Speed traps - pointless?
Author
Discussion

andye30m3

Original Poster:

3,501 posts

285 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
I've just driven through a speed trap (traffic cop with a gun) for the first time in ages and every single driver going the other way was flashing like mad, not just the odd one but everyone.

surely this makes these traps almost pointless as you'd have to be a idiot not to realise something was going on up the road.

Is this a sign of the general motorist having had enough?

andye30m3

Original Poster:

3,501 posts

285 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
Fair point john.

it was just a bit strange, i haven't driven past one in years and back then the average person wouldn't have warned you IMO.

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
Reminds me when Radar (PETA) was used it was Force policy to place warning sign boards half a mile before the device.....................and we still got full books.

dvd

Jasandjules

72,710 posts

260 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
John57 said:
It's always been done .... and if it slows people down then it has achieved the desired effect.
Wrong. If it slows people down, then the police look to prosecute the driver who warned other road users.

The desired effect of a speed trap is to make money, and to p**s off the motorist. Ergo, they are not pointless, for they p**s off most people I know, and they seem to make money.

Mr Trophy

6,811 posts

234 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
Dwight VanDriver said:
Reminds me when Radar (PETA) was used it was Force policy to place warning sign boards half a mile before the device.....................and we still got full books.

dvd
You bad bad man hehe

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
John57 said:
It's always been done .... and if it slows people down then it has achieved the desired effect.
Wrong. If it slows people down, then the police look to prosecute the driver who warned other road users.

The desired effect of a speed trap is to make money, and to p**s off the motorist. Ergo, they are not pointless, for they p**s off most people I know, and they seem to make money.
Nope they are normaly in response to complaints from locals or due to an officer deciding to use is as an excuse to stop vehicles to have a look at them. Or an officer who believes that limits are there to be enforced and as such has decided to enforce them for a period of time.

They are not about making money thats just what the pro-speed groups brainwash everyone into thinking.

Love it, officer doing enforcement is a bad thing as are cameras. So its clear that what people on this forum want is nothing to do with automated or non-automated enforcement, they want no enforcement.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
Guam said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Jasandjules said:
John57 said:
It's always been done .... and if it slows people down then it has achieved the desired effect.
Wrong. If it slows people down, then the police look to prosecute the driver who warned other road users.

The desired effect of a speed trap is to make money, and to p**s off the motorist. Ergo, they are not pointless, for they p**s off most people I know, and they seem to make money.
Nope they are normaly in response to complaints from locals or due to an officer deciding to use is as an excuse to stop vehicles to have a look at them. Or an officer who believes that limits are there to be enforced and as such has decided to enforce them for a period of time.

They are not about making money thats just what the pro-speed groups brainwash everyone into thinking.

Love it, officer doing enforcement is a bad thing as are cameras. So its clear that what people on this forum want is nothing to do with automated or non-automated enforcement, they want no enforcement.
Sorry Annie can you please put a qualifier into some of your comments like the word SOME!!!!!!!!!!!

If we are now going to have the Bib generalise about all of us on here in the same vein then basically the point of this forum has gone, also it reinforces the perception issue we have been talking about. I have NO issue with manned enforcement or Trafpol, I am on record several times as saying that, I have a problem with much more fundamental issues and TBH this kind of sweeping generalisation drives even people like me into the other camp.


Cheers
No. Speed enforcement is not about money or making money. Automated enforcement is not ideal but it is not about money the revenue is tiny and their are easier ways to raise that revenue without causing the negative public relations impact. Anyone who thinks its about money is the same person who thinks that officers getting speeding tickets somehow helps the police hit targets at the end of the month.

Its this kind of ill-informed publicity that has created some of the perception problems we have.

As for the comments about people on this forum I will qualify by saying that some have that view about officers doing enforcement.

The most complained about issues we have are, nuisance cars, nuisance bikes, speeding cars, dog mess on the paths, bad parking, kids on corners oh and something about trees dropping leaves.

cs02rm0

13,966 posts

222 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
If it makes so little money... you'd think they'd put that little money where their mouth is and not fine the motorist at all, just apply the points.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
cs02rm0 said:
If it makes so little money... you'd think they'd put that little money where their mouth is and not fine the motorist at all, just apply the points.
I'd have no problem with that. If it was about money there would be no points at all.

cs02rm0

13,966 posts

222 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
cs02rm0 said:
If it makes so little money... you'd think they'd put that little money where their mouth is and not fine the motorist at all, just apply the points.
I'd have no problem with that. If it was about money there would be no points at all.
No, if it was about money the points would provide ample pretense for brainwashed coppers to pretend it wasn't about the money? :P

Not that I entirely believe that's the case, but that statement just isn't true.

CommanderJameson

22,096 posts

257 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
Speed enforcement (automated or otherwise) is road safety enforcement on the cheap.

Nicking actual bad drivers requires much more effort and resource, so they do that only sparingly.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
cs02rm0 said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
cs02rm0 said:
If it makes so little money... you'd think they'd put that little money where their mouth is and not fine the motorist at all, just apply the points.
I'd have no problem with that. If it was about money there would be no points at all.
No, if it was about money the points would provide ample pretense for brainwashed coppers to pretend it wasn't about the money? :P

Not that I entirely believe that's the case, but that statement just isn't true.
I'm afraid the only brainwashing is for those who think its about revenue. Those that are not wiling to look beyond headlines or soundbites.

Its about cheap roads policing an nothing else.

DucatiGary

7,765 posts

256 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Its about cheap roads policing an nothing else.
but it doesnt work does it, admit itwink

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
DucatiGary said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Its about cheap roads policing an nothing else.
but it doesnt work does it, admit itwink
It does make some difference to the nature of injuries, but does not do a lot for reducing the number of crashes.

I'd rather there were more un-marked vehicles focussing on bad driving. No-one wants to pay for it though.

DucatiGary

7,765 posts

256 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
id rather there are MARKED vehicles, unmarked vehicles stop nothing other than innocent people for victimless crimes becuase they didnt see the unmarked car.

marked cars show the chavs who where not driving badly when they seen you, not to bother as they can clearly see we actually have police on the roads.

unlike what we have at the moment.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
DucatiGary said:
id rather there are MARKED vehicles, unmarked vehicles stop nothing other than innocent people for victimless crimes becuase they didnt see the unmarked car.

marked cars show the chavs who where not driving badly when they seen you, not to bother as they can clearly see we actually have police on the roads.

unlike what we have at the moment.
No they focus on careless driving/dangerous driving not on speed unless its far above the posted limit. More un-marked cars means people will forever be thinking the mondeo the 5 series bmw the saab are police vehicles and will adjust their driving behaviour all the time rather than just for the marked vehicle.

Un-marked means having to drive better all the time. They also allow focus on criminals using motor vehicles to travel to commit crime.

Un-marked cars would be far more impactive upon dealing with the idiots on our roads and getting their licences off them.

Jasandjules

72,710 posts

260 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
John57 said:
Two recent speed 'hits' we conducted were merely to catch the extreme speeders (read 84 in a 30 at the last one) and drink drivers.
Could you clarify how a speed trap prevents or detects drink drivers please.

That's one of my hates you see, the fact that these feckin' yellow boxes Don't catch drink drivers.

If you tot up the total revenue made by all the speed camera, Scum Camera Pratnerships, and plod with hairdyers, what is it? Does anyone know? I don't mean profit (as clearly it's easy enough with judicious spending to reduce profit), I mean simply revenue. i.e. total tickets issued in the country for a year, multiplied by £60 for simplicities sake.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
John57 said:
Two recent speed 'hits' we conducted were merely to catch the extreme speeders (read 84 in a 30 at the last one) and drink drivers.
Could you clarify how a speed trap prevents or detects drink drivers please.

That's one of my hates you see, the fact that these feckin' yellow boxes Don't catch drink drivers.

If you tot up the total revenue made by all the speed camera, Scum Camera Pratnerships, and plod with hairdyers, what is it? Does anyone know? I don't mean profit (as clearly it's easy enough with judicious spending to reduce profit), I mean simply revenue. i.e. total tickets issued in the country for a year, multiplied by £60 for simplicities sake.
Drink drivers tend to speed/drive badly or show out in some other way.

No idea but for it to be about money you have to show the profit to make it worthwhile. I think the revenue was somewhere in the region of 130 million, famously Clarkson even said that Simon Cowell paid more in income tax allegedly than the revenue from cameras ( how true that is I do not know).

Jasandjules

72,710 posts

260 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
No idea but for it to be about money you have to show the profit to make it worthwhile.
Not at all, it's perfectly possible to "hide" revenue to reduce profit, in order to ensure that one's tax is lower - companies do it all the time. That's why I said simply the money brought in, not profit. £130m may be about right.

Drink drivers IME (which is in no way anywhere near yours) drive within the speed limit (for obvious reasons), and late at night/early mornings (i.e. 2am) - so a 10-2pm slot sat on the roadside on a Saturday afternoon doesn't detect them?

And the plod I've seen manning the guns in my area don't have cars, they are standing by the road, so how would they catch a drunk driver? They don't stop vehicles?

Jasandjules

72,710 posts

260 months

Saturday 31st May 2008
quotequote all
John57 said:
I am referring to Traffic Police doing speed enforcement - not some arm of the SCP's ..... the guys I work with probably spend less than 1% of their time using a Laser or the like. They do have cars and they do stop the motorists .... but that's just where I am based.
And I am not !! I am referring to the big yellow boxes, or the plod sat in an unmarked horsebox, or hiding behind a bridge etc.. nicking people on Saturday afternoon on a nice long stretch of road...That's where the confusion lies.

I have NO problem at all with Trafpol - I want more of them. TO catch dangerous drivers, and yes, I totally agree THEY can nick drunks !!