Telegraph: 'Rude' police punishing middle classes
Telegraph: 'Rude' police punishing middle classes
Author
Discussion

Peter Ward

Original Poster:

2,097 posts

287 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
Any of our resident BiBs recognise this? It seems like a very critical report, but we know that everyone produces reports about anything they like now in order to get some publicity/funding for their "think tank"/pressure group.

telegraph said:
Police are targeting the law-abiding middle classes over minor misdemeanours so they can meet government targets, a report claims.

The public find officers to be The public find officers to be "rude", according to the report

Officers are having to put Home Office targets before serving the public and are becoming increasingly alienated from ordinary people as a result.

Members of the public find officers to be "rude" and accuse them of neglecting their duties and failing to respond to reports of crime.

The report, by the think-tank Civitas, said political interference meant incidents that might previously have been regarded as innocuous were now treated as crimes.

Police performance is measured in "sanction detections" which means officers have detected or cleared a case by charging someone, issuing a penalty notice or giving a caution. Many officers are expected to complete a certain number each month.

Arresting or fining a normally law-abiding person for a trivial offence is a good way of achieving the target and pleasing the Home Office.

"The police seem intent on criminalising those whose offences, if they can be regarded as offences at all, are trivial," the report said.

"They are accused of concentrating on easy-to-deal with offending like speeding, while the real criminals seem to be getting away with it."

One case was highlighted in which a 19-year-old foreign student was arrested, detained for five hours and cautioned for holding open the door of a lift in a London Underground station.

The report said: "In a city where knife crime is exploding and the public are crying out for more police on the streets three officers are tied up for half the night arresting a young man for holding a lift door open with his foot."

Harriet Sergeant, the journalist who wrote the report, said the target culture meant police were less likely to concentrate on complex crimes.

It also meant officers exercised less discretion when dealing with a member of the public.

Performance-related pay bonuses of between £10,000 and £15,000 a year for commanders who manage frontline officers partly depend on reaching targets for sanction detections.

The report said: "In order to meet targets police are now classifying incidents as crimes that would previously have been dealt with informally, classified differently or ignored."

One officer interviewed for the study said he warned his own teenage son to take extra care at the end of the month when police are looking to fill their detection quota.

Another said: "We are bringing more and more people to justice but they are the wrong people."

Complaints against the police have risen and much of the increase comes from law-abiding, middle-class, middle-aged and retired people who no longer feel the police are on their side, the report said.

It called for an end to targets and proposed a local tax to pay for policing, with commanders selected through local government or direct elections.

Shadow home secretary David Davis said: "This is a desperate but not surprising indictment of Labour’s red tape, target-driven culture which has distorted police priorities and undermined the relationship between the police and the public.

"At the same time, bureaucracy has tied officers to their desks and kept them off the streets."

satchbot

1,916 posts

227 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
Sounds all to familiar frown So much is crimed these days that the workload has exploded leaving little time to "Police" and the drive for a detection wherever possible has made things silly. That, and the added pressure of sorting out peoples lives because they are too stupid/lazy/incompetent/spineless to deal themselves.

A new drive towards basic Policing is needed and not these government ideas on what the Police should do.

XMG5

1,082 posts

258 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
Peter Ward said:
Any of our resident BiBs recognise this? It seems like a very critical report, but we know that everyone produces reports about anything they like now in order to get some publicity/funding for their "think tank"/pressure group.

telegraph said:
Police are targeting the law-abiding middle classes over minor misdemeanours so they can meet government targets, a report claims.

The public find officers to be The public find officers to be "rude", according to the report

Officers are having to put Home Office targets before serving the public and are becoming increasingly alienated from ordinary people as a result.

Members of the public find officers to be "rude" and accuse them of neglecting their duties and failing to respond to reports of crime.

The report, by the think-tank Civitas, said political interference meant incidents that might previously have been regarded as innocuous were now treated as crimes.

Police performance is measured in "sanction detections" which means officers have detected or cleared a case by charging someone, issuing a penalty notice or giving a caution. Many officers are expected to complete a certain number each month.

Arresting or fining a normally law-abiding person for a trivial offence is a good way of achieving the target and pleasing the Home Office.

"The police seem intent on criminalising those whose offences, if they can be regarded as offences at all, are trivial," the report said.

"They are accused of concentrating on easy-to-deal with offending like speeding, while the real criminals seem to be getting away with it."

One case was highlighted in which a 19-year-old foreign student was arrested, detained for five hours and cautioned for holding open the door of a lift in a London Underground station.

The report said: "In a city where knife crime is exploding and the public are crying out for more police on the streets three officers are tied up for half the night arresting a young man for holding a lift door open with his foot."

Harriet Sergeant, the journalist who wrote the report, said the target culture meant police were less likely to concentrate on complex crimes.

It also meant officers exercised less discretion when dealing with a member of the public.

Performance-related pay bonuses of between £10,000 and £15,000 a year for commanders who manage frontline officers partly depend on reaching targets for sanction detections.

The report said: "In order to meet targets police are now classifying incidents as crimes that would previously have been dealt with informally, classified differently or ignored."

One officer interviewed for the study said he warned his own teenage son to take extra care at the end of the month when police are looking to fill their detection quota.

Another said: "We are bringing more and more people to justice but they are the wrong people."

Complaints against the police have risen and much of the increase comes from law-abiding, middle-class, middle-aged and retired people who no longer feel the police are on their side, the report said.

It called for an end to targets and proposed a local tax to pay for policing, with commanders selected through local government or direct elections.

Shadow home secretary David Davis said: "This is a desperate but not surprising indictment of Labour’s red tape, target-driven culture which has distorted police priorities and undermined the relationship between the police and the public.

"At the same time, bureaucracy has tied officers to their desks and kept them off the streets."
The lack of BiB response may indicate the report is an accurate summary of present day policing.

It certainly mirrors the general feelings of PH'ers posts over recent months. scratchchin

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
It's true and sums up why I my respect for the Police continues to diminish. In the City, the constables just love to shout at people in suits for no good reason. I've upbraided them on more than one occasion for it.

XMG5

1,082 posts

258 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
satchbot said:
Sounds all to familiar frown So much is crimed these days that the workload has exploded leaving little time to "Police" and the drive for a detection wherever possible has made things silly. That, and the added pressure of sorting out peoples lives because they are too stupid/lazy/incompetent/spineless to deal themselves.

A new drive towards basic Policing is needed and not these government ideas on what the Police should do.
But that has always been the case. It's not new and isn't the cause of current problems IMHO. Policing away from those "stupid/lazy/incompetent/spineless" people has changed and that is where the current problems have arisen.

Even if you were to remove those people from the equation, the standard of policing would not improve without a total rethink of ACPO Policy and Government meddling. Neither of which would be likely.

As for "spineless", it seems that whenever MoP show some spine and deal with a situation accordingly, the legal system fall over themselves to stamp on the hapless MoP and make him pay for "taking the law into his own hands" "he should have lleft it for the police to deal with" etc.,

The police themselves wash their hands of them and limply advise "People should not attempt to do the police's job for them." "They should let the Police deal with it" etc.,

So I don't think spineless is necessarily a valid reason for the MoP expecting the police to do the job they signed up for.

Or is it more a case of a greater number of Modern Day recruits sign up for the pay, pension, job security, power and uniform but never factored in the confrontations, abusive and vomitting drunks and less socially aware elements of the great unwashed.

Like it or not, it all counts towards the pension at the end of the day.

Edited by XMG5 on Friday 30th May 14:14

marlinmunro

3,071 posts

236 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
My personal experience of dealing with the police has been very negative. As a near pensioner who has never been in trouble, has been a model citizen for some 60 years, speaks volumes of how things have changed. See this months EVO for the tale of the lad that runs a Lambo being stopped on the M1 for doing 91 ( fair enough ) but see how he was treated by the skid mark that pulled him.
TAX COLLECTORS vomit

John57

1,870 posts

259 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
Well, my own experiences of the Police are actually very positive.... polite officers who just try to help and do what they can .... biggrin

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
No excuse for rudeness, nothing wrong with reporting offenders though.

Chrispy Porker

17,764 posts

259 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
No doubt there are many people who think the police are picking on them because of their colour, or the fact they are poor, or some other reason.
Always have been, always will be.
I wish I had a quid for everytime someone told me I should be catching rapists..

p1esk

4,914 posts

227 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
Chrispy Porker said:
No doubt there are many people who think the police are picking on them because of their colour, or the fact they are poor, or some other reason.
Always have been, always will be.
I wish I had a quid for every time someone told me I should be catching rapists..
You should be catching rapists. Sorry, can't help you with the quid though. laugh

Best wishes all,
Dave.

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
Who would have thought that setting targets for police commanders would end up in them directing their offices to pick on the easy targets?

Well, just about everybody.

Don't moan about it, do something, Write to your MP and tell him or her that, unless they change it not only will you be voting for some other party but you will campaign for them as well.

Your individual letter will have no effect but if enough can be bothered you never know.

I emailed my MP, Des Turner, on 18th May. Apart from an acknowledgement on the 20th that it had been received I've had nothing. It's the only thing I've asked of him in the 10 years or so he's been there. I'll give him 3 weeks in total and then that's it. I'll campaign for the tories. The previous incumbent ( tory) did reply to a letter, made an appointment for me to see him and then did bugger all but at least he explained why.

skymaster

731 posts

238 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
No excuse for rudeness, nothing wrong with reporting offenders though.
If our loony government made it illegal to wear blue trousers Von would go around arresting everyone wearing them from the minute the Act came into force. Irrespective of any morals involved.


satchbot

1,916 posts

227 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
XMG5 said:
As for "spineless", it seems that whenever MoP show some spine and deal with a situation accordingly, the legal system fall over themselves to stamp on the hapless MoP and make him pay for "taking the law into his own hands" "he should have lleft it for the police to deal with" etc.
I'm not saying all situations will be suitable for the MOP to deal with but there are a number of MOPs who use the BiB to fight their battles. And sometimes when the MOPs get involved they do overdo it hence getting arrested. There have been occasions recently where the courts have praised MOPs for getting involved so it's not all "making MOPs pay for getting stuck in".

Frix

678 posts

222 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
There is actually nothing in that article which makes much sense. While the sentiment is nearly correct the examples used are misleading.
Speeding is not a recordable offence so won't help the figures. Not sure what offence was being investigated in the lift door incident but I doubt that was recordable either.
Police are not classifying crimes which they would not have done previously because they want to. NCRS dictates that they have to. We wish it wasn't there either but there you go.
As for the so-called "Officer comments" well you surely only have to read them to see the contradiction.
This post is in no way meant to defend the practice of over-recording crime which they know will be detected it is merely to highlight the frankly useless journalism and put a few things straight.

FishFace

3,790 posts

239 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
skymaster said:
vonhosen said:
No excuse for rudeness, nothing wrong with reporting offenders though.
If our loony government made it illegal to wear blue trousers Von would go around arresting everyone wearing them from the minute the Act came into force. Irrespective of any morals involved.
What you consider to be a moral issue another may consider it to be straight up criminal. The police must not pick and choose which laws to enforce (a separate issue to discretion).


Digby

8,362 posts

277 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
They were talking about this on the radio earlier.One copper called in and said they would arrest people for walking on cracks in the pavement if they could, simply to get the figures up.He talked about how much pressure they were under to not be bottom of the targets list.

Speed cameras etc cropped up a few times too and it seems we are far from alone in feeling that respect is being lost towards the BIB due to the often ridiculous enforcment of speed. frown


satchbot

1,916 posts

227 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
Digby said:
They were talking about this on the radio earlier.One copper called in and said they would arrest people for walking on cracks in the pavement if they could, simply to get the figures up.He talked about how much pressure they were under to not be bottom of the targets list.

Speed cameras etc cropped up a few times too and it seems we are far from alone in feeling that respect is being lost towards the BIB due to the often ridiculous enforcment of speed. frown
Sounds right (both points) frown

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
skymaster said:
vonhosen said:
No excuse for rudeness, nothing wrong with reporting offenders though.
If our loony government made it illegal to wear blue trousers Von would go around arresting everyone wearing them from the minute the Act came into force. Irrespective of any morals involved.
What a lot of tosh.

skymaster

731 posts

238 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
FishFace said:
skymaster said:
vonhosen said:
No excuse for rudeness, nothing wrong with reporting offenders though.
If our loony government made it illegal to wear blue trousers Von would go around arresting everyone wearing them from the minute the Act came into force. Irrespective of any morals involved.
What you consider to be a moral issue another may consider it to be straight up criminal. The police must not pick and choose which laws to enforce (a separate issue to discretion).
OK, lets say someone witnesses a hit and run in which a child is seriously hurt. Then follows the driver of the offending car.... they follow him and call the police to say what they are doing, asking for a patrol car to come and take over... But, they dont have hands free so are technically breaking the law. The hit and run driver realising he is being followed speeds away so fast the persuing driver gives up and returns to the scene to tell officers what happened.... You gonna book him for using a hand held phone while driving? Or not?

bcnrml

2,107 posts

241 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
skymaster said:
FishFace said:
skymaster said:
vonhosen said:
No excuse for rudeness, nothing wrong with reporting offenders though.
If our loony government made it illegal to wear blue trousers Von would go around arresting everyone wearing them from the minute the Act came into force. Irrespective of any morals involved.
What you consider to be a moral issue another may consider it to be straight up criminal. The police must not pick and choose which laws to enforce (a separate issue to discretion).
OK, lets say someone witnesses a hit and run in which a child is seriously hurt. Then follows the driver of the offending car.... they follow him and call the police to say what they are doing, asking for a patrol car to come and take over... But, they dont have hands free so are technically breaking the law. The hit and run driver realising he is being followed speeds away so fast the persuing driver gives up and returns to the scene to tell officers what happened.... You gonna book him for using a hand held phone while driving? Or not?
hehe

Nice scenario. Now let's wait for the response!wink