular it states that: You should not keep images for longer than strictly necessary to meet your own purposes for recording them. On occasion, you may need to retain images for a longer period, where a law enforcement body is investigating a crime, to give them opportunity to view the images as part of an active investigation.
Many organisations have no policy on retention of CCTV images ... and it appears that they are frequently "not available" when there are questions raised in regard to the conduct of officials "caught on camera".
In relation to informing people that they are under CCTV surveillance, the Information Commissioner says: You must let people know that they are in an area where CCTV surveillance is being carried out. The most effective way of doing this is by using prominently placed signs at the entrance to the CCTV zone and reinforcing this with further signs inside the area. This message can also be backed up with an audio announcement, where public announcements are already used, such as in a station. Clear and prominent signs are particularly important where the cameras themselves are very discreet, or in locations where people might not expect to be under surveillance. As a general rule, signs should be more prominent and frequent where it would otherwise be less obvious to people that they are on CCTV. In the exceptional circumstance that audio recording is being used, this should be stated explicitly and prominently.
Similar requirements were in the previous guidance, but there are many examples of these being ignored.
Streaky
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


